
Seafood
Teddy's By the Sea
5096 Carpinteria Ave
Carpinteria, CA 93013
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
FOOD (3PO)
Appetizers
Dinner Rolls with Herb Butter
7 Rolls per order, served warm from the oven in a cast iron pan, side of herb butter. *Allergens: Wheat, Milk$6.506 Oysters of the Day
Our most common oyster served is Blue Point Oysters: From Long Island Sound on the East Coast, usually in Connecticut. Medium salinity, springy meat, light mineral finish. Served over ice with: Mignonette Sauce and Cocktail Sauce. *Allergens: Shellfish$21.256 Grilled Oysters
Freshly shucked oysters are prepared with butter and garlic, grilled on the char broiler and finished with parsley and parmesan *Allergens: Shellfish, Milk$22.75Crispy Calamari
Our calamari is of superior quality – very clean and tender. We soak the calamari in milk and then coat with flour and spices, then deep fried. Served with fried pepperoncini peppers, Lemon Aioli and Warm Marinara Dipping Sauce. *Allergens: Fish, Wheat, Egg, Milk$19.50Crab Cakes
House-made with Wild Caught Red Crab, panko breadcrumbs, topped with lemon Aioli. **Allergen: Wheat, Shellfish, Egg$21.00Bacon Wrapped Dates
Dates stuffed with Goat cheese, wrapped in bacon, roasted and then glazed with a sweet brown sugar bourbon glaze. **Allergen: Milk (goat cheese)$14.40Onion Dip
Fresh fried house made potato chips. Dips: Warm caramelized onion, gruyere (a Swiss Cheese), Bacon dip with sour cream, served with a side of Blue Cheese Dip. **Allergen: Milk$13.80Ahi Poke Nachos
Fresh ahi tuna (yellowtail) cubes, tossed with a soy marinade, served over wonton chips, topped with wasabi cream, avocado, edamame (soy beans), tobiko (flying fish roe (eggs)), crispy fried shallots (similar to an onion – sweet) Topped with a soy glaze. **Allergens: Soy, fish, wheat (shallots & wontons)$17.75Buffalo Cauliflower
Battered spicy cauliflower. With a side of buttermilk ranch for dipping. Reddish tint from Aleppo and cayenne peppers. ** Allergens: Wheat, Milk$13.80Lobster Mac & Cheese
House-made cream sauce (lobster stock, cream, Parmesan cheese, white cheddar and provolone), chunks of lobster meat, macaroni pasta, topped with herb bread crumbs and diced red pepper. **Allergens: Shellfish, milk, wheat$22.20Ceviche Cocktail
Sea Bass and Halibut (both wild caught) Marinated in lime juice, then tossed with a vinaigrette, mango, avocado, cucumber, jicama and tomato. Served with blue and yellow tortilla chips (fried in-house) **Allergens: Fish$20.00Steamed Clams
Fresh white wine steamed clams with garlic, shallots, red pepper, parsley, extra virgin olive oil, served with a side of 3 crostini's. **Allergens: Shellfish, Wheat$21.40Fresh-Made Guacamole
Crispy tortilla chips, with a side of house-made salsa. **Allergens: Avocado$16.20Single Raw Oyster
$3.90Chicken Wings
$15.00Crispy Onion Rings
OUT OF STOCK$12.00Flash Fried Coconut Shrimp
$19.00
Soup & Salad
Boston Clam Chowder (8oz Cup)
AKA New England Clam Chowder *Contains bacon, chopped clams, potatoes, carrots, celery, seasoning, cream **Allergens: Wheat, Shellfish, Milk$11.50Carpinteria Wedge
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, ranch dressing, avocado, thick-cut bacon **Allergens: Milk (can sub vinaigrette and remove blue cheese to make milk-free)$16.90Caesar Salad
Hearts of romaine, shaved parmesan, house-made croutons, Caesar dressing **Allergens: Fish (anchovy in dressing), Egg, wheat$16.50Teddy's Cobb
Grilled free-range chicken breast, crispy thick-cut bacon, hard-boiled egg, tomato, blue cheese crumbles, avocado, hearts of romaine, red wine vinaigrette. **Can sub protein **Allergens: Egg, milk$20.40Kale & Quinoa Salad
Tuscan kale, quinoa, shaved parmesan, walnuts, lemony vinaigrette. **Vegan option without the cheese **Allergens: milk, tree nuts$17.00
Handhelds
Fish and Chips
Wild caught sustainable Alaskan Cod Battered and fried. Served with choice of French fries, or potato chips. Upgrades available. Side of Pineapple Coleslaw (vinaigrette based – no mayonnaise.) Served with a side of Remoulade. **Allergens: fish, milk, wheat, egg$22.75Wild Salmon Sandwich
Wild caught Coho Canadian Salmon, fresh-made bun, remoulade, butter lettuce, sliced tomatoes, sliced red onion. **Allergens: wheat, fish, milk, egg$22.00Crab Cake Sliders
2 Sliders per order, Sweet Portuguese buns, crab cakes, pineapple slaw, lemon aioli. **Allergens: shellfish, wheat, egg$22.50Fish Tacos
Wild caught Alaskan cod served with batter-fried or grilled Lime slaw, white cheddar cheese, cilantro sauce, served with house-made salsa on the side. Allergens: (grilled) fish, milk, **Allergens: (fried) wheat, egg, milk, fish$19.75Teddy's Tavern Burger
Grass-fed wagyu beef. Beef is Halal certified, the unique taste and tenderness of highly marbled Wagyu beef makes for an unrivalled eating experience. Candied jalapeno mayo, crispy shallots, white cheddar cheese, thick-cut bacon, butter lettuce, sliced tomatoes *can add avocado *Available lettuce wrapped *Can sub regular mayonnaise **Allergens: wheat, egg, milk$21.00Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Free-range chicken breast, roasted red bell pepper, provolone cheese, garlic aioli, arugula. **Allergens: wheat, milk, egg$19.50Classic Burger
Same patty as Tavern Burger Can add choice of cheese, white cheddar, sharp yellow cheddar, provolone, blue cheese Comes with butter lettuce, tomato, sliced red onion, mayonnaise *Available lettuce wrapped *add avocado or bacon **Allergens: wheat, egg, milk$18.00Veggie Burger
Three wholesome grains, brown rice, quinoa and bulgar with roasted corn, black beans and roasted red peppers for a vegan burger that is packed with fiber and is kosher Comes with butter lettuce, tomato, sliced red onion, mayonnaise *Can add avocado Can be made vegan without mayonnaise – sub ketchup, mustard **Allergens: wheat, egg, milk$17.75Salmon Tacos
Wild caught Salmon served with Lime slaw, cotija cheese, tomatillo salsa, avocado, pico de gallo. **Allergens: fish, avocado, dairy$20.40Cauliflower Tacos
Battered cauliflower, corn tortillas, cabbage slaw, white cheddar, cilantro crema. **Allergens: Wheat, Milk$19.60Spicy Honey Fried Chicken Sandwich
Crispy fried free-range chicken breast, siracha-honey glaze, creamy coleslaw, dill pickles on fresh-baked bun. **Allergens: Wheat (can lettuce wrap)$19.80Ahi Tuna Club
$20.00
House Specialties
Spanish Chorizo Shrimp & Grits
Wild caught Argentinian red shrimp, white cheddar grits, creamy tomato sauce made with white wine, herbs, lemon, garlic, onions, spices, cream and Spanish style chorizo. **Can be made without the chorizo if someone is a pescatarian or does not eat pork **Allergens: shellfish, milk$27.00Cedar Plank Wild Salmon
Wild Coho Canadian salmon, cooked on a cedar wood plank to impart the flavors of the wood. Glazed with a sweet glaze of maple and Dijon, crispy smashed potatoes (fingerling potatoes, steamed *allgeries garlic, onion, dairy, gluten and then ‘smashed’ and cooked until crispy with herbs), and sautéed garlic green beans. **Allergens: fish, milk (sauce)$30.60Seared Sesame Ahi Tuna
Yellowfin tuna, coated in sesame seeds, seared rare. Cilantro-coconut rice, sautéed Asian vegetables **Allergens: fish, soy, garlic sesame. nuts$30.60Buttermilk Fried Chicken
Free-range chicken breast (boneless), buttermilk and herb marinated and then breaded and crispy fried gravy is a sweet onion gravy from slowly caramelized onions, sherry wine, chicken stock, balsamic, and herbs. Garlic green beans and mashed potatoes (Yukon gold potatoes) **Allergens: milk, wheat$25.80Grilled New York Steak
10oz New York Steak – strip loin-center cut, mashed potatoes, crispy brussels sprouts – sweet and salty with dates and lime juice **Allergens: milk$45.00Linguine with Clams
Fresh clams, garlic, white wine sauce, fresh herbs. **Allergens: Shellfish$23.70Linguine Pomodoro
Tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, fresh basil, parmesan cheese. **Allergens: Dairy (Can be dairy free.)$22.00Cioppino
Fresh fish, calamari, mussels, shrimp, and clams in a classic tomato and white wine broth, and 3 grilled crostini. **Allergens: Fish, Shellfish, Wheat, onions, garlic, citrus$31.60
Dessert
Sides
2 Grilled Jalapenos (Side Only)
$1.50Caesar Salad (Side Only)
$7.80Extra Side of Ranch
$0.90French Fries (Side Only)
$6.60Green Beans (Side Only)
$7.80Mashed Potatoes (Side Only)
$7.80Organic Green Salad (Side Only)
$7.80Pineapple Slaw (side only)
$3.00Potato Chips (Side Only)
$6.60Side Broccolini (side only)
$8.00Side Fruit
$4.80side of Crostini (4 pieces)
$3.90Seasonal Veggies (side only)
$7.80Avocado (Side Only)
$3.30Sweet Potato Fries (Side Only)
$6.00
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 7:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Quality seafood, fish tacos, burgers and salads. Open for dine-in, delivery and pick-up.
Location
5096 Carpinteria Ave, Carpinteria, CA 93013
© 2026 Toast, Inc.




