American
Gray Willow 2168 New York 81
2168 New York Highway 81
Earlton, NY 12058
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
Brussels and Kale Caesar
with shaved parmesan and house made croutons. top with a protein... Grilled Salmon, Chicken or Shrimp... $7.00 each$13.99Kids Chicken Fingers with Fries
Breast of chicken cut into strips, panko breaded and deep fried. Served with our hand cut fries$10.00Willow House Burger
half pound custom blend of chuck and pork belly grilled and served on a brioche roll with lettuce and tomato. served with hand cut fries and house made pickle. Additional toppings available: Beer Cheese, Pepper Bacon or Cheese (American, Cheddar, gruyere, Hootenanny) add $2.00 each$19.99
Food Menu
Chef's Specials
Cowboy Caviar with Tortilla Chips
Zesty dip with chickpeas, black beans, jalapenos, red onions, roasted corm and bell peppers served with fresh housemade tortilla chip$14.99Bacon Jam Crotstini
toasted French bread with house made bacon jam, goat cheese, pesto, cherry tomatoes, our garden basil and balsamic glaze$15.99Willow Wedge Salad
Iceberg wedge with oven roasted tomatoes, pepper bacon, fried onion slivers and roquefort dressing.$16.99Corn Ribs
corn on the cob cut into quarters and drizzled with chipotle aioli, lime, tajin and parmesan cheese$15.99Cheeseburger Quesadilla
flour tortilla with spicy ground beef, bacon, cheddar cheese and red onion. Served with sour cream and salsa$16.99Italian Sausage Burger
ground pork sausage burger topped with melted mozzarella cheese, marinara and sauteed peppers, onions and mushrooms, on a brioche bun$21.99Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
vanilla ice cram and rainbow sprinkles with your choice of chocolate chip cookie or mint chocolate chip cookie$11.99
All for Me
Brussels and Kale Caesar
with shaved parmesan and house made croutons. top with a protein... Grilled Salmon, Chicken or Shrimp... $7.00 each$13.99Burrata with Roasted Beets
creamy burrata, baby arugula, roasted beets, candied pecans, balsamic glaze, Malden sea salt sprinkle. Served with grilled Tuscan bread.$15.99Cascatelli Mac and Cheese
Local Sfoglini pasta with our custom blend of sharp cheddar, gruyere and tilsit cheese. Baked in cast iron with chunks of pepper bacon a fried onion sliver topping.$22.99Crispy Pork Schnitzel
with sweet and savory red cabbage, garlic mashed potatoes, and HOT and sweet pepper gravy.$23.99Frickadellan Burger
Griddle fried German meat patty on a pretzel bun with melted Hootenanny cheese (McGrath Cheese Company, Hudson, NY), sweet and sour red cabbage, and whole grain mustard. Served with our hand cut fries and house made pickle.$21.99Grilled Black Bean Burger
house made black bean burger with sauteed peppers, onions and your choice of cheese. Served on our branded brioche bun with chipotle aioli. Includes out hand cut fries and house made pickle.$18.99Grilled New York Strip Steak
A 10oz New York Strip and char grilled to your desired doneness. Topped with our caramelized garlic butter and served with hand cut fries.$32.99Honey Garlic Salmon
Char grilled Faroe Island salmon fillet basted with our roasted garlic and local honey syrup served over herbed jasmine rice.$25.99Psychedelic Rabbit Gumbo
Louisiana inspired “slow and low” gumbo with andouille sausage and Fossil Farms (Boonton, NJ) free range white rabbit. Served over steamed jasmine rice and grilled Tuscan bread$29.99Stuffed Chicken Caprese
Airline chicken breast, stuffed with tomato, fresh mozzarella and spinach. Topped with homemade garden pesto and balsamic glaze. Served with a light summer pasta salad$27.99Tuscan Chicken Ravioli
Ravioli filled with prosciutto, basil and chicken with a sundried tomato and spinach cream sauce.$24.99Willow House Burger
half pound custom blend of chuck and pork belly grilled and served on a brioche roll with lettuce and tomato. served with hand cut fries and house made pickle. Additional toppings available: Beer Cheese, Pepper Bacon or Cheese (American, Cheddar, gruyere, Hootenanny) add $2.00 each$19.99
Dessert
Campfire Smores Indoors
Marshmallows, graham crackers and Hershey’s chocolate for make your own smores.$13.99Creme Brulee Cheesecake
$11.99Gluten Free Chocolate Torte
with raspberry preserves$11.99Homemade Cookie Skillet
choice of cookie, baked into a skillet topped with vanilla ice cream.$11.99Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
vanilla ice cram and rainbow sprinkles with your choice of chocolate chip cookie or mint chocolate chip cookie$11.99Janes Ice Cream
Handmade in the Hudson Valley. Choose from Limoncello, Cappuccino Kahlua Calypso, or Vanilla.$6.00+Raspberry Lemondrop Cake
$11.99Ultimate Chocolate Cake
$11.99
I Want More
Side Arugula Salad
$6.99Side Bacon
$4.00Side Beer Cheese
$1.00Side Brown Gravy
$1.00Side Chef Veggies
Weekly rotation of chef's choice of veggies. Ask your server for current offering.$7.50Side Garlic Mashed
$7.00Side Hand Cut Fries
$7.00Side Hot Pepper Gravy
$1.50Side of BBQ Sauce
$0.50Side of Buffalo Wing Sauce
$0.75Side of Garlic Parm Wing Sauce
$0.75Side of Guacamole
$1.00Side of Jerk Wing Sauce
$0.75Side of Mayo
$0.50Side of Sour Cream
$0.50Side of Steak Sauce
$0.50Side Ranch Dressing
$1.00Side Rouquefort
$1.00Side Salsa
$0.75Side Whole Grain Mustard
$1.00
Gluten Free Menu
GF Airline Chicken Breast
Grilled house brined airline chicken breast topped with marsala demiglace. Served over garlic mashed red potatoes.$26.99GF Burrata with Roasted Beets
creamy burrata, baby arugula, roasted beets, candied pecans, balsamic glaze, and Malden sea salt. served with grilled gluten free bun.$15.99GF Honey Garlic Salmon
Char grilled Faroe Island salmon fillet basted with our roasted garlic and local honey syrup served over herbed jasmine rice.$25.99GF Ignacio's Nachos
Platter of warm corn tortillas topped with cheddar cheese, fresh made salsa, and black olives. Served with sour cream and guacamole. (Top with grilled spicy chicken or ground beef- add $7.00)$13.99GF New York Strip Steak
A 10oz New York Strip steak seasoned and char grilled to your desired doneness. Topped with caramelized garlic butter, served with garlic mashed potatoes.$32.99GF Willow Beet Salad
with arugula, roasted butternut squash, and goat cheese. Topped with peanuts and balsamic reduction.$16.99GF Willow House Burger
Half pound custom blend of chuck and pork belly grilled and served on a gluten free bun with lettuce and tomato. served with side of arugula salad. Additional toppings available: Pepper Bacon or Cheese (American, Cheddar, gruyere, Hootenanny) add $2.00 each$19.99
Drink Menu
Crafted Cocktails
Aphrodite
East End Gin, Aperol, Carpano Antica Sweet Vermouth, hibiscus, lemon.$15.00Apricot Ginger Whiskey Sour
Taconic bourbon, apricot liqueur, ginger liqueur, honey, lemon, block ice.$14.00Black Raspberry Honey Drop
Titos, Black Raspberry liqueur, Limoncello, Pierre Ferrand dry curacao, lemon, sugared rim, honeycomb garnish$14.50Blood Orange Cosmo
Belvedere, Solerno, lime, blood orange puree$15.00Chocolate Hazelnut Old Fashioned
Woodford Reserve burbon, Frangelico, hazelnut syrup, chocolate bitters$15.00Controlled Burn
Mijenta Reposado, grapefruit juice, Scrappy's fire tincture, club soda$15.50Cranberry Irish Mule
Jameson, cranberry preserves, ginger beer, lime.$13.00Espresso Martini
$15.00French 99
Hendricks gin, Litchie liqueur, St. Germain, lime, sparkling wine$15.00Garden Martini
$15.00Greenhouse Martini
$15.00House Red Sangria
Red wine, brandy, blackberry liqueur, lemon, orange, curacao.$14.50Hugo's Sister
St Germain, Butterfly Pea, sparkling wine, fresh mint, lime, club.$13.00Irish Cream Soda
Shanky’s Whip, ginger beer, lime.$13.00Justin' Case
Ketel One, fresh muddled grapes, lemon, lime, mint simple, large cube$14.00Last Laugh
East End gin, Green Chartreuse, Grand Marnier, lime$17.00Mafia Manhattan
Woodford Reserve, Disaronno, Apricot liqueur, bitters, Luxardo cherry.$15.00Passion Fruit Margarita
Mijenta Silver, passion fruit puree, lime, tajin rim$14.00Peach Berry White Sangria
Protea dry rose, brandy, peach liqueur, curacao, lemon, fresh berries, peaches.$14.50Pearadise
Mezan Jamaican rum, St. George Spiced Pear liqueur, pear syrup, lime, bitters.$14.00Pickled Mary
$13.50Pink Panther
Titos, St. Germain, pomegranate, lemon, pineapple, aquafaba$14.00White Lotus
Hendricks, St. Germain, lime, butterfly pea truth serum.$14.50
Hard Seltzer / Cider
Beer
Black Widow Export Stout
ABV 6.7 a bold foreign extra stout with rich notes of coffee and chocolate$6.00+Brennan's School House Red
ABV 5.5 Rich and robust malt with a slight caramel flavor and beautiful amber color. ABV 5.5 / IBU 33.7$6.00+Cuppa JoJo Coffee Blonde
ABV 5.4 blonde lager infused with subtle flavor and aroma of fresh light roasted coffee. Brewed with locally roasted Brewtus beans and finished with a touch of mosaic hops$6.00+Driving Mizz Hazy
ABV 7.4 Light bodied with a clean, crisp, refreshing taste$6.00+Golden Sombrero Mexican Lager
ABV 5.0 IBU 16.1 A clean high clarity lager that is light in body with a slight sweetness that is balanced by just enough hoppy bitterness.$6.00+Liberty Lager
ABV 4.9 Traditional American Lager, inspired by George Washingtons original beer recipe. Made with Liberty Hops$6.00+S & K IPA
ABV 6.1 IBU 62.9 The first original Gray Willow brew, its namesake inspired by the Salvino and Konopka adventure into partnership. Smooth west coast style IPA with a bold hoppy aroma and a beautiful amber color.$6.00+Skeeter Creek Pilsner
ABV 5.0 IBU 37.1 Light bodied with a clean crisp and refreshing taste.$6.00+Willow Light
ABV 4.3 IBU 15.4 American light lager with a light crisp flavor, mild hop bitterness; highly carbonated with less calories, lower carbs, and lower alcohol content.$6.00+Zoinks!
Inspired by Shaggy from Scooby-Doo, this great tasting West Coast style IPA is made with Mosaic and Simcoe hops.$6.00+
Mocktails / Zero Proof / NA
Athletic Brewing IPA N/A
$6.00Athletic Brewing Lite N/A
$6.00Blueberry Lemondrop Mocktail
$7.50Ginger Beer
$6.00Guinness 0
$6.00Juices
$3.00Limeade
$6.50Miss Sydneys Bottle Of Bloody Mary Mix TO GO
$20.00Passion Fruit Spritzer
$8.00Roy Rogers
$4.00Saratoga Sparkling
$7.50Saratoga Still
$7.50Shirley Temple
$4.00Tonic
$3.00Truth Serum Mocktail
$7.00Virgin Mary
$8.00
Non-Alcholic Beverages
Wine
Pinot Noir - Cono Sur (Organic)
(Chile) - toasted oak, grass, and berry notes; medium acidity with spicy, fruit-forward palate.$9.50+Merlot - Chateau Ste Michelle
(Washington, Columbia Valley) -aromas of black cherry, leather, and spice; rich dark red fruit and jam; complex, long, smooth, sweet finish.$10.00+Malbec - Don Rodolfo
(Argentina, Mendoza) – garnet black; leather, mocha, and black cherry flavors; vibrant with medium tannins.$9.00+Cabernet Sauvignon - Hess Shirttail Ranch
(California) – ripe blackberry and dark chocolate; full-bodied, smooth texture with moderate tannins.$12.00+Chardonnay - Penfold Max's
(South Australia) – stone fruit, citrus and jasmine with balanced oak; fresh and subtly nutty.$13.00+Pinot Grigio - Pighin
(Italy, Friuli) – fruity floral notes of banana and wisteria; dry, well-balanced with light amber hue.$11.50+Prosecco Santa Marino (split)
$10.00Riesling - Brotherhood
(New York) – floral and lime aromas; fruity, off-dry with a long, clean finish; pairs well with seafood, white or pink meats.$10.00+Rose (Dry) - Rupert Protea
(South Africa) – blush pink; nectarine and citrus zest flavors; juicy, vibrant, and finishes dry.$11.50+Sauvignon Blanc - Dashwood
(New Zealand) – distinct punchy aromas of guava, gooseberry and citrus peel; delicate floral and herbaceous notes.$9.50+Wycliff Sparkling - BTL
$35.00
Kids Menu
Kids Chicken Fingers with Fries
Breast of chicken cut into strips, panko breaded and deep fried. Served with our hand cut fries$10.00Kids Grilled Cheese with fries
a traditional combination of white bread and American cheese grilled and served with our hand cut fries.$9.00Kids Mac and Cheese
Short ruffle pasta with our house made creamy cheese sauce.$8.00Kids Pasta with Butter
Castcatelli pasta tossed with butter.$7.50Kids Pasta with Red Sauce
Castcatelli pasta tossed with marinara.$8.50
Monday Night Specials
Monday Night Speical
Grilled Black Bean Burger
$15.00Italian Cudighi Sausage Burger
ground pork sausage burger topped with melted mozzarella cheese, marinara, and sauteed pepper, onion and mushrooms; on a brioche bun$15.00Jamaican Me Crazy
our signature beef grind topped with fried Jamaican jerk boneless wings, cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomato, on a brioche bun$15.00Reuben Kincaid
our signature beef grind topped with sliced corned beef, Swiss cheese, Russian dressing and sauerkraut; on a brioche bun$15.00Wild Turkey Burger
dark meat turkey burger, American cheese, cranberry mayo, fresh arugula; on a brioche bun$15.00Willow House Burger
half pound custom blend of chuck and pork belly grilled and served on a brioche roll with lettuce and tomato. served with hand cut fries and house made pickle. Additional toppings available: Beer Cheese, Pepper Bacon or Cheese (American, Cheddar, gruyere, Hootenanny) add $2.00 each$15.00GF Willow House Burger
$15.00
Driving Mizz Hazy
$0.00
ABV 7.4 Light bodied with a clean, crisp, refreshing taste
Customize your item
Size
Required
Select 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Saturday | 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Gathering place for house brews, a full bar, & elevated comfort food. Casual seating spaces, table seating, and large L-shaped bar, as well as a large outdoor space where Adirondack chairs, fire pits, picnic tables, and games will be available in the Spring.
Location
2168 New York Highway 81, Earlton, NY 12058
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
