American
Papsy's Place Sweets & Treats
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURT
FROZEN YOGURT
New York Cheesecake
$4.00+OUT OF STOCK☝ Today's Flavors 👆
$4.00+Georgia Peach Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPeach/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon Pound Cake
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMango Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPassion Fruit Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCK
Key Lime Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon Lime/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCherry Cheesecake
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWatermelon Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWatermelon/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Cheesecake
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon Berry/ Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPink Lemonade Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPeach/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCitrus Sunrise/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry-Lime Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKKey Lime/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry-Lemon/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry-Lemon Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWild Berry/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon Mist Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWatermelon Tart/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry-Mango Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMango-Strawberry/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlueberry Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKIsland Punch/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPeach/Dragon's Blood Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWild berry Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPeach Cheesecake
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWild Berry Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon Lime/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon Lime/Strawberry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKTaro
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPomegranate Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPomegranate /Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate/Pomegranate Tart Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCherry Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCitrus Sunrise Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKOrange Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple-Mango Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKpineapple-Mango/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKOrange/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMango-Strawberry/Coconut Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKGreen Apple Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCherry/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMango-Strawberry Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon Berry Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKIsland Punch
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlueberry/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKTriple Berry Cheesecake
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlueberry Cheesecake
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCranberry Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCranberry/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKRaspberry/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKKey Lime/ Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPear Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKRaspberry Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple-Mango/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Shortcake
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKTropical Twist Freeze
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKTropical/cherry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMango-Strawberry/ Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWild Berry/chz Cake Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKTutti-Fruity
$4.00+OUT OF STOCK
DAIRY FREE OPTIONS
Watermelon Fruit Whip
$4.00+Blue Raspberry Fruit Whip
$4.00+☝ Today's Flavors 👆
$4.00+Pineapple-Mango Sorbet
Dairy Free, Vegan$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWatermelon Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKDouble Fudge
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKDouble Fudge/Vanilla
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKOrange Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKRaspberry/Greene apple
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMango Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKHawaiian Pineapple Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKGreen Apple Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKRaspberry Dole Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPassion Fruit Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKKey Lime Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKKiwi Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKGrape
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlue Raspberry / Pineapple-Mango Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPink Lemonade Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPink Lemonade Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlue Raspberry Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCitrus Sunrise
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKgreen apple/blue raspberry
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMango Strawberry/Lemon Lime Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKTutti-Fruiti
Dairy Free, Vegan$4.00+OUT OF STOCK
Orange Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKDragon's Blood
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple/Fudge Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple Dole Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPassion Fruit Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMountain Ripe Strawberry
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKDragon's Blood/Pineapple Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPeach Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCherry/Apple Cider Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCK
Lemon-Lime Sorbet
Dairy Free, Vegan$4.00+OUT OF STOCKApple Cidar Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlue Raspberry/Dragon's Blood Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlue Raspberry/Orange Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlue Raspberry/Pineapple Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlueberry Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlueberry/Peach Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCherry limeade
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCherry/Pineapple Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChristmas Pomegranate
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCitrus Sunrise/Blue Raspberry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCitrus Sunrise/Strawberry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKDouble Fudge/Raspberry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKDragon's Blood/Green Apple Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKDragon's Blood/Lemon Twist
Dairy Free, Vegan$4.00+OUT OF STOCKKiwi/Pomegranate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKDragon's Blood/Orange Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKGreen Apple/ Dragon's Blood Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKDragon/lemon-lime
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKDragons Bl/Pink Lemonade Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKFruit Punch Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKGreen Apple Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKGreen Apple/Cherry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKKiwi/Watermelon
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKGreen Apple/Pineapple-Mango Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKHawiian Pineapple/Green Apple
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKHawiian pineapple/Green Apple Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKKey Lime/Watermelon Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKKiwi/Pineapple-Mango
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon Sorbet
Dairy Free, Vegan$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon-Lime/Strawberry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKLemon-Lime Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMango-Strawberry
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMango/Kiwi
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKOrange Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPassion Fruit/Mango Strawberry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPeach Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPear Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple Lemonade Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple-Mango Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple-Mango/Lemon-Lime Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple-Orange
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple/Passion Fruit Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPistachio (DF)
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPistachio/Dragon's Blood Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPomegranate Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple-Mango/Green Apple Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPomegranate-Orange/Pineapple Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPineapple-mango/Tiger's Blood Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPomegranate/Orange Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKRaspberry Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKRaspberry/Lemon Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKRaspberry/Pineapple Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCK
Strawberry-Kiwi Sorbet
Dairy Free, Vegan$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry-Limeade Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry/Pinapple-Mango Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKTiger's Blood
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKTropical Mango
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKTropical Twist Freeze
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKVegan Vanilla
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWatermelon Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWatermelon/Kiwi Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWatermelon/Pistachio Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWatermelon/Tutti-Fruitti Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWild Berry Fruit Whip
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWild Berry Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWild Berry Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKWild Cherry Sorbet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCK
ICE CREAM
Chocolate
$4.00+☝ Today's Flavors 👆
$4.00+Biscoff
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCandy Cane
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKVanilla
$4.00+Blue Raspberry Cream
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKVanilla/Salted caramel
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKSalted Caramel
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKiced coffee
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKVanilla/Iced Coffee
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCake Batter
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKVanilla/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate/Banana
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBanana Cream Pie
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStevia Chocolate
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKFruity Cereal Milk
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlue Rasp/ Fruity Cereal Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKTaro
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKButter Pecan
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPeanut Butter
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPistachio
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStevia Vanilla (Sugar Free)
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMocha
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate / Orange Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCandy Cane/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMatcha
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMatcha/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMaple Waffle
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCinnamon Apple Pie
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCake Batter/Double Fudge Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCereal Milk/Fudge Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlue Rasp/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate -Pistachio Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBanana Cream/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate/Birthday Cake Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBirthday Cake
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Shortcake
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStevia Blue Raspberry Cream
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBirthday Cake/Cherry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKSugar Free Chocolate & Blue Raspberry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlue/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate/Strawberry Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCherries &Cream
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlueberry/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate Cake Batter
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCake Batter/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKStrawberry
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPeanut Butter Cup
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPecan Praline/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKOrange Tart
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate/Orange Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCK
Praline Pecan
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMaple/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPB Cup
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate/Peanut Butter Banana
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKButterscotch/Double Fudge Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKButter Pecan
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKEspresso
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKToasted Coconut
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate Banana
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPumpkin Spice
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCoconut
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKRed Velvet
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKEspresso/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKElvis Special (Pb &Banana)
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKCinnamon Apple Pie
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKOatmeal Cookie
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlue Raspberry Cream/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBlue Raspberry/Double Fudge Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKBirthday Cake/Double Fudge Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKSnickerdoodle
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKSnickerdoodle/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKButterscotch/Chocolate Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate Raspberry
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKChocolate/Oatmeal Cookie Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKEgg Nogg
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKMaple Waffle
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKButterscotch
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPeanut Butter/Double Fudge Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPeach/Vanilla Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKPistachio/Double Fudge Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCKVanilla / Strawberry Cheesecake Twist
$4.00+OUT OF STOCK
DRINKS, SHAKES & FREEZES
MILKSHAKES
Clayton's Black Raspberry Shake
$6.25Vanilla Shake
$6.25
Chocolate Shake
$6.25Chocolate Peanut Butter Shake
$6.25Peanut Butter Shake
$6.25
Strawberry Shake
$6.25Raspberry Shake
$6.25Chocolate Raspberry Shake
$6.25Salted Caramel
$6.25New York Cheesecake Shake
$6.25☝Today's Shake Flavors👆
$6.25Georgia Peach Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKMango Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKPistachio Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKCereal Milk
$6.25OUT OF STOCKBlue Raspberry Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Cheesecake Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKChocolate Monkey Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKBanana Cream Pie Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKKey Lime Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKChocolate Strawberry Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKPeppermint Mocha Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKEgg Nogg Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKMatcha
$6.25OUT OF STOCKMaple Waffle Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKBiscoff Shake
$6.25Orange Creamsicle Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKCandy Cane Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKButter Pecan Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKCinnamon Apple Pie Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKCereal Milk Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKPineapple Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKBirthday Cake Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKCake Batter Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKCherry Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKPineapple-Mango Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKTaro Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKPistachio Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKStevia Vanilla Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKWild Berry Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKPumpkin Spice Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKVampire Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKCherry Cheesecake Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Shortcake Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKMango-Strawberry Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKCoffee Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKRed Velvet
$6.25OUT OF STOCKEspresso Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKBlueberry Froyo Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKTriple Berry Cheesecake Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKCherry Pie Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKElvis Special Shake (PB & Banana)
$6.25OUT OF STOCKMango-Strawberry Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKToasted Coconut Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKButterscotch
$6.25OUT OF STOCKLemon Meringue Pie Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKOatmeal Cookie Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCKPraline Pecan
$6.25OUT OF STOCKSnickerdoodle Shake
$6.25OUT OF STOCK
SPECIALTY SUNDAES
SPECIALTY SUNDAE OPTIONS
ULTIMATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP
Smooth and creamy soft-serve cream nestled in a homemade waffle bowl, drizzled with hot fudge and Reese's Peanut Butter sauce. Then topped with chopped Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, chocolate chips and finished off with fluffy whipped cream, sprinkles, chocolate dust and a peanut butter cookie.$8.50
Tasty Turtle
Smooth and creamy swirl of Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream nestled in a homemade waffle bowl, topped with hot fudge, Ghiraradelli Caramel, and sprinkled with pecans and chocolate chips. We finish it off with a cloud of whipped cream dusted with cocoa powder and cookie.$8.50Hot Fudge Sundae
$8.50Wild Berry Bliss
$8.50OUT OF STOCKBanana Split
$8.50OUT OF STOCKUltimate Brownie Delight
Fresh baked, fudge brownie covered with a creamy swirl of vanilla ice cream, drenched with hot fudge and sprinkled with chocolate chips. To finish it off, we add a cloud of whipped cream and top off with crushed peanuts and a cherry.$8.50OUT OF STOCKCoral Reef Sundae
$8.95OUT OF STOCKCaramel Apple Pie Ultimate Sundae
$8.50OUT OF STOCKPumpkin Spice Ultimate Sundae
$8.50OUT OF STOCKThe Fudgy Raspberry Sundae
$8.50OUT OF STOCKHot Apple/wild Berry Bliss
$8.50OUT OF STOCKPeach Berry
Georgia Peach Tart frozen yogurt swirled into a fresh homemade waffle bowl topped with our berry blend of strawberries, blackberries, raspberries and blueberries, sprinkled with cinnamon granola, strawberry sauce, whipped cream and a dusting of graham cracker crumble.$8.50OUT OF STOCKUltimate Cheesecake Sundae
$8.50OUT OF STOCK
Ultimate Unicorn
Smooth and creamy swirl of Cotton Candy ice cream nestled in a homemade waffle bowl. We topped with marshmallow cream, sour gummy dots, unicorn bark, whipped cream and cotton candy crunch.$6.95OUT OF STOCKPinapple Upside Down
$8.00OUT OF STOCKUltimate Chocolate Raspberry
$8.50OUT OF STOCKChocolate Chip Banana Bread Ultimate Sundae
$8.00OUT OF STOCKFruitella Waffle
$8.95OUT OF STOCKFruitella Waffle With Ice Cream
$9.95OUT OF STOCKUltimate Cupcake Sundae
Nestled in a homemade waffle bowl is our homemade mini cupcake atop our creamy soft serve cake batter ice cream. We then top with Ghirardell caramel sauce, unicorn bark white chocolate, marshmallows, whipped cream and sprinkles.$7.00OUT OF STOCKGrogu Kiddie
$3.50OUT OF STOCKPrincess Leia Sundae
$7.00OUT OF STOCKLight Saber Ultimate Sundae
$8.50OUT OF STOCKFlufferNutter
$8.50OUT OF STOCK
SWEET TREATS & BAKED GOODS
CANDY
Gummy Shapes
Butter Toffee Almonds
$5.95Candy Necklace
$1.99Choward's Gum
$1.50Choward's Mints
$1.95Blue Raz PopRocks
$1.50OUT OF STOCKBlue Unicorn Pop
$1.00Pink Unicorn Pop
$1.00Jelly Belly Sour Pumpkins
$5.95Haribo Twin Cherries
$4.95Strawberry PopRocks
$1.50Regal Crown Lemon
$1.95Regal Crown Sour Grape
$1.95Regal Crown Sour Cherry
$1.95Regal Crown Sour Apple
$1.95Reed's Butterscotch
$1.95Reed's Cinnamon
$1.95Big Hunk Candy Bar
$2.50Rock Candy
$1.00Pink Lemonade Sour Patch
$3.95OUT OF STOCKAsher's Chocolate Co. Dark Chocolate Nonpareils
$5.50OUT OF STOCK
Asher's Milk Chocolate Graham Crackers
Crisp Graham Crackers Covered In Milk Chocolate covered in rainbow jimmies (quantity 2)$4.50OUT OF STOCKChocolate Pretzels
$4.50OUT OF STOCKBlue Sour Patch
$3.95OUT OF STOCKChocolate Sea Salt Vanilla Caramel
$6.95OUT OF STOCKFreeze Dried Skittles
$9.95OUT OF STOCK
Fruit Slices
Aprox. 1/2 pound tender assorted fruit jell candy slices. Assorted Fruit slices are the perfect snack to satisfy your sweet tooth! These classic soft and chewy sugar sanded fruit slices come in an assortment of sweet fruity flavors which may include most but not all of the following flavors: orange, raspberry, lemon, lime, cherry, watermelon, grape, peach, lemon-lime, pink grapefruit, blue raspberry, strawberry-banana and apple. (Flavors will vary)$5.95OUT OF STOCKPink Nonpereil Gum Drops
$4.95OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Malt Balls
$5.95OUT OF STOCK
Wilbur Dark Chocolate Buds
Smooth and creamy dark chocolate drops. Wilbur buds are a long time classic Lancaster County treat.$9.95OUT OF STOCKWilbur Milk Chocolate Buds
$9.95OUT OF STOCKSOUR Freeze Dried Skittles
$9.95OUT OF STOCKSour Worms
$4.95OUT OF STOCKChocolate Covered Preztels
$4.00OUT OF STOCK
COOKIES
Chocolate Chip Cookie Bar
$2.50OUT OF STOCK
Custom Themed Buttercream Cookies
Delicious large sugar cookies with buttercream icing and custom designed fondant logo. You pick the theme and we will create the magic. These are great for any occasion. We can even do pictures too!$16.00+Cookie Bag
$3.00Small Sugar Cookie
$1.25OUT OF STOCKButter Buttons (3/1.50)
$1.00+OUT OF STOCKChristmas Buttercream Cookie
$2.95OUT OF STOCKChocolate Chip
$1.75OUT OF STOCKKitchen Sink Cookie qty 2
$4.95OUT OF STOCKMemaw Jelly Strawberry Wells
$2.00OUT OF STOCKDouble Choc. Chunk
$2.00OUT OF STOCKSmore Cookie
$1.25OUT OF STOCKM&M Cookie
$2.00OUT OF STOCKDouble Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.00OUT OF STOCKCookie Bundle
$3.00OUT OF STOCKFather's Day Cookies
$3.50OUT OF STOCKPeanut Butter Cookie Gluten Free
$1.50OUT OF STOCKValentine Cookie Kit
It's creative fun in a box! Leave the baking and mess to us when you choose this cookie kit which includes six freshly baked heart shaped cookies, three colors of buttercream icing in prefilled piping bags and valentine sprinkles. This is a great way to make some sweet memories with your family and friends.$16.00OUT OF STOCK
Valentine Share the Love Box
Our "Share the Love Box" is the perfect solution for a crowd. Box includes 12 beautifully decorated sugar cookies with buttercream icing.$28.00OUT OF STOCK
Valentine Sweetheart Box
Shower that special someone with some "sweet" love' Give them a Papsy's Sweetheart box containing 4 beautifully hand decorated, homemade heart-shaped sugar cookies with butter cream frosting, nestled gently in a pink bakery box with valentine ribbon and tag.$12.00OUT OF STOCK
FOOD
HOMEMADE SOUP
Delicious hearty soup with meatballs, potatoes, kidney beans, lima beans, chili beans, onion, green peppers and corn, perfect for dipping our fresh baked crusty baguette.
Chili
$6.00☝ Today's Soup 👆
ITALIAN WEDDING SOUP WITH FRESH BAKED BREAD
Savory chicken broth based soup with Italian style beef and sausage mini meatballs, buttery Acini Di Pepe pasta pearls, onion, spinach and a blend of Italian spices. Truly a burst of flavor in your mouth!$6.00OUT OF STOCKRoasted Tomato Basil Soup with Baked Grilled Cheese
$8.95OUT OF STOCKBroccoli Cheese
$6.00OUT OF STOCKGrilled Cheese
$3.95OUT OF STOCKVegetable Beef Soup & Bread
$6.00OUT OF STOCKLasagna Soup
$6.00OUT OF STOCKLunch Special
Lunch special includes a bowl of our tasty soup of the day, bread/chips, bottle of water and a cookie.$10.25OUT OF STOCKTaco Soup
$6.00OUT OF STOCKextra bread
$1.00
Candy Cane Shake
$6.25
Customize your item
Select 1 to 2
Select 1
Optional
1
All hours
| Sunday | 12:00 pm - 6:00 pm |
| Monday | 3:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 3:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 3:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 3:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 3:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Family owned soft serve ice cream, sorbet and frozen yogurt shop with additional sweet treats such as hot drinks, baked goods and soup. We always have a variety of dairy free options as well. Place your order online and we will bring it out to you. Simply give us a call and let us know you have arrived. If you prefer to order in person, try our new walk-up window located on the back patio or visit us inside!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
