
American Southern
MCL Restaurant & Bakery | Castleton
5520 Castleton Corner Lane
Indianapolis, IN 46250
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
$9.99er
A complete homemade meal at an incredible value - 1 entrée + 2 sides for just $9.99.
Entrees

Fried Chicken - Light Meat
Includes one breast and one wing, hand-breaded with Charles O’s special seasoning blend.$7.49
Fried Chicken - Dark Meat
Includes one thigh and leg, hand-breaded with Charles O’s special seasoning blend.$7.29
Fried Chicken - Individual Pieces
Order our famous fried chicken by the piece. Chose from breasts, wings, thighs, or legs.OUT OF STOCK
Carved Turkey
Oven-roasted and hand-carved turkey breasts. Our turkeys are raised humanely on family farms in Michigan.$5.49
Turkey Manhattan
Hand-carved oven-roasted turkey breast sandwich topped with a large portion of mashed potatoes and homemade turkey gravy.$10.69
Stuffed Chicken Breast
Our most popular entree! Stuffed with savory cornbread dressing.$9.39
Carved Roast Beef
Slow roasted for 12 hours and hand-carved.$7.39
Beef Manhattan
Tender, hand-carved roast beef sandwich topped with mashed potatoes and homemade brown gravy.$10.79
Baked Tilapia - Junior Portion
A simply seasoned tilapia filet for the lighter appetite. This smaller filet is around half the size of our regular portion.$4.89
Crumb Top Tilapia
Topped with breadcrumbs and herbs and oven roasted.$8.49OUT OF STOCK
Meatloaf
An original recipe and absolutely delicious version of this classic American dish.$7.89
Southern Fried Catfish
Hand breaded in cornmeal.$8.79OUT OF STOCK
Oven Roasted Salmon
Atlantic salmon seasoned with herbs and oven roasted. Our salmon is sustainably raised in the Atlantic Ocean and is antibiotic and GMO free.$11.59
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken breast hand breaded with bread crumbs and Parmesan cheese topped with homemade marinara.$8.89OUT OF STOCK
Chicken Pot Pie
Thyme butter brushed biscuit crust with peas, carrots, celery, and onion.$8.79OUT OF STOCK
Chicken Cordon Bleu
We hand-bread a chicken breast with Panko breadcrumbs and Parmesan then top it with carved ham, Swiss cheese, and bechamel sauce.$8.39OUT OF STOCK
Grilled Chopped Steak
Handmade chopped steak simply seasoned with salt and pepper and grilled on an open flame.$7.69OUT OF STOCK
Chicken & Noodles
Homemade dumplings & chunks of chicken in a rich gravy.$7.79
Salmon Supreme
Our take on a classic salmon patty prepared with wild Atlantic salmon. Choose from cheese sauce, cocktail sauce, or tartar sauce.$8.89OUT OF STOCK
Pecan-Encrusted Whitefish
$8.59Country Fried Tenderloin
Our pork tenderloin is hand-breaded and served with your choice of homemade cream or brown gravy.$7.99OUT OF STOCKParmesan Breaded Pork Chop
A thick boneless chop is lightly breaded with breadcrumbs and Italian cheeses then seared to seal in juices before an oven-roasted finish.$8.59OUT OF STOCK
Salisbury Steak with Mushroom Gravy
Our delicious homemade gravy makes this dish!$7.99OUT OF STOCK
BBQ Dark Chicken Quarter
$7.29OUT OF STOCK
Lillian's Casserole
Egg noodles with creamy mushroom and red pepper sauce topped with crispy bread crumbs.$7.69OUT OF STOCK
Reuben
$7.49
Chili
Our homemade version with fresh ground beef, onions, dark red kidney beans, tomatoes, & spaghetti.$6.69OUT OF STOCK
Tenderloin Sandwich
$7.39OUT OF STOCK
Salads

Tossed Salad
Fresh Iceberg and spinach, red cabbage, celery, & green onions.$5.79
Strawberry Field - Small
Baby field greens, romaine, chopped walnuts, shaved Parmesan and Reggiano and sliced fresh strawberries. We recommend oil & vinegar dressing.$6.89OUT OF STOCK
Cobb Salad - Entree
Iceberg lettuce topped with diced turkey breast, diced tomatoes, shredded Colby cheese, bacon, hard boiled egg, and scallions.$10.99
Cobb Salad - Small
Iceberg lettuce topped with diced turkey breast, diced tomatoes, shredded Colby cheese, bacon, hard boiled egg, and scallions.$6.99
Pineapple
$3.99
Strawberries
$3.99OUT OF STOCK
Watermelon - Large
$6.29Cranberry Relish
$3.49OUT OF STOCK
Cucumber & Onions
$3.69
Cream Slaw
Our slaw has a uniquely delicious tangy dressing.$3.79
Deviled Eggs
$3.99
Hot Sides & Fresh Vegetables

Mashed Potatoes
Our original buttery recipe, homemade gravy.$3.99
Homestyle Green Beans
Blue Lake, Wisconsin beans slowly simmered with bacon.$3.99
Macaroni & Cheese
Three cheeses, Charles O’s seasoning salt, premium noodles.$4.59
Fresh Broccoli
Steamed, seasoned broth and choice of cheese sauce.$4.49
Broccoli with Cheese
$4.79
Harvard Beets
Whole beets in our version of the classic sweet and sour sauce.$3.69OUT OF STOCKParsley Potatoes
Steamed Idaho potatoes simply seasoned and garnished with fresh parsley.$3.69OUT OF STOCK
Fresh Carrots
Boiled and simply seasoned.$3.69OUT OF STOCK
Lima Beans
Boiled in a simply seasoned broth.$3.79
Corn
Exceptionally sweet and buttery.$3.69OUT OF STOCK
Dressing
$3.79
Sweet Potatoes
Brown sugar and nutmeg.$4.19OUT OF STOCK
Baked Beans
Our take on this classic includes bbq sauce and bacon.$3.69
Brussel Sprouts
Steamed and simply seasoned.$4.09OUT OF STOCK
Green Bean Casserole
$3.99OUT OF STOCK
Peas
Boiled in a simply seasoned broth.$3.79Succotash
$3.69OUT OF STOCK
Broccoli Cheese Bake
$4.29
Desserts

Devil's Food Cake
$4.79
Coconut Cream Pie
$4.79
Cherry Pie
$4.79
Pumpkin Pie
$4.79
Strawberry Shortcake
Our version of this classic calls for white cake, fresh strawberries and glaze, and whipped topping.$5.49Strawberry Shortcake Family Size
Feeds 5 - 7$17.99OUT OF STOCK
Pecan Pie
$4.79
Apple Pie
$4.79OUT OF STOCK
Frosted Sugar Cookie
$3.29OUT OF STOCK
Cookie (6 count)
$17.25OUT OF STOCK
Cookie (Dozen)
$26.95
Carrot Cake
$4.79OUT OF STOCKPumpkin Cake
$4.79OUT OF STOCK
Lemon Supreme Cake
$4.79OUT OF STOCK
Strawberry Cake
$4.79
Custard
$3.99
Chocolate Cream Pie
$4.79OUT OF STOCK
Lemon Meringue Pie
$4.79
Peach Pie
$4.79OUT OF STOCK
Homemade Cheesecake
$6.19Fresh Blueberry Pie
$4.99Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake
$6.19OUT OF STOCK
Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake
$6.19OUT OF STOCK
Bread Pudding
$4.49OUT OF STOCK
Chocolate Cheesecake
$6.19OUT OF STOCK
Sugar Cream Pie
$4.79
Rolls & Bread
Beverages

Fountain Drinks
Choose from Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Mug Root Beer or Sierra Mist.$3.85+
Coffee
Locally roasted for MCL by Hubbard & Cravens.$2.89
Iced Tea
Famously crisp black tea.$3.69
Iced Tea (Quart)
Famously crisp black tea.$4.09
Fresh Brewed Sweet Tea
Famously crisp black tea. Sweetened with real sugar.$3.49
Fresh Brewed Sweet Tea (Quart)
Famously crisp black tea. Sweetened with real sugar.$3.89OUT OF STOCK
Serviceware

Grilled Chopped Steak
$7.69
Handmade chopped steak simply seasoned with salt and pepper and grilled on an open flame.
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Serving homemade comfort food with heaps of hospitality, since 1950!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.









