Skip to Main content
  • Gotham Bagels Madison, WI

    • Home
    • /
    • Madison
    • /
    • Gotham Bagels Madison, WI
    Restaurant banner image
    American

    Gotham Bagels Madison, WI

    112 East Mifflin Street

    Madison, WI 53703


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Bagels, Lox, & More
    Sandwiches
    Deli & Bulk
    Extras
    Beverages
    Catering
    Grocery
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • BACON, EGG, & CHEDDAR

      Fried egg, aged cheddar, & thick cut bacon.
      $9.75
    • THE YELLOW C.A.B.

      Cheddar, avocado, bacon, arugula, tomato & mayo.
      $11.00
    • BAGEL & CREAM CHEESE

      $5.25

    Bagels, Lox, & More

    Women Founded Brand, 72% Cacao 3 oz
    • Single Bagel

      Loose bagels do not come sliced.
      $2.25
    • BAGEL & CREAM CHEESE

      $5.25
    • x Dozen Bagels

      Choose 13 bagels
      $23.00
    • 8oz Container of Cream Cheese

      8oz House whipped cream cheese or 8oz Whipped Butter.
      $8.00
    • Fresh Fruit Cup

      10 oz. Pineapple, blueberries, and grapes.
      $6.00
    • Thinly Sliced Lox by the Half Pound or Pound

      With capers and red onion. *Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
      $18.75
    • Traditional Matzo Ball Soup

      Served Hot
      $7.00
    • Spicy Chicken Tortilla Soup

      Spicy chicken tortilla soup topped with cotija cheese. Ask for no cheese makes it dairy free.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.00
    • Clam, Bacon and Kale Bisque

      Clam Bacon and Kale Bisque available in several sizes.
      $6.00
    • Big City Coffee Cake

      $6.25
    • Curried Hummus with Za'atar

      8 oz.
      $8.00
    • Hot Smoked Salmon

      $18.00
    • Freezer bags (1 each)

      $0.35
    • Freezer Bags (5 pack)

      Eco-friendly 5-pack of freezer bags. Bio-based film derived from Sugar Cane. Each bag hold 6 NY bagels.
      $2.25
    • Gotham Frozen Bagels

      Better than others' fresh! 6 pack assorted. Please do not request flavors on frozen bagels; flavors fluctuate daily.
      $8.00
    • Babka for One

      $7.00
    • Babka Loaf

      24 oz. Certified Kosher and Parve.
      $18.00
    • Traditional Rugelach

      14 oz bag. Certified Kosher and parve.
      $13.00
    • Traditional Hamantaschen

      12 oz box.
      $10.25
    • Black and White Cookies 3.5 oz

      Individually wrapped.
      $3.00
    • Gluten free chocolate chip cookie

      $1.25
    • Oatmeal Walnut Raisin Cookie

      $3.00
    • Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

      $2.50
    • Shrimp Bisque

      Seafood Stock & Tomato Base, Grilled Shrimp, Cream, Spice, Herbs, and Lemon.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.00

    Sandwiches

    • KENNY'S MONTAUK LOBSTER ROLL

      A LONG ISLAND SUMMER TRADITION--packed lobster salad with Vitruvian greens, Tomato.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.00
    • BAGEL & CREAM CHEESE

      $5.25
    • BACON, EGG, & CHEDDAR

      Fried egg, aged cheddar, & thick cut bacon.
      $9.75
    • LOX & CREAM CHEESE

      Lox and your choice of cream cheese. *Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
      $10.75
    • SPICY ITALIAN SAUSAGE, EGG, & CHEDDAR

      Over-Easy Egg, Aged Cheddar, Gotham-made Spicy Italian Sausge.
      $11.75
    • BRIGHTON BEACH

      Lox, caper cream cheese, Greens, tomato, red onion, capers. *Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
      $14.75
    • O.M.F.G.

      Fried egg, aged cheddar, nashville fried chicken, thick cut bacon, & Calabrian chili aioli.
      $13.75
    • THE ROCKY'S DELI

      The return of a Gotham Original - Fried Egg, Thick Cut Bacon, Aged Cheddar, Potato Latke, Spicy Ketchup.
      $13.75
    • EGG & CHEDDAR

      $9.00
    • PASTRAMI & EGG, Early Willy

      Piled high over an over easy egg
      $10.75
    • SMOKED HERITAGE HAM, EGG, & GOUDA

      Fried Egg, Locally Smoked Ham, Aged Gouda, fried egg.
      $10.75
    • THE YELLOW C.A.B.

      Cheddar, avocado, bacon, arugula, tomato & mayo.
      $11.00
    • SUPER TUSCAN

      Fried egg, Fresh Mozzarella, Heirloom Tomato, Vitruvian Greens, and Pesto.
      $12.25
    • BRONX BOMBER

      Piled High Calabrese Salami, La Quercia Prosciutto,Mortadella, Provolone, Greens, Tomato, Chicago Johnny's Hot Giardiniera.
      $11.25
    • WILLIAMSBURG HOT PASTRAMI

      Piled high Hot Pastrami with NY STRONG mustard. Served with pickle and NY deli cole slaw.
      $13.00
    • ATHENIAN

      Gyro "Style" Lamb, Greens, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Tzatziki.
      $11.75
    • MASSAPEQUA

      Grilled Herbed Chicken Breast, Roasted Red Peppers, Fontina, Greens and pesto.
      $12.25
    • WOODLAWN CORN BEEF

      Piled High Corn Beef & NY Strong mustard. Make it a Rueben +2.75
      $13.00
    • THE ORIGINAL "V" ....THE GREAT VEGAN!

      Vegan scallion cream cheese, poblano salad, tomato, arugula, & avocado. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle
      $11.25
    • THE AMAGANSETT

      House Made Whitefish Salad, Vitruvian Baby Greens, Cucumber, Hot House Tomato, Red Onion
      $11.25
    • PORT WASHINGTON

      Hot Smoked Salmon Salad(Red Onion, Celery, Parsley, Salt & Pepper), Avocado Mash, Tomato, Baby Greens, Citrus Vinaigrette
      $13.25
    • LONG ISLAND

      House-Roasted Turkey Breast, Fontina, Greens, Tomato, Mayo
      $11.25
    • NY DELI CHICKEN SALAD

      Petite Greens, Heirloom Tomatoes
      $9.75
    • TRADITONAL TUNA SALAD SANDWICH

      Arugula, Tomato.
      $9.75

    Deli & Bulk

    • Bowtie Pesto Pasta Salad 8oz.

      8oz.
      $4.75
    • Traditional Tuna Salad

      $5.75
    • Gotham Chicken Salad

      $5.75
    • Gotham Whitefish Salad

      8 oz.
      $10.50
    • Port Washington Salmon Salad

      $8.00
    • Pastrami by the Pound

      Sold by the pound. Comes with NY Strong Mustard.
      $20.50
    • Gotham Pickles

      $6.50
    • NY Deli Coleslaw

      $3.25
    • Virtruvian Farms Baby Greens Mix

      5 OZ. Locally grown Produce, McFarland, Wisconsin
      $5.50
    • 30-Month-Old Parmigiano-Reggiano

      Per pound. The one and only.
      $25.00

    Extras

    • Bag of Bagel Chips

      Made in house.
      $4.00
    • Joe Chips

      Retro potato chips.
      $2.25
    • Coffee Refill

      $0.50
    • 4 oz Fruit Cup

      $2.50
    • 12 oz Fruit Cup

      $6.00
    • Little Bag of Lillie's Chips

      5 oz.
      $2.50

    Beverages

    • Strong Coffee

      Your Choice Light or Dark Roast Coffee served HOT in iconic NYC Coffee Cups
      $2.75
    • Iced Coffee

      $3.25
    • Fresh Squeezed Juice

      $5.50
    • Coca-Cola Products

      $1.25
    • Dr. Brown's Soda

      $1.75
    • Aqua Panna Water

      $2.75
    • San Pellegrino Sparkling Mineral Water

      $3.00
    • Poland Spring Water

      $2.00
    • Fiji Bottled Water

      1 Liter Bottle
      $5.00
    • Waiakea Water

      1 Liter Hawaiian Volcanic Water
      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.00
    • Powerade

      $2.75
    • San Pellegrino Fruit Soda

      $3.00
    • Joe Tea

      $3.50
    • Summer Lemonade

      Joe's Lemonade 16 Oz Can Made with Cane Sugar
      $3.50
    • RA! Elevated THC Infused

      RA! Elevated 10 MG Hemp Derived THC 12 OZ Can
      $8.00
    • The Mountain Valley Spring Water

      $6.00

    Catering

    • Riverside Park Platter

      NY Dozen®, 1 lb lox, 2-8oz spreads, Baby Greens, Tomato, Cucumber, Big City Pickles, Red onion, and capers *Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
      $112.00
    • Long Island Platter

      NY Dozen®, 1 lb. Traditional Tuna Salad, 1 lb. Traditional Chicken Salad, 1lb. Sliced Turkey, Tomatoes, Baby Greens, Red Onion, Big City Pickles and Gotham Finest Cole Slaw
      $105.00
    • Brighton Beach Platter

      NY Dozen®, 1 lb Lox, 8 oz Hot Smoked Salmon, 8 oz Smoked Whitefish Salad, 2- 8 oz Spreads, Baby Greens, Red Onion, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Big City Pickles *Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
      $139.00
    • Williamsburg Platter

      NY Dozen®, 1lb. smoked Heritage Ham, 1lb Pastrami, 1lb Corned Beef, 8oz Deli Coleslaw, (2) 4 oz Gotham Deli Mustard, & Big City Pickles.
      $120.00
    • Big City Fruit Platter

      Pineapple - grapes - blueberries - cantaloupe
      $45.00
    • Joe to Go Coffee Service

      Collectivo Coffee service for 12 people. Includes cups, cream, and sugar.
      $49.00

    Grocery

    • Cav. Giuseppe Cocco - Farfalle

      17.6 oz. Product of Italy.
      $5.75
    • Cav. Giuseppe Cocco - Penne

      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.75
    • Garofalo - Orzo

      $4.00
    • Garofalo - Linguine

      $4.00
    • Mafaldine (Imported Sicilian Pasta)

      Joey Bagels Preferred dry pasta
      $8.94
    • Everything Spice

      12oz container.
      $6.00
    • Hot Giardiniera

      Olive oil based, bold and smoky flavor. 16 oz.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.75
    • JBC - Black Earth Coffee - Whole Bean

      12 OZ Whole Bean Coffee Notes of Praline, Vanilla, Dark Chocolate.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $14.00
    • Sicilian Oregano on Branches

      25g, Imported
      $8.00
    • St. Elmo Steak House Shrimp Cocktail Sauce

      Very Spicy, 12 oz
      $9.95
    • Bonito Tuna

      White Tuna in Olive Oil - 112g.
      $8.00

    EGG & CHEDDAR

    $9.00

    Customize your item

    WI bagel flavors (sandwiches)

    Required
    Select 1

    WI Sides

    Optional

    WI extra add-ons

    Optional

    WI cream cheese flavors (add on/upcharge for sandwiches)

    Select up to 1

    Egg whites

    Select up to 1
    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
    1

    All hours
    Sunday8:00 am - 12:30 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday8:00 am - 2:00 pm
    Wednesday8:00 am - 2:00 pm
    Thursday8:00 am - 2:00 pm
    Friday8:00 am - 2:00 pm
    Saturday8:00 am - 12:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    NY Bagels prepared using traditional technique passed down through generations. Sandwiches and Cream Cheese utilizing modern flavors and ingredients.

    Location

    112 East Mifflin Street, Madison, WI 53703

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Heritage Tavern
    View restaurantnext
    Graze Restaurant
    View restaurantnext
    Young Blood Beer Company
    View restaurantnext
    Prost! - Madison 401 E Washington
    View restaurantnext
    Ancora - Downtown
    View restaurantnext
    Settle Down Tavern
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook