Mythical Pizza 1855 Valley Road, #200
Featured Items
- YOUR PIZZA. YOUR WAY. 13" Full Size Pizza$14.00
Customize YOUR PIZZA. YOUR WAY! Select your sauce, cheeses, toppings, edgers and finishes!
- Yeti's Pepperoni Pie (Standard Pepperoni Pizza)$14.00
Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds & Pepperoni
- YOUR SALAD. YOUR WAY.$14.00
Our Mythically HUGE 64oz Salad Bowls provide you a salad that is always made fresh to order! Our gigantic salad, custom made to your appetite!
Pizzas & Salads
Pizza & Salads
- YOUR PIZZA. YOUR WAY. 13" Full Size Pizza$14.00
Customize YOUR PIZZA. YOUR WAY! Select your sauce, cheeses, toppings, edgers and finishes!
- Grafton Monster Style DEEP DISH 10" Pizza$19.80
Our legendary 10" DEEP DISH pizza is full of melty cheese and your choice of toppings & a Loch Ness Garlic Edge, then covered in 8 ounces of Classic Marinara and Parmesan Cheese and baked to perfection!
- MEGA Munch Meal$6.00
TWO slices of our famous pizza and a 16.9oz Pepsi product for only $6! Available all day, every day!
- Individual Slices$2.25
Choose From Mozzarella Monster (Cheese), Yeti's Pepperoni Pie (Pepperoni) or our Mothman's Meaty Treat (Pepperoni, Ham & Sausage)
- 7" Personal Pizza - Baby Mothman$9.00
Personalize your meal! 7" Personal Pizza fully customized for your taste!
- 4" Mini Pizza - Baby SQUONK$5.00
KIDZ Rejoice! 4" Mini Pizza fully customized for your taste!
- YOUR SALAD. YOUR WAY.$14.00
Our Mythically HUGE 64oz Salad Bowls provide you a salad that is always made fresh to order! Our gigantic salad, custom made to your appetite!
- Baby Nessie's Personal Salad$9.00
Our personal size 24oz Salad Bowls are made fresh to order with our Arcadia lettuce blend and the ingredients you crave!
- The Flight of the Squonks$12.00
Select a flight of three of our Signature Pizzas in Baby Squonk's 4" mini form! Please note, while we'll accept special requests to remove certain ingredients, please no substitutions.
Signature Pizzas
- Mozzarella Monster (Standard Cheese Pizza)$14.00
Classic Marinara and Mozzarella Shreds
- Yeti's Pepperoni Pie (Standard Pepperoni Pizza)$14.00
Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds & Pepperoni
- Fast Times at Cheeseburger High$14.00
Classic Marinara, Cheddar Shreds, Ground Beef, Bacon, Green Pepper, Red Onion & Dill Pickles
- The Mothman Strikes Back$14.00
Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds, Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage. After Bake: Fresh Spinach & Barbecue Drizzle.
- Wyld Shaggyns$14.00
Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds, Bleu Cheese, Pepperoni, Sausage, Diced Tomato & Dill Pickles.
- E.T. The Extra-Toppings Supreme$14.00
Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds, Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Marinated Mushrooms, Red Onions, Green Peppers & Black Olives.
- Flatwood Bueller's Day Off$14.00
Classic Marinara, Mozzarella Shreds, Sliced Ham, Pineapple & Jalapeño Peppers.
- Balsamic S.T.R.I.P.E.S.$14.00
Classic Marinara, Fresh Mozzarella & Diced Tomato. After Bake: Fresh Spinach & Balsamic Glaze.
- Poultrygeist$14.00
Buffalo Sauce, Cheddar Shreds, White Meat Chicken, Banana Peppers & Jalapeño Peppers. After Bake: Ranch Drizzle.
- Krampus Story$14.00
Garlic Oil, Mozzarella Shreds, Whole Milk Ricotta, Steak Crumbles, Green Peppers, Marinated Mushrooms, Red Onion & Italian Seasoning.
- Smokey and the Bigfoot$14.00
Barbecue Sauce, Mozzarella Shreds, Cheddar Shreds, White Meat Chicken, Bacon, Green Peppers & Corn. After Bake: Barbecue Drizzle.
- Uncle Beak$14.00
Ranch, Mozzarella Shreds, White Meat Chicken, Bacon, Red Onion. After Bake: Fresh Spinach & Ranch Drizzle.
- Sprout-Man$14.00
Garlic Oil, Mozzarella Shreds, Bacon Crumbles, Feta Crumbles, Red Onion, Garlic Roasted Brussels Sprouts. After Bake: Balsamic Glaze.
- QUADZILLA - King of Pepperoni$14.00
Classic Marinara, SUPER MEGA PEPPERONI (that's a whopping 1/3 lb.). After Bake: Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle & Fine Red Pepper Dusting.
- Nightmare on Braxie Street$14.00
Alfredo, Mozzarella Shreds, Cheddar Shreds, Whole Milk Ricotta, Bacon, White Meat Chicken. After Bake: Fresh Spinach & Honey Sriracha Drizzle.
Surreal Sides
Snacks
- Skinwalker Slim Roll$7.25
Are you scared of the dark? The Skinwalker Slim Roll is the perfect companion to keep you safe. This roll includes our fresh dough wrapped around a pile of Mozzarella Shreds and Cheddar Dhreds, coated in Garlic Oil and dusted with our secret Parmesan and Garlic topping - served with a Dipperzzz of Choice!
- Mothman's Pepperoni Roll$8.50
The West Virginia staple now has a Cryptid Twist! Our fresh dough is wrapped around a pile of Pepperoni and Mozzarella Shreds, coated in Garlic Oil, and then baked to a golden brown, and dusted with our secret Parmesan and Garlic topping - served with a Dipperzzz of Choice!
- Hodag Monster Roll$9.25
A mixture of Wisconsin and West Virginia twists! Our fresh dough is wrapped around a carnivore treat, including Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham and Mozzarella Shreds, coated in Garlic Oil, then baked and dusted with our secret Parmesan and Garlic topping - served with a Dipperzzz of Choice!
- Thunderbird Roll$9.25
Whether you believe the Thunderbird is real or not, doesn't change the fact that this roll has it's own level of myth! Our fresh dough is wrapped around a sweet and smoky treat, including White Meat Chicken, Bacon, Ranch, Cheddar Shreds and Mozzarella Shreds, coated in Garlic Oil, then baked and dusted with our secret Parmesan and Garlic topping - served with a Dipperzzz of Choice!
- Jersey Devil Jalapeño Jolts$8.25
Experience the thrill of six tantalizing jalapeño bites, each brimming with a blend of spicy excitement and savory satisfaction. Nestled within is a molten medley of melty cheese, cocooned by our signature fresh dough that bakes to a perfect golden hue. Crafted to perfection, these devilishly delicious treats are served with a cool and creamy ranch dipper.
- Chupacabra Cheesesteak Chunks$8.50
Immerse yourself in the intrigue of six savory bites, each featuring succulent steak and rich cheddar cheese, lovingly enveloped in our signature fresh dough. Baked to perfection, these morsels offer a symphony of textures and tastes that embody both indulgence and adventure. Paired with a marinara dipper.
- Wendigo's Wicked Garlic Whirls$7.50
Indulge in the sinister allure of six expertly crafted garlic knots, fashioned from fresh dough and adorned with a captivating blend of garlic Parmesan seasoning. Each bite promises a whirlwind of savory satisfaction, with a perfect balance of warmth and zest that lingers on your palate. Paired with a marinara dipper.
- Yeti's Yummy Chicken Parm Portions$8.50
Discover the magic of six savory bites, each a masterpiece of tender chicken and rich mozzarella cheese, lovingly enveloped in our signature fresh dough. Baked to perfection, these portions offer a symphony of taste and texture in every bite. Paired with a marinara dipper.
BIG(FOOT) Breads
- Small Garlic Bread [No Cheese]$7.75
7" Personal Size: Garlic Oil, Fresh Garlic & our Signature Loch Ness Seasoning Blend
- Small Cheesy Garlic Bread$8.75
7" Personal Size: Garlic Oil, Fresh Garlic, Mozzarella Shreds & our Signature Loch Ness Seasoning Blend
- Large Cheesy Garlic Bread$12.75
13" Full Size: Garlic Oil, Fresh Garlic, Mozzarella Shreds & our Signature Loch Ness Seasoning Blend
- Large Garlic Bread [No Cheese]$11.75
13" Full Size: Garlic Oil, Fresh Garlic & our Signature Loch Ness Seasoning Blend
- Feta-n-Pesto Folded Bread$6.75
Hand-folded Fresh Dough, Pesto Sauce, Feta and Mozzarella Shreds. Drizzled lightly with Garlic Oil.
- Jalapeño-n-Cheese Folded Bread$6.75
Hand-folded Fresh Dough, Alfredo Sauce, Mozzarella Shreds and Jalapeños. Drizzled with Honey Sriracha.
- Buffalo-n-Bleu Folded Bread$6.75
Hand-folded Fresh Dough, Buffalo Sauce, Mozzarella & Bleu Cheese. Drizzled with Buffalo Sauce.
- Tomato-n-Balsamic Folded Bread$6.75
Hand-folded Fresh Dough, Minced Garlic, Mozzarella Shreds & Diced Tomatoes. Drizzled with Balsamic Glaze.
Drinks
- 16.9oz Pepsi Products$2.75+
- 2 Liter Pepsi Products$4.50
- Juice Box$1.50
Delicious, simple Apple Juice. No added sugar and 100% of the day's vitamin C in a juice box? If you won't tell the kids, we won't either.
- 16.9 oz Dasani Water$2.25
Redefine refreshment with Dasani Purified Water.
- *NEW* Cheat River Lemon-Lime$3.50
This citric refresher is the perfect way to quench any thirst! Lemon, lime and a hint of orange make this the best drink ever!
- Mothman's West Virginia SCREAM SODA (Cream Soda)$3.50
We use only the finest vanilla for the best vanilla cream soda!
- SQUONK (Raspberry Lime Rickey Soda)$3.50
Our unique north-eastern twist of a raspberry-lime rickey soda, or in layman's terms: a refreshing sparkling raspberry limeade!
- Perilous Pineapple$3.50
Our sweet tropical pineapple soda is made with real pineapple!
- Snallygaster Sweet Tea$3.50
Authentically brewed using real tea leaves and water and sweetened with real cane sugar.
- Fresno Nightcrawler Glowing Grape Soda$3.50
This provides a bold, fruity grape flavor. A fan favorite!
- Snarly Yow Strawberry Soda$3.50Out of stock
This sweet strawberry soda is sure to keep you focused on task!
- Bigfoot Brew Birch Beer$3.50
Our delightfully sharp, yet smooth minty taste is intensified with strong notes of sweet birch and minty wintergreen oil.
- Regulär Wolpentinger Weuzelbier (Root Beer)$3.50
Our award-winning root beer has hints of vanilla, anise and honey.
- Diät Wolpentinger Weuzelbier (Diet Root Beer)$3.50
Our diet version of our award-winning root beer has hints of vanilla, anise and honey.
- Flatwoods FANTAsie (Orange)$3.50
With just the right amount of sweet and tangy, our Flatwoods FANTAsie is the perfect soda for you.
- Jersey Devil Ginger Ale$3.50
This crisp and bubbly ginger ale is delicious and ready for quenching your thirst!
- Loveland Frogman Lemonade$3.50
Our lemonade is blasted full of lemon flavor and is extremely thirst-quenching!
- Sasquatch Sarsaparilla$3.50
Made with sassafras root extract and provides hints of licorice, caramel, vanilla and wintergreen.
Add-Ons & Extras
Desserts
- Chocolate Chip MONSTER Cookie$3.00
Our HUGE 1/4 LB. cookies are baked fresh in house every day featuring semi-sweet chocolate chunks & milk chocolate chunks.
- Chocolate Chip Cannoli$4.00
MADE TO ORDER! Our cannolis are out of this world!
- New York Style Cheesecake$3.50
Made with soft cheese, eggs, and sugar in the famous New York style of cheesecakes with a light graham cracker crust.
- Single Fresh Baked Mini-MONSTER Cookie$1.25
Looking for a lighter take on our MONSTER cookies? Try one of our MINI-MONSTER cookies instead! These are the same delicious cookies we serve with a HARPY MEAL!
- Chocolate Chip Brownie$3.00
A decadent chocolate chip brownie with dense, fudge texture and topped with semi-sweet chocolate morsels on top.
- Ginger Molasses MONSTER Cookie$2.00
Fall (get it?) in love with our tender, chewy molasses cookie with sweet spices of cinnamon and nutmeg and complimenting flavor of ginger and meticulously topped with sugar crystals!
- Salted Caramel MONSTER Cookie$3.00
A HUGE 1/4 LB. brown-sugar based dough cookies are accented with flakes of pure sea salt, caramel & toffee bits covered in milk chocolate.
Extras
- Sweet Chili Dipper$1.50
This flavor-packed sauce is made with red chili peppers and garlic for a balanced, sweet, tart, and slightly spicy taste.
- Garlic Parmesan Dipper$1.50
This flavor-packed sauce is made with parmesan cheese, garlic, vinegar, and salt for a rich, savory taste.
- Mike's Hot Honey Dipper$1.50
Made with 100% pure honey, real chili peppers, and tangy vinegar!
- 12oz Bottle of Mike's Hot Honey$13.99
Mike's Hot Honey is the original honey infused with chilies, a flavor combination of two of nature's most unique and delicious foods to drizzle on all your favorite foods.
- Dipper of Mythical Pizza's Honey Sriracha$1.50
Made with classic sriracha heat, red chili peppers, and honey sweetness, it's the perfect dipper for pizza!
- 14oz Bottle of Mythical Pizza's Honey Sriracha$13.99
Elevate your dishes with our infamous Mythical Pizza's 14oz Honey Sriracha Sauce. Made with classic sriracha heat, red chili peppers, and honey sweetness, it's perfect for any occasion.
- Dipper of Balsamic Glaze$1.50
This acidic, velvety liquid is a delicious add-on for any pizza or salad!
- Dipper of Barbecue Sauce$1.50
This deliciously thick and tangy-sweet barbecue adds a level of smokiness to any pizza!
- Dipper of Buffalo$1.50
Grab a side of the rich, buttery flavor of Buffalo! The heat is mild – but the flavor is anything but.
- Dipper of Classic Marinara$1.50
Our Vegan-Friendly Classic Marinara is ready to be your dipper of choice!
- Dipper of Pesto$1.50
Our nut-free basil pesto is the ultimate flavor dipper!
- Dipper of Ranch$1.50
This creamy and thick ranch dip is the ideal dipper for your favorite pizza!
- Parmesan Packet$0.08
Known as the King of Cheeses, with it’s buttery, fruity and nutty flavor, it is the perfect complement to every slice.
- Crushed Red Pepper Packet$0.08
Our fiery red flakes will add heat to any pizza, giving it that bite you crave.
- Oregano Packet$0.08
The aromatic, warm, slightly bitter taste is recognizable anywhere.
- Italian Spice Packet$0.08
A classic combination of oregano, basil, marjoram, garlic, thyme, savory and a dash of crushed red pepper for that extra kick.
- Garlic Packet$0.08
The unique, distinct pungent aroma and flavor pairs perfectly with any style pizza.
- Dressing Packet$1.00
Want to "dress" things up? Be it your salad, or your pizza, we're sure we have that right addition for your meal!