Skip to Main content

  • The Old Fashioned Supper Club 3498 E HWY 33

    • Home
    • /
    • West Bend
    • /
    • The Old Fashioned Supper Club 3498 E HWY 33

    This restaurant does not have any images

    American

    The Old Fashioned Supper Club 3498 E HWY 33

    3498 E HWY 33

    West Bend, WI 53095

    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant

    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Friday Menu
    Daily Menu
    Beverages
    Sunday Brunch

    Friday Menu

    Cod

    • Fried Cod

      $20.00

    • Butter Poached Cod

      $20.00

    • Blackened Cod

      $20.00

    Perch

    • Fried Perch

      $22.00

    • Blackened Perch

      $22.00

    • Butter Poached Perch

      $22.00

    Shrimp

    • 1/2 lb Golden Fried Shrimp Dinner

      $21.00

    • 1/2 lb Sauteed Shrimp Dinner

      $21.00

    • 1/2 lb Blackened Shrimp

      $21.00

    • 1/2 lb Grilled Shrimp

      $21.00

    Friday Old Fashioneds

    • Rail Short Friday Old Fashioneds

      $7.50

    • Rail Tall Friday Old Fashioneds

      $10.00

    Casual Fare

    • Mushroom Provolone Burger

      $17.00

    • Chicken Caesar Salad

      $18.00

    Entrees

    • Tenderloin Filet

      $39.00

    • Beef Tenderloin Tips

      $29.00

    • Ribeye (14-16 oz)

      $46.00

    • Tuscan Chicken

      $26.00

    • Ribeye (10 oz)

      $37.00

    Appetizers

    • Half Naked Curds

      OUT OF STOCK
      $11.00

    • Stuffed Mushrooms

      $18.00

    • Big Bang Shrimp

      $18.00

    • Baked Spin Dip

      $16.00

    Daily Menu

    Appetizers

    • Big Bang Shrimp

      6 Jumbo Fried Shrimp, served with house-made Big Bang sauce.
      $17.00

    • Baked Spinach Artichoke Dip

      $16.00

    • Hand Dipped Curds

      Melty cheese curds, lightly battered with a light, crunchy exterior that adds texture and flavor. Served with our house-made, German-Catalina or Ranch dressing.
      $10.00

    • Stuffed Mushrooms

      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.00

    • Garlic-Spinach Meatballs

      House-made meatballs (3) blended with spinach, roasted garlic, Italian herbs, Panko breadcrumbs, baked until tender and finished with Parmesan cheese and warm marinara.
      $18.00

    • Extra Sauce

      $0.50

    • Sub Ranch Dressing

    Entrees

    • Wet Aged Ribeye

      $37.00+

    • Center Cut Tenderloin

      OUT OF STOCK
      $39.00

    • Baked Seafood Alfredo

      $28.00

    • Chicken Carbonara

      $25.00

    • NY Strip Steak

      $29.00+

    • Tuscan Chicken

      $26.00

    • Beef Tenderloin Tips

      $29.00

    • Braised Short Ribs

      $36.00

    • Summer Salmon Skillet

      $28.00

    • Bone In Pork Chop

      OUT OF STOCK
      $29.00

    Casual

    • Prime Rib Dip Sandwich

      OUT OF STOCK
      $19.00

    • Mushroom Provolone Burger

      $17.00

    Salads

    • House Salad

      $13.00

    • Chicken Caesar Salad

      $18.00

    Desserts

    • Chocolate fudge layer cake

      $5.00

    • Chocolate cream pie

      $5.00

    • 1 Scoop of Ice Cream

      $2.00

    • Turtle Cheesecake

      $7.00

    • Pecan Pie

      $6.00

    • Apple pie

      $6.50

    • Strawberry cheesecake

      $6.00

    à la carte

    • BYO Side Salad

      $6.00

    • Cup of Soup

      $4.00

    • Bowl of Soup

      $6.00

    • Side Seasonal Veggies

      $3.00

    • Side Mashed Potatoes

      $3.00

    • Side Loaded Mashed

      $5.00

    • Side Baked Potato

      $3.00

    • Side Loaded Baked Potato

      $5.00

    • Shrimp Add On

      $15.00

    • Rolls

      $6.00

    Wednesday Nights

    • Spaghetti & Meatballs

      $21.00

    • Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo

      $23.00

    • Baked Mac & Cheese

      $18.00

    • Rigatoni alla Vodka

      $21.00

    • Wine & Pasta Pairing

      $45.00

    Kid's Menu

    • Kid's Cheeseburger

      $12.00

    • Kid's Pasta & Meatball

      $12.00

    • Kid's Tenders & FF

      $12.00

    Beverages

    Beer

    • Domestic Cans

      $4.00

    • Domestic Bottled Beer

      $5.00

    • Craft Bottled Beer

      $7.00

    • Draft beer

      $7.00

    Wine

    • House Red Wine

      $7.00

    • Meiomi Pinot

      $9.00

    • Prisoner Red Blend

      $9.00

    • Lo Duca Lambrusco

      $8.00

    • Conundrum

      $9.00

    • Other Red Wine

      $9.00

    • House White Wine

      $7.00

    • St Michelle Riesling

      $8.00

    • Bricco Riella Moscato

      $8.00

    • Other White Wine

      $9.00

    • Verdi Champagne

      $8.00

    • sangria

      $6.00

    Seltzers

    • Carbliss

      $6.00

    • White Claw

      $6.00

    • Other

      $6.00

    Cocktail Specials

    • OF short

      $8.00

    • Old Fashioned - tall

      $10.00

    • OF call

      $9.00

    • OF call Tall

      $11.00

    • Ice Cream Drink

      $10.00

    • Ice Cream Drink Tall

      $12.00

    • rail mixer

      $7.00

    • tall mixer

      $9.00

    • wine

      $8.00

    Gun Soda or Juice

    • Soda

      $2.50

    • Juice

      $2.50

    • Gun Refill

      $0.50

    Bourbon & Whiskey

    • Angel's Envy

      $9.00+

    • Bail Hayden Tall

      $9.00+

    • Other Call

      $7.00+

    • Rail

      $6.00+

    • Jameson

      $7.00+

    • Kessler's

      $6.00+

    • Knob Creek

      $9.00+

    • Limousin Rye

      $9.00+

    • Jack Daniel's

      $9.00+

    • Highland Park 12

      $8.00+

    • Angel's Envy Rye

    • Johnny Walker Red Label

      $11.00

    • Johnny Walker Blue Label

    • Tullamore Dew

    • Chivas Regal 12

    • Jim Beam

      $7.00+

    • Jim Beam Red Stag

    • Jack Daniel's Fire

    • Jack Daniel's Rye

    • Canadian Club

    • Seagram's VO

    • Seagram's 7

    • Walker's Cay

    Vodka

    • Pinnacle Short

      $5.00

    • Pinnacle Tall

      $7.00

    • Driftless Glen Cuke Short

      $6.00

    • Driftless Glen Cuke Tall

      $8.00

    • Belvedere Short

      $8.00

    • Belvedere Tall

      $10.00

    • Chopin Tall

      $8.00

    • Chopin Short

      $10.00

    • Other Rail Short

      $5.00

    • Other Rail Tall

      $7.00

    • Other Call Short

      $7.00

    • Other Call Tall

      $9.00

    Brandy

    • Korbel Short

      $7.00

    • Korbel Tall

      $9.00

    • Other Rail Short

      $5.00

    • Other Rail Tall

      $7.00

    Old Fashioneds

    • Top Tier Short Old Fashioned

      $10.00

    • Top Tier Tall Old Fashioned

      $12.00

    • Premier Short Old Fashioned

      $12.00

    • Premier Tall Old Fashioned

      $14.00

    • Peach Pecan Short Old Fashioned

      $8.00

    • Peach Pecan Tall Old Fashioned

      $10.00

    • Peaches & Cream Short Old Fashioned

      $8.00

    • Peaches & Cream Tall Old Fashioned

      $10.00

    • Smores Short Old Fashioned

      $8.00

    • Smores Tall Old Fashioned

      $10.00

    • Vanilla Cherry Short Old Fashioned

      $8.00

    • Cinnamon Vanilla Short Old Fashioned

      $8.00

    • Vanilla Cherry Tall Old Fashioned

      $10.00

    • Cinnamon Vanilla Tall Old Fashioned

      $10.00

    Rum

    • Captain Tall

      $9.50

    • Captain Short

      $7.50

    • Bacardi Tall

      $9.50

    • Bacardi Short

      $7.50

    Sunday Brunch

    Brunch Entrees

    • Steak & Eggs

      $17.00

    • Pancakes

      $12.00

    • Biscuits & Gravy

      $14.00

    • Hangover Burger

      $16.00

    Drink Specials

    • Bottomless Bloody

      $25.00

    • Bottomless Mimosa

      $25.00

    • Rail Bloody

      $7.00

    • Mimosa

      $7.00
    All hours
    SundayClosed
    MondayClosed
    TuesdayClosed
    WednesdayClosed
    ThursdayClosed
    FridayClosed
    SaturdayClosed
    Restaurant info

    At The Old Fashioned Supper Club, we take pride in serving fresh, flavorful, scratch-made meals that delight our guests. Whether modern or Old Fashioned, supper clubs are all about creating a memorable, immersive evening. We hope you enjoy every moment of your time with us!

    Location

    3498 E HWY 33, West Bend, WI 53095

    Directions

    Similar restaurants in your area

    Dooley's 315 N. Main Street West Bend, WI
    View restaurantnext
    The Hive 526 Franklin Street
    View restaurantnext
    Between the Greens
    View restaurantnext
    Cadiville Bar and Grille
    View restaurantnext
    Gary's Place
    View restaurantnext
    No Way Cafe 403 S. Main Street
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook