Skip to Main content
  • New York City Pizza Pope Ave

    • Home
    • /
    • Hilton Head Island
    • /
    • New York City Pizza - Hilton Head Island
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    New York City Pizza - Hilton Head Island

    81 Pope Ave

    Hilton Head Island, SC 29928


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Food-pope
    Pizza-pope
    Bevs-pope

    Food-pope

    Appetizers

    • Chicken Fingers

      Lightly breaded breast strips. Plain, mild, hot, garlic parmesan, calypso or Jack Daniels BBQ sauce
      $14.95
    • Buffalo Wings

      Plain, mild, hot, garlic parmesan, calypso or Jack Daniels BBQ sauce
      $16.95
    • Garlic Bread

      Italian bread with fresh garlic and Romano cheese
      $7.50
    • Italian Fries

      Our fabulous fries topped with special seasonings
      $7.95
    • Mamma's Housemade Meatballs

      2 meatballs in our tomato sauce
      $9.95
    • Fresh Zucchini Sticks (5)

      Fried fresh local zucchini, served with our tomato sauce
      $8.50
    • Mozzarella Sticks

      Served with our tomato sauce
      $9.50
    • Small Fries

      $3.50
    • Large Fries

      $6.00

    Salads

    • House Salad

      Mixed greens, bell pepper, crouton, sliced mushroom, onion, diced tomato, tossed with your choice of dressing
      $10.45
    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine lettuce, grated Romano croutons and our classic Caesar dressing
      $10.45
    • Side Salad

      Mixed lettuce greens and tomato
      $5.45
    • Side Caesar

      $6.45
    • Chef Salad

      Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Bacon, Ham, Turkey and Provolone Cheese
      $14.95

    Heroes

    • The Italian

      Ham, salami, pepperoni and provolone, with shaved lettuce, sliced onion, and tomato, oil and vinegar
      $16.95
    • Ham & Provolone

      With shaved lettuce, sliced onion, and tomato, oil and vinegar
      $15.95
    • Turkey & Provolone

      With shaved lettuce, sliced onion, and tomato, oil and vinegar
      $15.95
    • Chicken Parmigiana Heroe

      Breaded chicken cutlet covered in our tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, baked in the oven
      $15.95
    • Philly Cheesesteak

      Shaved top sirloin sautéed with onion, bell pepper, and mushroom, topped with white American cheese
      $16.95
    • Philly Chicken Cheesesteak

      Chicken sautéed with onion, bell pepper and mushroom, topped with white American cheese
      $13.95
    • Meatball Parmesan Heroe

      $15.95
    • Buffalo Chicken Heroe

      $14.95

    Pastas & Entrees

    • Spaghetti Meatballs

      Meatballs in our tomato sauce and tossed with spaghetti
      $17.50
    • Chicken Parmigiana Pasta

      Covered in our tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, served with penne pasta
      $17.95

    Extra Sauces & Dressings

    • House Vinaigrette

      $1.25
    • Caesar

      $1.25
    • Ranch

      $1.25
    • Blue Cheese

      $1.25
    • Honey Mustard

      $1.25
    • Oil and Vinegar

      $1.25
    • Sugo

      $1.25
    • Wing Sauce

      $1.25

    Calzone & Stromboli

    • Small Calzone

      Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
      $18.00
    • Large Calzone

      Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
      $20.00
    • Small Stromboli

      Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
      $18.00
    • Large Stromboli

      Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
      $20.00

    Kid's Menu

    • Kids Spaghetti w/ Tomato Sauce

      $8.95
    • Kids Spaghetti & Meatball

      $9.95
    • Kids Spaghetti Pasta w/ Butter Sauce

      $8.95
    • Kids Chicken Fingers (4)

      $8.95
    • Kids Buffalo Wings (5)

      $8.95
    • Kids Mac & Cheese

      $8.95
    • Kids Hamburger

      $8.95
    • Kids Chicken Alfredo

      $8.95

    Desserts

    • Housemade Cannoli

      $6.95
    • Housemade Plain Cheesecake

      $7.95

    Pizza-pope

    BYO Pizza

    • 14" New York

      $20.00
    • 16" New York

      $22.00
    • 14" Deep Dish Pan

      OUT OF STOCK
      $22.00
    • 16" Deep Dish Pan

      OUT OF STOCK
      $24.00
    • Sicilian

      OUT OF STOCK
      $27.00

    Medium 14" Specialty

    • 14" NYCP Special

      Pepperoni, sausage, bell pepper, onion and mushroom
      $28.50
    • 14" Vegetarian

      Mushroom, bell pepper, onion, tomato and spinach
      $25.50
    • 14" Meat Lovers

      Pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham and bacon
      $30.00
    • 14" BBQ Chicken Pizza

      Our BBQ fried chicken, bacon, mozzarella
      $28.00
    • 14" White Pizza

      Ricotta white sauce, mozzarella and romano cheese
      $24.00
    • 14" Hawaiian

      Tomato sauce, mozzarella, ham and pineapple
      $24.00
    • 14" Margherita

      Our fresh tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil and garlic
      $25.00
    • 14" Buffalo Chicken Pizza

      Ranch sauce, fried chicken, mozzarella with buffalo wing sauce
      $27.00

    Large 16" Specialty

    • 16" NYCP Special

      Pepperoni, sausage, bell pepper, onion and mushroom
      $31.50
    • 16" Vegetarian

      Mushroom, bell pepper, onion, tomato and spinach
      $28.50
    • 16" Meat Lovers

      Pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham and bacon
      $33.00
    • 16" BBQ Chicken Pizza

      Our BBQ fried chicken, bacon, mozzarella
      $31.00
    • 16" White Pizza

      Ricotta white sauce, mozzarella and romano cheese
      $27.00
    • 16" Hawaiian

      Tomato sauce, mozzarella, ham and pineapple
      $27.00
    • 16" Margherita

      Our fresh tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil and garlic
      $28.00
    • 16" Buffalo Chicken Pizza

      Ranch sauce, fried chicken, mozzarella with buffalo wing sauce
      $30.00

    10" Gluten Free Cauli Crust

    • 10" Cauli Crust (Gluten Free)

      $15.95

    Dough Balls

    • Med Dough Ball

      $5.00
    • Large Dough Ball

      $6.00

    Calzone & Stromboli

    • Small Calzone

      Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
      $18.00
    • Large Calzone

      Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
      $20.00
    • Small Stromboli

      Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
      $18.00
    • Large Stromboli

      Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
      $20.00

    Bevs-pope

    20oz Bottled Soda

    • 20oz Pepsi

      $3.00
    • 20oz Diet Pepsi

      $3.00
    • 20oz Sierra Mist

      $3.00
    • 20oz Mt.Dew

      $3.00
    • 20oz Dr. Pepper

      $3.00

    2 Liter Bottled Soda

    • 2L Pepsi

      $6.00
    • 2L Diet Pepsi

      $6.00
    • 2L Starry

      $6.00
    • 2L Mt Dew

      $6.00
    • 2L Dr. Pepper

      $6.00

    20oz Mt.Dew

    $3.00
    1

    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Monday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Tuesday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    South Carolina’s best New York-style pizza!

    Location

    81 Pope Ave, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Frosty Frog Cafe - Hilton Head Isla
    View restaurantnext
    The Bank
    View restaurantnext
    DOUGH BOYS PIZZA HILTON HEAD ISLAND
    View restaurantnext
    The Salty Dog - 6 Target Road
    View restaurantnext
    Giuseppi's Pizza & Pasta Shelter Cove, HHI 50 Shelter Cove Lane
    View restaurantnext
    New York City Pizza Festival Center
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook