
American
The New Fashioned
1122 Vel R. Phillips Avenue
Milwaukee, WI 53203
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
GRAB N'GO BEVERAGES
Water, Soda & Energy Drinks

Aquafina Bottled Water
$4.00
Celsius Arctic Vibe
$7.00
Celsius Tropical Vibe
$7.00
Rockstar Energy Drink
$6.00
Sugar Free Rockstar Energy Drink
$6.00
Gatorade Cool Blue 20oz
$4.00
Gatorade Fruit Punch 20oz
$4.00
Gatorade Zero Glacier Cherry 20oz
$4.00
Pepsi Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Diet Pepsi Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Pepsi Zero Sugar Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Mountain Dew Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Diet Mountain Dew Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Starry Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Starry Zero Sugar Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Soda Fountain Beverage 12oz
$3.00
Soda Fountain Beverage 20oz
$4.00
Sprecher Cherry Cola
$5.00
Sprecher Orange Dream
$5.50
System Black Cherry 0% Alcohol
$5.00
System Mango 0% Alcohol
$5.00
TAILGATE LOUNGE HIGH VOLUME
Entrees

New Fashioned Butter Burger
Certified Angus Beef patty, sharp American cheese, lettuce, tomato & butter-braised onions with a brandy old fashioned steak sauce. Served with crispy flat fries.$14.95
Cheese Butter Burger
All-beef burger patty, sharp American cheese, lettuce & tomato on a Sheboygan hard roll. Served with crispy flat fries.$13.95
Butter Burger
All-beef burger patty, lettuce, tomato on a Sheboygan hard roll. Served with crispy flat fries.$11.95
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Breaded crispy chicken breast with Black Forest ham, Swiss cheese, sweet & tangy mustard, lettuce, tomato on a Sheboygan hard roll. Served with crispy flat fries.$15.95
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy chicken on a buttered Sheboygan hard roll with lettuce & tomato. Served with crispy flat fries.$13.95
Chicken Tenders
Four crisp-breaded chicken tenders. Served with crisp flat fries.$15.95
Bunzel's Original Bratwurst
Roasted and grilled Bunzel’s original bratwurst on a toasted Paielli’s sausage roll. Served with crispy flat fries.$10.95OUT OF STOCK
Appetizers & Sides

Angus Beef Chili
12oz cup of loaded Certified Angus Beef chili with sour cream & cheddar cheese.$4.45
French Fries
The New Fashioned’s famous crisp flat fries.$5.95
Loaded Fries
Crispy fries with bacon, cheddar cheese sauce, green onion & sour cream.$9.95
Vickie's Sea Salt Chips
Kettle cooked potato chips with sea salt.$2.00
Kids Menu

Kids Burger
Certified Angus Beef patty, no cheese. Served with crisp flat fries & a juice box.$8.95
Kids Cheeseburger
All-beef burger patty, American cheese. Served with crispy flat fries & a juice box.$8.95
Kids Tenders
Two crisp-breaded chicken tenders. Served with crisp flat fries & a juice box.$8.95
Kids Candy
An array of nostalgic candy varieties that are sure wow your taste buds. Fun for all ages!OUT OF STOCK
Sweets

Dark Chocolate Ganache Three Layer Cake
Our goal at Elegant Foods is to provide niche, quality products that will give our customers the ability to create unique and exciting menus. In addition, we are committed to working with local Wisconsin and Illinois vendors and farmers who promote sustainable agriculture. This ganache cake is made with cacao barry extra brute cocoa powder and features a chocolate ganache between each layer, which makes it moist and decadent.$5.95
Door County Cherry Cheesecake
Our goal at Elegant Foods is to provide niche, quality products that will give our customers the ability to create unique and exciting menus. In addition, we are committed to working with local Wisconsin and Illinois vendors and farmers who promote sustainable agriculture. This rich, decadent cheesecake is made with our all butter graham crust, filled with Door County cherries, and topped with sliced almonds.$5.95
New Fashioned Vanilla Custard
4 oz of delicious frozen vanilla custard$4.00
Purple Door Ice Cream
Purple Door Ice Cream is owned and operated by Lauren and Steve Schultz. Both are passionate about creating a quality, delicious product while supporting the Milwaukee community and respecting the earth. Each flavor is served in a scrumptious 4 oz cup.$5.00
Pete's Pops
Pete’s Pops is all about bringing people together as a community to smile, laugh, and enjoy a tasty frozen treat. Our goal is simply to make you happy through more than 100 unique and delicious flavors of and pops made by real Milwaukee humans with all natural and fresh ingredients.$5.00
Indulgence Chocolate Bar
Founded in 2007 by owner and chocolatier Julie Waterman, Indulgence Chocolatiers meticulously handcrafts all of its confections in its Milwaukee, Wisconsin kitchen. Working with the finest chocolate from around the world and other locally sourced ingredients, our talented chocolatiers create confections that are as delicious as they are beautiful. No mass production, no artificial preservatives, just quality ingredients handcrafted into artisan confections in both classic and unique flavor combinations. Each bar is 3.5oz (99.22g).$8.50
Goody Gourmets Popcorn
Goody Gourmets is known as Milwaukee’s favorite gourmet popcorn shop. Only the finest, freshest ingredients go into making our popcorn and confections. Goody Gourmets variety and flavor is unmatched, so you’re sure to find something that fits your taste, whatever it may be.
Carrie's Crispies
Carrie’s Crispies started in 2015 when Carrie took her passion for Rice Crispie Treats and turned it into the first dedicated Rice Crispie Treat Company in the Midwest, basing themselves out of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Carrie’s Crispies are built on love, passion and an unceasing sweet tooth, that together make the perfect rendition of a childhood favorite.
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 4:00 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Saturday | 5:00 pm - 7:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Milwaukee is home to quirky traditions, remarkable food, and creative makers. You’ll find them all gathered at The New Fashioned—updated & curated for your perfect night out.
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.



