Magpies Softserve Highland Park
Featured Items
- Choose 2 Flavors (Regular 9 ounces)$6.95
Chose any two flavors!
- Slice of Cookies & Cream Softserve Pie (Vegan)$9.95
Vanilla Bean Softserve layered with fudge & oreo cookies, topped with oreo whipped cream & chocolate crumble in a chocolate graham crust. - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Sweet Cream$5.95+
"Tastes like real sweetened whipped cream" - Dairy Base
Softserve
- Choose 2 Flavors (Regular 9 ounces)$6.95
Chose any two flavors!
- Corn Almond (Vegan)$5.95+
"Tastes like the remaining milk after eating Frosted Flakes" - Allergens: Nuts, Gluten - Almond Milk Base
- Mexican Hot Chocolate (Vegan)$5.95+
“Classic cinnamon drink made with Abuelita chocolate and spun into Softserve for a cold treat on warm days” - Oat Milk Base
- Swirl Corn Almond & Mexican Hot Chocolate (Vegan)$5.95+
"Tastes like the remaining milk after eating Frosted Flakes" +“Classic cinnamon drink made with Abuelita chocolate and spun into Softserve for a cold treat on warm days” - Allergens: Nuts, Gluten - Almond & Oat Milk Base
- Sweet Cream$5.95+
"Tastes like real sweetened whipped cream" - Dairy Base
- Malted Milk Chocolate$5.95+
"Tastes like the best chocolate malt shake ever!" - Allergens: Gluten - Dairy Base
- Swirl Sweet Cream & Malted Milk Chocolate$5.95+
"Tastes like real sweetened whipped cream" + "Tastes like the best chocolate malt shake ever!" - Allergens: Gluten - Dairy Base
- Passion Fruit Orange (Vegan)$5.95+
“Passion fruit offers sweet-tart, aromatic and slightly floral notes combined with the citrus of fresh squeezed orange juice. Take a trip to the tropics without a long flight!” -Oat Milk Base
- Brown Sugar Banana (Vegan)$5.95+
"This flavor draws inspiration from the classic Bananas Foster, where ripe bananas blend seamlessly with the rich caramel and molasses notes of brown sugar" -Oat Milk Base
- Swirl Passion Fruit Orange & Brown Sugar Banana (Vegan)$5.95+
“Passion fruit offers sweet-tart, aromatic and slightly floral notes combined with the citrus of fresh squeezed orange juice. Take a trip to the tropics without a long flight!” + "This flavor draws inspiration from the classic Bananas Foster, where ripe bananas blend seamlessly with the rich caramel and molasses notes of brown sugar" - Oat Milk Base
- Tiramisu$5.95+
"A rich and complex flavor profile marked by a perfect blend of sweet, creamy, and coffee notes, finished with a touch of rum for added depth” - Allergens: Dairy, Egg(Egg whites), Gluten - Milk Base
- Chocolate Pudding$5.95+
"Travel back to childhood memories with each spoonful of a chocolate pudding cup. Simple, indulgent, and rich with chocolate flavor!" - Allergens: Dairy - Milk Base
- Swirl Tiramisu & Chocolate Pudding (Dairy)$5.95+
"A rich and complex flavor profile marked by a perfect blend of sweet, creamy, and coffee notes, finished with a touch of rum for added depth" + "Travel back to childhood memories with each spoonful of a chocolate pudding cup. Simple, indulgent, and rich with chocolate flavor!" - Allergens: Dairy, Gluten, Egg (Egg whites) - Milk Base
- Roasted Strawberry (Vegan)$5.95+
“To intensify the flavor and bring out the natural sweetness, we slow roast strawberries down to a puree and then fold it into our Softserve base” - Oat Milk Base
- Horchata (Vegan)$5.95+
“Rice milk blended with vanilla, cinnamon and spun into delicious Softserve” - Rice Milk Base
- Swirl of Roasted Strawberry & Horchata (Vegan)$5.95+
“To intensify the flavor and bring out the natural sweetness, we slow roast strawberries down to a puree and then fold it into our Softserve base” + “Rice milk blended with vanilla, cinnamon and spun into delicious Softserve” - Oat Milk Base + Rice Milk Base
Slices of Softserve Pie
- Slice of Original Fried Softserve Pie (Vegan, Nuts)$9.95
Corn Almond Softserve layered with fudge, honeycomb, topped with whipped cream & fried candied corn flakes in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten, Nuts - Almond Milk Base
- Slice of Chocolate Cream Softserve Pie (Vegan)$9.95
Frozen Hot Chocolate Softserve layered with fudge, devils food cake, topped with whipped cream & chocolate sprinkles in a chocolate graham crust - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Slice of Strawberry Rhubarb Softserve Pie (Vegan)$9.95
Strawberry Rhubarb softserve layered with housemade rhubarb jam, brown sugar coffee cake, whipped cream, brown sugar crumble in a graham cracker crust. - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Slice of Cookies & Cream Softserve Pie (Vegan)$9.95
Vanilla Bean Softserve layered with fudge & oreo cookies, topped with oreo whipped cream & chocolate crumble in a chocolate graham crust. - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Slice of Mexican Hot Chocolate Softserve Pie (Vegan)$9.95
Mexican Hot Chocolate softserve layered with vegan fudge, brown sugar pound cake, layered with whipped cream, brown sugar crumble & cinnamon dust in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Slice of Banana Pudding Softserve Pie (Vegan)$9.95
Brown Sugar Banana Softserve layered with vanilla pound cake, topped with whipped cream, graham streusel & toasted almonds in a graham cracker crust. - Allergens: Gluten, Nuts - Oat Milk Base
Whole Softserve Pies
- Whole Original Fried Softserve Pie (Vegan, Nuts)$49.95
Corn Almond Softserve layered with fudge, honeycomb, topped with whipped cream and fried candied corn flakes in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten, Nuts - Almond Milk Base
- Whole Chocolate Cream Softserve Pie (Vegan)$49.95
Frozen Hot Chocolate Softserve layered with fudge, devils food cake, topped with whipped cream & chocolate sprinkles in a chocolate graham crust - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Whole Strawberry Rhubarb Softserve Pie (Vegan)$49.95
Strawberry Rhubarb softserve layered with housemade rhubarb jam, brown sugar coffee cake, whipped cream, brown sugar crumble in a graham cracker crust. - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Whole Cookies & Cream Softserve Pie (Vegan)$49.95
Vanilla Bean Softserve layered with fudge & oreo cookies, topped with oreo whipped cream & chocolate crumble in a chocolate graham crust. - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Whole Mexican Hot Chocolate Softserve Pie (Vegan)$49.95
Mexican Hot Chocolate softserve layered with vegan fudge, brown sugar pound cake, layered with whipped cream, brown sugar crumble & cinnamon dust in a graham cracker crust - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Whole Banana Pudding Softserve Pie (Vegan)$49.95
Brown Sugar Banana Softserve layered with vanilla pound cake, topped with whipped cream, graham streusel & toasted almonds in a graham cracker crust. - Allergens: Gluten, Nuts - Oat Milk Base
Softserve Pints (16 ounces)
- Almond Joy Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“Chocolate, coconut and almonds, the OG candy bar reimagined into Softserve” - Allergens: Nuts - Almond Milk Base + Coconut Milk Base
- Blueberry Pie Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“Tastes like the filling of a blueberry pie with cinnamon and vanilla” - Allergens: - Oat Milk Base
- Brown Sugar Banana Pint (Vegan)$11.95
"This flavor draws inspiration from the classic Bananas Foster, where ripe bananas blend seamlessly with the rich caramel and molasses notes of brown sugar" -Oat Milk Base
- Brown Sugar Vanilla Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“Tastes like chocolate chip cookie dough, minus the chocolate chips” -Oat Milk Base
- Brownie Batter Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“Tastes just like brownie batter before baking” - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Chili Mango Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“If you've ever experienced the pleasure of tasting fresh mango topped with tajin chili powder and lime at a roadside stand, then you're familiar with this delicious flavor fusion!” - Oat Milk Base
- Chocolate Pudding Pint$11.95
"Travel back to childhood memories with each spoonful of a chocolate pudding cup. Simple, indulgent, and rich with chocolate flavor!" - Allergens: Dairy - Milk Base
- Corn Almond Pint (Vegan)$11.95
"Tastes like the remaining milk after eating Frosted Flakes" - Allergens: Nuts (Almonds), Gluten - Almond Milk Base
- Horchata Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“Rice milk blended with vanilla, cinnamon and spun into delicious Softserve” - Rice Milk Base
- Humboldt Fog Pint$11.95
"The external layer of ash imparts a subtle earthiness that balances the tanginess of the goat cheese while honey adds sweetness” - Allergens: Dairy, Cheese - Milk Base
- Irish Coffee Pint (Vegan)$11.95
"Creamy, sweet, vanilla almond with a splash of Irish Whiskey" - Allergies: Nuts - Oat Milk Base + Almond Milk Base
- Key Lime Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“A delicious balance of sweet, tart, and creamy elements. Its standout feature is the key lime juice, sourced directly from the Florida Keys” - Oat Milk Base
- Malted Milk Chocolate Pint$11.95
“Our ‘House’ Chocolate, tastes like a malted milkshake” - Allergens: Gluten - Dairy Base
- Mexican Hot Chocolate Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“Classic cinnamon drink made with Abuelita chocolate and spun into Softserve for a cold treat on warm days” - Oat Milk Base
- Mocha (Vegan)$11.95
"Coffee & Chocolate latte" - Oat Milk Base
- Passion Fruit Orange Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“Passion fruit offers sweet-tart, aromatic and slightly floral notes combined with the citrus of fresh squeezed orange juice. Take a trip to the tropics without a long flight!” -Oat Milk Base
- Roasted Strawberry Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“To intensify the flavor and bring out the natural sweetness, we slow roast strawberries down to a puree and then fold it into our Softserve base” - Oat Milk Base
- Strawberry Banana Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“What do you get when a banana and strawberry walk into a Magpies and sit at the bar? You get the picture, or rather, the flavor!” - Oat Milk Base
- Strawberry Lemonade Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“Lemonade blended with strawberries creates a Softserve that is refreshing, tart and sweet. A perfect summer treat!” - Oat Milk Base
- Strawberry Shortcake Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“Slow cooked strawberries, cream, and buttery shortcake, a tasty spin on a OG classic” - Allergens: Gluten - Oat Milk Base
- Sweet Cream Pint$11.95
“Tastes like real whipped cream sweetened with sugar” - Dairy Base
- Swirl of Humboldt Fog & Blueberry Pie Pint (Dairy)$11.95Out of stock
“In my previous life as a fine dining executive chef, I loved composing cheese boards, and Humboldt Fog was one of my favorite goat cheeses paired with dried blueberries. The external layer of ash imparts a subtle earthiness that balances the tanginess, while the blueberries add a dark fruit sweetness. Does this push the boundaries of Softserve? Absolutely, but what fun it is!” - Allergens: Dairy - Dairy + Oat Milk Base
- Tiramisu Pint$11.95
"A rich and complex flavor profile marked by a perfect blend of sweet, creamy, and coffee notes, finished with a touch of rum for added depth” - Allergens: Dairy, Egg(Egg whites), Gluten - Milk Base
- Yuzu Pint (Vegan)$11.95
“Yuzu is a unique and distinctive citrus fruit native to East Asia. Its flavor is often described as a harmonious blend of lemon, lime, and mandarin” -Oat Milk Base