- Home
- /
- North Cape May
- /
- Italian Affair
Italian Affair
3845 Bayshore Road
North Cape May, NJ 08204
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Main Menu
starters
- antipasto$16.00
all your favorite imported Italian meats, cheeses and veggies
- bacon wrapped scallops$19.00
5 luscious scallops with crisp bacon
- bruschetta$8.00
charred baguette, tomato, basil, evoo, balsamic reduction
- cheese fries$8.00
crispy coated and soft interior with cheddar sauce on the side
- cheese fries (cheese on top)$9.00
- cheesesteak eggrolls$15.00
loaded with fresh steak and cooper sharp cheese
- cheesy garlic bread$8.00
slathered with a buttery garlic spread and toasted
- chicken tender basket$13.50
Juicy and tender, breaded and fried to golden perfection, served with honey dijon
- coconut shrimp$12.00
shrimp coated in coconut flakes and fried until crispy, served with orange dipping sauce
- fried calamari$16.00
dipped and dusted, served with crisp wontons and pepperoncini, marinara
- fried shrimp basket$14.00
panko breaded and golden, served with fries
- fries$6.50
crispy coated and soft interior
- zucchini fries$8.00
hand battered, served with tomato sauce for dipping
- garlic bread$7.00
slathered with a buttery garlic spread and toasted
- garlic knots$6.00
A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.
- jalapeno poppers$8.00
Juicy jalapeno poppers breaded and filled with cheese and fried to golden perfection.
- mozzarella fries$9.00
loaded with melty mozzarella
- mozzarella stix$10.00
homemade and gooey mozzarella golden fried
- mussels marinara app$16.00
mussels are cooked in a tomato-based OR Wine/butter sauce with garlic, herbs, and wine.
- onion rings$9.00
thin, crispy and savory
- pizza fries$9.50
loaded with melty mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce and parmesan cheese
- steamed little neck clams$16.00
tender clams steeped in a garlic lemon-white wine-butter reduction
- Small Fries$4.95
crispy coated and soft interior
- Old Bay FF$8.00
- Broccoli Rabe$9.95
- Buffalo Chicken Loaded Tots$13.95Out of stock
Crispy Buffalo Chicken bites, Jalapeño peppers, melty mozzarella, smoky bacon drizzled with a Bleu Cheese Crema.
- 2 For $12 apps$12.00
Choose any 2 appetizers from the list for $12
soup and salad
- soup of the day$3.29+
ask for today's selection
- pasta fagioli$3.29+
tomato base, cannelinni, pasta
- crab bisque$4.95+
creamy and rich
- Spicy Sausage Escarole Soup$3.29+
Gluten free
- tuna garden salad$15.00
spinach mix, tomato, onion, egg, tuna, crouton
- chef's salad$16.00
ham, turkey, egg, provolone, peppers, tomato, onion, crouton
- garden salad$7.00
spring lettuce, iceberg, romaine, cherry tomato, cucumber, onion, crouton
- tomato caprese$13.50
vine tomato, basil leaf, fresh mozzarella, balsamic reduction, evoo
- caesar salad$7.00
our famous caesar with iceberg romaine blend, shaved parm cheese, buttery crouton, tableside-style dressing
classics
- 1/2 side meatballs (2)$4.00
old world recipe with beef pork and veal
- 1/2 side sausage (1)$4.00
locally sourced
- stuffed shells$17.00
stuffed with cheeses and baked to a light crisp in our old world sauce
- baked ziti$16.00
blend of cheeses, baked to a light crisp
- cheese ravioli$16.00
8 mouth watering pasta pillows topped with our old world recipe sauce
- fettucine alfredo$17.00
our famous alfredo made with rich cream and parmigiano reggiano
- lasagna$17.00
layer upon layer of fresh pasta sheets, beef, pork, veal, sauce, cheeses
- linguini and clam sauce$24.00
little neck and chopped clams
- pasta$15.00
- pasta and meatballs$16.50
old world sauce and meatball recipe
- pasta and meatsauce$16.50
old world sauce with beef, pork and veal
- pasta and sausage$16.50
old world sauce and locally sourced sausage
- side of meatballs (4)$6.00
old world recipe with beef pork and veal
- side of sausage (2)$7.50
locally sourced
- Penne A La Vodka$17.00
burgers
wraps
- chicken caesar wrap$12.95
like the salad, rolled up
- chicken cheesesteak wrap$13.49
shaved breast, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato
- b.l.t. Wrap$11.95
green leaf lettuce, crisp bacon, vine tomato mayo
- cheesesteak wrap$15.65
shaved premium cuts of real beef, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato
- buffalo chicken cheesesteak wrap$13.95
shaved breast, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato, creamy buffalo
- build your own wrap$12.95Out of stock
entrees
- chicken alfredo$21.00
rich parm cream sauce, fettuccine
- chicken and broccoli$18.50
garlic lemon white wine reduction pasta
- chicken and broccoli ALFREDO$23.00
rich parm cream sauce, fettuccine
- chicken marsala$19.50
mushroom marsala reduction pasta
- chicken parmigiana dinner$20.00
saucy and cheesy, side of pasta
- chicken Piccatta$18.00
garlic lemon white wine reduction pasta
- eggplant parmigiana dinner$18.00
layers of thin fried eggplant, saucy and cheesy, pasta
- GRILLED chicken parmigiana dinner$20.00
saucy and cheesy, pasta
- mussels marinara dinner$26.00
seafood infused sauce, pasta
- seafood alfredo$38.00
seared scallops and shrimp, rich parm cream sauce, fettuccine
- seared scallop scampi$35.00Out of stock
garlic lemon white wine reduction pasta
- shrimp and crab scampi$32.00
garlic lemon white wine reduction pasta
- shrimp fra diavolo$29.00
spicy robust marinara, pasta
- shrimp Scampi$29.00
spicy robust marinara, pasta
- veal Marsala$26.00
mushroom marsala reduction, pasta
- veal parmigiana dinner$26.00
real tender veal hand breaded, saucy and cheesy, pasta
- veal Piccatta$26.00
mushroom marsala reduction, pasta
sandwiches
- bbq chicken cheesesteak$12.50
smothered in tangy smoky BBQ, cooper sharp
- buffalo chicken cheesesteak$13.50
smother in our buttery house buffalo
- cheesesteak$14.00
real, quality cuts of shaved beef, cooper sharp
- cheesesteak hoagie$15.00
real, quality cuts of shaved beef, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato onion
- chicken cheesesteak$13.00
shaved real chicken breast, cooper sharp
- Chicken Italiano$15.25
- Chicken Parm Sub$13.00
- Chicken pizza steak$14.00
shaved real chicken breast, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato onion
- Chicken cheesesteak hoagie$14.50
shaved real chicken breast, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato onion
- eggplant parm sub$11.00
thin fried eggplant, sauce, cheese, toasted
- grilled cheese$9.00
buttery and loaded with melty cooper sharp
- italian hoagie$12.50
quality italian meats and cheeses, lettuce tomato onion
- meatball parm sub$12.50
simmered in our old world sauce, cheesy, toasted
- mixed cheese hoagie$12.00
swiss, provolone, cooper sharp, lettuce tomato onion
- pizzasteak$14.50
real, quality cuts of shaved beef, sauce, provolone
- Sausage Peppers & Onion Parm Sub$13.00
provolon, sauce, toasted
- spicy chicken sandwich$10.00
crispy chicken, pickles, lettuce tomato, housemade chipotle ranch, brioche
- steak sandwich NO CHEESE$13.00
real, quality cuts of shaved beef
- tuna hoagie$14.00
made to order tuna, lettuce tomato onion
- Turkey and Cheese hoagie$13.50
quality italian meats and cheeses, lettuce tomato onion
- veal parm sub$14.00
tender hand breaded real veal cutlet
- b.l.t. sandwich$10.95
green leaf lettuce, crisp bacon, vine tomato mayo
- Sausage Parm Sub$13.00
provolon, sauce, toasted
- Fried Shrimp Po'Boy$13.95
Golden fried jumbo shrimp on a long roll with lettuce tomato and house made Chipotle Ranch.
- Italian cheesesteak$14.95
children's menu
sweets
Pizza
12" personal pizzas
- 12" Pizza Create Your Own$12.50
- 12" italian affair works pizza$19.00
- 12" chicken italiano pizza$17.00
- 12" hawaiian pizza$16.00
- 12" margherita$14.00
- 12" chicken florentine pizza$17.50
- 12" marinara pizza$12.50
- 12" buffalo chicken pizza$17.50
- 12" b.b.q. chicken pizza$17.50
- 12" meatlovers pizza$18.50
- 12" veggie lovers pizza$17.50
- 12" cheesesteak pizza$18.50
- 12" four cheese pizza$15.50
- 12" white pizza$14.50
- 12" chicken bacon ranch pizza$18.50
- 12" MeatBall Vodka Pizza$19.50
With fresh mozzarella
- Bruschetta Pie$14.50
- 12" Fiery Florentine Pizza$17.50
This pizza combines the spicy kick of hot Italian sausage with the vibrant flavor of broccoli rabe giving a nod to the pizza's Florence influences.
- The "Joe Rogan" Personal pizza$16.50
Double Anchovy and Double Pineapple, Joe Rogan's favorite pizza! He's been known to finish an entire extra large in one sitting. Salty and sweet. The citrus of the pineapple hides the fishiness of the anchovy.
- The "Kate Middleton" Personal Pizza$18.50
Royals are no strangers to the divinity of pizza. Kate Middleton is said to be an avid pizza lover, and while on many trips to the U.S., she often indulges in a royal pizza featuring prosciutto and sausage toppings.
- The "Ed Sheeran" Personal Pizza$16.00
Ed Sheeran The famous English songwriter has a unique idea about a pizza and its toppings. For Sheeran, his pizza starts with a traditional sauce and cheese pie, then he tops it with chips (French fries) and rolls it up to dip it in ketchup before he indulges in this tasty creation.
16" large pizzas
- 16" pizza cyo$16.50
- 16" b.b.q. chicken pizza$22.00
- 16" Bruschetta Pizza$18.00
- 16" buffalo chicken pizza$22.00
- 16" cheesesteak pizza$25.00
- 16" chicken florentine pizza$22.00
- 16" chicken italiano pizza$22.00
- 16" four cheese pizza$20.50
- 16" hawaiian pizza$19.50
- 16" italian affair works pizza$26.50
- 16" margherita$19.50
- 16" marinara pizza$16.50
- 16" meatlovers pizza$24.00
- 16" veggie lovers pizza$22.00
- 16" white pizza$19.00
- 16" chicken bacon ranch pizza$24.00
- 16" MeatBall Vodka Pizza$25.00
With fresh mozzarella
- 16" Fiery Florentine Pizza$25.00
This pizza combines the spicy kick of hot Italian sausage with the vibrant flavor of broccoli rabe giving a nod to the pizza's Florence influences.
- The "Joe Rogan" Large Pizza$24.00
Double Anchovy and Double Pineapple, Joe Rogan's favorite pizza! He's been known to finish an entire extra large in one sitting. Salty and sweet. The citrus of the pineapple hides the fishiness of the anchovy.
- The "Ed Sheeran" Large Pizza$21.50
Ed Sheeran The famous English songwriter has a unique idea about a pizza and its toppings. For Sheeran, his pizza starts with a traditional sauce and cheese pie, then he tops it with chips (French fries) and rolls it up to dip it in ketchup before he indulges in this tasty creation.
- The "Kate Middleton" Large Pizza$24.50
Royals are no strangers to the divinity of pizza. Kate Middleton is said to be an avid pizza lover, and while on many trips to the U.S., she often indulges in a royal pizza featuring prosciutto and sausage toppings.
18" extra large pizzas
- 18" Pizza CYO$19.00
- 18" italian affair works pizza$28.00
- 18" chicken italiano pizza$25.00
- 18" hawaiian pizza$22.00
- 18" margherita$21.00
- 18" chicken florentine pizza$25.00
- 18" marinara pizza$20.00
- 18" buffalo chicken pizza$25.00
- 18" b.b.q. chicken pizza$25.00
- 18" meatlovers pizza$26.00
- 18" veggie lovers pizza$25.00
- 18" cheesesteak pizza$27.00
- 18" four cheese pizza$22.00
- 18" white pizza$21.00
- 18" chicken bacon ranch pizza$27.00
- 18" MeatBall Vodka Pizza$28.00
With fresh mozzarella
- 18" Fiery Florentine Pizza$28.00
This pizza combines the spicy kick of hot Italian sausage with the vibrant flavor of broccoli rabe giving a nod to the pizza's Florence influences.
- The "Joe Rogan" Extra Large Pizza$30.00
Double Anchovy and Double Pineapple, Joe Rogan's favorite pizza! He's been known to finish an entire extra large in one sitting. Salty and sweet. The citrus of the pineapple hides the fishiness of the anchovy.
- The "Ed Sheeran" Extra Large Pizza$24.00
Ed Sheeran The famous English songwriter has a unique idea about a pizza and its toppings. For Sheeran, his pizza starts with a traditional sauce and cheese pie, then he tops it with chips (French fries) and rolls it up to dip it in ketchup before he indulges in this tasty creation.
- The "Kate Middleton" Extra Large Pizza$27.00
Royals are no strangers to the divinity of pizza. Kate Middleton is said to be an avid pizza lover, and while on many trips to the U.S., she often indulges in a royal pizza featuring prosciutto and sausage toppings.
slices and novelties
Bolis, Calzones, Panzerottis
regular size
family size
Beverages
Soda 20oz
Iced Tea & Water
Miscellaneous
community
Miscellaneous
- Dough ball$3.50
- Dinner roll$1.00
- Chips$0.65Out of stock
- Side Ranch$0.65
- Side Bleu Ch$0.65
- Lg Sos$1.00
- Sm Sos$0.50
- Side Hot Sauce$0.65
- Side Parm$0.75
- Side Cheese Sauce$1.50
- Side BBQ$0.65
- Plates And Napkins
- Side Hot Peppers$0.65
- Quart Of Sauce$6.00
- Small Dinner Salad$3.50
- side coleslaw$2.00
- Side Ceaser$0.65
Side Hot Peppers
Back Of House Tips
Specials
Lunch Specials
- Broccoli Chicken Cheesesteak Wrap$12.95
shaved real chicken breast, provolone, broccoli and garlic on a wrap
- Drunken Meatball Parm$12.95
simmered in our old world vodka sauce, melted fresh mozzarella, on a toasted sesame seeded roll
- Buffalo Chicken Tender Salad$15.95
Crispy Tenders Tossed in our Buffalo sauce over a bed of mixed greens, tomato, onion and croutons with creamy bleu cheese dressing.
Dinner Specials
- Shrimp and Clams Arrabiata$29.00
Jumbo shrimp, little neck and chopped clams in a hot cherry pepper sauce with linguini
- Mediterranean Salmon$33.95
Pan seared Salmon with capers, roasted red peppers, kalamata olives and artichoke hearts over aglio-olio spinach pasta.
- Twisted Tortellini$17.95Out of stock
Cheese Tortellini and Petite Meatballs smothered in our luscious Vodka Sauce.
Merchandise
Sunday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
Monday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
Tuesday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
Wednesday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
Thursday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
Friday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
Saturday | 11:00 am - 9:45 pm |
ITALIAN AFFAIR PIZZA & PASTA offers Authentic Old World Cooking and provides a large selection of pasta dishes including: Chicken, Veal, Seafood, and New York Style Thin Crust Pizza. Our sauces, pizza dough, dinner rolls and more are made fresh daily and our chef works hard to prepare every dish from scratch. Hoagies and Cheesesteaks are a Must-Try.
3845 Bayshore Road, North Cape May, NJ 08204