American
Boichik Bagels College Ave
Featured Items
Bagels
Bagels
(as-is, in a bag)
Everything
$3.25
Plain
$3.25OUT OF STOCK
Sesame
Bagel$3.25
Poppy
$3.25
Onion
Bagel$3.25OUT OF STOCK
Salt
Bagel$3.25OUT OF STOCK
Salt & Pepper
Bagel$3.25
Egg
Bagel$3.25
Eggything
Bagel$3.25
Garlic
$3.25
Pumpernickel
Bagel$3.25
Pump Caraway Salt
Bagel$3.25
Pumperthingle
Bagel$3.25OUT OF STOCK
Cinnamon Raisin
Bagel$3.25
Bialy
Cousin to the bagel, a bialy is more savory and focaccia-like, topped with sauteed onions and poppy seeds.$3.25
GF Everything
Original Sunshine Everything bagels, made from gluten-free wheat starch. (Note that once we handle it out of the bag, it will be exposed to gluten.)$4.25
GF Plain
Original Sunshine Plain bagels, made from gluten-free wheat starch. (Note that once we handle it out of the bag, it will be exposed to gluten.)$4.25**SLICE ALL**
Online dozens
(as-is, in a bag)
Grab N Go
Plain CC
8 oz$6.00
Chive CC
8 oz$7.00
Lox CC
8 oz$9.00
Horse Cheddar CC
Horseradish Cheddar Scallion Cream Cheese 8 oz$7.00
Pink CC
Our recreation of TempTee in NY. Semi-cultured, so cheesier! 8 oz$7.00
Hatch Chile CC
8 oz$7.00
Sundried Tomato and Pesto CC
$8.00
Green Garlic CC
$8.00OUT OF STOCK
Strawberry CC
$10.00
Whitefish Salad
Salad$13.99
Egg Salad
$10.75
Tuna Salad
$8.50
Kite Hill (V)
Vegan almond-based cream cheese. 8 oz$8.00
Nova Lox (4oz)
$12.99
Nova Lox (8oz)
$21.99
B&W Cookie
$4.50
Challah
$12.00
Nova Lox (16oz)
$38.99
Nutella Packet
$1.00
Pastrami Lox (4oz)
$13.99OUT OF STOCK
Kippered Salmon
Rich, flaky, and smoked to perfection. Perfect for a bagel, or salad. approx. 8oz$18.99
Bagel Chips
$8.00
Vegemite packet
$1.00Mike's Hot Honey cup
$1.50
Sandwiches
Sandwich
(putting anything on the bagel)
Beverages
Hot Coffee
12 oz$3.75
Iced Coffee
$3.75
Choco Malt Coffee
Our signature iced coffee. Ghirardelli chocolate sauce, the same organic malt syrup we use for our bagels, our Mother Tongue coffee, and half and half. (Or swap for oat or 2%) Yum!$4.75
OJ 12oz
$6.00Sparkling Water
Beverage - 11oz Perrier$3.00
Hot Tea
$2.00
Iced Tea
$3.50
Iced Matcha
$6.00
Sanka Decaf
Yes, Sanka! Just like your grandmother enjoyed. Actually it's good if you make it 50% stronger.$2.25
Grapefruit 12oz
$4.50OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Lemonade 12oz
$6.00
YooHoo
6.5 oz in a drink box$2.00
Black Cherry Soda
$3.50
Cream Soda
$3.50
Cel-Ray Soda
$3.50
Whole Bean Coffee (1 lb.)
Mother Tongue Nebula Dark Roast whole bean 16 oz$19.00OUT OF STOCKCup of Water
$0.25Cup of Ice
$0.25
Merch
Bandana
$10.00
Cooler Bag (blue)
$12.00
Trucker Hat
$25.00
Dad Hat
$20.00OUT OF STOCKPride Hat Black
$30.00OUT OF STOCK
T-Shirt
Merch$20.00
Baby/toddler
$15.00
Mug (ceramic)
Merch$12.00
Hologram Sticker
$2.00
Hoodie
Merch$45.00
Schmear Knife
$6.50
Tote Bag (white canvas)
Merch$12.00
Shoe Charm
$5.00OUT OF STOCK
Magnet
$2.00Dog Toy
$12.00Beanie
$20.00OUT OF STOCK
Everything Spice Jar
Our blend of onion, sesame, poppy, and Maldon salt$6.50
Spice Gift Box
$16.00
Pin
$5.00Pride Holo sticker
$2.00
Greeting Card - Everything
You Are My Everything greeting card$5.00
Greeting card - Lox
Love You Lox greeting card$5.00
Greeting Card - Birthday
Birthday Bagel greeting card$5.00OUT OF STOCK
Greeting Card - Thanks
Thanks A Lox greeting card$5.00
Greeting Card - Congrats
Congrats On Your Little Bageleh greeting card$5.00Patch
Iron- on bagel patch$5.00Travel Mug
Merch$20.00OUT OF STOCKBeanie Bagel
$12.00
Frozen Packs
Frozen 6-pk Everything
$18.00OUT OF STOCK
Frozen 6-pk Plain
$18.00OUT OF STOCK
Frozen 6-pk Mixed
Pick Six Mix frozen 6 pack.$18.00OUT OF STOCK
Frozen 6-pk Sesame
$18.00OUT OF STOCK
Frozen 6-pk S & P
$18.00
Frozen 6-pk Cinnamon Raisin
$18.00OUT OF STOCK
Frozen 6-pk Pumpernickel Mix
$18.00OUT OF STOCK
Frozen 3-pack Bialy
$9.00OUT OF STOCK
Frozen 6-pk Gluten Free Everything
Original Sunshine Everything Bagels, made from gluten-free wheat starch. This is a sealed 6-pack with zero contamination from other products.$24.00OUT OF STOCKFrozen 6-pk Gluten Free Plain
Original Sunshine Plain Bagels, made from gluten-free wheat starch. This is a sealed 6-pack with zero contamination from other products.$24.00
Bagel
Egg
$3.25
Bagel
1
All hours
| Sunday | 7:45 am - 1:15 pm |
| Monday | 7:45 am - 1:15 pm |
| Tuesday | 7:45 am - 1:15 pm |
| Wednesday | 7:45 am - 1:15 pm |
| Thursday | 7:45 am - 1:15 pm |
| Friday | 7:45 am - 1:15 pm |
| Saturday | 7:45 am - 1:15 pm |
Restaurant info
Serious New York style bagels
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
