
Caribbean
Mobay Cafe
1022 South 1st Street
Milwaukee, WI 53204
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
‌
‌
‌
Featured Items
Jerk Chicken
Get ready for a flavor explosion with our irresistibly juicy bone-in chicken thighs! Marinated in our unique signature jerk spice blend, each bite is packed with incredible taste and tenderness, lovingly slow-grilled to perfection. And the best part? You can enjoy this mouthwatering dish with two delicious sides of your choice!$13.00+
Jamaican Patties
Jamaican favorite: crab and go, a flaky, golden-crusted pastry filled with a tasty, savory meat filling, such as ground beef, chicken, or an array of mixed vegetables. Select your patty of choice: Beef, Chicken, or Veggie$5.00
Braised Oxtail
Indulge in our Braised Oxtail, where tender and succulent oxtails are expertly braised to achieve melt-in-your-mouth perfection. Slow-cooked in a rich, deeply flavorful gravy, this dish is infused with the sweetness of carrots, the savory notes of onions, and the hearty texture of potatoes. To complete this satisfying meal, enjoy it with your choice of two delectable sides, carefully selected to complement the rich, comforting flavors of the braised oxtail.$24.00+
FOOD
APPETIZER

Conch Fritters (4)
Indulge in a delightful tropical treat with four succulent pieces of Bahamian-style conch, expertly infused with vibrant Jamaican spices. These delicious morsels are pan-fried to a perfect golden brown, delivering a crispy exterior that gives way to a tender, flavorful bite. Served alongside a zesty spicy mango sauce, this dish promises to take your taste buds on a thrilling adventure!$13.00
Jamaican Patties
Jamaican favorite: crab and go, a flaky, golden-crusted pastry filled with a tasty, savory meat filling, such as ground beef, chicken, or an array of mixed vegetables. Select your patty of choice: Beef, Chicken, or Veggie$5.00Mobay Beef Meatballs (4)
Get ready to indulge in four irresistibly juicy, perfectly round meatballs, crafted with our special blend of house-made herbs and spices. Each bite is a burst of flavor, enveloped in breadcrumbs and lovingly braised in our rich and savory signature brown sauce. It's a mouthwatering experience you won't want to miss!$13.00Mobay Egg Rolls (2)
Indulge in an irresistible fusion of flavors with our tantalizing spring rolls! Choose between delectable veggies, succulent shrimp, or tender chicken, all perfectly combined with vibrant shaved carrots and crisp cabbage. Each roll is expertly wrapped and deep-fried to golden perfection, delivering an exhilarating crunch with every bite and served alongside our enticing sweet and sour sauce that adds the perfect finishing touch!$12.00
Red Stripe BBQ Wings (6)
Get ready for an explosion of flavor with our irresistible Party Wings! These succulent wings are grilled to perfection, fried to a crispy finish, and then drenched in a bold, zesty BBQ sauce made with the famous Jamaican Red Stripe beer.$12.00
DINNA PLATTE

Braised Oxtail
Indulge in our Braised Oxtail, where tender and succulent oxtails are expertly braised to achieve melt-in-your-mouth perfection. Slow-cooked in a rich, deeply flavorful gravy, this dish is infused with the sweetness of carrots, the savory notes of onions, and the hearty texture of potatoes. To complete this satisfying meal, enjoy it with your choice of two delectable sides, carefully selected to complement the rich, comforting flavors of the braised oxtail.$24.00+Jerk Chicken
Get ready for a flavor explosion with our irresistibly juicy bone-in chicken thighs! Marinated in our unique signature jerk spice blend, each bite is packed with incredible taste and tenderness, lovingly slow-grilled to perfection. And the best part? You can enjoy this mouthwatering dish with two delicious sides of your choice!$13.00+Curry Chicken
Delight your taste buds with tantalizing small chicken pieces, expertly seasoned with our Signature house herbs and zesty Jamaican curry powder. This savory medley is then lovingly cooked with hearty white potatoes and vibrant carrots, creating a dish bursting with bold flavors that will transport you straight to the Caribbean!$13.00+Curry Goat Stew
Prepare yourself for a culinary adventure with our irresistibly flavorful, slow-cooked goat meat stew! Each tender morsel is bathed in our rich, house-made curry gravy, brimming with aromatic island spices and a thrilling kick of heat, served alongside two delightful sides, such as white rice and cabbage, to ignite your taste buds.$17.00+
Two-Meat Platter
Get ready for a tasty treat! You can choose from a fantastic selection of two different flavorful meats. How about some delicious Oxtail, Jerk Chicken, Curry Chicken, or Goat? You can mix and match your favorites! If you’re lucky, you might also find Pepper Steak and Brownstew Chicken, and Meatballs when available. Enjoy your meal!$30.00
SEAFOOD PLATTE
Caribbean Shrimp Rundown
Shrimp sauteed in coconut milk, various bell peppers, onions, and herbs for a finger-licking dish.$22.00Island Shrimp
Succulent shrimp sauteed in island curry or garlic and other herbs for a flavourful dish paired with your choice of Rice and Peas or White Rice$22.00
Steak Cut King Fish
$24.00
Sybil's Creole Grill Salmon
Zesty marinated Salmon with a smokey grilled flavor topped with a creamy coconut sauce, served with roasted garlic mash potatoes$30.00Whole Red Snapper
$30.00
SALAD
VEGAN PLATE

Coconut Curry Jackfruit
Slow-cooked Jackfruit with onions, peppers, and carrots in a rich, creamy coconut curry sauce, served with with rice and plantains.$13.00Veggie Medley
An array of broccoli, carrots, squash, cauliflower, onions and peppers sauteed with herbs and spices served with your choice of rice & peas or white rice and plantains$12.00Jerk Stir-Fried Bok Choy
Crispy bok choy and cabbage sauteed over a flaming skillet with spicy jerk sauce and vegan stir fry sauce served with your choice of rice & peas or white rice and plantains$15.00
Chick-Peas and Squash Curry
Slow-cooked chickpeas in a flavorful curry sauce with zucchini, onions, peppers, and carrots served with rice & peas or white rice and plantains$15.00
PICKNEY (KIDS) MENU
Chicken Tenders (3)
Homemade chicken strips seasoned with our in-house spices, deep fried, and serve with fries$11.00Wing Basket (4)
Four delicious party wings grilled then fired and dipped in your choice of sauce: In-House Jerk Sauce, BBQ, Honey Hot, or Garlic Parmesan. Serve with fries or Rice.$11.00Mac & Cheese
$10.00
ADDITIONAL SIDES
Callaloo
$6.00Festival
$5.00Fried Dumplings
$4.00Fried Jamaican Bammy
A triangle shape flatbread made from Cassava Root also known as Yucca pan-pan fried to a crispy exterior and tender on the side.$6.00
Fried Plantains
$5.00Fries
$4.00Mac & Cheese
$10.00Market Veggie
$5.00
Rice and Peas
$5.00
Steamed Cabbage
$4.00White Rice
$4.00Extra Gravy/Sauce
$0.50
CATERING MENU
APPETIZERS
ENTREES
Brown Stew Chicken
$85.00+Curry Chicken
$85.00+Curry Goat
$120.00+Escoveitch Snapper Fillet
$115.00+Jerk Chicken
$95.00+Pepper Steak
$135.00+Shrimp
$125.00+Chick Peas and Squash Curry (v)
Slow-cooked chickpeas in a flavorful curry sauce with zucchini, onions, sweet peppers, and carrots. (Serves 8-14 guests)$45.00+Oxtail
$210.00+
Mobay Beef Meatballs
$0.00
Customize your item
Size
Required
Select 1
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:30 am - 4:45 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4:00 pm - 8:30 pm |
| Thursday | 4:00 pm - 8:30 pm |
| Friday | 4:00 pm - 8:30 pm |
| Saturday | 4:00 pm - 9:30 pm |
Restaurant info
📍Where Everything is Irie
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.





