American
The New Fashioned
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
GRAB N'GO BEVERAGES
Water, Soda & Energy Drinks
Aquafina Bottled Water
$4.00
Celsius Arctic Vibe
$7.00
Celsius Tropical Vibe
$7.00
Rockstar Energy Drink
$6.00
Sugar Free Rockstar Energy Drink
$6.00
Gatorade Cool Blue 20oz
$4.00
Gatorade Fruit Punch 20oz
$4.00
Gatorade Zero Glacier Cherry 20oz
$4.00
Pepsi Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Diet Pepsi Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Pepsi Zero Sugar Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Mountain Dew Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Diet Mountain Dew Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Starry Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Starry Zero Sugar Bottle 20oz
$4.00
Soda Fountain Beverage 12oz
$3.00
Soda Fountain Beverage 20oz
$4.00
Sprecher Cherry Cola
$5.00
Sprecher Orange Dream
$5.50
System Black Cherry 0% Alcohol
$5.00
System Mango 0% Alcohol
$5.00
TAILGATE LOUNGE HIGH VOLUME
Entrees
New Fashioned Butter Burger
Certified Angus Beef patty, sharp American cheese, lettuce, tomato & butter-braised onions with a brandy old fashioned steak sauce. Served with crispy flat fries.$14.95
Cheese Butter Burger
All-beef burger patty, sharp American cheese, lettuce & tomato on a Sheboygan hard roll. Served with crispy flat fries.$13.95
Butter Burger
All-beef burger patty, lettuce, tomato on a Sheboygan hard roll. Served with crispy flat fries.$11.95
Black Bean Burger
Griddled black bean and brown rice patty on Sheboygan hard roll with lettuce, tomato and roasted pepper aioli. Served with crispy flat fries.$12.95
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy chicken on a buttered Sheboygan hard roll with lettuce & tomato. Served with crispy flat fries.$13.95
Chicken Tenders
Four crisp-breaded chicken tenders. Served with crisp flat fries.$15.95
Bunzel's Original Bratwurst
Roasted and grilled Bunzel’s original bratwurst on a toasted Paielli’s sausage roll. Served with crispy flat fries.$10.95
Caesar Salad
Crisp Romaine Lettuce, Shaved Parmesan-Romano blend, housemade croutons, & garlic Caesar dressing.$9.95
The Melty Original
American cheese melted to perfection on buttery griddled soft white bread$8.00
The Everything Avo Melt
Creamy Havarti, fresh avocado & everything bagel spice on buttery griddled all-grain wheat$11.00
The Orchard Hammer
Tillamook medium cheddar & Boar's Head ham with apple-butter mustard on griddled sourdough$12.00
Appetizers & Sides
Celsius Tropical Vibe
$7.00
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 4:00 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Saturday | 5:00 pm - 7:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Milwaukee is home to quirky traditions, remarkable food, and creative makers. You’ll find them all gathered at The New Fashioned—updated & curated for your perfect night out.
Location
1122 Vel R. Phillips Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53203
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
