This restaurant does not have any images
Seafood
Island Grill Islamorada
85501 Overseas Highway
Islamorada, FL 33036
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items

MAHI-MAHI REUBEN
Fresh grilled Mahi-Mahi on sliced daily baked sourdough bread with thousand island dressing, Swiss cheese and coleslaw, French fries$26.00
CONCH FRITTERS
A Keys tradition, fresh ground conch served with homemade chipotle sauce$17.00
BUFFALO SHRIMP PO-BOY
Crispy shrimp tossed in our Chef's buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, hoagie bread, French fries$25.00
LUNCH MENU
APPETIZERS

THE ORIGINAL TUNA NACHOS
Fresh sushi grade tuna nestled on a bed of wakame seaweed salad over crisp wontons topped with wasabi drizzle, sweet teriyaki, sesame seeds, sriracha & scallions$22.00
LOBSTER TOSTON
$25.00
COCONUT SHRIMP
Crispy coconut shrimp, coconut butter, sweet chili sauce$17.00
SMOKED FISH DIP
Fresh local fish, marinated, smoked and mixed with our Chef's spices served with assorted crackers$18.00
CONCH FRITTERS
A Keys tradition, fresh ground conch served with homemade chipotle sauce$17.00
FRIED CALAMARI
Fresh calamari cut by hand, dusted with graham cracker crumbs, fried served with homemade chipotle sauce$17.00
PHILLY CHEESESTEAK ROLL
$15.00
TEN JUMBO WINGS
Served with Bleu cheese and celery$15.00
SUSHI & POKE

TUNA POKE BOWL 🥣
$26.00
SALMON POKE BOWL 🥣
$26.00
ISLAND GRILL ROLL 🍥
Crispy shrimp, kani salad, spicy tuna, mango, topped with avocado, eel sauce, spicy aioli, tempura flakes & tobiko$22.00
ISLAMORADA ROLL 🍥
Crispy shrimp, cream cheese, avocado, with soy paper topped with fried plantain & eel sauce$24.00
SPICY TUNA ROLL 🍥
$24.00
OVERSEAS ROLL 🍥
Tuna, yellowtail, avocado, mango, serrano & tempura flakes, topped with tobiko, served with spicy mango chili sauce & ponzu$24.00
SANDBAR ROLL 🍥
Salmon, cream cheese, avocado, with soy paper, topped with eel sauce, spicy aioli, and ikura$24.00
SASHIMI ROLL 🍥
Tuna, salmon, yellowtail, avocado, topped with ikura & truffle oil, served with spicy chili sauce & ponzu$26.00
CALIFORNIA ROLL 🍥
Kani, cucumber, avocado, topped with tobiko$17.00
VEGGIE ROLL 🍥
Cucumber, avocado, beets, & mango, with soy paper$16.00
LARGE BOAT ⛴
50 Pieces$99.00SMALL BOAT ⛴
$70.00
TEMPURA PARADISE POKE🥣
$26.00
PREMIUM STEAKS
LAND

HALF BABY BACK RIBS
Fall-off-the-one tender baby back ribs with BBQ sauce "Locals favorite"$26.00FULL BABY BACK RIBS
Fall-off-the-one tender baby back ribs with BBQ sauce "Locals favorite"$37.00BAKED CHICKEN
Grilled skin-on chicken breast with the drumette (GF)$26.00
GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST
Grilled chicken breast marinated with garlic$24.00
SEAFOOD

SNOW CRAB LEGS
$38.00
MACADAMIA GROUPER
Pan seared Atlantic salmon served with passion fruit coconut aminos sauce$45.00
SEA PAELLA
$39.00
MAHI MAHI IMPERIAL
Seasoned and broiled mahi-mahi topped with crab cakes, shrimp served with Key Lime beurre blanc sauce$38.00
ATLANTIC SALMON
Pan seared Atlantic salmon served with passion fruit coconut aminos sauce$28.00SEAFOOD TOWER
Shrimp, mussels, clams, white wine, garlic sauce over linguine served with garlic bread$107.00
PASTA
Blackened, melted Gorgonzola cheese,
smoked bacon, caramelized onion, French fries
HANDHELDS

LOBSTER ROLL
Claw and knuckle Maine lobster tossed in our Chef's blend of herbs spices, dressing served with lettuce, tomato, scallions on a New England style roll and French fries$36.00
MAHI-MAHI REUBEN
Fresh grilled Mahi-Mahi on sliced daily baked sourdough bread with thousand island dressing, Swiss cheese and coleslaw, French fries$26.00
BUFFALO SHRIMP PO-BOY
Crispy shrimp tossed in our Chef's buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, hoagie bread, French fries$25.00
ISLAND TACOS
Shredded cabbage, guacamole, chipotle sour cream, pico de gallo$25.00
STEAK SANDWICH
Grilled steak, caramelized onions, pepper-jack cheese, hoagie bread, French fries$26.00
CLASSIC BURGER
1/2 lb Fresh ground Angus beef served with lettuce, tomato, onion, French fries$16.00
CHICKEN QUESADILLA
Sour cream, pico de gallo, guacamole, Cheddar-Jack cheese$20.00
CHICKEN SANDWICH
Chicken breast, tomato, onions, lettuce, brioche bun, French fries$18.00
SALADS

BIG BOB SALAD
Grilled chicken breast, bacon, avocado, cherry tomatoes, hard boiled egg, crumbled blue cheese over mixed greens, Italian vinaigrette$22.00
CAESAR SALAD
Fresh romaine lettuce, seasoned croûtons tossed in our classic Caesar dressing$15.00
SHRIMP SKEWER SALAD
Grilled shrimp skewers, black beans, jasmine rice, avocado, mixed greens, cucumber, pineapple chipotle salsa$26.00
SOUPS
SIDES
GARLIC MASH POTATO
$7.00CORN IN COB
$5.00AVOCADO
$6.00FRENCH FRIES
$5.00MAC & CHEESE
$8.00SWEET POTATO FRIES
$5.00JASMINE RICE
$5.00GARLIC BROCCOLI
$6.00GRILLED VEGGIES
$6.00SIDE SALAD
$6.00SIDE CAESAR SALAD
$6.00COLESLAW
$4.00GARLIC BREAD
$3.00TOSTONES
$4.00SWEET PLANTAIN
$4.00BLACK BEANS
$4.00WONTON
$3.00RANCH DRESSING
$0.50BLEU CHEESE DRESSING
$0.50CAESAR DRESSING
$0.50RASPBERRY VINAIGRETTE DRESSING
$0.50CREAMY ITALIAN DRESSING
$0.501000 ISLAND DRESSING
$0.50BALSAMIC GLAZE DRESSING
$1.00GARLIC AIOLI DRESSING
$0.50BALSAMIC VINAIGRETTE DRESSING
$0.50
DESSERTS

SLICE KEY LIME PIE
$8.00WHOLE KEY LIME PIE
$35.00
MANGO PASSION CAKE
$9.00
FLORIDA SUNSHINE CAKE
$9.00MADI RUM CAKE
An ultra moist cake soaked with vanilla spiced Madi Rum (Fair and Direct Trade Vanilla beans sourced from Madagascar). Served with vanilla ice cream$9.00
CHOCOLATE LAYER CAKE
$9.00
CARROT CAKE
$9.00
FULL MOON DRINKS
BEER
WINE BTG
WINE BOTTLES
COCKTAIL MENU
BOTTLE SERVICE
(FM) DON JULIO BLANCO BTL
$130.00(FM) DON JULIO REPOSADO BTL
$150.00(FM) KETEL ONE VODKA BTL
$100.00(FM) ZACAPA 23 BTL
$130.00(FM) BULLEIT BOURBON BTL
$150.00(FM) JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK BTL
$150.00(FM) CASAMIGOS BLANCO BTL
$160.00(FM) CASAMIGOS REPOSADO BTL
$180.00(FM) ROSE WHISPERING ANGEL BTL
$38.00(FM) VEUVE CLIQUOT YELLOW LABEL BTL
$123.00
BOTTLED WATER
$4.00
Request advisory
No substitutes. Additions may be charged extra.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 9:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 8:45 pm |
| Saturday | 9:00 am - 8:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.








