
American Southern
MCL Restaurant & Bakery | Castleton
5520 Castleton Corner Lane
Indianapolis, IN 46250
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
$9.99er
A complete homemade meal at an incredible value - 1 entrée + 2 sides for just $9.99.
Entrees

Fried Chicken - Light Meat
Includes one breast and one wing, hand-breaded with Charles O’s special seasoning blend.$7.49
Fried Chicken - Dark Meat
Includes one thigh and leg, hand-breaded with Charles O’s special seasoning blend.$7.29
Fried Chicken - Individual Pieces
Order our famous fried chicken by the piece. Chose from breasts, wings, thighs, or legs.OUT OF STOCK
Carved Turkey
Oven-roasted and hand-carved turkey breasts. Our turkeys are raised humanely on family farms in Michigan.$5.49OUT OF STOCK
Turkey Manhattan
Hand-carved oven-roasted turkey breast sandwich topped with a large portion of mashed potatoes and homemade turkey gravy.$10.69OUT OF STOCK
Stuffed Chicken Breast
Our most popular entree! Stuffed with savory cornbread dressing.$9.39
Carved Roast Beef
Slow roasted for 12 hours and hand-carved.$7.39
Beef Manhattan
Tender, hand-carved roast beef sandwich topped with mashed potatoes and homemade brown gravy.$10.79
Baked Tilapia - Junior Portion
A simply seasoned tilapia filet for the lighter appetite. This smaller filet is around half the size of our regular portion.$4.89
Crumb Top Tilapia
Topped with breadcrumbs and herbs and oven roasted.$8.49
Meatloaf
An original recipe and absolutely delicious version of this classic American dish.$7.89
Southern Fried Catfish
Hand breaded in cornmeal.$8.79
Oven Roasted Salmon
Atlantic salmon seasoned with herbs and oven roasted. Our salmon is sustainably raised in the Atlantic Ocean and is antibiotic and GMO free.$11.59OUT OF STOCK
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken breast hand breaded with bread crumbs and Parmesan cheese topped with homemade marinara.$8.89
Chicken Pot Pie
Thyme butter brushed biscuit crust with peas, carrots, celery, and onion.$8.79OUT OF STOCK
Chicken Cordon Bleu
We hand-bread a chicken breast with Panko breadcrumbs and Parmesan then top it with carved ham, Swiss cheese, and bechamel sauce.$8.39OUT OF STOCK
Grilled Chopped Steak
Handmade chopped steak simply seasoned with salt and pepper and grilled on an open flame.$7.69OUT OF STOCK
Chicken & Noodles
Homemade dumplings & chunks of chicken in a rich gravy.$7.79OUT OF STOCK
Salmon Supreme
Our take on a classic salmon patty prepared with wild Atlantic salmon. Choose from cheese sauce, cocktail sauce, or tartar sauce.$8.89OUT OF STOCK
Pecan-Encrusted Whitefish
$8.59OUT OF STOCKCountry Fried Tenderloin
Our pork tenderloin is hand-breaded and served with your choice of homemade cream or brown gravy.$7.99Parmesan Breaded Pork Chop
A thick boneless chop is lightly breaded with breadcrumbs and Italian cheeses then seared to seal in juices before an oven-roasted finish.$8.59OUT OF STOCK
Salisbury Steak with Mushroom Gravy
Our delicious homemade gravy makes this dish!$7.99OUT OF STOCK
BBQ Dark Chicken Quarter
$7.29OUT OF STOCK
Lillian's Casserole
Egg noodles with creamy mushroom and red pepper sauce topped with crispy bread crumbs.$7.69OUT OF STOCK
Reuben
$7.49OUT OF STOCK
Chili
Our homemade version with fresh ground beef, onions, dark red kidney beans, tomatoes, & spaghetti.$6.69OUT OF STOCK
Tenderloin Sandwich
$7.39
Salads

Tossed Salad
Fresh Iceberg and spinach, red cabbage, celery, & green onions.$5.79
Strawberry Field - Small
Baby field greens, romaine, chopped walnuts, shaved Parmesan and Reggiano and sliced fresh strawberries. We recommend oil & vinegar dressing.$6.89OUT OF STOCK
Cobb Salad - Entree
Iceberg lettuce topped with diced turkey breast, diced tomatoes, shredded Colby cheese, bacon, hard boiled egg, and scallions.$10.99
Cobb Salad - Small
Iceberg lettuce topped with diced turkey breast, diced tomatoes, shredded Colby cheese, bacon, hard boiled egg, and scallions.$6.99
Pineapple
$3.99
Strawberries
$3.99OUT OF STOCK
Watermelon - Large
$6.29Cranberry Relish
$3.49OUT OF STOCK
Cucumber & Onions
$3.69
Cream Slaw
Our slaw has a uniquely delicious tangy dressing.$3.79
Deviled Eggs
$3.99
Hot Sides & Fresh Vegetables

Mashed Potatoes
Our original buttery recipe, homemade gravy.$3.99
Homestyle Green Beans
Blue Lake, Wisconsin beans slowly simmered with bacon.$3.99
Macaroni & Cheese
Three cheeses, Charles O’s seasoning salt, premium noodles.$4.59
Fresh Broccoli
Steamed, seasoned broth and choice of cheese sauce.$4.49
Broccoli with Cheese
$4.79
Harvard Beets
Whole beets in our version of the classic sweet and sour sauce.$3.69Parsley Potatoes
Steamed Idaho potatoes simply seasoned and garnished with fresh parsley.$3.69OUT OF STOCK
Fresh Carrots
Boiled and simply seasoned.$3.69
Lima Beans
Boiled in a simply seasoned broth.$3.79
Corn
Exceptionally sweet and buttery.$3.69OUT OF STOCK
Dressing
$3.79OUT OF STOCK
Sweet Potatoes
Brown sugar and nutmeg.$4.19OUT OF STOCK
Baked Beans
Our take on this classic includes bbq sauce and bacon.$3.69OUT OF STOCK
Brussel Sprouts
Steamed and simply seasoned.$4.09OUT OF STOCK
Green Bean Casserole
$3.99OUT OF STOCK
Peas
Boiled in a simply seasoned broth.$3.79Succotash
$3.69OUT OF STOCK
Broccoli Cheese Bake
$4.29OUT OF STOCK
Desserts

Devil's Food Cake
$4.79
Coconut Cream Pie
$4.79
Cherry Pie
$4.79
Pumpkin Pie
$4.79
Strawberry Shortcake
Our version of this classic calls for white cake, fresh strawberries and glaze, and whipped topping.$5.49Strawberry Shortcake Family Size
Feeds 5 - 7$17.99OUT OF STOCK
Pecan Pie
$4.79
Apple Pie
$4.79OUT OF STOCK
Frosted Sugar Cookie
$3.29OUT OF STOCK
Cookie (6 count)
$17.25OUT OF STOCK
Cookie (Dozen)
$26.95
Carrot Cake
$4.79OUT OF STOCKPumpkin Cake
$4.79OUT OF STOCK
Lemon Supreme Cake
$4.79OUT OF STOCK
Strawberry Cake
$4.79
Custard
$3.99
Chocolate Cream Pie
$4.79OUT OF STOCK
Lemon Meringue Pie
$4.79
Peach Pie
$4.79OUT OF STOCK
Homemade Cheesecake
$6.19Fresh Blueberry Pie
$4.99Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake
$6.19OUT OF STOCK
Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake
$6.19OUT OF STOCK
Bread Pudding
$4.49OUT OF STOCK
Chocolate Cheesecake
$6.19OUT OF STOCK
Sugar Cream Pie
$4.79
Rolls & Bread
Beverages

Fountain Drinks
Choose from Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Mug Root Beer or Sierra Mist.$3.85+
Coffee
Locally roasted for MCL by Hubbard & Cravens.$2.89
Iced Tea
Famously crisp black tea.$3.69
Iced Tea (Quart)
Famously crisp black tea.$4.09
Fresh Brewed Sweet Tea
Famously crisp black tea. Sweetened with real sugar.$3.49
Fresh Brewed Sweet Tea (Quart)
Famously crisp black tea. Sweetened with real sugar.$3.89OUT OF STOCK
Serviceware
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Serving homemade comfort food with heaps of hospitality, since 1950!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.









