Skip to Main content
  • Keyhole Pizzeria Pierceton 301 1/2 N First Street

    • Home
    • /
    • Pierceton
    • /
    • Keyhole Pizzeria
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Keyhole Pizzeria

    301 1/2 N First Street

    Pierceton, IN 46962


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Website

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Main Menu
    Catering Menu - Tiered Packages
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • All The Meats

      Enjoy a delicious pizza topped with rich tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella cheese, tender chicken, savory ham, zesty sausage, juicy ground beef, and crispy bacon.
      $19.76+
    • Supreme

      Savor our delicious pizza topped with rich tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, savory ham, spicy sausage, juicy hamburger, crispy bacon, earthy mushrooms, colorful mixed peppers, and a blend of black and green olives and fresh onions.
      $18.79+
    • Cheese

      Savor the bold taste of our sumptuous tomato pizza sauce, perfectly paired with an irresistible three-cheese blend that guarantees an unforgettable flavor experience!
      $15.68+

    Main Menu

    Hand Crafted Pizza

    • Alfredo Chicken Bacon

      Experience our creamy Alfredo sauce made with a delightful three-cheese blend, tender chicken, and crispy bacon.
      $17.67+
    • BBQ Chicken

      Experience the ideal blend of BBQ sauce, rich cheddar cheese, creamy Monterey Jack cheese, and tender chicken, all drizzled with BBQ sauce on top.
      $17.36+
    • BBQ All The Meats

      Experience a delicious blend of BBQ sauce, melted cheddar cheese, rich Monterey Jack, savory chicken, sausage, crispy bacon, ham, and a juicy hamburger, all perfectly topped with BBQ goodness.dness.
      $20.49+
    • Buffalo Chicken

      Savor the irresistible combination of zesty Buffalo sauce and succulent chicken, perfectly complemented by a drizzle of creamy blue cheese dressing.
      $17.90+
    • Veggie

      Enjoy a delicious tomato pizza sauce topped with a rich provolone mozzarella blend, succulent mushrooms, vibrant peppers, fresh onions, and a mix of savory black and green olives. Experience a tasty tomato pizza sauce topped with a rich blend of provolone and mozzarella, succulent mushrooms, vibrant peppers, fresh onions, and a combination of savory black and green olives.
      $16.34+
    • Cheese

      Savor the bold taste of our sumptuous tomato pizza sauce, perfectly paired with an irresistible three-cheese blend that guarantees an unforgettable flavor experience!
      $15.68+
    • Margarita

      Transform your pizza experience with a luscious tomato sauce, creamy sliced mozzarella, and vibrant basil.
      $16.24+
    • Mushroom

      Treat yourself to an irresistible fusion of marinara sauce, decadent smoked provolone, luscious creamy mozzarella, and mouthwatering mushrooms.
      $16.82+
    • White

      Savor the luxurious creaminess of ricotta, perfectly paired with a delightful medley of three exquisite cheeses that elevate every bite.
      $15.54+
    • Pepperoni

      Treat yourself to a mouthwatering pizza, generously slathered with rich tomato sauce, blanketed in creamy mozzarella cheese, and crowned with flavorful pepperoni.
      $16.90+
    • Sausage

      Experience the irresistible taste of our tomato pizza sauce, crafted with a delectable blend of provolone, mozzarella, and mouthwatering sausage, all expertly topped to elevate your pizza to perfection.
      $16.22+
    • Supreme

      Savor our delicious pizza topped with rich tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, savory ham, spicy sausage, juicy hamburger, crispy bacon, earthy mushrooms, colorful mixed peppers, and a blend of black and green olives and fresh onions.
      $18.79+
    • Pepperoni Supreme

      Enjoy a tasty pizza with pizza sauce and melted mozzarella cheese. It features colorful toppings like bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, and both green and black olives. For meat lovers, we add ham, bacon, sausage, and hamburger, plus pepperoni.
      $19.79+
    • All The Meats

      Enjoy a delicious pizza topped with rich tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella cheese, tender chicken, savory ham, zesty sausage, juicy ground beef, and crispy bacon.
      $19.76+
    • Maximum Meats

      Discover our exquisite selection of premium meats, featuring mouthwatering pepperoni, savory sausage, tender ham, juicy hamburger, succulent chicken, and crispy bacon.
      $20.10+

    Build Your Own Pizza

    • Build Your Own - 1 Topping

      Build your own pizza! Choose your crust, sauce, cheese, and 1 included topping.
      $16.68+
    • Build Your Own - 2 Toppings

      Build your own pizza! Choose your crust, sauce, cheese, and select 2 toppings.
      $17.68+
    • Build Your Own - 3-4 Toppings

      Build your own pizza! Choose your crust, sauce, cheese, and select 3 to 4 toppings.
      $18.68+
    • Build Your Own Half & Half - 6 Toppings

      Build your own pizza! Choose your crust, sauce, and cheese, and select 3 toppings for one half and 3 for the other half, up to a total of 6 toppings.
      $19.68+
    • Half And Half Pizzas

      Half-and-half ordering section.
      $21.00+

    Oven Baked Sandwiches

    • The Bacon Double-Cheese Garlic Bread Sub

      Garlic-butter toasted sub stacked with double mozzarella-provolone and bacon, served with warm marinara for dipping. Add extra cheese or peppers.
      $8.99
    • The Build-Your-Own Pizzeria Stromboli

      Garlic butter, pizza sauce, and mozzarella baked into a stromboli. Choose up to 3 toppings.
      $11.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch (CBR)

      Garlic-butter toasted grinder with chicken, bacon, mozzarella, and ranch. Choose your ranch heat and add extra cheese or peppers.
      $9.99
    • Carolina Gold Chicken

      Toasted chicken grinder tossed in Carolina Gold BBQ with red onion and mozzarella. Choose your sauce level and add-ons.
      $9.99
    • The Sweet Chili Chicken Bacon

      Toasted chicken and bacon grinder in sweet chili sauce with mozzarella. Choose your sweet chili heat and add-ons.
      $9.99
    • The Buffalo Chicken

      Toasted chicken grinder with buffalo sauce, red onion, and mozzarella, finished with ranch. Choose your buffalo heat and add-ons.
      $9.99

    Cheesy Starters

    • Mozzarella Sticks

      Fried mozzarella sticks served hot and melty, perfect for dipping.
      $6.20
    • Cheesy Pizza/Bread

      Cheesy, melty pizza-style bread baked until golden.
      $6.33+
    • Cheesy Boneless Wings

      Boneless wings topped with warm cheese for an extra-indulgent bite.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $10.80
    • Nachos

      Tortilla chips loaded with warm cheese and classic toppings.
      $6.50

    Breadsticks

    • Parmesan Breadsticks

      Breadsticks topped with Parmesan and baked until golden.
      $6.10
    • Garlic Parm Breadsticks

      Soft breadsticks brushed with garlic butter and finished with Parmesan.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.20
    • Breadsticks + 2 Dips

      Includes breadsticks plus your choice of 2 dips.
      $7.99

    Wings

    • Boneless

      Crispy boneless wings tossed in your choice of sauce.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.80
    • 7 Bone-In

      7 bone-in wings cooked crispy and served with your choice of sauce.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.92
    • 7 Dry Rub

      Crispy wings coated in our signature dry rub seasoning.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $9.92

    Pasta

    • Spaghetti

      Classic spaghetti served with marinara sauce.
      $9.93+
    • Chicken Alfredo

      Pasta tossed in creamy Alfredo sauce with tender chicken.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $10.61+

    Meatballs

    • Meatballs

      Side of meatballs in marinara - perfect to share or add on.
      $8.59

    Desserts

    • Cinnamon Bites

      Warm cinnamon bites finished with a sweet cinnamon-sugar coating.
      $5.90+
    • Funnel Cake Fries

      Crispy funnel cake fries dusted with powdered sugar.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.90
    • Cinnamon Roll Bites

      Bite-size cinnamon roll pieces glazed sweet and served warm.
      $5.90+

    Add-Ons

    • Cheese Sauce (5oz)

      Side cup of warm cheese sauce for dipping.
      $1.50
    • Parmesan (5oz)

      Grated Parmesan cheese - perfect for finishing pizzas, pasta, and breadsticks.
      $2.00
    • Marinara (5oz)

      Side cup of marinara sauce for dipping.
      $1.75
    • Ranch (5oz)

      Side cup of ranch dressing for dipping.
      $1.75
    • Blue Cheese Dressing (5oz)

      Side cup of blue cheese dressing - great with wings.
      $1.25
    • Crushed Red Peppers (4 Packets)

      Four packets of crushed red pepper for extra heat.
      $1.00
    • Garlic Sauce (1.5oz)

      Side cup of garlic sauce for dipping or drizzling.
      $1.00

    Catering Menu - Tiered Packages

    Feeds 10

    • Pizza Package - Feeds 10 (Round or Square Pan)

      Includes 4x 16-inch pizzas (8 slices each). Choose 4 different pizzas. Pan style: Round or Square.
      $72.65
    • Wings Package - Feeds 10

      Catering wings package sized to pair with a Feeds 10 pizza package. Includes 50 wings. Choose your flavor(s).
      $43.20
    • Breadsticks Package - Feeds 10

      Catering breadsticks package sized to pair with a Feeds 10 pizza package. Includes 20 breadsticks. Choose your flavor.
      $24.80
    • Add-ons Package - Feeds 10

      Includes up to 5 add-ons. Select up to 5.
      $7.50

    Feeds 15

    • Pizza Package - Feeds 15 (Round or Square Pan)

      Includes 6x 16-inch pizzas (8 slices each). Choose 6 different pizzas. Pan style: Round or Square.
      $108.97
    • Breadsticks Package - Feeds 15

      Catering breadsticks package sized to pair with a Feeds 15 pizza package. Includes 30 breadsticks. Choose your flavor.
      $37.20
    • Wings Package - Feeds 15

      Catering wings package sized to pair with a Feeds 15 pizza package. Includes 75 wings. Choose your flavor(s).
      $64.80
    • Add-ons Package - Feeds 15

      Includes up to 7 add-ons. Select up to 7.
      $10.50

    Feeds 20

    • Pizza Package - Feeds 20 (Round or Square Pan)

      Includes 8x 16-inch pizzas (8 slices each). Choose 8 different pizzas. Pan style: Round or Square.
      $145.29
    • Wings Package - Feeds 20

      Catering wings package sized to pair with a Feeds 20 pizza package. Includes 100 wings. Choose your flavor(s).
      $86.40
    • Breadsticks Package - Feeds 20

      Catering breadsticks package sized to pair with a Feeds 20 pizza package. Includes 40 breadsticks. Choose your flavor.
      $49.60
    • Add-ons Package - Feeds 20

      Includes up to 9 add-ons. Select up to 9.
      $13.50

    Feeds 25

    • Pizza Package - Feeds 25 (Round or Square Pan)

      Includes 10x 16-inch pizzas (8 slices each). Choose 10 different pizzas. Pan style: Round or Square.
      $181.62
    • Wings Package - Feeds 25

      Catering wings package sized to pair with a Feeds 25 pizza package. Includes 125 wings. Choose your flavor(s).
      $108.00
    • Breadsticks Package - Feeds 25

      Catering breadsticks package sized to pair with a Feeds 25 pizza package. Includes 50 breadsticks. Choose your flavor.
      $62.00
    • Add-ons Package - Feeds 25

      Includes up to 11 add-ons. Select up to 11.
      $16.50

    Feeds 30

    • Pizza Package - Feeds 30 (Round or Square Pan)

      Includes 12x 16-inch pizzas (8 slices each). Choose 12 different pizzas. Pan style: Round or Square.
      $217.94
    • Breadsticks Package - Feeds 30

      Catering breadsticks package sized to pair with a Feeds 30 pizza package. Includes 60 breadsticks. Choose your flavor.
      $74.40
    • Wings Package - Feeds 30

      Catering wings package sized to pair with a Feeds 30 pizza package. Includes 150 wings. Choose your flavor(s).
      $129.60
    • Add-ons Package - Feeds 30

      Includes up to 13 add-ons. Select up to 13.
      $19.50

    Breadsticks + 2 Dips

    $7.99

    Includes breadsticks plus your choice of 2 dips.

    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
    1

    All hours
    Sunday1:00 pm - 7:45 pm
    MondayClosed
    TuesdayClosed
    Wednesday1:00 pm - 7:45 pm
    Thursday1:00 pm - 7:45 pm
    Friday1:00 pm - 7:45 pm
    Saturday1:00 pm - 7:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    301 1/2 N First Street, Pierceton, IN 46962

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    The River Coffee-Winona Lake
    View restaurantnext
    Rocksteady pizza parlour 108 e market street
    View restaurantnext
    Columbia City Pizza Company 202 CHICAGO STREET
    View restaurantnext
    The Patio Pizza & BBQ
    View restaurantnext
    Laly's Pizza And Cocktails
    View restaurantnext
    Z-Place 538 Warren St.
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook