
BBQ
Jefferson Street BBQ
101 N Jefferson St
Converse, IN 46919
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items

The Jeff
A great way to sample our smoked meats and scratch sides! Two smoked meats and two sides. Served with our famous Jalapeno Cornbread with hot honey and butter.$23.00
Overloaded Potato
Extra large baked potato filled sky high with nacho cheese, smoked bacon, choice of smoked meat, topped with ranch, choice of bbq sauce, Cowboy Candy jalapeños, guacamole and sour cream.$13.00
Wrap
spring mix • cheese • cowboy candy guacamole • bbq sauce • ranch served with Broad Ripple Chips + Pickle choice of Pulled Pork, BBQ Chicken, Beef Brisket +1, Turkey +1, Pork Belly +1$14.00+
July Specials
July Features

2 Hot Dogs & Chips and Pickle
Choose any two of our specialty hot dogs: The Nasty Dog, Mac Daddy Dog, Holy Mother Pupper, Chili Dog, or Island Dog. Each plate is served with Broad Ripple chips and a pickle.$17.76
Firecracker Potato Salad
Limited Time! Our house made southern style potato salad features a tangy and slightly dressing, red potatoes, hardboiled eggs and sweet pickle relish.$5.00+
Appetizers & Small Bites

Jalapeno Cornbread
Our cornbread is made with infused jalapeno juice and a healthy dose of sugar. Dense, almost cakey and served with butter + hot honey.$2.75+
Hot Honey Burnt Ends
Pork belly seasoned with house rub and brown sugar, smoked and sauced with our Coca-Cola & Honey Sweet Cheeks BBQ sauce and Hot Honey.$15.00
Smoked Wing Basket
Bone-in jumbo chicken wings tossed in our salty & savory rub then smoked & glazed in Sweet Cheeks BBQ sauce.$10.00+
OG BBQ Nachos
nacho cheese • smoked bacon • ranch bbq sauce • cowboy candy • sour cream housemade guacamole • tortilla chips$10.00+
Cecil Nacho
Mac & Cheese piled high to the sky on Broad Ripple chips, ranch, housemade buffalo, blue cheese crumbles, and sour cream.$10.00+
Street Taco
corn tortilla, tomatillo salsa, onion, cilantro, lime and cotija cheese.$4.00+Slaw Taco
tortilla, super slaw, pickled red onions, cotija cheese, cilantro and lime.$4.00+Smoked Tomatillo Salsa
$5.00+
Pickled Pineapple Salsa
$5.00+
Housemade Guacamole
$6.00+
Salads

Cranberry & Blue Salad
Sweet dried cranberries, fresh mixed greens, blue cheese crumbles and walnuts, bbq meat with Apple Cider Vinaigrette.$12.00+
Side Salad
Tomato, cucumber, croutons, cheese on fresh mixed greens with a choice of dressing.$4.50The Best Damn Wedge
Wedge of iceberg drizzled with blue cheese dressing, blue cheese crumbles, smoked bacon, pickled red onions, tomatoes and balsamic glaze.$6.00
Farmers Salad
Hard boiled egg, shredded cheese, smoked bacon, cucumber, tomato, croutons, spring mix and small batch pickled red onions.$13.00
Fire Roasted Corn & Sweet Potato Salad
agave roasted sweet potatoes • fire roasted corn • cowboy candy • red pepper • tomato • cilantro$12.00+
Burgers

Brisket Bacon Burger
Our fresh, house ground beef brisket burger smoked to perfection, loaded up with American cheese, smoked bacon, spicy chopped brisket, nacho cheese, fried onions and cowboy candy jalapeños. Served with local Broad Ripple chips and pickle.$17.00Jam Session
housemade pork belly jam sauce cowboy candy • crunchy fried onions smoked bacon slices • American cheese$15.00Way Out
housemade guacamole • smoked bacon pepperjack cheese • pickled red onions$15.00Classic
American cheese • lettuce • tomato ketchup • mustard$12.00BYO Burger
Our Juicy Housemade Brisket patty with exactly the toppings you desire$10.00
Sandwiches & Wraps
Sandwiches

The Nasty Sandwich
Chopped brisket, Holy Mother Pucker Spicy BBQ sauce, cowboy candy jalapeños, nacho cheese & fried onions$15.00
Spicy Chop & Cheese Sandwich
chopped brisket, spicy bbq, candied jalapeños, nacho cheese and fried onions$16.00
Smoked BLT
A slappin' BLT made with our own house smoked bacon with lettuce, mayo and tomato on Texas toast. Served with jalapeno cornbread.$15.00BBQ Sandwich
Fresh smoked meat piled high on a bun or toast. BBQ sauce served on the side.$9.00+
Nachos and Potatoes
Nachos
Bowls
Rice Bowls
Tacos & Hot Dogs
Tacos
Hot Dogs

All Beef Hot Dog
All beef smoked hot dog on a soft brioche bun. Served with Broad Ripple Chips & pickle.$8.00
The Nasty Dog
Our 100% all beef hot dog gets loaded up with juicy pulled pork, super slaw, fried onions and your choice of BBQ sauce! Served with Broad Ripple Chips & pickle.$10.00
Mac Daddy Dog
100% all beef hot dog loaded up with our famous Mac & Cheese, juicy pulled pork and your choice of BBQ sauce. Served with Broad Ripple Chips & pickle.$10.00+Holy Mother Pupper
spicy brisket chop • nacho cheese • fried onions • cowboy candy$10.00Chili Dog
beef brisket chili • shredded cheese fried onions • cowboy candy$10.00
Island Dog
pickled pineapple salsa • spicy mayo cilantro • tajin$10.00
Combos

The Jeff
A great way to sample our smoked meats and scratch sides! Two smoked meats and two sides. Served with our famous Jalapeno Cornbread with hot honey and butter.$23.00
The BBQ Tray
half rack spare ribs • half pound beef brisket half pound pulled pork • half pound turkey 6 smoked wings • quarter pound burnt ends 1 pint of each: Mac + cheese, baked beans, super slaw and loaded bacon mash, 6 pieces jalapeño cornbread$95.00OUT OF STOCK
Smoked Meats

Pulled Pork
Tender, juicy and bursting with smokey flavor - our pulled pork is truly perfect. We season with a Texas style rub, smoke over local hickory for up to 12 hours and hand pull each butt to order. Served with your choice of BBQ sauce on the side.$6.00+
BBQ Chicken Breast
All white meat chicken breast, seasoned in house rub and glazed in our Sweet Cheeks BBQ sauce.$6.00+
Spare Ribs
$6.00+OUT OF STOCK
Smoked Wing Basket
Bone-in jumbo chicken wings tossed in our salty & savory rub then smoked & glazed in Sweet Cheeks BBQ sauce.$10.00+
Pork Belly Burnt Ends
Smoked and seasoned in our house rub, brown sugar and tossed in our Sweet Cheeks BBQ sauce made with honey and Coca-Cola!$7.75+
Turkey Breast
our juiciest poultry! sliced to order$7.75+
Beef Brisket
Each brisket is hand-trimmed, seasoned with our Texas rub, smoked for up to 12 hours, and rested for up to 8. Sliced to order. Brisket is naturally fatty, but we'll gladly cut lean if requested.$7.75+Hot Dog (a la carte)
Hot Dog on brioche bun with choice of toppings.$6.25
Sides
Sides

Super Slaw
Kohlrabi, Broccoli, Carrots, Red Cabbage, Brussels Sprouts and Kale meet in our house made slaw dressing with a kick of Chipotle! Addictive and goes great with all of our BBQ.$5.00+
Pork Belly Baked Beans
Smoked low and slow over hickory with a healthy dose of seasoned and smoked pork belly!$5.00+
Mac & Cheese
Our most popular side for over 10 years! This creamy Mac & Cheese will have you coming back for seconds.$5.00+
Loaded Bacon Mash
garlic and herbed potatoes with cheese and smoked bacon$5.00+OUT OF STOCK
Side Salad
Tomato, cucumber, croutons, cheese on fresh mixed greens with a choice of dressing.$4.50The Best Damn Wedge
Wedge of iceberg drizzled with blue cheese dressing, blue cheese crumbles, smoked bacon, pickled red onions, tomatoes and balsamic glaze.$6.00
Jalapeno Cornbread
Our cornbread is made with infused jalapeno juice and a healthy dose of sugar. Dense, almost cakey and served with butter + hot honey.$2.75+Smoked Potatoes
$3.25Chips & Dips

Smoked Beef Brisket Chili
After countless requests, we’re thrilled to introduce our red bean chili—crafted with 100% fresh ground beef brisket, vibrant vegetables, ripe tomatoes, and a bold blend of spices for an unforgettable flavor experience.$5.00+Jasmine Rice
Perfectly steamed aromatic Jasmine rice.$3.00+
Firecracker Potato Salad
Limited Time! Our house made southern style potato salad features a tangy and slightly dressing, red potatoes, hardboiled eggs and sweet pickle relish.$5.00+
Beverage
Non-Alcoholic

Coca-Cola
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love$3.00
Diet Coke, Caffeine Free
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink$3.00
Coca-Cola Cherry
Delicious combination of Coca-Cola and cherry flavor$3.00
Coca-Cola Zero Sugar
Enjoy the great taste of Coca-Cola with zero sugar, zero calories$3.00
Sprite
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free$3.00
Mr. Pibb
$3.00
Rootbeer
$3.00
Sweet Tea
Brewed fresh in-house daily!$3.00
Iced Tea
Brewed fresh in-house daily!$3.00
Lemonade
Sweet, tangy, and full of flavor. Add fresh strawberry purée for the ultimate flavor explosion.$3.00
Arnold Palmer
$3.00
Half & Half Tea
$3.00Kids Drinks
$1.75
Bottled Beverages

Mexican Coke
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love$3.00
Berry Lemonade Jones
$3.50
Strawberry Lime Jones Soda
$3.50
Green Apple Jones Soda
$3.50
Cream Jones Soda
$3.50
Topo Chico Sparkling Mineral Water, 20oz
Topo Chico has always been known for the legend surrounding its origins. Whether you believe in the legend or not, you'll still be able to enjoy the crisp, no-calorie taste of Topo Chico.$3.00
Bottled Water
$1.00
Lime Jarritos Soda
$3.00
Mandarin Jarritos Soda
$3.00
FRESH BBQ AT HOME

1lb Fresh Ground Beef Brisket
We hand-trim every brisket so you get the best of the best. All that fresh trim gets ground in-house, giving you 100% fresh, never-frozen premium ground beef for your favorite recipes. Fire up juicy smash burgers, roll perfect meatballs, bake a classic meatloaf, or simmer Grandma’s famous chili. And don’t forget the beef tallow—it’s the secret to next-level smash burgers and unbeatable flavor in any sauté.$8.00
Smoked Beef Tallow
Smoked beef tallow, a flavorful and versatile ingredient, finds various uses in culinary applications. It adds a rich smoky flavor when used for frying or sautéing, enhancing the taste of dishes such as roasted vegetables, potatoes, or meats. Smoked beef tallow can also be incorporated into soups, stews, and sauces to impart a deep umami essence. Additionally, it serves as a decadent spread on bread or crackers, offering a unique and savory experience. Its high smoke point makes it ideal for high-heat cooking methods, making it a favorite among chefs and food enthusiasts for its distinctive taste and culinary benefits. Sold frozen. Best kept frozen and thawed in between uses.$6.00+
Dessert
Desserts

Banana Pudding Cheesecake
Velvety cheesecake coated in crunchy, crumbled banana chips, topped with a luscious layer of house-made banana pudding whipped cream and drizzled with our signature house-made caramel sauce.$10.00
Bacon Caramel Cheesecake
Our smoked bacon caramel cheesecake has been brought to the next level! A succulent individual New York style cheesecake, covered in our new house made vanilla salted caramel sauce, all topped off with our signature slow smoked bacon! This absolute delectable combination of sweet and salty is a must try.$10.00
Strawberry Cheesecake
Fresh strawberry puree over New York style cheesecake with graham cracker crust. Topped with fresh strawberries.$9.00Turtle Cheesecake
chocolate drizzle • housemade caramel walnuts • whipped cream$9.00
Maple Walnut Bread Pudding
Candied walnuts, rich maple, brown sugar meet in this dense and irresistible bread pudding. Topped with whipped maple cream and brown sugar caramel.$11.00Plain Cheesecake
$7.00
Kids Menu
Kids BBQ Meal
Choose one meat and one side. Comes with applesauce pouch and drink included.
Kids Plates
Kids Hot Dog w/Chips
Smoked hot dog with bun; choice of ketchup, mustard or nacho cheese. Served with 1 kids side and Broad Ripple Chips & pickle spear.$7.00Kids BBQ Nachos
Tortilla chips, nacho cheese, pulled pork or chicken, ranch, bbq sauce and sour cream. Substitute Brisket or Turkey for +$1.$7.00Kids Chips & Cheese
$3.00Kids BBQ Plate
One meat and one side - kid sized!$6.00Kids Pulled Pork Sandwich
$6.50
Kids Desserts
Kid's Sides

Kids Mac
$2.50
Kids Pork Belly Baked Beans
$2.00
Kids Loaded Mash
$2.00
Kids Super Slaw
$2.00
Jalapeno Cornbread
Our cornbread is made with infused jalapeno juice and a healthy dose of sugar. Dense, almost cakey and served with butter + hot honey.$2.75+Applesauce Cup
$1.15Kids Chips & Cheese
$3.00Kids Blue Wedge Salad
$3.50Kids Side Salad w/Ranch
$3.00
Retail
Cold Retail
Holy Mother Pucker Spicy BBQ Bottle
$8.00+Goldie Girl Sauce Bottle
We borrowed and tweaked from the original Texas Gold recipe from our friends at Goldees in Fort Worth, TX - this mustard base sauce is perfect to pair with our brisket and smoked turkey.$8.00+
Sweet Cheeks BBQ Sauce Bottle
$8.00+
Pickled Onions
$4.00+
Cowboy Candy Jalapeños
$4.00+Lemonade Gallon
Daily house-made lemonade. Includes cups.$8.00Unsweet Tea Gallon
Fresh made daily in-house. Includes sweeteners and stir sticks. Includes cups.$6.00Sweet Tea Gallon
The freshest, sweetest tea in town. Made in-house daily. Includes cups.$7.00
Smoked Beef Tallow
Smoked beef tallow, a flavorful and versatile ingredient, finds various uses in culinary applications. It adds a rich smoky flavor when used for frying or sautéing, enhancing the taste of dishes such as roasted vegetables, potatoes, or meats. Smoked beef tallow can also be incorporated into soups, stews, and sauces to impart a deep umami essence. Additionally, it serves as a decadent spread on bread or crackers, offering a unique and savory experience. Its high smoke point makes it ideal for high-heat cooking methods, making it a favorite among chefs and food enthusiasts for its distinctive taste and culinary benefits. Sold frozen. Best kept frozen and thawed in between uses.$6.00+
1lb Fresh Ground Beef Brisket
We hand-trim every brisket so you get the best of the best. All that fresh trim gets ground in-house, giving you 100% fresh, never-frozen premium ground beef for your favorite recipes. Fire up juicy smash burgers, roll perfect meatballs, bake a classic meatloaf, or simmer Grandma’s famous chili. And don’t forget the beef tallow—it’s the secret to next-level smash burgers and unbeatable flavor in any sauté.$8.00

Liquid Candy
$6.00
Jones Strawberry Lime Soda + Monin Dragonfruit
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 12:00 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Thursday | 12:00 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Friday | 12:00 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Saturday | 12:00 pm - 3:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Discover what real Indiana BBQ tastes like at Jefferson Street BBQ in Converse, where every cut is smoked slow and honest over local hickory. From our hand-trimmed beef brisket and pulled pork to our pork spare ribs, we keep things simple, scratch-made, and full of flavor.
Location
101 N Jefferson St, Converse, IN 46919
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
















