This restaurant does not have any images
American
Tony D's New Pal
5918 Dragon Drive
New Palestine, IN 46163
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
Chicken Wrap
Your choice of breaded or grilled chicken, rolled in a flour tortilla with lettuce, tomato, bacon, Monterey jack cheese and your choice of sauce$12.00Classic Cheese Pizza
Pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese$12.00Classic Cheese Burger
Half pound beef patty, topped with american cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle$13.00
Lunch/Dinner
Starters
Beer Battered Curds
White cheddar curds, coated in our savory beer batter and deep fried. Served with our house made sweet heat sauce and ranch.$10.00Boneless Wings (12)
Breaded and fried, served as either an 8 or 12 count and your choice of sauce$15.00Boneless Wings (8)
Boneless wings, breaded and fried, served as 8 count or 12 count and your choice of sauce.$10.00Brick Oven Breadsticks
Soft breadsticks baked in our lava brick oven, brushed with garlic butter and served with a side of nacho cheese and marinara$9.00Chips & Salsa
Homemade salsa and chips$6.00Loaded French Fries
Crispy french fries covered in nacho cheese, topped with bacon, diced tomatoes and green onions$11.00Pickle Fries
Delicious dill pickle fries, breaded and deep fried until golden brown. Served with our house made sweet heat sauce and ranch$10.00Pulled Pork Nachos
Tortilla chips topped with pulled pork, nacho cheese, diced tomatoes, bacon, green onions and drizzled with our house made BBQ$13.00Quesadilla
A flour tortilla stuffed with cheese, sauteed onions and green peppers and topped with green onion, diced tomato and served with a side of sour cream and our house-made salsa$9.00Traditional Wings (12)
Baked and broiled served with your choice of sauce$17.00Traditional Wings (8)
Baked and broiled served with your choice of sauce.$12.00Onion Rings Appetizer
Crispy, beer battered onion rings served with our house made sweet heat sauce and ranch$9.00
Brick Oven Pizza 11"
Classic Cheese Pizza
Pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese$12.00Barbecue Chicken Pizza
Barbecue sauce, mozzarella cheese, grilled chicken, red onions, and bacon bits$14.00Margherita Pizza
Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, grape tomatoes and fresh basil$13.00Tony's Signature Pizza
Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, ham, sausage, bacon and pepperoni$15.00The Works Pizza
$16.00Hawaiian Pizza
House made peach bourbon barbecue sauce, mozzarella cheese, diced ham, bacon and pineapple$15.50The Garden Pizza
Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, diced tomatoes, red onions, spinach and mushrooms$14.00
Salads
Hot Honey Fried Chicken Salad
Diced cucumbers, tomato, red onion, eggs, shredded Monterey jack cheese and our chicken strips coated in hot honey$16.00House Salad
Diced cucumber, tomato, red onion, shredded Monterey jack cheese, eggs and croutons$11.00Summer Salad
Strawberries, blueberries, feta cheese, & crunchy granola$15.00Chef Salad
Lettuce, Monterey jack cheese, smoked turkey, black forest ham, onion, cucumber, tomato, egg$15.00
Burgers
Bourbon Bacon Burger
Half pound beef patty, topped with cheddar cheese, our house made maple bacon jam and peach bourbon barbecue sauce all on a toasted brioche bun$16.00Classic Cheese Burger
Half pound beef patty, topped with american cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle$13.00Mushroom Swiss Burger
Sauteed mushrooms and swiss cheese melted on a half pound beef patty, served on a toasted brioche bun$14.00Patty Melt
Half pound beef patty, topped with sauteed onions, swiss cheese and thousand island dressing, sandwiched between two thick slices of Texas toast$14.00Vegan Black Bean Burger
Black bean burger topped with lettuce, tomato, fresh avocado and our house made sweet heat sauce$14.00
Entrees
Beef Manhattan
Mashed potatoes piled high and topped with sliced brisket and brown gravy on texas toast with your choice 1 side$16.00Catfish Dinner
Two catfish fillets breaded in our house-made cornmeal breading. Serve with tartar sauce, lemon slices and your choice of 2 sides$17.00Chicken & Dumplings Entree
Our house made chicken and dumplings served with your choice of 2 sides$14.00Chicken Strips
Fresh cut chicken tenderloins breaded and deep fried. Served with your choice of sauce and 1 side$13.00Fish N Chips
Hand battered cod in our house-made beer batter, cooked to perfection and served with steak cut french fries and coleslaw.$14.00Grilled Chicken Dinner
2 chicken breasts grilled and served with your choice of 2 sides$18.00Meatloaf
Homemade meatloaf served on a bed of mashed potatoes, topped with brown gravy and served with your choice of 1 side$16.00Salmon
Pan seared salmon served on a bed of brown rice, topped with maple bourbon glaze and your choice of 1 side$21.00Sirloin
Hand cut 8oz choice sirloin cooked to your desired temperature, topped with garlic herb butter and served with your choice of 2 sides$21.00Steak tips with Provolone
Sirloin tips cooked to your desired temperature, sauteed onions & mushrooms & topped with provolone. Served with your choice of 2 sides$18.00The Big Niemier
Hand cut 14 oz 21-day aged Prime ribeye cooked to your desired temperature, topped with garlic herb butter and served with your choice of 2 sides$32.00Spaghetti Dinner
$16.00
Sandwiches
BLT
Crispy bacon, lettuce, and juicy tomatoes layered between 2 pieces of sourdough toast$12.00Catfish Sandwich
A generous filet breaded in our house made cornmeal breading, deep fried and served on a toasted hoagie roll$12.00Chicken Salad Sandwich
Our house made chicken salad made with apples, dried cranberries and pecans, served on a toasted crossiant$12.00Chicken Wrap
Your choice of breaded or grilled chicken, rolled in a flour tortilla with lettuce, tomato, bacon, Monterey jack cheese and your choice of sauce$12.00Fried or Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Your choice of fried or grilled chicken, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle served on a toasted brioche bun$13.00Grilled Cheese
American cheese melted between two pieces of Texas toast.$9.00Hot Ham & Cheese
$12.00Philly Cheese Chicken
Thinly sliced grilled chicken with sauteed green bell peppers and onions, topped with provolone cheese served on a toasted hoagie roll.$12.00Philly Cheese Steak
Sauteed green peppers and onions, sliced brisket and melted provolone cheese on a toasted hoagie roll$12.00Philly Cheesesteak Wrap
Thinly sliced flank steak, sauteed green peppers and onions, and pepperjack cheese rolled in a flour tortilla$13.00Pulled Pork
BBQ pulled pork topped with pickles and house made coleslaw served on a toasted brioche bun$12.00Reuben
Marbled rye bread with sauerkraut, swiss cheese, thousand island dressing and sliced corned beef$14.00Tenderloin
Traditional Hoosier tenderloin, breaded or grilled. Served on a toasted brioche bun and topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle$14.00Veggie Wrap
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and monterey jack cheese rolled in a flour tortilla$10.00Club Sandwich
$15.00
Kids Menu
Kids Cheeseburger
Quarter pound beef patty topped with american cheese on a toasted bun$7.00Kids Dino Nuggies
Crispy dino nuggies served with your choice of dipping sauce$7.00Kids Grilled Cheese
American cheese melted between two slices of Texas toast$7.00Kids Mac & Cheese
House made cheddar mac & cheese$7.00Kids Pizza
6" round pizza topped with pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese. Add pepperoni or sausage for $1.00$7.00Kids Spaghetti
$7.00
Lunch/Dinner Special
A La Carte Sides
Broccoli
$5.00Chili
$5.00OUT OF STOCKColeslaw
$3.50Cottage Cheese
$3.50Fire Roasted Brussel Sprouts
$5.00Fire Roasted Street Corn
$5.00OUT OF STOCKFrench Fries Side
(Make your fries loaded for an additional $3.00)$3.50Fruit Cup
$5.00Green Beans
$3.50Mac & Cheese
$3.50Mashed Potatoes
$3.50Onion Rings Side
$5.00Potato Chips
$3.50Seasonal Soup
$5.00Side of Chicken & Dumplings
$3.50Side Salad
$5.00Side Tortilla Chips
$1.50Tater Tots
$3.50
Charged Sauces
1000 Island - 2 oz
$0.501000 Island - 4 oz
$1.00Balsamic - 2 oz
$0.50Balsamic - 4 oz
$1.00Bleu Cheese - 2 oz
$0.50Bleu Cheese - 4 oz
$1.00Brown Gravy
$1.50Buffalo - 2 oz
$0.50Buffalo - 4 oz
$1.00Carolina BBQ Sauce - 2 oz
$0.50Carolina BBQ Sauce - 4 oz
$1.00Country Gravy
$1.50French - 2 oz
$0.50French - 4 oz
$1.00Garlic Parmesan - 2 oz
$0.50Garlic Parmesan - 4 oz
$1.00Honey Mustard - 2 oz
$0.50Honey Mustard - 4 oz
$1.00Hot Honey - 2 oz
$0.50Hot Honey - 4 oz
$1.00Italian - 2 oz
$0.50Italian - 4 oz
$1.00Mango Habanero - 2 oz
$0.50Mango Habanero - 4 oz
$1.00Mild - 2 oz
$0.50Mild - 4 oz
$1.00Nacho Cheese
$1.50Peach Bourbon BBQ Sauce - 2 oz
$0.50Peach Bourbon BBQ Sauce - 4 oz
$1.00Pizza Sauce
$1.00Ranch - 2 oz
$0.50Ranch - 4 oz
$1.00Regular BBQ - 2 oz
$0.50Regular BBQ - 4 oz
$1.00Salsa - 2 oz
$0.50Salsa - 4 oz
$1.00Sour Cream - 2 oz
$0.50Sour Cream - 4 oz
$1.00Sweet Heat - 2 oz
$0.50Sweet Heat - 4 oz
$1.00Tartar - 2 oz
$0.50Tartar - 4 oz
$1.00
Beverages
Soft Drinks
Alert Energy
$3.00Coffee
$3.00Decaf Coffee
$3.00Diet Mountain Dew
$3.50Diet Pepsi
$3.50Dr Pepper
$3.50Flavored Lemonade
$3.50Grenadine
$0.50Homemade Lemonade
$3.50Hot Chocolate
$3.00Hot Tea
$3.00Kids Apple Juice Refill
$1.50Kids Chocolate Milk Refill
$1.50Kids Drink
$0.99Kids Milk Refill
$1.50Kids Orange Juice Refill
$1.50Kids Tomato Juice Refill
$1.50Large Apple Juice
$3.50Large Chocolate Milk
$3.50Large Cranberry Juice
$3.50Large Milk
$3.50Large Orange Juice
$4.00Large Tomato Juice
$4.00Mango Flavor
$0.50Mountain Dew
$3.50Pepsi
$3.50Pepsi Zero
$3.50Raspberry Flavor
$0.50Root Beer
$3.50Small Apple Juice
$2.50Small Chocolate Milk
$2.50Small Cranberry Juice
$2.50Small Milk
$2.50Small Orange Juice
$2.50Small Tomato Juice
$2.50Soda Water
Starry
$3.50Strawberry Flavor
$0.50Sweet Iced Tea
$3.50Unsweet Iced Tea
$3.50Water
Kids Spaghetti
$7.00
Customize your item
Kids Beverage
Required
Select 1
Choose 1 Side
Required
Select 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 8:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 8:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 8:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Thursday | 8:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Friday | 7:30 am - 8:30 pm |
| Saturday | 7:30 am - 8:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.


