American
Fairport Harbor Creamery
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Ice Cream Pies & Cakes
Ice Cream Pies
Customized Ice Cream Pie **NEED 48HRS NOTICE**
Don't like our options? We get it. You're the creative genius here! Build your own ice cream pie, add toppings as you please. **NEED 48 HRS NOTICE** If your pick up date isn't 48 hrs from when we receive your order, we will be calling you. Don't make us do that please :)$33.00Blueberry Crumble Ice Cream Pie
Graham crust, vanilla ice cream swirled with house blueberry jam, our brown butter Nilla wafer crumble & decorated with vanilla buttercream$37.00
PB Chocolate Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie
cookie dough ice cream layered with peanut butter, fudge and more house cookie dough! In a chocolate crust, decorated with vanilla buttercream$38.00
Ice Cream Cakes
Banana Cream Pie IC Cake WHOLE
vanilla cake + banana cream pie ice cream, house caramel/nilla wafer crunch layer, covered in fresh house whip, decorated with vanilla buttercream$58.00
Double Chocolate IC Cake WHOLE
chocolate cake + chocolate ice cream, fudge/oreo dirt layer, fresh whip and decorated with vanilla buttercream on top$58.00
Ice Cream
Ice Cream
To-Go Treats
House Drumstick With Peanuts
classic drumstick with vanilla ice cream, chocolate dipped + peanuts, made in house$7.00
BYO Ice Cream Sammy
Build Your Own Ice Cream Sammy!- choose a cookie option- choose a ice cream flavor (single scoop amount)- add toppings for us to roll them in!$7.50
Seasonal To-Go Sundaes
$9.00
Ice Cream Sammy
$7.00Spongebob Bar
$3.60Lemon Italian Ice
$3.60Strawberry Italian Ice
$3.60
Fluffernutter IC Cake Slice
Vanilla cake + candied peanuts/PB marshmallow sauce + marshmallow ice cream swirled with peanut butter + fresh whip and PB marshmallow drizzles$10.00
Buckeye Ice Cream Bar
Kind of like a PB Klondike bar! Our buckeye bar base + vanilla ice cream & our candied peanuts, dipped in chocolate dip, topped with PB drizzles, candied peanuts & a little Maldon salt$9.00Red Velvet Oreo IC Cake Slice
red velvet cake + fudge & oreo dirt layer + cookies & cream ice cream, topped with fresh whip, oreos, fudge drizzles$11.50
Pints (2026)
*BOOZY* Chocolate Pint
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey infused chocolate ice cream$11.65
*BOOZY* Mint Pint
whiskey and creme de menthe infused mint ice cream$11.50*BOOZY* Old Fashioned Pint
Bulleit Bourbon infused ice cream, flavored with Amarena cherries, orange zest and Angostura bitters$12.25*BOOZY* Pina Colada Dole Pint
VEGAN /GF - pineapple dole whip infused with coconut flavor and Myers dark rum$11.50
*BOOZY* Vanilla Pint
kahlua and seven brothers expresso vodka infused vanilla ice cream (approx. 4% - 4.5% ABV per pint)$11.50
Banana Cream Pie Pint
fresh banana ice cream with house brown butter, oat & vanilla wafer crumble$9.65
Bananas Foster Pint
a bananas foster ice cream made with house made bananas foster -- bananas, caramel, cinnamon, pecans, and Myers dark rum (cooked out)$9.85OUT OF STOCK
Better than Therapy Pint
our rich chocolate ice cream + house caramel streaks and our house chocolate cake crumbles$9.50BisCoffee Pint
biscoff cookie butter and coffee infused ice cream$9.85Black Cherry Oreo Pint
Black cherry flavored ice cream + Oreo chunks mixed throughout$9.75Blue Moon Pint
blue moon flavored ice cream..a Midwest favorite!$8.50
Butter Pecan Pint
butter pecan ice cream + buttery toasted pecans mixed in$9.75Cherry Almond Pint
almond extract "white" ice cream + chopped maraschino cherries (nut free)$9.75
Chocolate Pint
chocolate ice cream made with Extra Brute cocoa powder, making a sinfully delicious chocolate ice cream$9.75
Cookie Dough Pint
vanilla bean ice cream + house edible cookie dough crumbles$9.65
Cookies & Cream Pint
vanilla ice cream + Oreo cookie chunks$9.50
Mango Dole Whip Pint
mango flavored dole whip - gluten/soy/dairy free!$9.00
Mint Chip Pint
green mint ice cream + soft chocolate flakes$9.50
PB Oreo Pint
real peanut butter ice cream + oreo chunks$9.65
Pineapple Dole Whip Pint
gluten free / soy free / dairy free / vegan Pineapple Dole Whip$9.00Red Velvet Pint
Vanilla cheesecake ice cream + house red velvet cake crumbles & blue sprinks for the holiday!$9.85S'mOreo Pint
Chocolate marshmallow ice cream + house Oreo dirt, graham crumbles & mini marshmallows mixed in$9.95
Salted Caramel Pint
caramel ice cream + salted caramel streaks$9.65Strawberry Pint
strawberry ice cream + house roasted strawberries$9.65
Vanilla Bean Pint
classic vanilla ice cream made with pure Mexican vanilla and vanilla bean$9.65VEGAN Chocolate Pint
a completely vegan/gluten free/soy free chocolate ice cream, made with a coconut base$9.95VEGAN Cookies & NOCream Pint
vanilla coconut cream ice cream + oreo cookie chunks mixed throughout$9.85VEGAN Peach Pint
peach compote infused ice cream, with a coconut cream base - vegan!$9.95OUT OF STOCK
Toppings To Go (8oz)
Caramel Topping To Go Container
8oz of caramel sauce$5.00
Cherries To Go Container
8oz of maraschino cherries$4.00
House Crunch Coat
house candied peanuts & rainbow sprinkles$5.50
Homemade Jam
8oz of our homemade jam$7.00
Hot fudge To Go Container
8oz of hot fudge$5.00
PB Sauce To Go Container
8oz of peanut butter sauce$5.50
Sprinkles To Go Container
8oz of sprinkles$3.00
Strawberry Sauce (not jam!) To Go Container
8oz of strawberry sauce$4.00
Waffle Cones (2)
2 waffle cones, for ice cream cone making at home!$2.00
Whipped Cream Can
Did you forget the whip? We've got you!$4.25House Caramel
$7.00
Bakery
Take & Bake Menu
Take&Bake Brown Butter Cookies (6)
6 of our brown butter cookies, frozen and ready to bake! comes with parchment and directions$15.00
Take&Bake Chocolate Chip Cookies (6)
6 of our chocolate chip cookies, frozen and ready to bake. Includes 1 sheet parchment paper, instructions, and enough Maldon salt for all 6$15.00Take&Bake Peanut Butter Cookies (6)
6 of our peanut butter cookies, frozen and ready to bake. Includes 1 sheet parchment paper & instructions$15.004 Take&Bake Scones, savory only
Call for current flavor option! It will always be cheesey, but if you need to know specifics -- 440-898-0030$14.50OUT OF STOCK
Fluffernutter IC Cake Slice
$10.00
Vanilla cake + candied peanuts/PB marshmallow sauce + marshmallow ice cream swirled with peanut butter + fresh whip and PB marshmallow drizzles
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:30 am - 9:30 pm |
Restaurant info
If this menu is unavailable, it is because the ordering period has closed. Check our social media for when the next menu will be released. Thanks!
Location
202 High St, Fairport Harbor, OH 44077
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
