Skip to Main content
  • New York City Pizza Pope Ave

    • Home
    • /
    • Hilton Head Island
    • /
    • New York City Pizza - Hilton Head Island
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    New York City Pizza - Hilton Head Island

    81 Pope Ave

    Hilton Head Island, SC 29928


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Food
    Pizza
    Bevs

    Featured Items

    • 16" New York

      $22.00
    • 14" New York

      $20.00
    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine lettuce, grated Romano croutons and our classic Caesar dressing
      $10.45

    Food

    Appetizers

    • Chicken Fingers

      Lightly breaded breast strips. Plain, mild, hot, garlic parmesan, calypso or Jack Daniels BBQ sauce
      $14.95
    • Buffalo Wings

      Plain, mild, hot, garlic parmesan, calypso or Jack Daniels BBQ sauce
      $16.95
    • Garlic Bread

      Italian bread with fresh garlic and Romano cheese
      $8.50
    • Italian Fries

      Our fabulous fries topped with special seasonings
      $7.95
    • Mamma's Housemade Meatballs

      2 meatballs in our tomato sauce
      $9.95
    • Fresh Zucchini Sticks (5)

      Fried fresh local zucchini, served with our tomato sauce
      $9.50
    • Mozzarella Sticks

      Served with our tomato sauce
      $10.50
    • Small Fries

      $3.50
    • Large Fries

      $6.00

    Salads

    • House Salad

      Mixed greens, bell pepper, crouton, sliced mushroom, onion, diced tomato, tossed with your choice of dressing
      $10.45
    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine lettuce, grated Romano croutons and our classic Caesar dressing
      $10.45
    • Side Salad

      Mixed lettuce greens and tomato
      $6.45
    • Side Caesar

      $6.45
    • Chef Salad

      Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Bacon, Ham, Turkey and Provolone Cheese
      $14.95

    Heroes

    • The Italian

      Ham, salami, pepperoni and provolone, with shaved lettuce, sliced onion, and tomato, oil and vinegar
      $16.95
    • Ham & Provolone

      With shaved lettuce, sliced onion, and tomato, oil and vinegar
      $15.95
    • Turkey & Provolone

      With shaved lettuce, sliced onion, and tomato, oil and vinegar
      $15.95
    • Chicken Parmigiana Heroe

      Breaded chicken cutlet covered in our tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, baked in the oven
      $15.95
    • Philly Cheesesteak

      Shaved top sirloin sautéed with onion, bell pepper, and mushroom, topped with white American cheese
      $16.95
    • Philly Chicken Cheesesteak

      Chicken sautéed with onion, bell pepper and mushroom, topped with white American cheese
      $16.95
    • Meatball Parmesan Heroe

      $15.95
    • Buffalo Chicken Heroe

      $14.95

    Pastas & Entrees

    • Spaghetti Meatballs

      Meatballs in our tomato sauce and tossed with spaghetti
      $17.50
    • Chicken Parmigiana Pasta

      Covered in our tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, served with penne pasta
      $19.95

    Extra Sauces & Dressings

    • House Vinaigrette

      $1.25
    • Caesar

      $1.25
    • Ranch

      $1.25
    • Blue Cheese

      $1.25
    • Honey Mustard

      $1.25
    • Oil and Vinegar

      $1.25
    • Sugo

      $1.25
    • Wing Sauce

      $1.25

    Calzone & Stromboli

    • Small Calzone

      Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
      $18.00
    • Large Calzone

      Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
      $20.00
    • Small Stromboli

      Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
      $18.00
    • Large Stromboli

      Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
      $20.00

    Kid's Menu

    • Kids Spaghetti w/ Tomato Sauce

      $8.95
    • Kids Spaghetti & Meatball

      $9.95
    • Kids Spaghetti Pasta w/ Butter Sauce

      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.95
    • Kids Chicken Fingers (4)

      $8.95
    • Kids Buffalo Wings (5)

      $8.95
    • Kids Mac & Cheese

      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.95
    • Kids Hamburger

      $8.95
    • Kids Chicken Alfredo

      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.95

    Desserts

    • Housemade Cannoli

      $6.95
    • Housemade Plain Cheesecake

      $7.95

    Pizza

    BYO Pizza

    • 14" New York

      $20.00
    • 16" New York

      $22.00
    • 14" Deep Dish Pan

      $22.00
    • 16" Deep Dish Pan

      $24.00
    • Sicilian

      $27.00

    Medium 14" Specialty

    • 14" NYCP Special

      Pepperoni, sausage, bell pepper, onion and mushroom
      $28.50
    • 14" Vegetarian

      Mushroom, bell pepper, onion, tomato and spinach
      $25.50
    • 14" Meat Lovers

      Pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham and bacon
      $30.00
    • 14" BBQ Chicken Pizza

      Our BBQ fried chicken, bacon, mozzarella
      $28.00
    • 14" White Pizza

      Ricotta white sauce, mozzarella and romano cheese
      $24.00
    • 14" Hawaiian

      Tomato sauce, mozzarella, ham and pineapple
      $24.00
    • 14" Margherita

      Our fresh tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil and garlic
      $25.00
    • 14" Buffalo Chicken Pizza

      Ranch sauce, fried chicken, mozzarella with buffalo wing sauce
      $27.00

    Large 16" Specialty

    • 16" NYCP Special

      Pepperoni, sausage, bell pepper, onion and mushroom
      $31.50
    • 16" Vegetarian

      Mushroom, bell pepper, onion, tomato and spinach
      $28.50
    • 16" Meat Lovers

      Pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham and bacon
      $33.00
    • 16" BBQ Chicken Pizza

      Our BBQ fried chicken, bacon, mozzarella
      $31.00
    • 16" White Pizza

      Ricotta white sauce, mozzarella and romano cheese
      $27.00
    • 16" Hawaiian

      Tomato sauce, mozzarella, ham and pineapple
      $27.00
    • 16" Margherita

      Our fresh tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil and garlic
      $28.00
    • 16" Buffalo Chicken Pizza

      Ranch sauce, fried chicken, mozzarella with buffalo wing sauce
      $30.00

    10" Gluten Free Cauli Crust

    • 10" Cauli Crust (Gluten Free)

      $15.95

    Dough Balls

    • Med Dough Ball

      $5.00
    • Large Dough Ball

      $6.00

    Calzone & Stromboli

    • Small Calzone

      Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
      $18.00
    • Large Calzone

      Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
      $20.00
    • Small Stromboli

      Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
      $18.00
    • Large Stromboli

      Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
      $20.00

    Bevs

    20oz Bottled Soda

    • 20oz Pepsi

      OUT OF STOCK
      $3.00
    • 20oz Diet Pepsi

      $3.00
    • 20oz Sierra Mist

      $3.00
    • 20oz Mt.Dew

      $3.00
    • 20oz Dr. Pepper

      $3.00

    2 Liter Bottled Soda

    • 2L Pepsi

      $6.00
    • 2L Diet Pepsi

      $6.00
    • 2L Starry

      $6.00
    • 2L Mt Dew

      $6.00
    • 2L Dr. Pepper

      $6.00

    Side Caesar

    $6.45

    Customize your item

    Extra Dressings

    Optional

    Add Cheese

    Select up to 1

    Protein Choice

    Select up to 1
    1

    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Monday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Tuesday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    South Carolina’s best New York-style pizza!

    Location

    81 Pope Ave, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Frosty Frog Cafe - Hilton Head Isla
    View restaurantnext
    The Bank
    View restaurantnext
    DOUGH BOYS PIZZA HILTON HEAD ISLAND
    View restaurantnext
    The Salty Dog - 6 Target Road
    View restaurantnext
    Giuseppi's Pizza & Pasta Shelter Cove, HHI 50 Shelter Cove Lane
    View restaurantnext
    New York City Pizza Festival Center
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook