This restaurant does not have any images
American
The Penny Pub 79 W Main Street
79 W Main Street
bay shore, NY 11706
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Food Menu
Appetizers
Boneless Wings
$15.00Breakfast quesadilla
Scrambled eggs, American cheese, Bacon and chipotle ranch. comes with spicy ketchup and sour cream.$14.00Breakfast Tots
$14.00
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla
breaded chicken dipped in sauce with ranch and sour cream$17.00
Buffalo Chicken Tots
bed of tots with mozzarella cheese and buffalo chicken with a ranch and buffalo drizzle$16.00Celery, carrots and blue cheese
$5.00
Chicken Tenders
traditional style with honey mustard$14.00French Onion Soup
$12.00Fried Pickles
fried pickle chips with a horseradish sauce for dipping$14.00
Homemade Fried Mac & Cheese
with chipotle ranch for dipping$16.00
Hotzarella Sticks
mozzarella sticks tossed in buffalo sauce with ranch for dipping$13.00
Irish Nachos
waffle fries smothered in mozzarella cheese$15.00
Irish Whiskey BBQ Chicken Quesadilla
breaded chicken dipped in sauce with ranch and sour cream$17.00
Jalapeno Poppers
breaded and filled with cream cheese and cheddar, with a side of sour cream$12.00
Large Wings (16)
$26.00Late Night Fries
waffle fries smothered in mozzarella cheese and guinness gravy$12.00Mozzarella Sticks
served with marinara sauce$12.00Not So Irish Penny Nachos
$15.00Onion Ring Tower
$14.00Parmesan Truffle Fries
$12.00Parmesan Truffle Tots
$13.00Penny Pretzels
eight pretzel sticks lightly salted with your choice of two dipping sauces$13.00
Quesadilla
with salsa and sour cream | add: chicken +3 steak +4 bacon +2$14.00
Small Wings (8)
$16.00Potato Soup
$12.00Steak Fries
a large portion of fries with choice of dipping sauces$10.00Sweet Potato Fries
$12.00Tater Tots
a large portion of fries with choice of dipping sauces$11.00Waffle Fries
a large portion of fries with choice of dipping sauces$11.00
Catering
1/2 Tray Cheeseburger Sliders (25)
$75.001/2 Tray Chicken Tenders
$60.001/2 Tray Chipotle Chicken Sliders (25)
$75.001/2 Tray Mac n Cheese Bites
$60.001/2 Tray Mozzarella Sticks
$50.001/2 Tray Pretzel Sticks
$50.001/2 Tray Steak Fries
$35.001/2 Tray Wings
$70.00Full Tray Cheeseburger Sliders (50)
$100.00Full Tray Chicken Tenders
$120.00Full Tray Chipotle Chicken Sliders (50)
$140.00Full Tray Steak Fries
$60.00Full Tray Wings
$140.00Private Party Pretzels
Private Party Wings
Private Party Quesadillas Steak
Private Party Salad
Private Party Penne Alla Vodka
Full tray Mozzarella Sticks
$100.00Full tray Mac n Cheese Bites
$120.00Full Tray Pretzels
$100.001\2 tray onion rings
$40.00Full tray onion rings
$80.001/2 tray waffle fries
$35.00Full tray Waffle fries
$70.001/2 tray Tots
$35.00Full tray Tots
$70.00
Desserts

Cheesecake
a slice of our seasonal cheesecake$10.00Chocolate Lava Cake w/ Vanilla Ice Cream
Chocolate lava cake with vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce and powdered sugar.$10.00
Churros Con Chocolate
six churros with chocolate dipping sauce$10.00Oreo Mousse Cake
The description says it all! its a cake made with Oreos. Do yourself a favor and get a slice! Seved with chocolate syrup and powdered sugar.$10.00
Dipping Sauce (Side)
Balsamic Dressing
$0.75+BBQ/Buffalo mixed
$0.75+Beer Cheese
$0.75+Bleu Cheese
$0.75+Brown Mustard
$0.75+Buffalo - Hot
$0.75+Buffalo - Medium
$0.75+Buffalo - Mild
$0.75+Buffalo/BBQ Mix
$0.75+Caesar Dressing
$0.75+Cajun Ranch
$0.75+Chipotle mayo
$0.75+Chipotle Ranch
$0.75+General Tso
$0.75+Guinness Gravy
$0.75+Honey BBQ
$0.75+Honey Mustard
$0.75+Horseradish Sauce
$0.75+Irish Whiskey BBQ
$0.75+Ketchup
$0.75+Marinara
$0.75+Mayo
$0.75+Ranch
$0.75+Ranch Dressing
$0.75+Russian Dressing
$0.75+Salsa
$0.75+Sour Cream
$0.75+Spicy Ketchup
$0.75+Sriracha Mayo
$0.75+Tartar Sauce
$0.75+Thai Chili
$0.75+Truffle Mayo
$0.75+Maple Mayo
$0.75+
Entrees
BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger
Our famous Penny burger topped with our homemade whiskey BBQ sauce, Monterey jack cheese, red onions and bacon.$20.00Chipotle Chicken Sandwich
breaded chicken cutlet, bacon, american cheese, chipotle slaw, and chipotle mayo on texas toast, served with a side of steak fries$20.00Deluxe Wrap
$18.00
Dublin Dip
marinated steak, sauteed onions, and irish cheddar on toasted garlic bread with guinness gravy sauce for dipping$20.00
Fish & Chips
beer battered cod and waffle fries with malt vinegar and tartar sauce$18.00
Grilled Chicken B.L.T.
with truffle mayonnaise on toasted french bread$20.00Hungryman Burger
Our famous Penny burger topped with American cheese, bacon, fried egg and Tator tots. Seved with a side of fries.$22.00
Irish Grilled Cheese
irish cheddar and bacon on texas toast with a side of guinness gravy$16.00Italian Stallion
Our famous Penny burger smothered in marina sauce, mozzarella cheese and mozzarella sticks. Served with a side of fries.$20.00Mac & Cheese
Our bestselling app homemade fried Mac & Cheese is now an entree! our mac is covered in Doritos crumbs and gets your choice of toppings!$16.00Mexi-Burger
Our famous Penny burger topped with Monterey jack cheese, fried jalapeno poppers and ranch dressing. Seved with a side of fries.$20.00
Penny Reuben
corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese, and russian dressing on grilled rye bread$20.00Texan Burger
$20.00
The B.E.C.
bacon, egg, and cheese on a brioche bun, served with a side of tots$15.00The Cheesiest Burger
Our famous Penny burger topped with every cheese we have in house, American, Irish cheddar, Monterey jack, Mozzarella and Swiss.$19.00
The Penny Burger
half pound certified angus beef burger on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, and red onion, served with a pickle | add american, monterey jack, mozzarella, swiss, sauteed onions, fried egg +1 | add irish cheddar +1.50 | add bacon, fried pickles +2$18.00Double Steak with Avocado
$21.00
Salads
Sliders
NFL SPECIALS
SUMMER SPECIAL SURF N TURF
PREAKNESS SPECIAL
All hours
| Sunday | 12:00 pm - 2:30 am |
| Monday | 12:00 pm - 2:30 am |
| Tuesday | 12:00 pm - 2:30 am |
| Wednesday | 12:00 pm - 2:30 am |
| Thursday | 12:00 pm - 3:00 am |
| Friday | 12:00 pm - 3:00 am |
| Saturday | 12:00 pm - 3:00 am |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.





