
American
Fargo Bar & Grill
384 Main St
Aurora, NY 13026
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items

Classic Burger
Half pound prime chuck burger, grilled to temp, served with choice of cheese on a branded roll. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on the side$17.95
Chicken Wings
8 each, mixed drums and flats, tossed in choice of sauce, blue cheese dressing and celery on side$13.95
Carolina Crispy
Fried chicken with Jones Carolina Sauce, bread & butter pickles, fresh dill, and red onion on brioche roll$17.95
Online Daily Menu
*Shared Bites

Chicken Wings
8 each, mixed drums and flats, tossed in choice of sauce, blue cheese dressing and celery on side$13.95
Loaded Tots
Topped with bacon, cheddar, and green onion, malt aioli on side$14.95Pretzel Sticks
5 soft pretzels, cheese sauce, honey mustard$11.95
Chicken Tenders
5 crispy tenders with french fries and choice of dipping sauce$14.95Onion Petals
Batter fried with honey mustard dipping sauce$10.95
Moosarella Sticks
5 Jumbo breaded mozzarella sticks, house made tomato & garlic dipping sauce, Parmesan dust$12.95Poutine Ardennes
Crispy fries topped with cheese curds and a tangy Belgian beer & caramelized onion gravy.$12.95Burrata Bread Plate
Creamy burrata cheese topped with marinated sun dried tomatoes, accompanied by toasted Ithaca Bakery focaccia.$10.95
*Soup & Salad

French Onion Soup
Caramelized onions, beef broth, sherry, cracked black pepper, garlic croutons, and broiled cheese
Garden Salad Small
Mixed green, carrot, tomato, cucumber, dressing on the side$6.95
Garden Salad Large
Mixed green, carrot, tomato, cucumber, dressing on the side$14.95
Southwest Salad
Cheddar, bacon, garden veggies, corn & black bean salsa, chipotle-lime dressing$16.95Caesar Salad
Classic Caesar Salad with Garlic Croutons, Parmesan Cheese, and Romaine lettuce. Dressing is served on the side for take out orders to help keep your lettuce from wilting. our caesar dressing is made in house and contains anchoviesPeachtown Lady
Mixed greens, peaches, crumbled blue cheese, pickled red onion, pecans, poppyseed dressing on the side.$16.95
*Burgers
Bacon Blue
Topped with bacon, blue cheese crumbles, and caramelized onion$19.95Black Bean burger
Homemade black bean burger, served with choice of cheese on a branded roll. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on the side$17.95
Classic Burger
Half pound prime chuck burger, grilled to temp, served with choice of cheese on a branded roll. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on the side$17.95Jalapeno Crunch
Topped with american cheese, jalapeno, and crispy fried onion$18.95Mega Moose
2 half pound prime chuck burgers, grilled to temp, served with bacon and choice of cheese on a branded roll. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on the side$28.95
Mushroom Swiss
Topped with swiss cheese and marinated grilled mushrooms$18.95Piggy Back Burger
Half pound prime chuck burger grilled to temp on branded roll, topped with smoked pulled pork, cheddar cheese, bbq sauce, and crispy onions. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on the side$23.95
*Sandwiches
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine, parmesan, croutons, house made caesar dressing, flour tortilla wrap$16.95Firecracker Naan'which
Gluten Free - Homemade black bean burger, roasted red peppers, jalapeno, goat cheese, chipotle-lime dressing, herbed cauliflower flatbread wrap$17.95BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich
pulled pork sliders, crispy onions, sweet pickles, BBQ sauce, on moose branded roll$16.95Peach Brisket Melt
Smoked brisket, peaches, pickled onions, jalapenos, cheddar, hot honey bbq sauce, Ithaca Bakery Focaccia$23.95Ithaca Turkey Club
Turkey, Bacon, Tomato, Lettuce, Mayo, on Ithaca Bakery Focaccia$17.95
*Chicken Fry
Basic 'Wich
Fried or Grilled chicken on brioche roll. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on the side$16.95Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Fried chicken with buffalo sauce, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion, on brioche roll$17.95
Carolina Crispy
Fried chicken with Jones Carolina Sauce, bread & butter pickles, fresh dill, and red onion on brioche roll$17.95
Chicken Tenders
5 crispy tenders with french fries and choice of dipping sauce$14.95Oh Honey
Fried chicken with hot-honey garlic bbq, jalapeno, provolone, and bacon , on brioche roll$18.95
*Entree

Rodeo Mac n' Cheese - Full Size
Pulled pork, bbq sauce, cavatappi, house-made cheese sauce, crispy fried onions$20.95
Rodeo Mac n' Cheese - Small Portion
Pulled pork, bbq sauce, cavatappi, house-made cheese sauce, crispy fried onions$16.95Chicken "Riggie" Mac n' Cheese - Full Size
Inspired by Utica NY's famous "Chicken Riggies" this Mac' n Cheese packs a punch with hot cherry peppers, garlic, grilled chicken, roasted peppers, and a cheese blush sauce. topped with green onions. (can be made without hot peppers)$20.95Chicken "Riggie" Mac n' Cheese - Small Portion
Inspired by Utica NY's famous "Chicken Riggies" this Mac' n Cheese packs a punch with hot cherry peppers, garlic, grilled chicken, roasted peppers, and a cheese blush sauce. Topped with green onions. (can be made without hot peppers)$16.95Elote Shrimp Tacos - Three Each
Grilled flour tortillas filled with chilled shrimp, mixed greens, pickled onions, goat cheese, and Elote - a mexican style street corn tossed in chipolte-lime dressing.$19.95Elote Shrimp Tacos - Two Each
Grilled flour tortillas filled with chilled shrimp, mixed greens, pickled onions, goat cheese, and Elote - a mexican style street corn tossed in chipolte-lime dressing.$15.95Eggplant Bella Fargo
Marinated Eggplant and chickpeas, sun dried tomatoes, artichokes, creamy burrata cheese, fried capers, and focaccia crostini$19.95Pub Brisket & Fries
Smoked beef brisket with mushrooms in a tangy Belgian beer and caramelized onion gravy, served with french fries and topped with fresh parsley.$24.95
*Sides
Caesar Small
Romaine lettuce, parmesan, house made caesar dressing, parmesan, garlic crouton (dressing on side for take out)$6.95Garden Salad Small
Mixed green, carrot, tomato, cucumber, dressing on the side$6.95French Fries Side
$5.95French Fry Basket
$10.95Mac n' Cheese
House made cheese sauce, cavatappi, toasted bread crumb$4.95Sweet Potato Fries Side
$6.95Tater Tots Side
$6.95Loaded Tots side
$8.95
Beverages
Soda
Juices & Tea
Family Packs & Party Boxes
Party Box
Buffalo Chicken Box
4 Buffalo Chicken Sandwiches -lettuce, tomato, onion, swiss cheese, fried chicken, buffalo sauce- with choice of side$65.00
Cheese Burger Box
4 Fargo Classic Cheeseburgers -lettuce, tomato, onion, choice of cheese, on branded roll- *must all be same cheese and cooked to the same temperature choice of side$65.00Chicken Tender Box
20 Crispy Chicken Tenders with choice of side and 2 dipping sauces$55.00Chicken Wing Box
4 lbs. of Wings (32 each) choice of of to 2 sauce (1/2 and 1/2 or all the same) comes with blue cheese dipping sauce and celery$50.00Pretzel Box
20 Pretzel Sticks with sides of house made cheese sauce and honey mustard$40.00
Dr Pepper
$3.75
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 8:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Home of the best burgers in the Finger Lakes.
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.



