
Pizza
Bagels By Jarrett 451 Mt Pleasant Ave
451 Mt Pleasant Ave
West Orange, NJ 07052
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Lunch & Dinner
New Sicilian Pizzas

Plain Sicilian Pizza (toppings available)
Super light and crispy Sicilian pizza dough. Plum tomato sauce, cheese blend, basil, grated parm.$28.00
White Spinach Garlic Sicilian Pizza
Super light and crispy Sicilian pizza dough. ricotta con latte, our cheese blend, chopped spinach, garlic, grated parm.$33.00
Pepperoni Cup, Ricotta, Hot Honey Sicilian Pizza
Super light and crispy Sicilian pizza dough. house tomato sauce, cheese blend, pepperoni cups, house made hot honey, ricotta, basil$35.00
White Broccoli Sicilian Pizza
Super light and crispy Sicilian pizza dough. ricotta con latte, ricotta impastata, broccoli, garlic, grated parm.$32.00
Buffalo Chicken Roni Sicilian Pizza
Super light and crispy Sicilian pizza dough. house made buffalo sauce, lawsuit chicken (house made boneless fried chicken), cheese blend, pepperoni cups, ranch drizzle$35.00
Drunken Chicken Parm Sicilian Pizza
Super light and crispy Sicilian pizza dough topped with vodka sauce, lawsuit chicken (house made boneless buttermilk fried chicken), cheese blend and fresh mozzarella, basil.$34.00
Pizza Bombs & Pinwheels

Spinach and Garlic Pizza Bomb
Pizza dough filled with sautéed garlic spinach and cheese$8.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Bomb
Pizza dough filled with buffalo lawsuit chicken and cheese$8.00
Chicken Parm Pizza Bomb
pizza dough filled with chicken cutlet, sauce and cheese$8.00
Pepperoni Pizza Bomb
Pizza dough stuffed with cheese, pepperoni and marinara sauce.$8.00
Sausage, Peppers & Onion Pizza Bomb
pizza dough stuffed with sautéed peppers, onions, sausage and cheese.$8.00
Eggplant Rollatini Pizza Bomb
Pizza dough filled with breaded eggplant, marinara, mozzarella and ricotta. No modifications.$8.00
Pepperoni Pinwheels
(3 per order) pizza dough pinwheels stuffed with pepperoni, onion and our cheese blend. served with a side of marinara$12.00
White Spinach Garlic Pinwheels
(3 per order) pizza dough pinwheels stuffed spinach, garlic and our cheese blend. served with a side of marinara$12.00
Chicken Parm Pinwheels
(3 per order) pizza dough pinwheels stuffed with breaded chicken cutlet and cheese blend. served with a side of marinara$12.00
New 16" Pizza (cooked well done)

Plain Pizza
16" pizza crust topped with sauce and our cheese blend.$21.00
Meatball Ricotta Pizza
16" Pizzeria Style pie topped with marinara, house made meatballs, ricotta con latte and our cheese blend$25.00
Sausage Peppers & Onion Pizza
16" Pizzeria style pie with marinara, thinly sliced sweet sausage, peppers and onions, cheese blend$25.00
Chicken Francese Pizza
16" pizzeria style dough, lemon and white wine sauce, diced chicken, cheese blend.$25.00
White Cutlet Roni
16" pizzeria style pie with a ricotta base, cheese blend, sliced breaded chicken cutlets, pepperoni and marinara splats$25.00
Eggplant Rollatini Pizza
16” pizzeria style pizza, breaded eggplant, cheese blend and ricotta. Topped with basil$25.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
16" Pizzeria style dough, house made buffalo sauce, boneless buttermilk fried chicken, cheese blend, ranch drizzle$25.00
Margarita Pizza
our new pizzeria style crust, 16” pie with house made marinara, thinly slice tomato, house made fresh mozz, basil, grated parm$25.00
Pepperoni Lovers Pizza
16” pizzeria style pizza with deli style pepperoni and ricotta dollops topped with fresh basil$25.00
Meat Lovers Pizza
16" Pizzeria style pie topped with pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, marinara, ricotta and our cheese blend$27.00
Chicken Parm Pizza
16" 4 day fermentation dough topped with chicken cutlet, ricotta, marinara and our cheese blend.$25.00Veggie Pizza
16" dough with marinara, spinach, chopped tomato, broccoli and garlic$23.00I Love Ricotta Pizza
16" Pizzeria style pie topped with 2 types of ricotta (ricotta con latte & ricotta impastata) as well as our cheese blend.$25.00The White Pizza
16" Pizzeria style pie, ricotta con latte base topped with our cheese blend, caramelized onions and fresh cracked pepper. This is the white roundish pie as a pizzeria style pie.$25.00Vodka Meatball Pizza
16" Pizzeria style pie, vodka sauce, house made meatballs, cheese blend and spinach$25.00
White Broccoli Garlic Pizza
16" Pizzeria style pie with ricotta con latte, broccoli, cheese blend$25.00
My Ode to the Artichoke Pizza
My ode to artichoke basils pie, 16" Pizzeria style pie with a creamy white sauce, artichokes and our cheese blend$26.00
Lord's Caesar Pizza
16" pizzeria style crust, marinara, caesar salad #Trustme$25.00
Family Dinner Packages
Pre-fixe family dinner with add on options
Starters

Burrata Starter
4oz Burrata, garlic toast, sliced plum tomato, red onion and house made balsamic vinaigrette$12.00
Lords Caesar Salad
A generous portion of our homemade Caesar salad$17.00
Bread Service
house made bread with house made salted whipped butter$6.00
Donut in Carrozza
Mozzarella in Carrozza but utilizing a donut (no glaze or anything) with mozzarella in the middle. Served with a 2oz side of marinara. #TrustMe$6.00
Bruschetta Starter
(3 pieces per order) - garlic toast, garlic spread, tomato, onion and basil. It Rocks!$7.00
Buffalo Chicken Dip
house made buffalo chicken dip with shredded chicken, buffalo sauce and a cheese blend. served with tortilla chips.$12.00
Melanzane al Forno
Thin layers of eggplant, new plum tomato sauce, house grated parmesan, basil$16.00OUT OF STOCK
Counter Chicken
2 freshly breaded chicken cutlets with your choice of 2 free dipping sauces$17.00
Meatball Platter
2 per order - 4oz all beef meatballs in marinara, topped with ricotta$14.00
Shrimp Marsala Starter
7 jumbo shrimp in our house made marsala wine sauce. Touch of sweetness, perfectly tender shrimp.$14.00
BXJ Chili
topped with cheddar cheese, sour cream and scallions$12.00
Dips & Dogs
(8) pigs in the blanket & (8) mini corn dogs served with chili & warm cheese sauce$22.00
Zesty Ranch Side Salad
iceberg lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, cheddar cheese, bagel chips and a side of house made zesty ranch dressing$8.00
BXJ Asian Chopped Salad
romaine, shredded carrots, cucumber, red onion, grape tomato and crunchy thingies (gf) in a house made ginger carrot dressing$11.00
Prosciutto & Mozz Platter
house made fresh mozz, prosciutto, tomato, roasted red peppers served with a side of house made balsamic vinaigrette$18.00
6 Garlic Knots with 2oz Marinara
6 garlic knots, served with marinara$6.00
The Mini Corn Dog Nuggets You May Have Had...
(8 per order) corn dog battered mini hotdogs served with your choice of dipping sauce.$12.00
Pigs in a blanket
(8 per order) the most puffy pastry pigs in the blanket of your life served with either spicy ketchup or creamy honey mustard. you do you.$10.00
Burrata Salad
baby spinach, roasted red peppers and tomato tossed in our infused EVOO and topped with a 4oz ball of burrata and balsamic glaze$20.00
Sausage, Long Hots, Potatoes and broccoli rabe
white wine, garlic, grana - add grilled onions if you’re smart$14.00
Tipsy Sticks
(15 per order) mini breaded fresh mozz mozzarella sticks, served with marinara, ranch and pesto$15.00
Homemade Potato Chips & Dip
New potato chip recipe with freshly fried chips & veggie dip$12.00
Cheesy Garlic Bread
New sesame bread topped with our buttery garlic mixture and cheese blend. Served with a 4 oz side of homemade marinara$14.00
Mozzarella Sticks
8 thick cut battered mozzarella sticks with a side of homemade sweet basil marinara$12.00
Fresh Mozz Planks
4 per order. Housemade fresh Mozz, breaded and deep-fried. Served with a side of sweet basil marinara$14.00
House Breaded Fried Ravioli
5 per order. Large square cheese ravioli hand-breaded, deep-fried, and served with our sweet basil marinara sauce$14.00
Buffalo Chicken Rangoons
(6 per order) Buttery flaky dough with all white meat buffalo chicken inside, served with ranch or blue cheese.$12.00
Charred Brussels
Basically brussels sprout candy, sweet, tiny bit of red chili flake$14.00
Pepperoni Garlic Bread
New sesame bread, garlic mixture, cheese blend, pepperoni, served with a side of marinara$15.00
Meatball Sliders
(2 per order) homemade all beef meatballs, toasted garlic potato bun, ricotta impastata, marinara & cheese blend. #TrustMe$15.00
Chicken Parm Sliders
(2 per order) chicken cutlets, toasted garlic potato bun, ricotta impastata, marinara & cheese blend$15.00
Eggplant Parm Sliders
(2 per order) Thinly sliced, breaded and fried eggplant, toasted garlic potato bun, ricotta impastata, marinara & cheese blend$15.00
Scully’s Coconut Shrimp
(6 per order) butterflied and breaded tender shrimp, bravo if you get the name reference. Served with sweet thai dipping sauce$14.00
Chicken Caesar Croissant
freshly baked croissant, blackened grilled chicken, lord’s caesar$17.00
Chicken Parm Croissant
Chicken cutlet, marinara, mozzarella, touch of pesto on a freshly baked croissant topped with parm$17.00
Pommes Frites
Oven roasted seasoned potatoes with the best Pommes Frites dipping sauce you've ever had$10.00
Francese Wings
6 per order - a mix of flats and drums in a house made Francese sauce with a tiny amount of kick$12.00
Homemade Pasta (all pasta is made in house)

Steakhouse Tortellini
(8 tortellini per order) house made cheese tortellini and filet mignon in a creamy Parmesan sauce with spinach.$23.00
Tortellini Francese
5 jumbo house made lemon ricotta tortellini, chicken francese chunks and spinach in our house made lemon and white wine sauce. It's phenomenal.$17.00
SPO Ravioli
(8 per order) house made ravioli stuffed with our cheese blend, sausage, peppers & onions In our Acqua di Pomodoro sauce.$22.00
BXJ Lasagna
A 1 pound piece of homemade lasagna. House made pasta sheets, layers of seasoned meat, plum tomato sauce and our cheese blend.$23.00OUT OF STOCK
Truffle Tagliatelle
House made ribbon pasta in a truffle cream sauce. We do not use truffle oil in our sauces cause that's gross.$21.00
Drunken Roni Rigatoni (Large Portion)
house made rigatoni, vodka sauce, lawsuit fried chicken, pepperoni cups$24.00
College Ravioli
(8 per order) house made ravioli stuffed with a mix of cheese & college meat served In a marinara sauce$23.00
Fettuccine Alfredo (large portion)
House made ribbon pasta with blackened chicken and broccoli tossed In a cream sauce made with 24 month aged Parmesan.$23.00
Ravioli Acqua di Pomodoro
(8 per order) house made spinach and cheese ravioli in a tomato & butter emulsion$22.00
Homemade Cheese Ravioli Starter (4 pieces)
(4 per order) house made cheese and spinach ravioli in a sauce of your choice.$14.00
Homemade Ricotta Gnocchi
super light in house made gnocchi in a sauce of your choice$18.00
Rigatoni Limone
House made rigatoni in our creamy lemon sauce. Add shrimp or chicken$16.00
College Radiatore
House made radiatore pasta in our college all beef meat sauce.$20.00
Short Rib Bucatini
house made bucatini- short rib bolognese (8 hour slow cook with both bone-in short rib and ground short rib)$23.00
Wendy's Capellini
super thin house made pasta, tender chicken & broccoli In a white wine & garlic sauce (no cream)$18.00
Spicy Orecchiette
house made Orecchiette & chicken in a roasted red pepper, Calabrian chili & vodka sauce$21.00
Shrimp Capellini
house made thin pasta, shrimp, lemon butter wine sauce, chili flake, parsley$22.00
Fettuccine Acqua di Pomodoro
A delicate dish made from slow cooked campari tomatoes and butter served with light house made fettuccine$17.00
Sunday Sauce Tagliatelle
House made ribbon pasta with short rib, meatball and sausage. Topped with ricotta cheese$25.00
Drunken College Lumache
house made Lumache pasta (curved rigatoni) in a vodka (all beef) meat sauce. Warms the soul$18.00
Tagliatelle Marsala
house made ribbon pasta tossed with tender chunks of chicken and mushrooms in a marsala sauce. Shrimp available as well$20.00
Spicy Calabrian Rigatoni Vodka
house made rigatoni on a spicy Calabrian chili vodka sauce - no peas, don't you worry$21.00
Baked Ziti
House made rigatoni, marinara and ricotta, topped with mozz$21.00
Philadelphia Orecchiette
house made pasta with thinly shaved & diced roast pork, broccoli rabe and provolone in a white wine sauce with a touch of chili flake.$20.00OUT OF STOCK
Tuscan Rigatoni
house made rigatoni in a sherry cream sauce with chicken, spinach, and Calabrian chili. Add chili flake for more heat$21.00
Spicy Sausage Radiatore
house made radiatore shaped pasta, ground chorizo, long hots, white wine, basil, touch of tomato, grana$21.00
College Capellini
An ode to my budget ass version of a meat sauce back when I should have been going to college. in house fresh capellini in a well seasoned meat sauce topped with grated parm... Yes I know that it’s called spaghetti but I’m using homemade capellini., did you know what capellini was in college?$20.00
Creamy Fettuccine Pesto
homemade melt in your mouth fettuccine in our creamy pesto (nut free) sauce with a hit of chili flake.$20.00
Spaghetti & Meatballs (Large portion)
house made linguine tossed in our marinara sauce and served with 3 all beef homemade meatballs.$27.00
Hot Crispy Oil Bucatini
house made linguine tossed in a pink cream sauce with hot crispy oil and battered broccoli (some heat, not intense)$20.00
Homemade Rigatoni Vodka
house-made rigatoni tossed in our vodka sauce with peas and topped with ricotta$17.00
Rigatoni & Meatballs with Pot Cheese (Large Portion)
house made rigatoni marinara sauce with a touch of cream. served with 2 homemade all beef meat balls and a dollop of pot cheese (serves 2)$26.00
Creamy Garlic Linguine
Linguine tossed in a light creamy garlic sauce with a touch of red chili flake$17.00
Shrimp Beeps Over Pasta
Shrimp coated in our fra sauce over spaghetti$19.00
Blackened Garlic Shrimp Linguine
small shrimp, grilled in our blackened seasoned and tossed with our garlic linguine$21.00
Sayre’s Fettuccine
homemade fettuccine (by us) in our vodka sauce with sliced meatballs topped with fresh parsley, grated parm and a hit of chili flake.$18.00
Fettuccine ala vodka
homemade fettuccine (by us) in our homemade vodka sauce with tender chicken, broccoli and a hit of red chili flake$20.00Kid's Spaghetti and 1 Meatball (No Garnish)
House made Linguine and one house made meatball.$14.00Side Pasta Butter
house made linguine in butter topped with parm and parsley.$12.00Side Pasta Marinara
house made linguine in our marinara sauce$12.00
Dinner Mains

The BXJ Summer Parm
This is a #TrustMe Item. We dredge the chicken like you would chicken francese then we use our Acqua sauce (tomato and butter emulsion) The cheese is a house grated parm that pairs perfectly with the sauce$20.00
Truffle Cacio Wagyu
10oz wagyu steak and house made fettuccine In a sherry cream sauce with black truffle and toasted crushed black peppercorns$38.00
Manny's Chicken Parm Special
2 Thinly pounded cutlets, plum tomato sauce, house stretched fresh mozzarella topped with basil$22.00
Shrimp Parm W/ Pasta
(8 pieces) jumbo shrimp breaded and fried, topped with marinara and mozzarella. Served with house made linguine marinara.$28.00
Chicken Parm
Freshly breaded cutlets topped with homemade marinara and mozz, baked to perfection. Picture is over pasta which is additional.$20.00
Burrata Milanese
chicken cutlet, grape tomato, torn burrata, nut free basil oil, arugula, fresh cracked pepper, balsamic vinaigrette$24.00
Chicken Milanese
2 chicken cutlets topped with arugula, grape tomatoes and shaved parm. served with a side house made lemon vinaigrette$22.00
Roasted Chicken Platter
herb roasted chicken, yellow rice and mixed veggies served with house made Peruvian green sauce$17.00
Chicken Picatta
Sautéed thinly sliced chicken in a lemon and capers sauce, roasted potatoes and broccoli rabe.$23.00
Marsala Parmesan
Breaded chicken cutlet topped with marsala sauce and fresh house stretched mozzarella. served with grape tomatoes and over house made tagliatelle$25.00
Chicken Francese Platter
traditional chicken in our homemade lemon butter francese sauce with mixed veg and mash$26.00
Chicken Florentine
sauteed chicken In a white wine, shallot and garlic sauce with spinach and house stretched mozzarella served over homemade capellini$24.00
Chicken Ala Reagan
Sautéed chicken, breaded eggplant, mushroom and leek sauce, fresh mozzarella, grape tomatoes over house made linguine. This is the best main on the menu that no one knows about.$24.00
Chicken Limone
Tagliatelle pasta served in a light lemon cream sauce topped with a chicken cutlet and more limone sauce.$24.00
Buffalo Mac & Cheese
Shells and house made cheese sauce topped with our homemade boneless buttermilk fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce$22.00
BXJ Mac and cheese
house made pasta with our homemade cheese sauce.$18.00
Tzatziki Cutlets Platter
Chicken cutlets marinated In tzatziki, yellow rice, cucumber and tomato salad, homemade hummus, homemade white sauce and sriracha$18.00
Tony's Chicken Special
chicken, sweet sausage, hot cherry peppers, rigatoni white wine and garlic sauce (no cream)$21.00
Steak Frites
8oz steak, coated in salt and peppercorns, cooked to medium rare, served with house cut fries and steak sauce$28.00
Lord Milanese
1 breaded chicken cutlet covered in our lords caesar salad and topped with a mountain of pecorino$20.00
Manny's Eggplant Parm
freshly breaded eggplant, plum tomato sauce, house stretched fresh mozz$23.00
Drunken Chicken Parm
Our thin cutlets with vodka sauce and fresh homemade Mozz$20.00
Chicken & Waffles
Homemade buttermilk waffles topped with our homemade buttermilk fried chicken. Sweet and spicy syrup and a dollop of our honey everything butter$17.00
Eggplant Flatatini
Thinly sliced layers of eggplant breaded and fried to perfection, layered with creamy ricotta and topped with sweet basil marinara and mozz broiled to perfection$24.00
Shrimp Beeps Over Pasta
Shrimp coated in our fra sauce over spaghetti$19.00
Eggplant Fra
thinly sliced eggplant breaded and fried, coated in our spicy sauce and topped with mozz.$19.00
La Shrimp
named after my favorite dish at la primavera in west orange, my version of their rock shrimp cooked in a butter, lemon and wine sauce. tossed with linguine and chili flakes$20.00
Cutlet Francese Over Pasta
breaded chicken cutlets in our homemade garlic lemon butter sauce over house made linguine$25.00
Eggplant Parm
thinly sliced eggplant, breaded and fried with homemade marinara and mozz.$19.00
Jerry's Chicken Marsala Platter
lightly floured cutlets in our homemade marasala sauce with house made mash and mixed vegg$26.00
Eggplant Lasagna
I switched up how I’m doing all my eggplant cutlets and introducing it with our new eggplant lasagna. Layers of breaded eggplant, marinara, cheese blends$24.00
Chicken Giambotta
Boneless chicken, sweet sausage, potato, mushroom in a wine sauce topped with basil$24.00
Sides

Cacio E Pepe Roasted Cauliflower
Roasted cauliflower, pecorino, fresh cracked pepper$10.00
Sautéed Broccoli & Garlic
broccoli, evoo, garlic$8.00
Veggie Medley
Carrots, Zucchini, Yellow Sqaush, Red & Green Peppers$8.00Side mashed potatoes
$8.00Sautéed Brussel Sprouts
EVOO, Garlic$9.00Sautéed Broccoli Rabe
Garlic, Imported EVOO$9.00
Garlic Bread Parm Subs

New BXJ Chicken Parm Sub (suggested)
Sesame sub roll with garlic butter, house made boneless buttermilk fried chicken, homemade marinara and mozzarella,$18.00
The Parmageddon
Toasted Garlic Bread, Boneless Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Sliced Meatball, Pepperoni, Marinara, Mozzarella.$19.00
Meatball Parm Sub
Garlic Bread, homemade all-beef meatballs, Ricotta cheese, homemade marinara, mozzarella$16.00
Chicken Parm Sub (chicken cutlet)
Garlic Bread, freshly breaded thinly pounded chicken cutlets, homemade marinara, mozzarella$16.00
Eggplant Parm Sub
Garlic Bread, thinly sliced breaded eggplant, homemade marinara, mozzarella$16.00
Cheesesteaks / Hot Subs

BXJ Ribeye Cheesesteak
New soft sesame bread, shaved ribeye steak, cooper sharp American cheese, grilled onions, hot cherry pepper relish, ketchup$19.00
Buffalo Lawsuit Chicken Sub
Toasted sesame hoagie roll, house made boneless buttermilk fried chicken coated in our homemade buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion and ranch. Add pickles if you know what's up.$19.00
New bxj CHICKEN Cheesesteak
New soft sesame bread, shaved chicken, cooper sharp American cheese, grilled onions, hot cherry pepper relish, ketchup$17.00
New Chopped Cheese
New sesame seeded bread, ground beef blend, caramelized onions, American cheese, shredded lettuce, ketchup. Add fries onto the sandwich if you're a boss.$17.00
Chicken Cutlet Sub
New sesame bread, chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo$16.00
Test Kitchen

Lawsuit Caesar Sub
Sesame hoagie bread with boneless fried chicken, romaine, bagel chips and our lord's caesar salad dressing.$18.00
Jersey Grilled Cheese Platter
Bagel of your choice topped with our special grilled cheese mixture (contains red onions). Served with house made chips, coleslaw and pickles. #TrustMe$12.00
Cincinatti Spaghetti
house made buttered Linguine topped with our award winning chili (no beans). Topped with finely shredded cheddar cheese, sour cream and scallions.$17.00
Buffalo Chicken Fried Rice
Fried Rice with lawsuit buffalo chicken. Topped with a special aioli that I can't really explain but it all just works. Add the hot chili oil for a real flavor bomb.$15.00
Fried Croissant Bites
I have no words. Fried croissant dough tossed in cinnamon sugar and served with buttercream dipping sauce. Crunch that then melts in your mouth.$10.00
PHB Popcorn Chicken
small bites of chicken coated in our bbq sauce with a little kick. Served with ranch or blue cheese.$10.00
The Pizza Party Pizza
Chef's Choice

Chef's Choice Lunch
1/4 catering tray filled with fun lunch food, can be a mix of anything, could be burgers and dogs, could be Mexican, could be Italian, you just have to trust me.. You're welcome to put notes but we make no promises. Let's have fun$28.00
Chef's Choice Asian
A mix of house made asian specialties. You can put notes but they won't always be listened to as it's chefs choice$28.00
Chef's Choice Mexican
1/4 catering tray filled with whatever Mexican food we decide to give you$28.00
The Lawsuit Family

The BXJ Lawsuit
New Bread, buttermilk boneless fried chicken, shredded lettuce and mayo$12.00
The Buffalo Lawsuit
New Bread, buffalo lawsuit chicken, pickles, zesty ranch, Leaf Lettuce & tomato slices.$14.00
The Lawsuit 451
New bread, world famous boneless buttermilk fried chicken, pickles, leaf lettuce, sliced tomato, sliced onion and 451 sauce (house made chipotle mayo on crack)$14.00
The BIG Lawsuit (Triple Decker)
Boneless buttermilk fried chicken, triple bun, lettuce, pickles, onion and 451 sauce. served with house cut fries$16.00
The PHB Lawsuit
Boneless buttmilk fried chicken coated in our bbq sauce with a little bit of kick on our new bread. Topped with pepper jack cheese, ranch dressing, lettuce and tomato.$14.00
Lawsuit Box: Double Jeopardy
2 full-size steamed potato buns, lawsuit chicken, mayo, and shredded lettuce. Served with fresh-cut salted fries and pickle chips$20.00
Lawsuit Wrap
Lawsuit chicken, lettuce and mayo in a wrap$16.00
Lawsuit on a Potato Bun
1 lawsuit on a potato bun with lettuce and mayo$10.00
Chef's Choice Pizza Slices
Gluten Free Pizza
Gluten Free Whole Pizza Plain (toppings available)
$30.00
Gluten Free Plain Slice (toppings available)
marinara, cheese blend, oregano$5.00
Gluten Free Margarita Slice
Marinara, fresh house stretched mozz, basil$5.00
Gluten Free White Broccoli Garlic Slice
ricotta, broccoli, garlic oil$5.00
Gluten Free Vegan Slice
marinara, onions, peppers, mushrooms - no cheese$5.00
Gluten Free White Pepperoni Slice
ricotta base, pepperoni, cheese blend$5.00
Gluten Free Blackened Grilled Chicken Slice
marinara, grilled blackened chicken, cheese blend$5.00Gluten Free Lord's Caesar Slice (No bagel chips)
house made gluten free crust with marinara and caesar salad (no bagel chips). add blackened grilled chicken if you'd like.$5.00
Gluten Free Bruschetta Slice
tomato, onion, basil, balsamic, grated parm$5.00
Gluten Free Hot Pepperoni Slice
marinara, hot cherry peppers, pepperoni and onions$5.00
Gluten Free White Spinach Garlic Slice
ricotta, spinach, garlic oil$5.00
BXJ Bar Pies (14")

Cherry Poppin Pepper Bar Pie
Thin bar pie with homemade sauce, cherry peppers and onions$20.00
The Roundish Bar Pie (best seller)
Our best selling pie - roundish dough stretched thinner and larger topped with our marinara, cheese blend, oregano and parsley. We no longer put chili flake without you clicking to add it.$18.00
The White Roundish Bar Pie
Ricotta, Cheese Blend, Caramelized Red Onion, Garlic cut into party slices cause it just feels right$20.00
Onion Fra Bar Pie
My goto pie at Kinchley’s is always the fra with onion so here we are. Spicy marinara, cheese blend and super thin onion$20.00
Richie's Upside Down Roundish Bar
cheese on the bottom, sauce on the top plus grated parm what richie parm wants richie gets. I can’t believe the flavor difference just from cooking it like this$20.00
The Bargarita Pie
super thin dough, plum tomato sauce, fresh mozz, onion, spinach, cracked black pepper, finished with parm and dried basil$20.00
Lord's Caesar Roundish Bar Pie
Roundish dough with homemade marinara and topped with our homemade caesar salad$24.00Vodka Meatball Bar Pie
63% hydration dough baked at 700 - vodka sauce, homemade meatball, fresh mozz, topped with basil$20.00
Sausage, Peppers & Onions Bar Pie
63% hydration dough baked at 700 - marinara, thinly sliced sweet sausage, peppers & onions cooked in white wine and topped with basil$22.00
Garlic, Onion & Bacon Bar Pie
63% hydration dough baked at 700 with roasted garlic shallot, caramelize onion and bacon$20.00
White Roni Bar Pie
63% hydration dough baked at 700 - ricotta + our cheese blend, topped with pepperoni and oregano$20.00
White, Spinach & Garlic Bar Pie
63% hydration dough baked at 700 - ricotta, cheese blend, spinach, garlic oil, perfection.$20.00
Drunken Chicken Parm Bar Pie
63% hydration dough baked at 700 - homemade vodka sauce, lawsuit chicken, spinach and our cheese blend$20.00
Vegan Peppers & Onions Bar Pie
63% hydration dough baked at 700 - homemade marinara sauce, thinly sliced peppers and onions. topped with oregano - no cheese$20.00
Meatball Ricotta Bar Pie
baked at 700 - homemade meatballs, ricotta, marinara, cheese blend and topped with basil$22.00
Pepperoni & Onion Bar Pie
Made this combo last night with old school pepperoni and super thin onions. It’s perfect and I want you to try it.$19.00
White Tomato Pesto Bar Pie
63% hydration dough, ricotta con latte, ricotta impastata, cheese blend, thinly sliced tomato, pesto oil and topped with basil$20.00
White Broccoli Garlic Bar Pie
thin crust bar pie - ricotta con latte base, cheese blend, broccoli, ricotta impastata, garlic oil$20.00
Upside Down Fra Bar Pie
super thin dough, cheese blend, thinly sliced onion, fra diavlo sauce, baked and topped with grated parm and additional spices$20.00Veggie Bar Pie
Thin crust 14" pizza with marinara, spinach, broccoli, chopped tomato and garlic$20.00
Chicken Parm Bar Pie
Thin Crust, Marinara, Chicken Cutlet, Ricotta, Cheese Blend$22.00
Buffalo Chicken Bar Pie
$22.00
I love ricotta bar pie
ricotta 2 ways, cheese blend, parm on our thin crust$20.00
Meat Lovers Bar Pie
Thin crust pie with our marinara, homemade meatballs, sweet sausage, pepperoni, ricotta and our cheese blend$23.00
White Mushroom Truffle Bar Pie
14” super thin crust with ricotta and a white cheese blend, mushrooms, truffle and salt. Inspired by Neros in Livingston$22.00
Gluten Free

Gluten Free Chicken Tender Box (sauced available)
(5 pieces per order) deep fried in our dedicated gluten free deep fryer, served with house cut GF fries and house made creamy honey mustard and bbq sauce.$18.00Gluten Free Buffalo Wings
12 Gluten free wings fried in a gluten free dedicated fryer. Buffalo contains dairy, PHB is dairy free.$20.00
Chez Le Frites Good (GF)
Fresh cut seasoned fries, American cheese, onion, tomato, the finest shredded lettuce in the world and Russian dressing. gluten free$17.00
Fries with Sweet Chili & Sour Cream (GF)
Gluten free - fried in a dedicated gf deep fryer - dairy free w/o the sour cream.$15.00Gluten Free PHB Wings
12 Gluten free wings fried in a gluten free dedicated fryer. PHB is poblano, habanero bbq. It's sweet with a little heat at the end. PHB is GF and Dairy Free$20.00
Animal Style Fries (Gluten Free)
house cut fries, caramelized onion, American cheese, diced pickle, Russian dressing$15.00
Gluten Free General Tso's Broccoli (GF)
Broccoli crowns coated and fried, tossed in our homemade sauce and served on top of a bed of white rice$20.00Gluten Free Chicken Tender Sandwich (GF)
Gluten free bread with gluten free chicken tenders. Lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo.$17.00
Gluten Free Crispy Sesame Beef (GF)
Thinly sliced and pounded ribeye, dredged and fried, coated in generals sauce with steamed broccoli & carrots served over a bed of white rice$23.00
Gluten Free Mall Chicken Teriyaki (GF)
my ode to everyones favorite food court dish but this is like if short hills mall had a food court. Super tender chicken teriyaki over white rice$18.00
Gluten Free General Rob’s Shrimp (GF)
butterflied shrimp, coated and fried, tossed in our homemade sauce with steamed broccoli and served on top of a bed of white rice$24.00
Gluten Free General Jarrett's Chicken (GF)
all white meat chicken, coated and fried, tossed in our homemade sauce with steamed broccoli and served on top of a bed of white rice$20.00
Gluten Free Chicken Salad Sub (GF)
Toasted GF Udi sub roll, house made chicken salad, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion$17.00
Gluten Free Chicken Parm Sub (GF)
Gluten free toasted udi roll, gf fried chicken tenders (fried in a dedicated, marinara and mozzarella.$17.00
Gluten Free Buffalo Chicken Sub (GF)
Udi sub roll, gluten free chicken tenders fried in a dedicated gf deep fryer tossed in homemade buffalo sauce, pickles, lettuce, tomato, onion and ranch dressing.$17.00Gluten Free Ribeye Cheesesteak (GF)
Udi's Gluten free sub roll, shaved steak, cooper sharp american cheese, grilled onions, hot cherry pepper relish, ketchup$21.00
Boardwalk Slices
BYO Side Salad
Clamshell container with a salad of your choice
The Reasonable Deli

The P&T Joe Salad Knish
A knish is your bread. Filled with our chopped pastrami, turkey, coleslaw and russian salad. Just trust me.$15.00
Potato Knish
Coney Island style potato knish$6.50
The 451 Knish
A Coney Island knish is your bread, lawsuit chicken, pickles, lettuce, tomato and onion with our house made chipotle mayo (451 sauce)$14.00
The Turknish
A Knish is your bread, house roasted turkey, mayo mustard or Russian dressing.$12.00
The Pastrami Knish
The knish is your bread, hot pastrami, pickles and your choice of condiment.$16.00
Hot Corned Beef on Rye
house made corned beef on rye bread$15.00
Loaded Tots
crispy tater tots, house made cheese sauce, bacon, sour cream and scallions$14.00
Double Hot Pastrami
1/2 pound of thinly shaved pastrami on rye. Served with slaw and pickles.$24.00
Reasonable Pastrami Joe
toned down the price and portion - rye bread with house made slaw, super thin melt in your mouth pastrami and russian dressing. served with dill pickle chips$14.00
Pastrami & Turkey Joe Triple Decker
layers of Russian, slaw, pastrami and house made turkey on rye bread. served with dill pickle chips$19.00
Pastrami on Rye
Thinly sliced Pat LaFrieda pastrami on rye$14.00
Turkey on Rye
house made turkey on rye$12.00
Box of Tater Tots
a box of tots served with spicy ketchup$8.00
4oz House Made Coleslaw
4oz container of house made coleslaw$3.00
4 Potato Pancakes
4 potato pancakes served with an optional sour cream$9.002oz Russian Dressing
$2.00
Dr. Brown's Diet Cream Soda
$2.25
Dr. Brown's Cream Soda
$2.25
Wraps

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
12" tortilla stuffed with lawsuit chicken (house made boneless buttermilk fried chicken) coated in our house made buffalo wing sauce with romaine lettuce, tomato and onion. Served with ranch or blue cheese$16.00
Caesar Buffalo Chicken Wrap
cheesesteak style chicken, buffalo sauce, lord’s caesar dressing, romaine, bagel chips. served with house cut fries$18.00
Lord of the Caesar Wrap
12" wrap filled touched on the grill and filled with grilled chicken, caesar salad and bagel chips.$16.00Chicken Salad Wrap
homemade chicken salad, lettuce, tomato, onion in a soft wrap$16.00BLT Wrap
Crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo in a wrap$16.00
Lawsuit Wrap
Lawsuit chicken, lettuce and mayo in a wrap$16.00
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
lawsuit chicken, crispy bacon, cheese blend, lettuce and tomato. homemade ranch comes on the side as this wrap is meant to be dipped.$17.00
Honey Mustard Chicken Bacon Wrap
Lawsuit chicken, cheese blend, bacon, lettuce, tomato, homemade creamy honey mustard$17.00LOE Rap
Flour tortilla, homemade caesar, bagel chips, breaded eggplant$16.00
BXJ Asian Specials

Chicken Dumpling Crunch Bowl
(6 dumplings per order). Steamed doughy chicken and veggie dumplings in a broth with soy, scallion, crispy chili oil. Topped with sesame seeds. Not that spicy.$14.00
BXJ Bibimbap
Shaved ribeye, fried rice, veggies, fried egg, sriracha$17.00
New Sesame Chicken Platter
(Large Portion) New crispy chicken coated in a sweet sauce with sesame seeds served over lo mein and veggie fried rice. Not Gluten Free$25.00
New General Jarrett's Chicken
all white meat chicken, coated and fried, tossed in our homemade sauce with steamed broccoli and served on top of a bed of white rice. Not Gluten Free$20.00
New Crispy Sesame Beef
Tender crunchy pieces of beef coasted in a sweet sauce served with broccoli and carrots. Served over white rice (or fried rice for an additional cost)$22.00
New Orange Chicken
All white meet chicken coated in our house made orange chicken sauce with broccoli and carrots. Served over a bed of lo mein and topped with sesame and scallion$20.00
BXJ Lo Mein
Lo Mein noodles tossed in our house made sauce with sesame seeds. Add veggies and/or protein$12.00
Pork Belly Fried Rice
Fried rice and fried egg mixed with melt in your mouth sweet and sticky pork belly.$16.00
Szechuan Dumplings
(6 per order) your choice of pork or veggie dumplings tossed in a sweet and spicy sauce$12.00
Wagyu Lo Mein
Cubed Kobe Beef, Lo Mein Noodles, Scallion, Sesame$17.00
Mini Veggie Spring Rolls
(8 per order) vegetarian friendly, served with sweet thai dipping sauce$10.00
Chicken Teriyaki Dumplings
(6 per order) fried dumplings filled with saucy chicken. Served with a side of sweet thai sauce for dipping$12.00
Pork & Veggie Dumplings
6 per order, served with sweet thai dipping sauce$12.00
Gluten Free General Tso's Broccoli (GF)
Broccoli crowns coated and fried, tossed in our homemade sauce and served on top of a bed of white rice$20.00
Mall Chicken Teriyaki (GF)
my ode to everyones favorite food court dish but this is like if short hills mall had a food court. Super tender chicken teriyaki over white rice$18.00
Gluten Free General Rob’s Shrimp (GF)
butterflied shrimp, coated and fried, tossed in our homemade sauce with steamed broccoli and served on top of a bed of white rice$24.00
Gluten Free Crispy Sesame Beef (GF)
Thinly sliced and pounded ribeye, dredged and fried, coated in generals sauce with steamed broccoli & carrots served over a bed of white rice$23.00
General Sprout
general tso’s brussel sprouts, chili, sesame seed$14.00
3 All Veggie Eggrolls
3 veggie eggrolls (no meat) with a side of sweet thai sauce$12.00
6 Veggie Dumplings
6 per order, served with sweet thai dipping sauce.$8.00
3 Pork & Veggie Eggrolls
3 egg rolls served with sweet thai dipping sauce$12.00korean bao
$12.00
Hot Dog Cart

Chef's Choice Dogs
2 deep fried wagyu hotdogs in a potato bun with Russian Dressing and coleslaw. #TrustMe$16.00
Wagyu Hot Dog Box
2 deep fried wagyu hotdogs on potato buns, house cut salted fries and homemade coleslaw$16.00
Chili Cheese Dogs
2 per order - homemade chili on top of a wagyu hotdog with freshly shredded cheddar$16.00
Greek / Street Cart Platters

Street Pita
Soft pita pockets filled with the protein of your choice, hummus, tzatziki, lettuce, tomato, onion, sriracha$12.00
Greek Chicken Platter
Romaine Lettuce, greek yogurt marinated grilled chicken, tomato, cucumber and red onion. comes with our homemade white sauce$20.00
Tzatziki Cutlets Platter
Chicken cutlets marinated In tzatziki, yellow rice, cucumber and tomato salad, homemade hummus, homemade white sauce and sriracha$18.00
Street Cart Chicken Platter (gf w/o pita)
homemade yellow rice, marinated chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, homemade pita, street cart sauce, sriracha$18.00
Street Cart Falafel Platter (gf w/o pita)
homemade yellow rice, 5 homemade falafel balls, lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, homemade pita, street cart sauce, sriracha$18.00
Street Cart Mixed Platter
homemade yellow rice, lamb & beef gyro, Marinated chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, homemade pita, street cart sauce, sriracha$20.00
Street Cart Gyro Platter
homemade yellow rice, lamb & beef gyro, lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, homemade pita, street cart sauce, sriracha$18.004oz Homemade Street Cart Sauce
$3.504oz Homemade White Sauce (Gyro II in NYC Recipe)
$3.50
Burger Bar

BXJ Double Smash Burger Box
my ode to in-n-out burger. 2 smashed house ground burger meat patties with a blend of short rib, brisket and chuck on a seeded bun with American cheese, special sauce, tomato, raw onion and leaf lettuce. served with house cut fries$18.00
The New Jalapeño Double Smash Burger
double house ground burger patty smashed with thinly sliced jalapeños, pepper jack, lettuce, raw onion, ancho chipotle sauce. Served with curly fries from that fast food roast beef chain.$18.00
The BXJ Mac
2 house ground burgers on triple bread with our house made burger sauce, pickles, lettuce, onion and American cheese. served with house cut fries$18.00
Cooper Sharp Jalapeño Bacon Burger Box
house ground burger blend, double smash patty, cooper sharp American, raw jalapeño (trust me), bacon and ketchup. Served with house cut fries$18.00
Double Smash Cheese Burger Box (onions and pickles)
toasted sesame bun, 2 double smash burgers with house ground blend (short rib, brisket, chuck), American cheese, raw onion, pickles and ketchup. served with house cut fries$18.00
Rodeo Double Smash Burger Box
Toasted Sesame Bun, 2 In-House burger grind (brisket, short rib, chuck) smash patties topped with house made onion straws, bbq sauce and American cheese. Served with house cut fries$18.00
Lil Macs
(3 per order) house ground burger blend, potato bun, diced onions, & pickles, lettuce and house made lil mac sauce that’s the bomb served with house cut fries$18.00
Bacon Double Smash Burger Box
double patty house ground blend of brisket, short rib and chuck, toasted sesame bun, onion, American cheese, bacon, ketchup and mayo. served with house cut fries$18.00
Pat LaFrieda Veggie Burger Box
My favorite veggie burger I’ve ever tasted served on a toasted brioche with our burger sauce, lettuce, tomato and onion. served with salted house cut fries$18.00
BXJ Sliders
(3 per order) - house blend of chuck, brisket and shortrib, freshly ground and served on a toasted potato bun with caramelized onions, american cheese and ketchup. comes with house cut fries$18.00
The Pastrami Burger
Double smash burger, American cheese, hot pastrami, pickles, burger sauce and coleslaw. Served with house made fries$23.00
"Kid's" Cheese Burger
Martins Potato Bun, Burger, American Cheese, Ketchup.$5.00
Mexican Menu

Steak & Chicken Fajitas w/ Homemade Tortillas
A mix of chicken & steak, peppers and onions. Served with cheese, rice, refried beans, crema, salsa rojo and guac. Tortillas by request$28.00
Steak Fajita Platter w/ Homemate Tortillas
5 flour tortillas, Lime marinated tender ribeye, peppers and onions, refried beans, yellow rice, cheese, guac, crema and salsa rojo$28.00
Chicken Fajita Platter w/ Homemade Tortillas
5 flour tortillas, blackened chicken, peppers and onions, refried beans, yellow rice, cheese, guac, crema and sour cream$25.00
Chicken Burrito
Al Pastor Chicken, Yellow Rice, Guacamole, Refried Beans, Cheese blend, Crema and Salsa Rojo on the side$17.00
BXJ Cali Burritos
12" tortilla shell filled and grilled with your choice of protein, yellow rice, refried beans, guac, sour cream, salsa rojo, cheese blend, crispy fries$18.00
Jarrett Goridta Crunch
(2 per order) house made gordita with a layer of cheese followed by a house made crunchy tortilla filled with ground beef, lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese and cilantro lime crema. salsa rojo on the side$16.00
Barbacoa Burrito
12" tortilla filled with our house made barbacoa, yellow rice, refried beans, peppers and onions, white cheese blend, sour cream, guacamole. Salsa verde on the side.$17.00
BXJ Crispy Beef Taco Box
6 house fried corn tortilla shells stuffed with our ground beef mixture, lettuce, cheese and crema. served with house fried chips, salsa rojo and verde$26.00
Crew Chicken Enchiladas
(3 per order) 3 creamy chicken enchiladas in flour tortillas with our homemade verde topped with a cheese blend$20.00
BXJ Steak Tacos
(3 per order) - flour tortillas filled with tender marinated ribeye, house cheese blend, romaine, cilantro lime crema, queso fresco$17.00
Barbacoa Tacos (gf)
(3 per order) double corn tortillas, slowed cooked barbacoa beef, guacamole, onions, cilantro and salsa verde on the side.$16.00
Soft Beef Tacos
(3 per order) house made flour tortillas, ground beef, lettuce, cheddar, tomato and crema. salsa rojo on the side$15.00
Nacho Ordinary Nachos (gf)
catering style tray of house fried corn chips, seasoned beef blend, cheese mix, jalapeno, lettuce, guac, pico, salsa$25.00
BXJ Quesadilla
Giant 14” quesadilla filled with a protein of your choice and our cheese blend served with 2oz sides of salsa rojo, salsa verde, crema, guac and pico$25.00
Properly Stuffed Steak Quesadilla
super tender marinated ribeye, cheese blend, potato, special sauce inside a 12inch tortilla. served with salsa rojo, crema, guac and freshly fried chips$25.00
Properly Stuffed Chicken Quesadilla
grilled chicken, onions, peppers, cheese blend sour cream, salsa, guac and freshly fried tortilla chips$24.00
Properly Stuffed VEGGIE Quesadilla
onions, peppers, cheese blend sour cream, salsa, guac and freshly fried tortilla chips$22.00
Steak Street Quesadillas (gf)
3 per order - corn tortillas with steak and our cheese blend. topped with romaine & queso fresco served with salsa verde and crema$15.00
Street Quesadillas (GF/V)
(3 per order) small corn tortillas filled with our cheese blend and topped with queso fresco and lettuce. served with crema and salsa rojo$10.00Chips & Salsa (gf/v)
Fresh fried chips and homemade 8oz container of red salsa (salsa rojo)$12.00
Chips & Guac (gf/v)
fresh fried chips and homemade guacamole$15.00Rice & Beans (gf/v)
homemade refried beans and yellow rice$10.00
Desserts

House Made Salted Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Creamed French Butter, Dark Brown Sugar, 62% hand cut chocolate, maldon salt flakes$4.00OUT OF STOCK
Fresh Fruit Platter
mixed fruit$7.00
Fried Croissant Bites
I have no words. Fried croissant dough tossed in cinnamon sugar and served with buttercream dipping sauce. Crunch that then melts in your mouth.$10.00
Fried Oreos
4 per order - double stuffed oreos wrapped in pastry dough and deep fried for good measure - topped with powdered sugar$12.00
Tres Leches
1 slice$6.00
Proper Ratio Crumb Cake
Just right amount of cake to crumb topping$5.00
Cinnamon Sugar Pretzel Bites
a box of freshly made pretzel bites coated in cinnamon sugar and served with buttercream.$14.00
Fried Dough
kicking it old school and bringing fried dough back today with a 4oz side of Reagan Rainbow$10.00
Funnel Fries
funnel cake fries tossed in our cinnamon sugar blend served with a side of house made butter cream frosting$10.00
Chocolate PB Mousse Pie
$12.00OUT OF STOCK
Calzones & Strombolis

The bXL Calzone
A giant calzone filled with mozzarella, ricotta and proteins/veg of your choice. Served with sides of marinara sauce.$23.00
Cheese & Spinach Stromboli
Cheese blend, spinach, and garlic served with a side of marinara$17.00
Sausage Peppers & Onions Stromboli
Our dough is stuffed with a cheese blend, Ricotta, sausage, peppers, onions, and dried basil. Served with a 4 oz side of marinara$18.00
Cutlet Stromboli
Cutlet & cheese blend served with a side of marinara$17.00
Sausage Stromboli
Cheese blend & sausage served with a side of marinara$17.00
Meatball Stromboli
Cheese blend & meatballs served with a side of marinara$17.00
Pizza Fritta 1969
2 per order. Our roundish dough is stuffed with Ricotta & our cheese blend, sealed and deep-fried. Served with our sweet basil marinara$20.00
Cutlet Calzone
Chicken cutlet, Ricotta, and cheese blend served with a side of marinara$17.00
Sausage Calzone
Ricotta, cheese blend, and sausage served with a side of marinara$17.00
Meatball Calzone
Ricotta, cheese blend, and meatballs served with a side of marinara$17.00
Cheese & Spinach Calzone
Ricotta, cheese blend, spinach, and garlic served with a side of marinara$17.00Breaded eggplant calzone
$17.00Breaded eggplant stromboli
$17.00
Containers

Small Pastrami & Turkey Joe Salad
Pastrami, House Roasted Turkey, Coleslaw and Russian all chopped up together.$14.00Chicken Salad
award winning homemade chicken salad$10.00+
Small Reagan Rainbow
Sweet cream cheese with rainbow sprinkles and cookie pieces$10.00Plain Cream Cheese
Plain Cream Cheese$10.00+Lox Portion
3.3oz portion$12.00Small Tuna Salad
homemade tuna salad with celery (no onion)$10.00Butter
salted butter$10.00+Scallion Cream Cheese
homemade scallion cream cheese$12.00+Veggie Cream Cheese
homemade with big chunks of peppers, scallions and carrots$12.00+Roasted Garlic Shallot Cream Cheese
homemade cream cheese with slowly roasted garlic and shallot$12.00+8oz Bacon Chive Cream Cheese
homemade cream cheese with bacon and chives$12.008oz Jalapeño Scallion Cream Cheese
homemade cream cheese with jalapeños and scallions$12.008oz Lox Spread
$15.00Everything Butter
butter mixed with our roasted everything seeds$10.00+8oz Everything Honey Butter
butter with our roasted everything seeds and honey$10.008oz Whitefish Salad
8oz container of whitefish salad$15.00OUT OF STOCK16oz Coleslaw
16oz homemade coleslaw$10.00Everything Seasoning Mix
16oz container of our homemade everything seasoning mixture$17.00
Sandwiches / Triple Deckers / Wraps

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
12" tortilla stuffed with lawsuit chicken (house made boneless buttermilk fried chicken) coated in our house made buffalo wing sauce with romaine lettuce, tomato and onion. Served with ranch or blue cheese$16.00
Tamago Sando
House made Japanese style egg salad on a farmhouse roll.$7.00
Chicken Sandwich 101
The best white toast there is with a thin chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, red vinegar and oil. Served with house made potato chips and pickle chips.$12.00
Nugget Sliders
(3 per order) I’ve officially recreated the chicken sandwich you may have had at another establishment but this is a better and fresher chicken slider$12.00
Grilled Chicken Honey Mustard Wrap
12" flour tortilla stuffed with grilled chicken, romaine, lettuce, tomato, onion and our house made creamy honey mustard$17.00
Caesar Buffalo Chicken Wrap
cheesesteak style chicken, buffalo sauce, lord’s caesar dressing, romaine, bagel chips. served with house cut fries$18.00
Lord of the Caesar Wrap
12" wrap filled touched on the grill and filled with grilled chicken, caesar salad and bagel chips.$16.00
Pastrami & Turkey Joe Triple Decker
layers of Russian, slaw, pastrami and house made turkey on rye bread. served with dill pickle chips$19.00
The Turkey Triple Decker Club Box
Fresh in-house made turkey, lettuce, bacon, tomato, mayo across 3 layers of toasted bread. Homemade chips, coleslaw and pickles.$24.00
The Loe Down (original bread)
house made crusty, super thin and crispy eggplant topped with homemade caesar salad$20.00
Lord’s Lawsuit Caesar Triple Decker Club
Triple decker with lawsuit chicken, lord’s caesar and bagel chips$22.00
The Popped Collar Turkey Sub (original bread)
house made turkey on new sesame bread with bacon, romaine lettuce and our roasted garlic aioli which is the real game changer$22.00
The Cutlet Joe Triple Decker Box
Triple decker - breaded chicken cutlet, coleslaw and russian served with house cut chips, pickles and coleslaw$23.00
The BLT Triple Decker Club Box
Triple decker - crispy bacon, shredded lettuce, tomato and a generous amount of mayo. Served with house made chips, coleslaw and pickle chips$23.00
The Chicken Salad Triple Decker Club Box
Triple decker with chicken salad, tomato, lettuce, bacon and mayo. Served with coleslaw, house made chips and dill pickles.$23.00
Chicken Up in Da Club Triple Decker Box
toasted bread, crispy bacon, chicken salad, bacon chive spread, tomato served with fresh made chips and coleslaw$24.00
Chicken Salad Croissant
freshly baked croissant, our homemade chicken salad, lettuce, tomato and onion. Served with house cut potato chips$12.00
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
lawsuit chicken, crispy bacon, cheese blend, lettuce and tomato. homemade ranch comes on the side as this wrap is meant to be dipped.$17.00
Honey Mustard Chicken Bacon Wrap
Lawsuit chicken, cheese blend, bacon, lettuce, tomato, homemade creamy honey mustard$17.00
Eyyy Jen
Grilled crusty bread, in-house same day stretched fresh mozz, Proscuitto Di Parma, roasted red peppers, pesto aioli, balsamic drizzle$24.00
Eyyy Nicky Boy
grilled crusty bread, in-house same day stretched fresh mozz, roasted red peppers, basil, pesto aioli, balsamic drizzle$20.00Veggie Joe Wrap
Coleslaw, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Cucumber, Bagel Chips and russian dressing in a soft wrap$16.00
Veggie Joe Croissant
everything croissant, russian dressing, coleslaw, tomato, red onion, cucumber, bagel chips$12.00
DXJ Small Bites

Buffalo Chicken Bites
boneless chicken bites tossed in our house made buffalo sauce with your choice of ranch or blue cheese.$10.00
The Mini Corn Dog Nuggets You May Have Had...
(8 per order) corn dog battered mini hotdogs served with your choice of dipping sauce.$12.00
Yuca Fries
Crispy yuca fries served with 451 sauce (homemade chipotle mayo on crack)$12.00
BXJ Onion Straws
thinly sliced sweet onions, soaked in buttermilk and then a homemade dredge before frying. Served with a dipping sauce of your choice$10.00
Mini Chicken Empanadas
(6 per order) - served with 451 sauce which is our homemade blend of chipotle, lime, and the rest is a secret #TrustMe$12.00
Spinach Artichoke Poppers
8 per order - a mixture of spinach, cheese and artichokes breaded and fried, served with creamy honey mustard (trust me)$12.00
Salted Pretzel Bites
a box of freshly made pretzel bites with your choice of house made cheese sauce or creamy honey mustard$15.00
Cinnamon Sugar Pretzel Bites
a box of freshly made pretzel bites coated in cinnamon sugar and served with buttercream.$14.00
Sassy Nuggs
The nuggets you love but sauced. variations of 8,16 and 24. No combining sauces.$12.00+
Kid's Chicken Fingers
Chicken tenders and house-cut fries served with either honey mustard or BBQ sauce$16.00Bagel Chips
$10.00
The nuggets you may have had at another establishment but this is a better nugget™
8 per order - served with choice of bbq, creamy honey mustard or sweet thai sauce$12.00
Jalapeño Poppers
8 per order - served with sour cream and homemade salsa rojo$12.00
Beer Battered Onion Rings
box of beer battered onion rings with homemade creamy honey mustard$16.00
Salted Fries (Gluten Free)
A box of house cut salted fries$10.00
Animal Style Fries (Gluten Free)
house cut fries, caramelized onion, American cheese, diced pickle, Russian dressing$15.00
Tom's Fried Pickles
My buddy Tom had the best fried pickles with buttermilk ranch at his rehearsal dinner in South Carolina. This is my ode to those served with a homemade buttermilk sriracha ranch cause we needed another homemade condiment.$12.00
Fries with Sweet Chili & Sour Cream (Gluten Free)
fresh cut seasoned fries with a side of sour cream and sweet chili for dipping. If you know, you know.$12.00
Dunk Yo Tots
Circle tater tots served with 451 sauce (house made chipotle mayo)$8.00
Salads / Platters

Lord's Caesar Salad
Chopped Romaine, homemade caesar dressing and crumbled bagel chips.$17.00Buffalo Chicken Salad
Our buttermilk fried chicken coated in our homemade buffalo sauce on a bed of lettuce with tomato and red onion$20.00Chicken Salad Platter
Chicken Salad, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Cucumber, 4oz Russian Dressing$20.00
Build Your Own Side Salad
Build your own small side salad.$5.00Tuna Salad Platter
Tuna Salad, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Cucumber, 4oz Russian Dressing$20.00Crispy Honey Mustard Chicken Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, crispy chicken and topped with our homemade original honey mustard dressing.$20.00
Burrata Salad
baby spinach, roasted red peppers and tomato tossed in our infused EVOO and topped with a 4oz ball of burrata and balsamic glaze$20.00
Bagel Chip Platter
3 circle bagel chips, chicken salad, russian, coleslaw and shredded lettuce$20.00
Greek Chicken Platter
Romaine Lettuce, greek yogurt marinated grilled chicken, tomato, cucumber and red onion. comes with our homemade white sauce$20.00
Chicken & Wings

Carolina Gold Wings
(12 per order) sweet and tangy with a tiny kick$20.00
Lemon Pepper Wings
a dozen wings tossed in a lemon sauce with a touch of pepper$20.00
Sassy Nuggs
The nuggets you love but sauced. variations of 8,16 and 24. No combining sauces.$12.00+
Buffalo Chicken Box
Buttermilk boneless fried chicken tossed in homemade buffalo sauce. Served with homemade coleslaw and pickles$20.00
Buffalo Wings
12 fresh (not breaded) fried wings in our homemade buffalo sauce$20.00
PHB Box
boneless fried chicken coated in A bbq sauce base with charred poblano peppers and habanero. Sweet with a heat at the end. Served with pickles.$20.00
PHB Wings
12 wings per order. A BBQ sauce base with charred poblano peppers and habanero. Sweet with heat at the end.$20.00Korean Chicken Box
boneless buttermilk chicken coated in a sweet and spicy sauce$20.00Korean Fried Wings
12 fresh (not breaded) wings in our homemade sweet and spicy sauce$20.00Sweet Thai Box
buttermilk boneless fried chicken tossed in sweet thai sauce. Served with homemade coleslaw and pickles$20.00Naked Chicken Box
buttermilk boneless fried chicken served with a side sauce$20.00
Honey Heat Wings
12 wings per order. New homemade sauce with a sweetness up front and a bit of heat at the end$20.00
Condiments
4oz Caesar Dressing
$4.004oz fresh made guacamole
$4.004oz BXJ Garlic Pizza Dipping Sauce
$4.004oz House Grated Parm
$5.004oz Marinara
$4.004oz Sweet Basil Marinara
$4.004oz Vodka Sauce
$4.004oz Fra Sauce
$4.004oz Homemade Street Cart Sauce
$3.504oz Russian
Because I make smart decisions$3.004oz Homemade Creamy Honey Mustard
$4.004oz Original Homemade Honey Mustard
$4.004oz Ranch
$3.004oz Blue Cheese
$3.004oz crema
$3.754oz Sour Cream
$4.001oz Hot Sauce
$1.004oz Homemade Buffalo Wing Sauce
$3.504oz Homemade Ranch
$4.004oz BBQ Sauce
$3.004oz sweet Thai sauce
$4.00
Drinks
Red Gatorade
$3.50Yellow Gatorade
$3.5016 Oz Diet Lemon Snapple
$3.00The WB! 24 Oz
$5.00The Crew B! 24Oz
Our WB (iced tea and lemonade) with a shot of grenadine$5.00Poland Spring
16.9oz$2.0016 Oz Lemon Snapple
$3.0016 Oz Diet Peach Snapple
$3.0016 Oz Peach Snapple
$3.0016 Oz Diet Raspberry Snapple
$3.0016 Oz Raspberry Snapple
$3.00Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
$6.50Orange Juice
$3.0015.2 Oz Apple Juice
$3.00
Coke
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love$3.00
Diet Coke
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink$3.00
Sprite
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free$3.00Chocolate Nesquik
$3.00Yoo-Hoo 15.5 Oz Bottle
$3.00
Mexican Coke
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love$4.00
Mexican Sprite
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free$3.75
same day catering payments
Drinks

99 Cent Arizona Iced Tea
$0.99OUT OF STOCKRed Gatorade
$3.50Orange Gatorade
$3.50Yellow Gatorade
$3.50Blue Gatorade
$3.50The WB! 24 Oz
$5.0016 Oz Diet Lemon Snapple
$3.0016 Oz Lemon Snapple
$3.0016 Oz Diet Peach Snapple
$3.0016 Oz Peach Snapple
$3.00The Crew B! 24Oz
Our WB (iced tea and lemonade) with a shot of grenadine$5.0016 Oz Diet Raspberry Snapple
$3.0016 Oz Raspberry Snapple
$3.00Orange Juice
$3.00Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
$6.5015.2 Oz Apple Juice
$3.00
Coke
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love$3.00
Diet Coke
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink$3.00
Sprite
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free$3.00Chocolate Nesquik
$3.00Yoo-Hoo 15.5 Oz Bottle
$3.00Dr. Brown's Cream Soda
$2.25Dr. Brown's Diet Cream Soda
$2.25fanta
$2.50V8
$1.50Poland Spring
16.9oz$2.00
If you use a credit card, Bagels By Jarrett 451 Mt Pleasant Ave will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what Bagels By Jarrett 451 Mt Pleasant Ave pays in fees.
Everything Butter
$0.00
butter mixed with our roasted everything seeds
Customize your item
Size
Required
Select 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 8:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 10:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Thursday | 10:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 10:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Saturday | 8:00 am - 8:00 pm |
Restaurant info
The most confused bagel shop you've ever loved. Make sure to choose your pickup time in order to see the correct menu. You can preorder as well.
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.









