
American Southern
Lucy in the Rye
612 W Main St.
Sylva, NC 28779
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Breakfast
Classic Breakfast
2 egg breakfast
$10.99
2 eggs with Natural Applewood Bacon
Two eggs, choice of two sides, and natural applewood smoked bacon$12.99
2 eggs with Pasture Raised Sausage Links
Two eggs, choice of two sides, and local Hickory Nut Gap pasture raised sausage links$13.99
2 eggs with Natural City Ham
Two eggs, choice of two sides, and naturally preserved ham$13.99
2 eggs with Plant Based Chorizo
Two eggs, choice of two sides, and house created vegan chorizo$13.99
House Specialties

Babylon Benedict
Panko tomatoes, fresh avocado, poached eggs, diced bacon, and hollandaise, over a biscuit with one side. A house favorite.$16.99
Ham Benedict
Thick slices of naturally preserved ham, poached eggs, and daily made from scratch hollandaise over a grilled english muffin with one side$14.99
Florentine Benedict
Seared greens, poached eggs, caramalized onions, garlic, and hollandaise over a grilled english muffin with one side (add avocado $3)$13.99
Smoked Salmon Benedict
Norwegian smoked salmon, pickled red onions, capers, poached eggs, cherry tomatoes, chives, and hollandaise over a grilled english muffin with one side$16.99
Corned Beef Hash
Two eggs and house made slightly spicy corned beef hash with two sides$16.99
Huevos Rancheros
Two eggs, sunflower oil refried beans, melted cheddar jack, house made salsa, sliced avocado, sour cream, grilled tortilla, and one side (add diced bacon $2)$14.99
Chopped Steak Lucy Style
Two eggs, two 3oz 100% grass fed Hickory Nut Gap ground beef patties smothered in sausage gravy and caramelized onions with two sides$15.99
Smothered Fried Chicken
Two buttermilk fried chicken breasts topped with sausage gravy, cheddar jack cheese, two eggs, diced bacon, crispy onions, and chives$17.99Crab Cake Benedict
$16.99
Breakfast In Bread

Breakfast Burrito
Choice of bacon, sausage, avocado, or vegan chorizo, with eggs, potatoes, cheddar jack, onions, and peppers wrapped in a flour tortilla. Topped with sausage gravy (add bacon jam or poblano jam $1 or double protein $3)$14.99
Breakfast Sandwich
Grilled Annie’s Bakery potato bun, blackened fried egg, cheddar jack, mayo, tomato, and choice of bacon, sausage, or avocado (add bacon jam or poblano jam $1 or double protein $3)$10.99
Velt's Cafe Sandwich
Grilled Annie’s Bakery potato bun, blackened fried egg, Norwegian smoked salmon, two panko crusted tomatoes, capers, pickled red onions, chives, cheddar jack, and mayo$14.99
Biscuit Egg & Cheese
Scrambled and folded egg, melted cheddar jack cheese (add bacon or sausage $2, add ham $2.50, cover in gravy $2)$8.99Bacon Jam Chicken Biscuit
Buttermilk fried chicken in our house made biscuit with bacon jam and American cheese$12.99
Biscuits & Quiche
Biscuit & Gravy
$8.99
Half Biscuit & Gravy
$5.99
Biscuit Bandit
Biscuit and seasoned potatoes topped with sausage gravy, panko crusted tomato, caramelized onions, and seared greens (add an over easy egg $1.50)$11.99
Biscuit Egg & Cheese
Scrambled and folded egg, melted cheddar jack cheese (add bacon or sausage $2, add ham $2.50, cover in gravy $2)$8.99Biscuit & Bacon Jam
$5.95Biscuit & Strawberry Jam
$5.95Biscuit & Poblano Jam
$5.95Biscuits and Jam Flight
$11.99
Quiche w/ Strawberry Fields Salad
Choose from Gouda Bacon Cheddar or Quiche Lorraine. Includes a Mini Strawberry Fields Salad and a side of our lemon maple vinaigrette.$16.99Quiche w/ Side
Completely from scratch, even the crust. Choose from Gouda Bacon Cheddar or Quiche Lorraine.$13.99
Quiche Slice
Completely from scratch, even the crust. Choose from Gouda Bacon Cheddar or Quiche Lorraine$10.99
Griddle

Belgian Waffle
Secret recipe buttermilk waffle topped with powdered sugar. Served with butter and syrup. Add fresh berries for $2$11.99Carnival King
Belgian waffle plus two eggs scrambled with cheese and sausage links or bacon$15.99French Toast
$11.99
Chicken & Waffles
Belgian Waffle topped with one or two pieces of buttermilk fried chicken and drizzled with hot honey$14.99
Chocolate Waffle
Our scratch made Belgian Waffle topped with house made chocolate sauce and chocolate chips$13.49Candied Walnut Waffle
$13.99
The Ringo
Belgian Waffle topped with cheddar jack cheese, diced bacon, sliced avocado, chives, and maple chipotle mayo$14.99
Good Ol' Boy
Belgian Waffle Sandwich with grilled shoulder bacon, cheddar jack cheese, maple chipotle mayo, poblano jam, caramelized onions, fried egg, and tomato$16.99GF Waffle
$10.99GF Carnival King
$14.99GF Chocolate Waffle
$12.49GF Candied Walnut Waffle
$12.99
Omeletes
Cheese Omelet
$12.79
Western Omelet
Three egg omelet with ham, peppers, caramelized onions, cheddar jack. Go Team!$14.59Greek Omelet
$14.49
Sausage & Cheddar Omelet
Local Hickory Nut Gap Pasture Raised Sausage Links diced and stuffed inside a three egg omelet with cheddar jack cheese$14.59Bacon & Cheddar Omelet
$13.99Broccoli Cheddar & Gouda Omelet
$14.49Ham & Cheese Omelet
$14.59
Stovall's Five & Dime
Corned beef hash and cheddar jack inside an omelet topped with hollandaise and chives$16.99
Fancy Toast
Lunch
Sandwiches
Fried Chicken Sandwich
$14.99
Maple Chipotle Chicken Club
Buttermilk fried chicken breast, applewood bacon, avocado slices, maple chipotle mayo, caramelized onion, lettuce, and tomato on a locally baked potato bun$15.99
Grilled Pastrami
1/3rd Lb. of natural pastrami, melted provolone, caramelized onions, charred garlic, and chipotle mayo on toasted Annie’s Bakery marble rye bread$15.99Bacon Jam Smashburger
Two 3oz local grass-fed Hickory Nut Gap beef patties, house made bacon jam, American cheese, and mayo on a locally baked potato bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles$15.79Classic Smashburger
$14.99
Poblano Jam Super Deluxe
Two 3oz local grass-fed Hickory Nut Gap beef patties, avocado, applewood bacon, house made poblano jam, provolone cheese, and chipotle mayo on a locally baked potato bun$16.79Reuben
$15.99Grilled Ham & Bacon
$13.95
Spanakopita w/ Strawberry Fields Salad
House made spinach pie (spinach and feta wrapped in philo dough) served with a strawberry, feta, candied walnut, and romaine salad tossed in our maple lemon vinaigrette **for just a spinach pie without the salad navigate to the "bakery" section**$15.99
Spanakopita (Pie Only)
House made spinach pie (spinach and feta wrapped in philo dough and baked)$9.99Panko BLT
$13.99BLT
$11.99
Plant Power Burrito
Sunflower oil refried black beans, vegan chorizo, avocado, fresh spinach, and house made salsa wrapped in a flour tortilla$14.99Plant Power Bowl
Sunflower oil refried black beans, vegan chorizo, avocado, and house made salsa in a bowl over romaine lettuce$14.99
Miso Beet Burger
$14.99
Salads
Burrata Salad
$14.99
Smokin' Kale Salad
Softened kale, cherrywood smoked bacon, smoked gouda cheese, and avocado tossed in our house maple lemon vinaigrette$14.99Large Strawberry Fields Salad
$13.99Mini Strawberry Fields Salad
$8.99
Spanakopita w/ Strawberry Fields Salad
House made spinach pie (spinach and feta wrapped in philo dough) served with a strawberry, feta, candied walnut, and romaine salad tossed in our maple lemon vinaigrette **for just a spinach pie without the salad navigate to the "bakery" section**$15.99Ranch Hands
$15.99
Sides
1 Egg
$1.992 Eggs
$3.993 Eggs
$5.98Avocado
$3.00Bacon
$4.99Bacon Jam
$1.99Beef Patties
$6.99Biscuit
$3.99Cheese Grits
$4.49Chipotle Mayo
$1.00Corned Beef Hash Side
$9.99English Muffin
$3.99French Fries
$4.99Fruit Cup
$4.99Gluten Free Toast
$3.99Grilled Cherry Tomatoes
$3.99Grits
$3.99Ham
$5.99Hollandaise
$1.99Hot Honey
$1.99Maple Chipotle Mayo
$1.00Miso Beet Patty
$4.99Panko Tomatos
$4.99Poblano Jam
$1.99Potatoes
$3.99Pure Maple
$1.00Ranch
$1.00Refried Black Beans
$5.99Salsa
$1.00Sausage
$5.99Sausage Gravy
$3.99Seared Greens
$4.99Side Fried Chicken
$4.99Side Grapes
$4.99OUT OF STOCKSide Pineapple
$5.99Side Smoked Salmon
$7.99Sliced Tomatoes
$2.99Sour Cream
$1.00Sour Cream
$1.00Strawberries Side
$7.99Strawberry Jam
$1.99Toast
$3.99Vegan Chorizo
$5.991000 island
$1.00
Beverages
Coffee
$3.99Decaf Coffee
$3.99Iced Tea
$3.79Hot Tea
$2.99Fountain Soda
$3.99
Orange Juice
100% daily fresh squeezed in house orange juice now available in three sizes$5.49+Apple Juice
$2.99Grapefruit Juice
$2.99Cranberry Juice
$2.99
Mexican Coke
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love$3.99Waynesville Soda Jerks
$4.59Boylan Soda
$4.59Milk
$3.49Hot Chocolate
$3.99Chocolate Milk
$3.49Kombucha
$5.99Bottled Water
$2.99Tomato Juice
$2.99Fresh Squeezed Lemonade
$3.99Kids Soda
$1.99Kids Juice
$1.99
Grilled Cherry Tomatoes
$3.99
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 7:45 am - 2:00 pm |
| Monday | 7:45 am - 2:00 pm |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 7:45 am - 2:00 pm |
| Thursday | 7:45 am - 2:00 pm |
| Friday | 7:45 am - 2:00 pm |
| Saturday | 7:45 am - 2:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Scratch Made, Chef Driven Lucyintheryesylva@gmail.com
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.





