Skip to Main content
  • Pudgies

    • Home
    • /
    • Ithaca
    • /
    • Pudgies
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Pudgies

    215 Elmira Road

    Ithaca, NY 14850


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Thursday Special
    Packages
    Slices
    Pizza
    Stromboli
    Drinks
    Pasta
    Fryers
    Subs
    Salad
    Sauces
    Crowd Pleasers
    Cookies
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • Sheet Pizza

      Rectagular pizza cut into 32 slices
      $25.49
    • Party Pack

      Sheet Pizza, 20 Wings and 2 Large Drinks
      $50.94
    • Large Pizza

      17" round pizza cut into 12 slices
      $18.19

    Thursday Special

    • Plain Special

      $5.44+
    • Pepperoni Special

      $5.55+
    • 2 Topping Special

      $5.66+
    • 3 Topping Special

      $6.36+

    Packages

    • Party Pack

      Sheet Pizza, 20 Wings and 2 Large Drinks
      $50.94
    • Family Pack

      Large Pizza, 10 Wings and 1 Large Drink
      $33.78
    • Snack Pack

      Medium Pizza and 10 Wings
      $24.39
    • Triple Treat

      3 Medium
      $29.59
    • Family Pleaser

      1 Large Pizza with 2 Large Breadsticks, 2 Pastas and 2 Garden Salads
      $35.97

    Slices

    • Pepperoni Special

      $6.69
    • Bread Sticks

      $3.94+
    • Plain Slice

      $2.99
    • Pepperoni Slice

      $3.09
    • Stromboli Slice

      Pepperoni, ham, sausage, green peppers, pizza sauce, american cheese and mozzarella cheese
      $5.83
    • Plain Special

      $6.49
    • Slice & Breadstick Special

      $6.19
    • Stromboli Special

      $7.38
    • Cheesy Bread Sticks

      $4.94+
    • Pepperoni and Sausage Slice

      $3.59
    • White Garlic Slice

      $2.99
    • Sausage Slice

      $2.99
    • Green Peppers and Onions Slice

      $3.59
    • Chicken Wing Slice

      $3.59
    • Roll Special

      $7.38
    • Chicken Parm Roll

      $5.83
    • Sausage Roll

      $5.83
    • Buffalo Chicken Roll

      $5.83
    • Pepperoni And Mushroom Slice

      $3.59
    • Surprise Box

      $5.00
    • Gp,on

      $3.59
    • Chicken Parm Slice

      $3.59
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice

      $4.29
    • White Garlic Broccoli

      $3.59

    Pizza

    • Medium Pizza

      13" round pizza cut into 6 slices
      $12.76
    • Large Pizza

      17" round pizza cut into 12 slices
      $18.19
    • Deep Dish

      Square pizza cut into 16 slices
      $18.19
    • Sheet Pizza

      Rectagular pizza cut into 32 slices
      $25.49
    • Veggie Pizza

      Tomatoes, Onions, Green Peppers, Broccoli and Mushrooms
      $23.11+
    • Everything Pizza

      Pepperoni, Sausage, Meat Sauce, Onion, Green Pepper and Mushrooms
      $23.11+
    • Meat Lovers Pizza

      Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Meat Sauce and Bacon
      $23.11+
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      $18.97+
    • Chicken Wing Pizza

      $16.90+
    • Breadstick Sheet

      $20.79
    • Cheesy Breadstick Sheet

      $25.79
    • Personal Pizza

      $7.99

    Stromboli

    • Small Stromboli

      Pepperoni, ham, sausage, green peppers, pizza sauce, american cheese and mozzarellla cheese
      $12.48
    • Large Stromboli

      Pepperoni, ham, sausage, green peppers, pizza sauce, american cheese and mozzarellla cheese
      $19.74
    • Custom Stromboli

      Make your own
      $12.48

    Drinks

    • Small Drink

      16 oz Drink
      $2.07
    • Large Drink

      32 oz Drink
      $2.89
    • Can

      $2.07
    • Bottle of Water

      $2.07
    • Gatorade

      Fruit Punch
      $2.99

    Pasta

    • Spaghetti

      $8.29
    • Rigatoni

      $8.29
    • Pasta Dinner

      Pasta, small bread sticks and a side salad
      $10.39

    Fryers

    • French Fries

      $2.59
    • Mozzrella Sticks

      5 Mozzarella sticks with a side of marinara
      $6.49
    • Chicken Tenders

      4 crispy tenders with your choice of dipping sauce on the side
      $8.29
    • Pizza Frette

      Fried dough with confectionary sugar
      $3.49
    • 10 Wings

      10 chicken wings
      $15.38
    • 20 Wings

      20 chicken wings
      $29.09

    Subs

    • Ham & Cheese

      Ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoe, onion, mayo and sub oil
      $6.99+
    • Turkey

      Turkey, lettuce, tomatoe, onion, mayo and sub oil
      $6.99+
    • Itailian

      Salami, capicola, cheese, lettuce, tomatoe, onion, mayo and sub oil
      $6.99+
    • Super

      Salami, capicola, ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoe, onion, mayo and sub oil
      $6.99+
    • Meatball Sub

      Meatball, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese
      $9.87+
    • Pudgie Burger

      Pudgie burger, cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomatoe and onion
      $9.87+
    • Cheesesteak

      Cheesesteak, cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomatoe and onion
      $9.87+
    • Chicken Parm

      Chicken, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese
      $9.87+
    • Chicken Club

      Chicken, cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomatoe and onion
      $9.87+
    • Buffalo Chicken Sub

      Chicken, medium sauce, cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomato and onion
      $9.87+
    • Hot Ham & Cheese

      Ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoe, onion and mayo
      $9.87+
    • Sausage Sub

      Sausage, grilled green peppers and onions on a toasted bun
      $9.87+

    Salad

    • Side Salad

      Lettuce, onions, tomatoes and dressing of choice
      $4.15
    • Garden Salad

      Lettuce, onions, tomatoes and dressing of choice
      $5.89
    • Chef Salad

      Lettuce, onions, tomatoes, turkey, ham, cheese and dressing of choice
      $7.47
    • Chicken Salad

      Lettuce, onions, tomatoes, chicken and dressing of choice
      $7.47
    • Buffalo Chicken Salad

      Lettuce, onions, tomatoes, chicken sauced in medium sauce and dressing of choice
      $7.47

    Sauces

    • Blue Cheese

      2 oz Cup
      $0.57
    • Ranch

      2 oz Cup
      $0.57
    • BBQ side

      $0.57
    • Garlic Butter

      $0.57
    • Honey BBQ Side

      $0.57
    • Honey Mustard

      $0.57
    • Mild Side

      $0.57
    • Medium Side

      $0.57
    • Hot Side

      $0.57
    • XHot Side

      $0.57
    • Marinara Side

      $0.57
    • Pizza Sauce Side

      $0.57
    • Tin of Marinara

      $3.12
    • French Dressing

      $0.57
    • Italian

      $0.57
    • Golden

      $0.57

    Crowd Pleasers

    • Medium Salad

      Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion and Choice of Dressing (Feeds 8-10)
      $24.69
    • Large Salad

      Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion and Choice of Dressing (Feeds 20-25)
      $35.86
    • Large Pasta

      *NEEDS 24 HOUR NOTICE* A large rigatoni with our homemade marinara covered in mozzarella. Serves 20-25
      $40.55
    • Sub Platter

      15 4" Subs with Lettuce, Onion and Tomatoe condiments on the side
      $47.95
    • Sheet of Subs

      *NEED 24 HOUR NOTICE* A Sheet box full of 48- 3 inch subs of your choice fully dressed with condiments on the side.
      $99.99
    • 50 Cookies

      *NEED 24 HOUR NOTICE*
      $49.99
    • Sheet of Frettes

      *NEED 24 HOUR NOTICE* A sheet worth of fried dough cut into bit sized piece.
      $29.99

    Cookies

    • 1 Chocolate Chip Cookie

      $1.50
    • 3 Chocolate Chip Cookies

      $4.00
    • 10 Chocolate Chip Cookies

      $12.00
    • 24 Chocolate Chip Cookies

      $24.00
    • Dozen cookies mixed

      $15.00
    • 1 Snickerdoodle

      $2.00
    • 3 Snickerdoodles

      $5.00
    • 10 Snickerdoodles

      $15.00
    • 24 Snickerdoodles

      $30.00
    If you use a credit card, Pudgies will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what Pudgies pays in fees.

    Personal Pizza

    $7.99

    Customize your item

    Whole

    Optional

    Sauce

    Select up to 1

    Cook

    Select up to 1
    1

    All hours
    Sunday11:30 am - 7:30 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday11:00 am - 7:30 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 7:30 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 7:30 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    Pizza made fresh daily!! Original homemade recipes that Pudgie used for more than 60 years.

    Location

    215 Elmira Road, Ithaca, NY 14850

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Eta Pie 1006 W Seneca St
    View restaurantnext
    Aurora Brewing Co - King Ferry NY
    View restaurantnext
    Pudgie's Pizza - Watkins Glen Watkins Glen
    View restaurantnext
    Town Tavern Erin, NY
    View restaurantnext
    Good Brothers Pizza 2121 Grand Central Ave
    View restaurantnext
    Mario's Pizza Owego
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook