American
The Cider Mill
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
Riggies
homemade rigatoni, parmesan, spicy tomato-cream sauce (choose roasted chicken thighs, breaded chicken, roasted eggplant and/or Gianelli spicy ground sausage) You may add a second protein or double up, if you wish. (Gluten free pasta available)$29.00Cider Mill Salad
greens, pickled apples, candied pecans, dried cranberries, cider-dijon vinaigrette (gf, V, nuts)$14.00Daily Bread
$5.00
Appetizers
Sprouts
fried brussels sprouts, maple chipotle sauce, house-made bleu cheese (gs, VO)$16.00Tuna Crudo
crunchy soy-ginger slaw, crispy wontons, pineapple glaze (df, gfO)$19.00Beet & Hummus
sliced beets, parsnip hummus, oranges, goat cheese, balsamic (dfO, gf)$14.00Scallops
red pepper coulis, summer succotash (df, gf)$22.00Summer Flatbread
flatbread crust, blueberry cream cheese base, goat cheese, arugula salad, prosciutto$14.00Sautéed Mussels
lemon thyme garlic butter, crostini (gfO)$20.00Crispy Pork Belly
cabbage slaw, cranberry gastrqiue, apple chutney (df, gs)$15.00Sourdough Crostini
herb and lemon stracciatella , roasted tomatoes, balsamic glaze (veg)$14.00Daily Bread
$5.00Summer Deviled Eggs
house-made chili crisp, scallions, wontons (df, gfO, veg)$9.00
Entrees
Blackened Mahi
pineapple ginger fried rice, soy-ginger slaw, lime crema, sesame seeds (dfO)$42.00Grilled Chicken Thighs
cilantro lime marinade, avocado hummus, basmati, mexican corn, jalapeño ranch dressing, cotija (dfO, gf)$29.00Herb Marinated Tofu
Sauteed. Basmati rice, summer succotash, red pepper coulis (gf,V)$26.00Lamb Loin Chops
farro pilaf, heirloom carrots, mint vinaigrette$45.00Mushroom Pasta
rotini, king oyster mushrooms, creamy cauliflower sauce, sundried tomatoes, spinach (gf, V) 27-$28.00Pan Seared Salmon
chimicurri risotto, mango salsa, lemon aioli (gf)$42.00Pork Tomahawk
roasted fingerling potatoes, red chimichurri, tonight’s veg (df, gf)$39.00Riggies
homemade rigatoni, parmesan, spicy tomato-cream sauce (choose roasted chicken thighs, breaded chicken, roasted eggplant and/or Gianelli spicy ground sausage) You may add a second protein or double up, if you wish. (Gluten free pasta available)$29.00Shrimp Alfredo
shells, andouille sausage and sweet corn cream sauce (gfO)$30.00Sirloin Filet
(9oz.) red smashed potatoes, black garlic demi, tonight’s vegetable, (gs)$43.00
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 5:00 pm - 8:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 5:00 pm - 8:30 pm |
| Thursday | 5:00 pm - 8:30 pm |
| Friday | 5:00 pm - 8:30 pm |
| Saturday | 5:00 pm - 8:30 pm |
Restaurant info
A little family-owned restaurant in Syracuse, NY.
Location
4221 Fay Road, Syracuse, NY 13219
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
