Skip to Main content
  • Over The Counter

    • Home
    • /
    • Worthington
    • /
    • Over The Counter

    This restaurant does not have any images

    American

    Over The Counter

    5596 N High Street

    Worthington, OH 43085


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    FOOD
    DRINKS
    Pickup Only
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • Kid Side Fry

      $3.49
    • Kid Chicken Tenders

      $6.99
    • Pretzel Bites

      Salted soft pretzels with Guinness beer cheese
      $7.99

    FOOD

    1. Appetizers

    • Chicken Tenders

      Juicy tempura-breaded tenders with buttermilk ranch
      $14.99
    • Chicken Wings

      Rubbed, baked and deep fried
      $8.99+
    • Fried Pickle Spears

      Tempura-breaded Kosher dill pickles with buttermilk ranch
      $7.99
    • Pile of Fries

      $5.99
    • Pretzel Bites

      Salted soft pretzels with Guinness beer cheese
      $7.99
    • Brussel Sprouts

      Bacon, red onion, balsamic glaze
      $9.99
    • Spinach Artachoke Dip

      Served with tortilla chips
      $11.99

    2. Soups

    • Cup Chicken and Rice

      $5.99
    • Bowl Chicken and Rice

      $8.99
    • Cup French Onion

      $5.99
    • Bowl French Onion

      $8.99
    • Cup Cactus Chili

      $5.99
    • Bowl Cactus Chili

      $8.99
    • Bowl Soup du jour

      $8.99
    • Cup Soup du jour

      $5.99

    3. Salads

    • CAESAR Full

      Romaine, garlic croutons and parmesan crisps with Caesar dressing
      $9.99
    • CAESAR Half

      Romaine, garlic croutons and parmesan crisps with Caesar dressing
      $6.99
    • COBB Salad Full

      Romaine, tomato, bacon, hard boiled eggs, red onion & bleu cheese with choice of dressing
      $9.99
    • COBB Salad Half

      Romaine, tomato, bacon, hard boiled eggs, red onion & bleu cheese with choice of dressing
      $6.99
    • ROUTE 23 Full

      Spring mix, fried herbed goat cheese medallions, balsamic marinated shallots, strawberries and candied walnuts with our House 23 dressing
      $9.99
    • ROUTE 23 Half

      Spring mix, fried herbed goat cheese medallions, balsamic marinated shallots, strawberries and candied walnuts with our House 23 dressing
      $6.99

    4. Sandwiches and More

    All sandwiches are served with kettle chips. You can sustitute another side for an upcharge.
    • 1. BURGERS

      $13.99
    • BLT

      Brown sugar and cayenne spiced bacon, lettuce, tomato, red pepper aioli on multigrain bread
      $12.99
    • Corn Beef Rueben

      Sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, thousand island, on grilled rye swirl bread, creamy coleslaw & pickle spear
      $15.99
    • French Dip

      Seared rib-eye, Swiss, crispy onions, on an hoagie bun with au jus
      $16.99
    • Fried Egg Sandwich

      2 fried eggs, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on multigrain bread
      $9.99
    • Grilled Cheese

      Cheddar, provolone, swiss, grilled tomato and spicy mayo on grilled sourdough
      $10.99
    • Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich

      Spicy fried chicken, hot honey glaze, spicy mayo, coleslaw on a kaiser roll. Served with a pickle.
      $15.99
    • Hot Dog

      1/4 lb. Angus beef hot dog with spicy mustard on a New England roll
      $10.99
    • Italian Chicken Sandwich

      Grilled marinated chicken, red peppers, lettuce, tomato, provolone, & pesto aioli on grilled tomato swirl bread.
      $15.99
    • Pulled Pork

      Pulled BBQ pork shoulder roasted in brown sugar and Coca-Cola served on a grilled split-top bun, topped with an onion ring and pickles, served with creamy coleslaw on the side
      $15.99
    • Sloppy Joe

      Sweet & saucy lean beef, red pepper, & onion on a bun with creamy Cole slaw.
      $9.99
    • Tuna Melt

      Dolphin-safe Albacore covered with melted cheddar and Swiss on grilled sourdough
      $13.99
    • Turkey Club

      Stack of thin-sliced turkey breast with bacon, Swiss, spring mix, tomato, & mayo on a grilled tomato swirl bread.
      $15.99
    • Where's Waldo

      Famous Falter's thick-sliced German bologna, bourbon onions, on grilled sourdough. Served with spicy mustard and pickle spear.
      $13.99

    5. Sides

    • Chips

      Kettle Chips
      $2.49
    • Cole Slaw

      Fresh and creamy slaw with green peppers and red onions
      $4.49
    • Fried Cod

      $6.99
    • Fruit

      $2.99
    • Fry Basket

      Fresh cut fries with rosemary oil and seasoning salt
      $5.99
    • Grilled Chicken Breast

      $6.99
    • Mac & Cheese Full

      House made cheese sauce, cavatappi pasta, topped with buttery herb bread crumbs
      $10.99
    • Mac & Cheese Half

      House made cheese sauce, cavatappi pasta, topped with buttery herb bread crumbs
      $6.99
    • Onion Rings

      Dipped to order in tempura beer batter
      $6.99
    • Side Sauce

      $0.99
    • Veg: Broccoli

      $3.99
    • Celery

      $0.99
    • 4 oz Salmon

      $5.99
    • 8 oz Salmon

      $9.99

    7. Kids

    • Kid Burger

      $6.99
    • Kid Chicken Tenders

      $6.99
    • Kid Grilled Cheese

      $6.99
    • Kid Mac & Cheese

      $6.99
    • Kid Side Fry

      $3.49
    • Kids Fruit cup

      $2.49
    • Kid Hot Dog

      $5.99

    Allergies

    • Dairy Allergy / alergia a los lacteos

    • Gluten Allergy / alergia al gluten

    • Nut Allergy / alergia a las nueces

    • Vegan

    • Vegetarian

    Dollar wing weds

    • Wings

      $1.00

    DRINKS

    • Apple Juice

      $2.49
    • Cold Brew

      $2.99
    • Cranberry Juice

      $2.49
    • French Press

      $2.99
    • Ginger Beer

      $2.99
    • Grapefruit Juice

      $2.49
    • Hot Chocolate

      $2.79
    • Hot Tea

      $2.99
    • IBC Root Beer

      $2.99
    • Iced Tea

      $2.29
    • Milk

      $2.49
    • Milk Chocolate

      $2.79
    • Orange Juice

      $2.49
    • Pineapple Juice

      $2.49
    • Shirley Temple

      $2.39
    • Soda

      $2.29
    • Tomato Juice

      $2.49
    • Lemonade

      $2.99

    Hot Dog

    $10.99

    1/4 lb. Angus beef hot dog with spicy mustard on a New England roll

    Customize your item

    Side Substitions

    Select up to 1

    Bread Choices

    Optional

    Add Cheese

    Optional

    Split

    Optional

    Sauces

    Optional

    Remove

    Optional

    ADD ONS

    Optional

    Add Ons

    Optional

    Remove

    Optional

    Hot Dog Substitution

    Optional
    Request advisory
    No substitutes. Additions may be charged extra.
    1

    All hours
    SundayClosed
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Wednesday11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Saturday10:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    Wednesday through Saturday 11:00am - 2:00pm and 5:00pm - 8:00pm. We are open Saturdays and Sundays from 11:00am - 2:00pm featuring our full brunch and lunch menus. Take out orders can be made on-line or over the phone. Beer and wine is available for carry out at state minimum prices!

    Location

    5596 N High Street, Worthington, OH 43085

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    TK's Hangout 5295 N High St
    View restaurantnext
    Worthington Tavern
    View restaurantnext
    Pat & Gracie's Kitchen X Tavern 138 Graceland Blvd
    View restaurantnext
    George's Linworth Diner
    View restaurantnext
    Ritzy’s
    View restaurantnext
    Tee Jaye's #21 - North High Street
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook