Pizza
Madison’s Pizza 17 North Ave
17 North Ave
Pleasant Valley, NY 12569
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
FULL MENU
Pizza
Personal Cheese
$11.49Gluten Free (Personal)
$14.49Cauliflower (Personal)
$14.49Personal Deluxe
$14.49Personal Veggie
$14.49Personal Chicken Cheddar Bacon Ranch
$14.49Personal Barbecue Chicken
$14.49Personal Big Cheese Plus
Any two toppings plus extra cheese$14.49Personal Buffalo Chicken
$14.49Personal Meat Madness
$14.49Personal White
Ricotta, mozzarella & garlic$14.49Personal White Plus
Ricotta, mozzarella, broccoli, tomato & garlic$14.49Personal Philly
Steak, peppers, and onions$14.49Personal Margherita Pizza
Tomato, fresh mozzarella, grated cheese, olive oil & basil$14.49Personal Stuffed Pizza
Pepperoni, mozzarella, sausage, or chicken parm$14.49Personal Old Country
Thin crust with tomatoes, grated cheese & mozzarella$14.49Personal Chicken Parmigiana
$14.49Personal Hawaiian
$14.49personal chix marsala
$14.49personal penne ala vodka
$14.49personal baked ziti
$14.49personal salad pizza
$14.49Medium Cheese
$14.45Medium Meat Madness
$20.95Medium Deluxe
$20.95Medium Buffalo Chicken
$20.95Medium Barbecue Chicken
$20.95Medium Veggie
$20.95Medium Chicken Cheddar Bacon Ranch
$20.95Medium Chicken Parmigiana
$20.95Medium Big Cheese Plus
Any two toppings plus extra cheese$20.95Medium White
Ricotta, mozzarella & garlic$16.95Medium White Plus
Ricotta, mozzarella, broccoli, tomato & garlic$20.95Medium Philly
Steak, peppers, and onions$21.49Medium Margherita Pizza
Tomato, fresh mozzarella, grated cheese, olive oil & basil$20.95Medium Old Country
Thin crust with tomatoes, grated cheese & mozzarella$19.95Medium Hawaiian
$19.95Medium Stuffed Pizza
Pepperoni, mozzarella, sausage, or chicken parm$20.45medium chicken marsala
$20.95medium penne ala vodka
$20.95medium baked ziti
$20.95Large Cheese
$15.95Sicillian Pizza
$17.95Large Meat Madness
$21.45Large Chicken Cheddar Bacon Ranch
$21.95Large Deluxe
$22.45Large Barbecue Chicken
$21.95Large Buffalo Chicken*
$21.95Large White
Ricotta, mozzarella & garlic$18.50Large White Plus
Ricotta, mozzarella, broccoli, tomato & garlic$21.95Large Veggie
$21.95Large Margherita Pizza
Tomato, fresh mozzarella, grated cheese, olive oil & basil$21.95Large Chicken Parmigiana
$21.95Large Big Cheese Plus
Any two toppings plus extra cheese$21.95Large Philly
Steak, peppers, and onions$21.45Large Hawaiian
$20.95Large Stuffed Pizza
Pepperoni, mozzarella, sausage, or chicken parm$21.45large chix marsala
$22.45large penne ala vodka
$22.45large baked ziti pizzz
$22.45large salad pizza
$22.45Large Old Country
Thin crust with tomatoes, grated cheese & mozzarella$20.95school pizza
$13.50Large Shrimp Scampi Pizza
$26.45
Wraps
CREATE YOUR OWN WRAP
create your own wrap!!!$10.49The Amy wrap
Chicken cutlet, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella & pesto mayo$13.49The Maddie wrap
Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers & balsamic vinaigrette$13.49The Mia wrap
Grilled chicken, chipotle ranch, Cheddar & bacon$13.49Chicken Caesar wrap
$13.49Buffalo Chicken wrap
$13.49bbq chicken wrap
$13.49Chicken, Cheddar, Bacon wrap& Ranch
$13.49Chicken Parmigiana wrap
$13.49Chicken Cordon Bleu wrap
$13.49chicken cali wrap
$13.49West Coast wrap
$13.49Tex Mex wrap
cajun chicken, jalapeños, sour cream, salsa and cheddar$13.49Veggie wrap
eggplant, broccoli, spinach, tomatoes, provolone,$13.49The Greek wrap
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, feta cheese, and Greek dressing$13.49Turkey BLT wrap
$13.49Turkey Cheddar Bacon wrap
$13.49Summer Salad Wrap
Grilled chicken, craisins, tomato, bacon, crumbly blue, cucumbers & raspberry vinegar$13.49Roast Beef and Cheddar wrap
Roast beef, lettuce, tomato, Cheddar, and horseradish mayo$13.49Italian Combo wrap
lettuce, tomatoe, oil ving, ham, salami, cappi, provolone$13.49becker wrap
$13.49grill wrap
grilled chicken, provolone, bacon, pesto mayo$13.49philly wrap
$13.49
Appetizers
6 Garlic Knots
$5.95Buffalo Wings
$13.95Mozzarella Sticks (6)
$9.99French Fries
$5.95Chicken Fingers (6)
$10.9512 garlic knots
$7.95Boneless
$13.95Mac & Cheese Bites
$9.95Curly Fries
$6.95chicken fingers and fries
$13.95Garlic Bread
$7.451\2 bone in wings
$8.00Fried Mushrooms
$10.49jersey fries
$7.95Popcorn Chicken with Fries
$11.49Pesto Bread
$7.951\2 bonless wings
$8.00Jalapeño Poppers (6)
$9.99Sweet Potato Fries
$6.95Gluten Free Chicken Fingers (6)
$12.95Nachos Supreme
Onions, olives, grilled chicken, tomato & cheese$13.49Sampler
Mozzarella sticks, poppers, chicken fingers, and fried mushrooms$13.95Fried Ravioli
$9.99Onion Rings
$7.95Zucchini Sticks
$10.49Fried Calamari
$13.45Buffalo Calamari
$13.95cajun fries
$6.95Cheese Fries
$7.95Quesadilla
$9.45Shrimp Basket with Fries
$12.95Clam Strips with Fries
$12.95
Chicken
Pasta
Meatball* pasta
$13.95Sausage* pasta
$13.95Tomato Sauce pasta
$11.95Garlic Oil. pasta
$11.95Vodka Sauce pasta
$15.95Alfredo Sauce pasta
$15.95Alfredo Chicken & Broccoli pasta
$18.95Fradiavolo pasta
$12.95Grilled Chicken, broc garlic and oil
Broccoli, garlic & oil$15.95Pesto Sauce pasta
$12.95Sausage with Broccoli Rabe pasta
Garlic & oil$18.95Chicken with Broccoli Rabe pasta
Garlic & oil$18.95Tortellin Alfredo
$16.95PV Pasta
Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, and basil with garlic & oil$18.95meat sauce
$13.95butter pasta
$11.95
slices
slice
$3.12sicilian slice
$3.64grandma slice
$4.16bbq slice
$4.16buffalo slice
$4.16pepperoni slice
$3.75meatball slice
$3.75sausage slice
$3.75white slice
$3.50CBR slice
$4.16stuffed chicken parm slice
$4.16stuffed meat slice
$4.16mushroom slice
$3.75veggie slice
$4.50italian combo pizza roll
$5.75pinwheel
$5.00slice of the day
$4.50topping
$0.75
Hot Subs
Meatball Parmigiana subs
$11.95Meatball subs
meatball sub gets no cheese$11.45Eggplant Parmigiana subs
$11.99Shrimp Parmigiana subs
$14.65Sausage Parmigiana subs
$12.45Chicken Parmigiana subs
$12.45chicken parm ala vodka sub
$14.45Veal Parmigiana subs
$14.45Sausage & Peppers Parmigiana subs
$12.75sausage and pepper sub
$12.00Veal & Peppers Parmigiana subs
$14.05Chicken California subs
$12.95Cheese Steak subs
only American cheese and steak$12.99Pepper & Eggs subs
$11.49crispy chicken subs
ONLY comes with crispy chicken$11.49grill chicken subs
ONLY comes with grilled chicken$11.49
Salads
Tossed Salad
tossed salad with tom, cucumber, onions, carrots$6.45+Taco salad
Cajun meat, lettuce, tomatoes, olives, onions, cucumbers in a crisp taco shell served with salsa and sour cream$13.95Chopped Teriyaki Chicken
Teriyaki grilled chicken, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, crumbled blue cheese in a balsamic dressing$10.45+Caesar
$7.95+Grilled Chicken Caesar
$10.45+Cajun Chicken Caesar
$10.45+Shrimp Caesar
$11.94+Cajun Shrimp Caesar
$11.95+The Madison Salad
Lettuce, tomato, artichokes, roasted red peppers, & fresh mozzarella$11.45+Chef Salad
tossed salad topped with ham, turkey, and American cheese$10.45+Antipasto
Tossed salad topped with assorted meats, cheese, fresh mozzarella, green and red peppers and artichokes$11.45+Buffalo Chicken Salad
Tossed salad with crispy buffalo chicken$10.45+BBQ Chicken Salad
Tossed salad with grilled bbq chicken and shredded mozzarella$10.45+Salad Fresca
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, romaine, and grated cheese with balsamic vinaigrette$10.00+Salad Maddalena
Romaine, fresh lemon, fresh garlic, salt & olive oil$8.45+Greek Salad
Tossed salad with feta, calamata olives, pepperoncici peppers$9.95+Salad Giuliana
Breaded chicken, Cheddar, and bacon$11.45+Summer Salad
Grilled chicken, craisins, tomato, bacon, crumbly blue, cucumbers & raspberry vinaigrette$11.95+The Bella
Romaine, garlic, salt, olive oil, roasted red peppers, black olives, artichokes & broccoli$9.95+
Seafood Dishes
Baked Dishes
Calzones, Stromboli, and Rolls
Specialty Subs
CREATE YOUR OWN SUB
$11.00West Coast subs
Chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, tomato & garlic mayo$12.95The Richie subs
Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, Cheddar, lettuce & tomato$12.95Big Philly Style subs
Steak & cheese with grilled onion & white American on garlic bread$12.95Hot Veggie subs
Mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, green & red peppers, spinach, broccoli, eggplant & provolone$12.95The Grill subs
Grilled chicken provolone, bacon & pesto mayo$12.95The Maddie* subs
Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers & balsamic vinaigrette$12.95The Becker subs
Sausage, bacon, egg & cheese with hot sauce$12.95The Gemma subs
Prosciutto, capicola, salami, melted mozzarella, tomato, roasted red peppers & pesto$14.95
Soups & Sides
Small Soup of the Day
$4.95Large Soup of the Day
$6.95Small Lobster Bisque
$5.95OUT OF STOCKLarge Lobster Bisque
$7.95OUT OF STOCKSmall Shrimp Corn Chowder
When available$5.95OUT OF STOCKLarge Shrimp Corn Chowder
When available$7.95OUT OF STOCKside Meatballs
$5.95side Sausage
$5.95side of Broccoli, Garlic & Oil
$6.95side of Broccoli Rabe
$7.95Madeline's Vegatables
Sautéed veggies with goat cheese$12.95Large NE Clam Chowder
$7.95Small NE Clam Chowder
$5.95small crab
$7.95OUT OF STOCK
Veal
Gluten free
thin square pizza
Burgers & Clubs
kids
FAMILY STYLE (feeds a family of 4 served with pasta, a salad and bread!)
EXTRAS
UTENSIL (fork,knife,spoon,salt pepper, napkin)
$1.50EXTRA DRESSING
side sauce
$0.75side of honey mustard
$0.75side of vodka sauce
$1.25CUPS
1 piece of grilled chicken
$7.001 piece of crispy chix
$7.00Extra side of bread
$2.00sub roll
$2.00NAPKINS
side of grated
$0.75PLATES
small soup cup of Alfredo sauce
$3.50large soup cup of Alfredo sauce
$7.00small soup cup of sauce
$3.00large soup cup of sauce
$4.50small soup of vodka cup of sauce
$4.50large soup cup of vodka sauce
$7.00side of BC
$0.75side of ranch
$0.75side of feta
$2.00side of hot sauce
$0.75side of house
$0.75SIDE OF MAYO
$0.75side garlic mayo
$0.75side pesto mayo
$0.75pink crew neck
$40.00side chipotle ranch
$0.75pizza dough
$3.50Ketchup packets
side of bbq
$0.75side of mild
$0.75crushed red hot pepper
HEART SHAPE PIZZA
SUPER BOWL SPECIALS
CROWD FAVS
GO FOR THE EXTRA POINT
DINNER SPECIALS
cheesesteak eggrolls
severed with horseradish cream sauce$14.95burger special
Burger with fresh mozzarella, red peppers and pesto served with a side of sweet potato fries$18.00FAJITA BOWL SPECIAL
Grilled chicken, peppers and onions with melted cheddar over rice topped with lettuce, sliced avocado, and drizzled with southwest dressing in a crispy tortilla shell$21.00SOURDOUGH SPECIAL
Chicken cutlet, malted fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato , sliced avocado and chipotle mayo served with a side of fries$19.00EGGPLANT special
Crispy eggplant topped with a spinach parmesan cream sauce served over a bed of spaghetti garlic and olive oil , Served with a side salad and bread.$22.00MANICOTTI DINNER special
3 Manicotti topped with vodka sauce, melted mozzarella and grilled chicken Served with salad and bread$19.00TARTUFO special
Nutella and peanut butter filled fried dough$10.00OUT OF STOCKFried dough special
Fried dough with Nutella and peanut butter$10.00
DESSERTS
cakes
DRINKS
Drinks (Copy)
self serve 20oz/ tea
$3.122 liter
$4.5020oz water
$3.1220oz pepsi
$3.1220oz diet pepsi
$3.1220oz zero sugar pepsi
$3.12wild cherry pepsi
$3.12diet wild cherry pepsi
$3.1220oz starry
$3.1220 oz gingerale
$3.1220oz MT dew
$3.1220oz diet MT dew
$3.1220oz rootbeer
$3.1220oz zero sugar rootbeer
$3.1220oz cream soda
$3.1220oz sunkist
$3.1220oz diet sunkist
$3.1220oz lemon lime selzer
$3.1220oz black cherry selzer
$3.1220oz original selzer
$3.12lemonade
$3.12Gatorade
$3.50orange juice
$3.50apple juice
$3.50yoohoo
$3.50pure leaf unsweetened
$3.12pure leaf sweet tea
$3.12pure leaf lemon
$3.12pure leaf peach
$3.12pure leaf diet lemon
$3.12pure leaf unsweetened green tea
$3.12pure leaf tea/lemonade
$3.12pure leaf blackberry
$3.12pure leaf honey green tea
$3.12large fountain
$3.50medium fountain
$3.00small fountain
$2.50coffee
$2.00pellegrino
$3.75energy drink
$4.50saranac rootbeer
$4.002 liter pepsi
$4.502 liter diet pepsi
$4.502 liter sunkist
$4.502 liter diet sunkist
$4.502 liter rootbeer
$4.502 liter MT dew
$4.502 liter starry
$4.502 liter brisk ice tea
$4.502 liter ginger ale
$4.50pure leaf diet peach
$3.12pure leaf rasberry
$3.12san pellegrino can
$3.75poppi cherry
$3.50poppi strawberry
$3.50poppi raspberry
$3.50poppi doc pop
$3.50poppi orange
$3.50liter water
$4.50pure leaf peach
$3.12poland spring water
$2.00shirley temple poppi
$3.50
CBR slice
$4.16
Customize your item
slice toppings
Optional
pizza prep
Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
