Pewter Spoon Cafe
FOOD
Breakfast Sandwiches
- SPECIAL: The Mabel Egg Sandwich$6.00
Fried local egg on toasted cheddar-oregano focaccia with local butter and Gouda cheese.
- Classic Egg Sandwich$5.00
Fried local egg, local butter, NY cheddar on toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich option!
- Peppery Egg Sandwich$6.00
Fried local egg, local butter, pepper jelly, roasted red peppers, NY provolone on toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich option!
- Southwestern Egg Sandwich$6.00
Fried local egg, chipotle aioli, bacon/vegetarian sausage, NY cheddar on toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich option!
- Swiss Egg Sandwich$6.00
Fried local egg, local butter, spinach, NY swiss on toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich option!
- Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich$4.00
Egg Scrambles
- Burrito Egg Scramble$7.00
Three local eggs, black beans, salsa, NY cheddar in a wrap or bowl. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Scramble option!
- Alpine Egg Scramble$7.50
Three local eggs, sautéed mushrooms, spinach, NY Swiss in a wrap or bowl. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Scramble option!
- Build Your Own Egg Scramble$5.50
Greens
- Mediterranean Greens$10.00
Lettuce, feta, olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, creamy tahini dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Granny Greens$10.00
Lettuce, apples, goat cheese, walnuts, raisins, homemade balsamic dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Chicken Caesar Greens$10.00
Romaine, chicken, tomatoes, homemade croutons, parmesan, caesar dressing. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Italian Market Greens$10.00
Lettuce, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, homemade croutons, italian dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Curried Chicken Salad Greens$10.00
Lettuce, chicken salad with raisins, pecans, celery, homemade balsamic dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Veggie Hummus Greens$10.00
Lettuce, homemade hummus, cherry tomatoes, roasted red peppers, roasted red onions, cucumbers, Italian dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Build Your Own Greens$6.50
Panini
- Caprese Panini$8.00
Pesto aioli, tomato, mozarella, balsamic dressing on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Garden Panini$9.00
Kalamata olive spread, roasted red peppers, roasted red onions, arugula, goat cheese OR homemade hummus on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Mushroom Panini$9.00
Sautéed mushrooms, roasted red onions, garlic aioli, arugula, NY swiss on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Chipotle Panini$10.00
Chicken, bacon, chipotle aioli, NY cheddar on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Grilled Cheese Panini$6.00
Local butter, NY cheddar cheese on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Pesto Chicken Panini$10.00
Chicken, pesto aioli, tomato, roasted red onion, arugula, NY provolone. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Build Your Own Panini$6.50
COFFEE, TEA, & OTHER DRINKS
Coffee
- SEASONAL: Ginger-Molasses Nitro Cold Brew$5.50
- Nitro Cold Brew$4.75
Our Gimme! cold brew on Nitro for a creamier mouthfeel and smooth flavor.
- Cold Brew$3.50+
Cold-brewed coffee using Stargazer Blend from Gimme! Coffee.
- 64 oz. Cold Brew Jug$16.00
24 HOURS NOTICE MAY BE REQUIRED! Depending on stock, we may not be able to guarantee same-day pickup.
- Drip Coffee$2.50+
Your choice of our house blend, Rally, or our featured brew of the week, both roasted by the folks at Gimme! Coffee in Ithaca. *PLEASE NOTE: We are not currently brewing decaf on drip. Try a decaf Americano or decaf cold brew instead!
- Cafe Au Lait$2.75+
Drip coffee with steamed milk.
- Pour Over$3.75
Specialized, slow-pour drip coffee using Rally Blend from Gimme! Coffee in Ithaca. Smooth, balanced, nutty medium roast.
- Espresso$2.75
1.5 oz double shot of Leftist Espresso Blend by Gimme! Coffee in Ithaca. Hints of dark chocolate, cherry, sweet toffee.
- Hot Americano$3.00
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with hot water.
- Iced Americano$3.25
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with cold water over ice.
- Macchiato$3.25
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso just slightly marked with steamed milk. *PLEASE NOTE: Our macchiatos are served in the traditional Italian style. Not to be confused with the large milky drink made by a big coffee franchise ;)
- Cortado$3.50
1.5 oz double shot of espresso with about 3 oz. steamed milk.
- Cappuccino$3.75
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with about 6.5 oz. steamed milk.
- 12 oz. Hot Latte$4.10
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with about 10.5 oz. steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Hot Latte$4.60
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with about 14.5 oz. steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Iced Latte$4.50
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with cold milk.
- 20 oz. Iced Latte$5.00
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with cold milk.
- 12 oz. Hot Mocha$4.60
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) and about 10 oz. steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Hot Mocha$5.10
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) and about 14 oz. steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Iced Mocha$5.00
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) and cold milk over ice.
- 20 oz. Iced Mocha$5.50
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) and cold milk over ice.
Tea
- Hot Tea$3.00
Hot loose-leaf teas from Samovar Tea Lounge in San Francisco.
- Black Iced Tea$2.50+
Unsweetened English Breakfast
- 12 oz. Hot Chai Latte$4.10
Homemade chai concentrate made with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, star anise, cardamom, caffeinated black tea, and sugar, with about 4 ounces steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Hot Chai Latte$4.60
Homemade chai concentrate made with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, star anise, cardamom, caffeinated black tea, and sugar, with about 6 ounces steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Iced Chai$4.50
Homemade chai concentrate made with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, star anise, cardamom, caffeinated black tea, and sugar, with cold milk over ice.
- 20 oz. Iced Chai$5.00
Homemade chai concentrate made with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, star anise, cardamom, caffeinated black tea, and sugar, with cold milk over ice.
- 12 oz. Hot Matcha Latte$4.60
Lightly sweetened matcha green tea powder with steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Hot Matcha Latte$5.10
Lightly sweetened matcha green tea powder with steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Iced Matcha Latte$5.00
Lightly sweetened matcha green tea powder with cold milk over ice.
- 20 oz. Iced Matcha Latte$5.50
Lightly sweetened matcha green tea powder with cold milk over ice.
- 12 oz. London Fog$4.10
Hot Earl Grey tea with vanilla syrup and steamed milk. Topped lightly with cinnamon.
- 16 oz. London Fog$4.60
Hot Earl Grey tea with vanilla syrup and steamed milk. Topped lightly with cinnamon.
Other
- San Pellegrino$2.50
- Water Bottle$2.25
- 8 oz. Hot Chocolate$2.50
Homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) with steamed milk.
- 12 oz. Hot Chocolate$3.00
Homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) with steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Hot Chocolate$3.50
Homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) with steamed milk.
- 8 oz. Steamer$2.25
Steamed milk with your choice of organic flavor shot. Lightly topped with cinnamon!
- 12 oz. Steamer$2.75
Steamed milk with your choice of organic flavor shot. Lightly topped with cinnamon!
- 16 oz. Steamer$3.00
Steamed milk with your choice of organic flavor shot. Lightly topped with cinnamon.
- 8 oz. Milk$2.00
- 8 oz. Chocolate Milk$2.25
Homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) with milk.
BEER, WINE, HARD CIDER
Wine
- Pinot Noir$8.00
Canned Oregon -- 12 oz. -- 13.5% ABV.
- Pinot Gris$8.00
Canned Oregon -- 12 oz. -- 12.5% ABV.
- Riesling Bottle$17.00
750mL bottle of Heron Hill Winery's Riesling, Finger Lakes, NY. This is a semi-dry white wine with notes of green apple, lime, cantaloupe, and green plum. *MUST PRESENT ID AT PICKUP*
- Chardonnay Bottle$16.00
750mL bottle of Maggio Family Vineyards' Chardonnay, Lodi, CA. This is a dry white wine with a vanilla and tropical fruit aroma. *MUST PRESENT ID AT PICKUP*
Beer
- Haus Lager$3.00
16 oz. light-bodied lager brewed in Utica, NY by Saranac/F.X. Matt Brewing Co. *MUST PRESENT ID AT PICKUP*
- Fika Stout$6.00
16 oz. Milk stout brewed with cholaca, cardamom with Gimme! Coffee & vanilla beans. Brewed by Nap Time Liquid Creations in Blauvelt, NY.
- Citra Session IPA$6.00
Common Roots Brewing Company - South Glens Falls, NY -- 16 oz. -- 5% ABV.
MERCH & RETAIL
Coffee Beans
- Base Layer (12oz.)$14.00
Tasting Notes: chocolate toffee, brown sugar, baking spice, cranberry cobbler.
- Brazil Cerrado (12oz.)$12.00
Tasting notes: rich toasted nuts, brown butter, dark cocoa finish
- Colombia La Primavera Decaf (12oz.)$15.00
DECAF. Rich and dense like sweet bread cocoa, currant, brown sugar.
- Guatemala Guaya'b (12oz.)$14.00
Milk chocolate, almond, cherry, tangerine.
- Rally Blend (12oz.)$16.50
This fairly traded organic blend is mild and smooth, with a comforting milk chocolate base. Crowd-pleasing flavor makes this the perfect blend to kickstart any rally. Tasting Notes: toasted hazelnut, dried cherry, milk chocolate
Loose Teas
Merchandise
- Indigo Blue 87 Albany St. Crewneck$22.00
Unisex
- Garnet 87 Albany St. Crewneck$22.00
Unisex
- Black 87 Albany St. T-Shirt$15.00
Unisex Gildan brand. 87 Albany St. design on front.
- Pewter Spoon Travel Mug$28.00
16 oz. Miir custom Pewter Spoon travel mug with medical grade stainless steel interior.
- Faded Blue Pewter Spoon Hat$20.00
- Faded Red Pewter Spoon Hat$20.00
- Red Logo T-Shirt$15.00
Unisex - Logo on front
- Black Logo T-Shirt$15.00
Logo on front.
- Light Grey Logo T-Shirt$15.00
X-Large unisex. Logo on front.
- Gimme! Coffee Iron-On Patch$2.00
- EcoJarz Reusable Cold Cup
Lids fit on any wide-mouth jar.
- Happy Roaster Camp Cup$25.00
12 oz. Miir custom Happy Roaster Camp Cup made with medical grade stainless steel.
- Gimme! Coffee Travel Tumbler$25.00
12 oz. Double-Wall Vacuum Insulated Thermos.
- 32 oz. Cold Brew Growler$8.00
32 oz. Cold Brew Growler with Gimme! Coffee design
- 32 oz. Cold Brew Growler$8.00
with Gimme! Coffee design.