This restaurant does not have any images
American
Alexander's on the Lake 10417 Main St
10417 Main St
Findley Lake, NY 14736
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Food
Starters
Pretzel Sticks & Cheese
Oven-baked pretzel sticks served with white cheddar cheese sauce.$11.00Jalapeño Poppers
Mild jalapeño pepper halves with cheddar and breaded with a light, crispy coating.$9.00Findley Lake Nachos
$12.00+Pickle Chips
$8.00Pizza Logs
Deep fried Pepperoni and cheese logs - served with marinara!$12.00Gouda Mac Bites
Breaded gouda mac and cheese bites - served with aioli!$12.00Breaded Ravioli
Deep fried, breaded ravioli filled with ricotta cheese - served with marinara!$10.00Shrimp Bites
Beer-battered Alaskan shrimp bites served with sweet chili sauce!$13.00Loaded Tater Tots
Tater tots topped with our white cheddar cheese sauce and bacon bits!$8.00Provolone Wedges
Breaded, gooey provolone wedges. Served with marinara!$10.00Fish and Chips
$12.00
Burgers
BYO Burger
1/2 lb. burger served on a brioche bun and topped with your choice of cheese and two toppings.$15.00Bulldog Burger
Our most popular burger at Rosco’s. Bacon, tomatoes, BBQ sauce, and cheddar cheese topped with deep fried onion rings.$17.00Findley Lake Stacker
Two 8 oz. Angus beef patties, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, bacon, and cheese all neatly stacked between a brioche bun.$21.00The Classic Burger
$15.00Southern Slaw Burger
1/2 lb burger topped with coleslaw, pickles, french fries, and your choice of cheese! Choose your side!$16.00PBBJ Burger
1/2 lb burger with American cheese, creamy peanut butter, jam, bacon, tomato, and caramelized onion. Don’t knock it ‘til you try it!$16.00BBQ Mac Burger
$17.00Italian Stallion
$17.00
Featured Items
Alexander's Macaroni & Cheese
Creamy shells made with a three-cheese blend and topped with bourbon-glazed bacon.$14.00Quesadilla
Served with lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream on the side. Topped with spicy aioli.$12.00Adult Tenders
Juicy tenders and fries. Served with your choice of dipping sauce.$12.00Deep Fried Tilapia
$12.00
Pizza
CAULI - Chicken Basil
Cauliflower crust — mozzarella cheese, basil pesto, tomato, chicken, and a balsamic glaze.$19.00CAULI - Chicken Bacon Ranch
$19.00CAULI - Pepperoni Pizza
Choice of toppings.$17.00Chicken Bacon Ranch Flatbread
$14.00Chicken Basil Flatbread
Mozzarella cheese, basil pesto, tomato, chicken, and a balsamic glaze.$14.00Pepperoni Flatbread
Topped with pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese.$12.00
Wraps
Turkey Bacon Ranch Wrap
Served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, slab-cut bacon, cheddar cheese, and homemade ranch dressing.$14.00Southwest Chicken Wrap
This wrap is packed with nutrition. Sliced chicken breast, corn, jalapeños, red peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cheddar cheese and sour cream.$15.00Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Chicken served with lettuce, tomatoes, shredded cheddar cheese, and your choice of ranch or bleu cheese.$14.00House Salad Wrap
$12.00Phili Wrap
Lettuce, provolone cheese, thinly shaved steak, onions, and peppers.$14.00
Salads
House Salad
Blend of mixed greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, onions and homemade croutons.$12.00Southwest Chicken Salad
A house mix of greens topped with chicken breast, corn, jalapeños, green peppers, tomatoes, red onions, and cheddar cheese.$15.00Buffalo Chicken Salad
$14.00Turkey Bacon Salad
$14.00Philli Philli Salad
$14.00
Sandwiches
Big Bad Wolf
Alexander's Reuben made with corned beef brisket, sauerkraut, and swiss cheese on toasted rye bread with homemade thousand island dressing on the side.$15.00Phindley Cheese Steak
Thinly sliced beefsteak topped with provolone cheese and sautéed peppers and onions.$14.00Crowd Pleaser
Alexander's Turkey Rachael served with swiss cheese, your choice of sauerkraut or coleslaw, and a side of homemade thousand island dressing. Served on rye bread.$15.00Grilled Cheese
Served on sourdough bread. Made with three cheeses, tomato, and bourbon-glazed slab-cut bacon.$11.00Cuban
Smoked ham, house-made mojo pulled pork, salami, thinly sliced dill pickles, swiss cheese and yellow mustard.$15.00Club Sandwich
A triple layer sandwich, our club combines ham, turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato with swiss and cheddar cheese.$14.00Shorebird Sandwhich
$14.00Shrimp Po Boy
Beer battered shrimp, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles on a sub roll - topped with aioli.$17.00BBQ Pulled Pork
Smoked pork, smothered in BBQ sauce. Topped with pico and aioli on a hoagie roll!$16.00Chicken Parm Sub
Deep fried, breaded chicken (or grilled) topped with marinara, mozzarella, and Parmesan cheese. Toasted to perfection!$14.00
Kids Menu
Sides
Extras
2oz Ranch
$0.502oz Bleu Cheese
$0.502oz Italian
$0.502oz Thousand Island
$0.502oz Balsalmic
$0.502oz Mount Rushmore
$0.502oz Honey Mustard
$0.504oz Ranch
$1.004oz Blue Cheese
$1.004oz Italian
$1.004oz Thousand Island
$1.004oz Balsalmic
$1.004oz Honey Mustard
$1.002oz Mayo
2oz Other Sauce
$0.504oz Mayo
4oz Other sauce
$1.002oz Marinara
$0.502oz BBQ
$0.504oz BBQ
$1.00Side pickles
$1.004oz Salsa
$3.504oz Pico
$3.502oz Pico
$2.752oz Salsa
$2.754oz Cheese Sauce
$1.002 oz Cheese Sauce
$0.50
Dessert
Turkey Trot
Gluten Free
Burgers- Gluten Free
Sandwiches- Gluten Free
Big Bad Wolf- Gluten Free
Alexander's Reuben made with corned beef brisket, sauerkraut, and swiss cheese on toasted rye bread with homemade thousand island dressing on the side.$18.00Phindley Cheese Steak- Gluten Free
Thinly sliced beefsteak topped with provolone cheese and sautéed peppers and onions.$18.00Crowd Pleaser- Gluten Free
Alexander's Turkey Rachael served with swiss cheese, your choice of sauerkraut or coleslaw, and a side of homemade thousand island dressing. Served on rye bread.$18.00Cuban- Gluten Free
Smoked ham, house-made mojo pulled pork, salami, thinly sliced dill pickles, swiss cheese and yellow mustard.$18.00Pulled Pork - Gluten Free
$19.00
Mac & Cheese- Gluten Free
Sides- Gluten Free
Salads-Gluten Free
House Salad- Gluten Free
Blend of mixed greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, onions and homemade croutons.$14.00House Salad with Steak- Gluten Free
Blend of mixed greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, onions and homemade croutons.$20.00House Salad with Chicken- Gluten Free
Blend of mixed greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, onions and homemade croutons.$18.00House Salad with Shrimp- Gluten Free
Blend of mixed greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, onions and homemade croutons.$20.00
Liquor
Vodka
Whiskey/Bourbon
SHOTS
Birthday Cake shot
$6.00Blowjob shot
$5.50Buttery Nipple shot
$5.00Cinnamon Toast Crunch shot
$5.50Green Tea shot
$7.50Jager Bomb shot
$6.00Jello Shot
$1.00Jolly Rancher shot
$6.00Kamikaze shot
$5.00Lemon Drop shot
$6.00Mini Beer shot
$4.00PickleBack shot
$7.00Vegas Bombs shot
$7.00Washington Apple shot
$7.00White Tea shot
$7.50White Gummy Bear
$7.50
Cocktails
Cocktails
Lakeside Lemonade
$7.00Blackberry Breeze
$7.50Rum Runner
$9.00Sunnyside Fishbowl
$20.00Shadyside Fishbowl (BG)
$20.008th Barstool
$8.00Bailey's & Coffee
$8.00Bay Breeze
$7.50Black Russian
$7.00Bloody Mary
$11.00Catching Fire
$7.50Chocolate Covered Strawberry Martini
$10.00Chocolate Kiss
$7.00Chocolate Strab Martini
$8.00Corona-Rita
$12.00Cosmo
$8.00Cranberry Mule
$8.00Crankitini
$8.00Cupid's Kiss
$7.50Cupids Kiss
$7.00Drunky Monkey
$7.00Findley Frost
$6.50Findley Sunrise
$7.50Fire Hard Cider
$5.00Fuzzy Leprechaun
$8.00Ghost 75
$7.00Gin Martini
$8.00Harvest Heat
$8.50Hot Toddy
$5.00Irish Car Bomb (Copy)
$9.50Kaluha and cream
$4.50Kentucky Mule
$8.00Long Island
$7.00Lucky Leprachaun
$6.00Manhattan
$8.00Margarita
$8.00Merry Berry Fizz
$6.50Mimosa
$7.00Moscow Mule
$8.00Old Fashioned
$8.00Orange Cream Soda
$8.00Red, white & booze
$12.00Rootbeer Float
$8.00Scrabble on the Beach
$8.50Screwdriver
$6.00Shamrock Shake
$8.50Shamrock Sour
$8.00Sweet Water
$6.50The Gobbler
$6.00The Sparkler
$7.00Vodka Martini
$8.00Vodka Spritzer
$7.50White Russian
$8.00
Hawaiian night
Beer And Wine
Draft Beers
Bottled Beers
Angry Orchard
$5.50Bud Light
$4.00Bud Light Lime
$4.00Budweiser
$4.00Busch Light
$3.75Coors Lite
$4.20Corona
$5.00Corona Lite
$5.00Domestic 6 Pack
$12.00Heineken
$5.50Labatt Blue
$4.00Labatt Blue Light
$4.00Labatt Blue N/A
$4.00Mic Ultra
$4.00Mike's Black Cherry
$5.50Mike's Hard Lemonade
$5.50Molson Canadian
$4.20Twisted Tea
$5.00Twisted Tea 1/2 and 1/2
$5.00WC Soda - Peach
$6.00Sun Cruiser Half and Half
$6.75Sun Cruiser Tea
$6.75WC Soda - Wild Cherry
$6.00White Claw Black Cherry
$5.50White Claw Lime
$5.50White Claw Raspberry
$5.50White Claw Vodka
$5.50Yuengling
$4.00Miller Lite bottle
$4.00So Tier IPA bottle
$4.00GF meteor shower
$4.00GF kick step ipa
$4.00Athletic N/A
$4.00Guiness Bottle
$3.50Southern Tier IPA Bottle
$4.00Sam Adams October Fest
$4.00Blue Moon Bottle
$4.00Stateside Vodka
$6.50
Wine by the Glass
Cavit Pinot Noir
$8.00Corbett Canyon Pinot Nior
$6.00Federalist Zinfandel Glass
$6.00J Lohr Cabernet
$12.00J Lohr Chardonnay
$10.00Luna Pinot Grigio
$8.00Mazza Bare Bones Red Glass
$6.00Monkey Bay Sauvignon
$8.00House Cabernet Glass
$6.00House Moscato Glass
$6.00House Pinot Grigio
$6.00House Riesling Glass
$6.00Woodbridge Chardonnay Glass
$6.00Woodbridge Pinot Noir Glass
$6.00Champagne
$5.00
Wine by the Bottle
Cavit Moscato Bottle
$27.00Cavit Pinot Noir Bottle
$32.00Federalist Zinfandel Bottle
$35.00J. Lohr Cabernet Bottle
$60.00J. Lohr Chardonnay Bottle
$30.00J. Roget Champagne Bottle
$23.00Luna Pinot Grigio Bottle
$32.00Monkey Bay Sauvignon Bottle
$34.00Sutter Home Cabernet Bottle
$23.00Sutter Home Chardonnay Bottle
$18.00Sutter Home Moscato Bottle
$23.00Sutter Home Pinot Grigio Bottle
$23.00Sutter Home Rielsing Bottle
$23.00Sutter Home Zinfandel Bottle
$18.00Woodbridge Cabernet Bottle
$19.00Woodbridge Chardonnay Bottle
$24.00Woodbridge Pinot Grigio Bottle
$19.00
N/A Beverages
N/A Drinks
Coffee
$3.00Cranberry Juice
$3.00Diet Pepsi
$3.00Ginger Ale
$2.99Hot Chocolate
$3.00Hot Tea
$3.00Root Beer
$3.00Kids Drink
Mountain Dew
$3.00Pepsi
$3.00Pink Lemonade
$3.00Raspberry Tea
$3.00Unsweetened Tea
$3.00Starry
$3.00Water
Soda Water
$3.00Tonic Water
$3.00Bottled Water
$1.50Apple Juice
$3.00Hot Cider
$3.00Dr. Pepper
$3.00Orange Juice
$3.00Pineapple Juice
$3.00FH pop
$1.50
Bottled Water
$1.50
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | Closed |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.




