American
Fitzgerald's Restaurant
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
Smashburger
Two ground beef patties topped with lettuce, onions, burger sauce, and American cheese. Comes with fries.$17.00
Kikusui Funaguchi Nama Genshu
Unfiltered sake clocking in at 19% ABV. Big notes of vanilla, a bit of honey and banana bread and a pleasantly long finish.$13.00
*NEW* Tiramisu
Ladyfingers soaked in coffee and an Italian coffee liqueur with a mascarpone cream and cocoa powder. -Consuming raw or undercooked egg may increase the chance of foodborne illness-OUT OF STOCK$10.00Carrot Cake
$9.00
Takeout Starters
Poutine
Fries in a rich beer gravy with cheese curds and pearl onions.$17.00
Arancini
Roasted garlic risotto stuffed with mozzarella, fried and served on basil walnut pesto with balsamic$17.00
Umami Fries
Vietnamese fish sauce caramel provides the foundation for this delightful combination of sticky, sweet and savory. Served with jalapeno and soy braised chicken.$17.00
Takeout Meals
Takeout BBQ
Outdoor Dining Cocktails
Bottled Beer A-M
Arvon Headless Jack 16oz can
$8.00Black Note 2023
$10.00
Cuvee Armand and Gaston 375ml
Blend of one, two and three year old lambics from 3 Fonteinen in Belgium. Funky, bright and acidic. 6.5% ABV.OUT OF STOCK$24.00Deth's Tar
Bourbon barrel aged imperial stout. 14.8% ABV.OUT OF STOCK$10.00Double Nnazareth 16oz Can
$9.00Drie Fonteinen Oude Kriek 375ml
$22.00Dusted 16oz can
Double N.E. IPA that's primarily driven by Galaxy hops from Other Half Brewing in New York. 8% ABV.$8.00Godric's Heir 500ml bottle
$32.00Hop Butcher Grid 16oz can
$7.00Hop Butcher Megabite 16oz can
$8.00Hop Butcher Your Wish Is Granted 16oz Can
West Coast style double IPA brewed with Citra and Nelson Sauvin hops from Hop Butcher in Chicago. 7.5% ABV.$8.00Howlin' Drifter 16oz Can
West Coast style IPA from Waxwings Brewing in Kalamazoo. 8% ABV.$7.00
Bottled Beer N-Z
Oberon 19.2
$7.00Ore Dock Porter 12oz Can
Roasty and malty without being heavy, brewed by Ore Dock Brewing in Marquette. 5.7% ABV.$5.00
Platinum Blend 375ml
Blend of lambics up to four years old from 3 Fonteinen in Belgium, with plenty of funk along with flavors of dry oak, white grape, pear and hint of apricot. Fuuunky. 6.5% ABV.$32.00Saison Dupont 19.2oz Can
Iconic farmhouse ale from Belgium full of aromas of coriander, lemon and fresh bread. 6.5% ABV.$7.00Scatter Signal 500ml bottle
$32.00Self Destructive Destiny 16oz can
$8.00Side Pull 16oz Can
A light Czech style lager with a soft, malty body from Fair State Brewing in Minnesota. 4.1% ABV.$6.00Strawberry M-43 16oz Can
$9.00Stumble Berry 19.2oz Can
Blueberry and honey form the backbone of this malty, boozy treat from Fat Heads in Ohio. 9% ABV.$8.00Thomas Hardy Golden Edition Barleywine 11oz bottle
$12.00Tilquin Rhubarbe 750ml bottle
$34.00Tomato Pie 16oz Can
Light bodied N.E. IPA that's big on hop aroma from Other Half Brewing in New York.$7.00
Two Hearted 19.2
Classic Midwestern IPA in a big ol' can 192oz can. 7% ABV.$6.00Underbru 375ml bottle
$16.00Vanilla Deth
$10.00
Zombie Dust 19.2oz Can
Legendary pale ale that's a great balance of bitter hop and subtle malt backbone. 6.2% ABV.$7.00
Ciders/Seltzers
Wine
Ancient Peaks Cab Bottle
$36.00
Avinyo Cava Brut Reserva
$28.00Chateau Grand Francais Bordeaux Superior
$42.00
Domaine de Chateaumar Cuvee Bastien Cotes du Rhone
$29.00Duckhorn Cabernet
$75.00Duckhorn Chardonnay
$54.00Duckhorn Merlot
$55.00Fabre Rose
$34.00Footbolt Shiraz
$32.00
Hopler Gruner Veltiner
$32.00Les Grenettes Sauvignon Blanc
$40.00Migration Pinot Noir
$60.00
Poutine
$17.00
Fries in a rich beer gravy with cheese curds and pearl onions.
Customize your item
Select up to 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. DO NOT USE THIS TO ORDER OFF-MENU ITEMS.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 10:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Monday | 3:00 pm - 8:45 pm |
| Tuesday | 3:00 pm - 8:45 pm |
| Wednesday | 3:00 pm - 8:45 pm |
| Thursday | 3:00 pm - 8:45 pm |
| Friday | 12:00 pm - 8:45 pm |
| Saturday | 12:00 pm - 8:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Join us on the shores of Lake Superior for fresh wood fired barbecue, great drinks and an eclectic mix of other offerings!
Location
5033 Front Street, Eagle River, MI 49950
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
