
American
Island Homemade Ice Cream 21 Commerce Street
21 Commerce Street
Williston, VT 05495
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
Essex
Sausage, egg, and cheddar cheese grilled on a croissant.$9.45Newport
Just cheese, please! Your choice of cheddar or Swiss cheese on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$5.95Williston
Made to order! Bacon, egg, and cheddar cheese on a grilled croissant.$9.45
Ice Cream Menu
Hand Scooped Ice Cream
Milkshake
Choose any flavor (up to 2) ice cream, select your mixer white or chocolate milk (Oat milk +.50), and top with your favorite toppings!
Milkshake - Apple Pie
$7.25Milkshake - Black Raspberry
$7.25Milkshake - Black Raspberry w/ Choc Chunk
$7.25Milkshake - Cake Batter
$7.25Milkshake - Choc Chip Cookie Dough
$7.25Milkshake - Chocolate Supreme
$7.25Milkshake - Coffee Chip
$7.25Milkshake - Cookies n Creme
$7.25Milkshake - Double Choc Supreme
$7.25Milkshake - Funfetti
$7.25Milkshake - Island Coconut
$7.25Milkshake - Island Coconut w/ Choc Chunk
$7.25Milkshake - Mint Chocolate Chip
$7.25Milkshake - Mint Cookies n Creme
$7.25Milkshake - Peanut Butter Cup
$7.25Milkshake - Peppermint Stick
$7.25Milkshake - Pink Grapefruit
$7.25Milkshake - Pumpkin Pie
$7.25Milkshake - Red Raspberry Sorbet
$7.25Milkshake - Sea Salt Caramel
$7.25Milkshake - Sensational Strawberry
$7.25Milkshake - Vanilla
$7.25Milkshake - Vanilla Chocolate Chip
$7.25Milkshake - Vanilla M&M
$7.25Milkshake - Vermont Maple
$7.25Milkshake - Vermont Maple Bacon
$7.25Milkshake - Vermont Maple Walnut
$7.25Milkshake - Wild Blueberry Sorbet
$7.25
Float
Pint

Pint - Black Raspberry 108
$5.95Pint - Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk
$5.95
Pint - Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough 122
$5.95
Pint - Chocolate Supreme 119
$5.95
Pint - Coffee Chip 153
$5.95OUT OF STOCK
Pint - Cookies n Creme 123
$5.95Pint - Double Chocolate Supreme 118
$5.95
Pint - French Vanilla Bean 124
$5.95Pint - Hand Packed - Dipping Station
$5.95
Pint - Island Coconut 151
$5.95Pint - Island Coconut w/ Chocolate Chunk
$5.95
Pint - Mint Chocolate Chip 128
$5.95Pint - Mint Cookies n Creme
$5.95
Pint - Peanut Butter Cup 131
$5.95Pint - Peppermint Stick 164
$5.95Pint - Pink Grapefruit Sorbet 309
$5.95Pint - Red Raspberry Sorbet 310
$5.95
Pint - Sea Salt Caramel 904
$5.95
Pint - Sensational Strawberry 137
$5.95
Pint - Vanilla 125
$5.95Pint - Vermont Maple 136
$5.95
Pint - Vermont Maple Bacon 182
$5.95
Pint - Vermont Maple Walnut 126
$5.95Pint - Wild Blueberry Sorbet
$5.95
Single Serve - 4oz
4oz - Black Raspberry #108
$3.354oz - Chocolate Supreme #119
$3.354oz - French Vanilla #124
$3.354oz - Pink Grapefruit Sorbet #309
$3.354oz - Red Raspberry Sorbet #310
$3.354oz - Sea Salt Caramel #904
$3.354oz - Sensational Strawberry #137
$3.354oz - Vanilla #125
$3.354oz - Vermont Maple #136
$3.35OUT OF STOCK
Single Serve - 8oz
8oz - Black Raspberry #108
$4.258oz - Chocolate Supreme #119
$4.258oz - Coffee Chip #153
$4.258oz - French Vanilla Bean #124
$4.258oz - Mint Chocolate Chip #128
$4.258oz - Pink Grapefruit Sorbet #309
$4.258oz - Red Raspberry Sorbet #310
$4.258oz - Sensational Strawberry #137
$4.258oz - Vanilla #125
$4.258oz - Vermont Maple #136
$4.25
Ice Cream Pie
Pie - Apple
$19.95OUT OF STOCKPie - Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk
$19.95Pie - Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough 122
$19.95Pie - Coffee Chip 153
$19.95Pie - Cookies n Creme 123
$19.95Pie - Double Chocolate Supreme 118
$19.95Pie - Island Coconut 151
$19.95Pie - Island Coconut w/ Chocolate Chunk
$19.95Pie - Mint Chocolate Chip 128
$19.95OUT OF STOCKPie - Mint Cookies n Creme
$19.95OUT OF STOCKPie - Peanut Butter Cup 131
$19.95Pie - Peppermint Stick 164
$19.95Pie - Pumpkin - Oreo
$19.95OUT OF STOCKPie - Pumpkin - Graham Cracker
$19.95Pie - Sea Salt Caramel 904
$19.95Pie - Vanilla Pie - Don't Use - We don't have
$19.95Pie - Vermont Maple Walnut 126
$19.95Pie - Vanilla Chocolate Chip
$19.95OUT OF STOCKPie - Gluten Free Pie Crust
$26.95OUT OF STOCK
Ice Cream Sandwiches
ICS - Black Raspberry
$5.95ICS - Black Raspberry w/ Choc
$5.95ICS - Cake Batter
$5.95ICS - Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
$5.95ICS - Chocolate Supreme
$5.95ICS - Coffee Chip
$5.95ICS - Cookies n Creme
$5.95ICS - Dbl Chocolate Supreme
$5.95ICS - French Vanilla
$5.95ICS - Funfetti
$5.95ICS - Island Coconut
$5.95ICS - Island Coconut w/ Chocolate
$5.95OUT OF STOCKICS - Mint Chocolate Chip
$5.95ICS - Mint Cookies n Creme
$5.95ICS - Peanut Butter Cup
$5.95ICS - Peppermint Stick
$5.95ICS - Sea Salt Caramel
$5.95ICS - Sensational Strawberry
$5.95ICS - Vanilla
$5.95ICS - Vanilla Choc. Chip
$5.95ICS - Vanilla M&M
$5.95ICS - VT Maple
$5.95ICS - VT Maple Bacon
$5.95ICS - VT Maple Walnut
$5.95ICS - Donut with Apple Pie
$5.95OUT OF STOCKICS - Donut with VT Maple
$5.95
Sandwiches
Breakfast Sandwiches
Bristol
Tomato, egg, and cheddar cheese on a grilled croissant.$9.45Essex
Sausage, egg, and cheddar cheese grilled on a croissant.$9.45Richmond
A meat lovers delight! Ham, bacon, sausage, egg, and cheddar cheese on a grilled croissant.$12.45Warren
Ham, egg, and cheddar cheese on a grilled croissant.$9.45Williston
Made to order! Bacon, egg, and cheddar cheese on a grilled croissant.$9.45
Breakfast Specials
Maple Morning
Sausage patty, egg, sliced apple, Cabot cheddar cheese and a healthy drizzle of VT Maple syrup grilled on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$10.00Southwest
Bacon, egg, sliced jalapeños, sriracha, and cheddar cheese grilled on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$10.45
Lunch Sandwiches
Barton
Turkey, ham and Swiss cheese grilled on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$10.50Bethel
Turkey, Cabot cheddar cheese, bacon and tomato grilled on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$9.95Dorset
Turkey, Cabot cheddar cheese, cranberry and apple grilled on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$9.50Dover
Ham and Swiss cheese grilled on your choice of VT's very own Great Harvest Bakery Farmer's White or Whole Wheat bread.$7.95Eden
Cabot cheddar cheese with apple grilled on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$6.95Ludlow
Our signature sandwich! Caramelized bacon, sliced apple, and Cabot cheddar cheese grilled on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$8.95Morgan
Cabot cheddar cheese and bacon grilled on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$7.95Newport
Just cheese, please! Your choice of cheddar or Swiss cheese on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$5.95Pizza-wich
Satisfy your pepperoni pizza craving with a panini of Cabot cheddar cheese, pepperoni and Bove's pizza sauce, all contained neatly in a grilled sandwich!$9.95Ripton
Turkey, Cabot cheddar cheese, cranberry and apple grilled on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$9.95Woodstock
Cabot cheddar cheese, ham, and tomato grilled on your choice of Great Harvest farmer white or honey whole wheat. Add a croissant for $1.75 or gluten free bread for $2.00.$8.50
Pastries
Brownies & Cookies
Donuts
Cold Beverages
Carbonated Beverages
Alani Nu - Blue Slush
$2.35Alani Nu - Cherry Twist
$2.35Alani Nu - Cotton Candy
$2.35Alani Nu - Orange Kiss
$2.35Alani Nu - Pink Slush
$2.35Alani Nu - Sherbet Swirl
$2.35
Barq's Root Beer - 12 oz Can
Barq's has bite! Do you know why? Well, its unique Barq's spice is what makes this root beer soda truly original and truly tasty. Root beer is a bold choice for bold people who know what they want. Barq's has always had bite. 120 years of it to be exact. Inspired by its southern roots, Barq's aims to bottle the essence of colorful, bold and creative people for enjoyment in every sip.$1.85OUT OF STOCK
Coca-Cola - 12 oz Can
Coca-Cola's crisp, refreshing taste has stood the test of time since 1886. These carefully crafted soft drinks are meant to be enjoyed anytime, anywhere. Pop open a Coca-Cola soda for a taste experience like no other. The familiar fizz and caffeine create an instant magic moment. Refreshing the world for over 130 years, Coca-Cola brings people together and spreads optimism wherever it goes. Find your magic and make life delicious with an ice-cold Coca-Cola.$1.85
Diet Coke - 12 oz Can
Enjoy a break with Diet Coke, the perfect no-sugar, no-calorie companion. With its bold taste and distinctive blend of flavors, Diet Coke is an everyday hero when it comes to refreshing your day. Every sip of Diet Coke delivers the same great taste that's delighted fans for over 40 years. When you want a sugar-free soda that doesn't sacrifice on taste, reach for a Diet Coke.$1.85Ginger Ale - 12 oz Can
$1.85Grape Soda
$1.85Orange Soda
$1.85Pepsi - 12 oz Can
$1.85Polar - Pink Apple & Lemon
$1.85OUT OF STOCKPolar-Black Cherry
$1.85Polar-Cran Lime
$1.85Polar-Lemon
$1.85Polar-Lime
$1.85Polar-Pink Grapefruit
$1.85OUT OF STOCKSpindrift - Cranberry Raspberry
$2.35OUT OF STOCKSpindrift - Grapefruit
$2.25OUT OF STOCKSpindrift - Blood Orange
$1.85Spindrift - Lemon
$2.25Spindrift - Lime
$2.25
Sprite - 12 oz Can
Sprite's cool and crisp lemon-lime flavor will keep you invigorated and inspired. You know why? Because Sprite keeps it real just like you when pursuing your passions. No caffeine. Just you, an iconic flavor, and whatever you can think of next.$1.85
Hot Beverages
Float
$5.95
Customize your item
Carbonated Beverage
Required
Select 1
Ice Cream Flavor
Required
Select 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 7:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Monday | 7:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 7:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 7:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Thursday | 7:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Friday | 7:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Saturday | 7:00 am - 7:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Vermont's Other Ice Cream!
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.



