The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
Food
Pies
- Large Pie$20.95
- Sicilian Pie$23.95
- Grandma Pie$23.95
- The Bay Shore Pie$28.95
Our version of a Magherita Pie. Olive oil curst with fresh mozzarella, pizza sauce and parmesan cheese.
- Vodka Margarita Pie$28.95
Olive oil crust topped with fresh mozzarella cheese, vodka sauce and parmesan cheese.
- Tri-Fecta Pie$28.95
Olive oil crust with fresh mozzarella cheese. Topped with pizza sauce, vodka sauce and pesto.
- Bar Pie$28.95
Olive oil crust with pizza sauce and light mozzarella cheese. Topped with hot honey and dollops of burrata cheese.
- The Uncle Benny$31.95
Olive oil crust with light pizza sauce and fresh mozzarella. Topped with crumbled sausage, cup and char pepperoni, hot honey and fresh basil.
- The Honey Pep Pie$29.95
Sicilian pie topped with cup and char pepperoni, hot honey and fresh basil.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie$31.95
Breaded Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Crispy Bacon and Ranch Dressing
- White Pie$28.95
Square Pie w/Ricotta, Mascarpone, Mozz & Truffle Oil
- Crumbling Vodka Pie$29.95
Grandma crust with fresh mozzarella cheese, crumbled sausage and seasoned vodka sauce.
- Upside Down Caputo Pie$27.95
Our updated upside down pie featuring fresh mozzarella under seasoned marinara sauce and olive oil drizzle
- Buffalo Chicken Pie$31.95
Marinated Buffalo Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Buffalo Sauce
- Thai Chili Chicken Pie$29.95
Thai Chili Sauce on Pizza? Yes, Trust Us
- Bruschetta Pie$32.95
Balsamic Infused Crust, Cherry Tomatoes, Burrata & Glaze
- Meat Ball Burrata Pie$29.95
Meatballs, Burrata, Basil & Red Sauce
- Salad Pie$29.95
Slices
- Regular Slice$3.50
- Sicilian Slice$3.68
- Grandma Slice$3.68
- Bay Shore Slice$5.50
- Vodka Margherita Slice$5.50
- Trifecta Slice$5.50
- Bar Slice$5.50
- Uncle Benny Slice$5.50
- The Honey Pep Slice$5.50
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice$5.50
- White Slice$5.50
- Crumbling Vodka$5.50
- Caputo Slice$5.50
- Buffalo Chicken Slice$5.50
- Thai Chili Chicken Slice$5.50
- Bruschetta Slice$5.50
- Meat Ball Burrata Slice$5.50
- Gigi bear$5.50
- Salad Slice$7.50
Personal Pies
Starters
- Garlic Knots
No Order is Complete Without Them
- Buffalo Knots
Knots Tossed in our Specially Formulated Buffalo Sauce. These are Special.
- Pepperoni Pinwheel$4.50
Cup and Char Pepperoni with Mozz Cheese twirled in our Fresh Dough
- Broccoli Pinwheel$4.50
Broccoli, Cheddar, Mozz & Freshly Chopped Garlic all wrapped up
- Rice Ball$1.95
Risotto, Chop Meat, Mozz Cheese and Red Sauce. (No Peas)
- Chicken Roll$10.95
Breaded Chicken Cutlets w/Mozz Cheese, Red Sauce and Seasonings
- Side Meatballs$11.95
- Garlic Bread w/Mozzarella$6.95
- Mozzarella Sticks$10.95
- Fried Ravioli$10.95
Breaded Ravioli w/ Vodka Sauce to Dip
- Wings$15.95
10 Wings Per Order
- Ricotta Toast$12.00
Whipped Ricotta with honey drizzle and lemon zest on rustic ciabatta bread
- Burrata Rustica$14.00
Grilled rustic ciabatta, olive oil, arugula, burrata cheese and cherry tomatoes
- Calamari$17.00
Traditional, Thai Chili or Buffalo Style
- Traditional Calzone$10.95
- Crumble SG\Roni Calzone$14.00
- Arancini$10.00
Heros, Sandwiches & Wraps
- Chicken Parm Hero$13.95
- Eggplant Parm Hero$13.95
- Meatball Parm Hero$13.95
- Shrimp Parm Hero$13.95
- THE Hero$15.95
Chicken or Meatball with Burrata, Fresh Basil, Olive Oil & Shaved Parmesan on Seeded Semolina Bread
- Sausage & Pepper Parm Hero$13.95
- Sausage Parm Hero$13.95
- Fresh Focaccia Prosciutto Sandwich$13.95
Prosciutto, Fresh Mozz, Tomato, Basil, Olive Oil on Freshly Made Focaccia
- Fresh Focaccia Pesto Chicken Sandwich$13.95
Freshly Made Focaccia w/ Grilled Chicken, Pesto, Fresh Mozz & Roasted Peppers
- Fresh Focaccia Caprese Sandwich$11.95
- Chicken Ceaser Wrap$10.95
- Pizzeria Chicken Wrap$10.95Out of stock
Breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, arugula and balsamic glaze on our freshly baked warp
Salads
- House Salad$13.95
Mixed Field Greens, Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onion, Cucumbers, Freshly Made Croutons & Mozz Cheese
- Caesar Salad$14.95
Romain, Shaved Parmesan cheese, Parm Crisps and Croutons
- THE Salad$15.95
Field Greens, Honey Crisp Apple Sticks, Cherry Tomatoes, Croutons, Candied Pecans, Parm Crisps and Cheddar Cheese
- Side House Salad$9.95
- Side Caesar Salad$9.95
Pastas
- Penne Alla Vodka$19.95
- Beggars' Purses$19.95
5 cheese filled pasta pouches with vodka sauce and crumbled spicy sausage
- The Mezzi Rig$19.95
Mini rigatoni pasta with seasoned vodka sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
- Broccoli Rabe Pasta$19.95
Orecchiette pasta with crumbed sausage, garlic and broccoli rabe
- Baked Ziti$17.95
- Pasta with Meatballs$19.95
- Spaghetti With Tomato Sauce$13.00
- Pasta With Butter$9.00
- Small Pasta with Red Sauce$8.00
- Penne Broccoli and Garlic Oil$16.00
- Cacio E Pepe$18.00