Pizza
Pienezza Pizza 3236 N John Young Pkwy
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pizza
Classic New York Round
P 10".. NY Neapolitan
The classic NY pizza$10.50
M 14"..NY Neapolitan
The classic NY pizza$14.50
L 16".. Ny Neapolitan
The classic NY pizza$17.50
P 10".. Italian Margherita
Italian style with fresh mozzarella and basil$11.50
M 14".. Italian Margherita
Italian style with fresh mozzarella and basil$15.50
L 16".. Italian Margherita
Italian style with fresh mozzarella and basil$19.50
P 10".. NY White Pie
Ricotta cream sauce and garlic$12.50
M 14".. NY White Pie
Ricotta cream sauce and garlic$17.00
L 16".. NY White Pie
Ricotta cream sauce and garlic$21.00
P 10".. Garlic Margherita
Margherita sauce with extra garlic, white sauce and fresh basil$11.50
M 14".. Garlic Margherita
Margherita sauce with extra garlic, white sauce and fresh basil$15.50
L 16".. Garlic Margherita
Margherita sauce with extra garlic, white sauce and fresh basil$19.00
P 10".. Crazy Margherita
A house special with 4 sauces: margherita, white cream sauce pesto, and balsamic with garlic$12.50
M 14".. Crazy Margherita
A house special with 4 sauces: margherita, white cream sauce pesto, and balsamic with garlic$17.50
L 16".. Crazy Margherita
A house special with 4 sauces: margherita, white cream sauce pesto, and balsamic with garlic$21.50
P 10".. Vodka Margherita
Classic margherita with a la vodka sauce$14.00
M 14".. Vodka Margherita
Classic margherita with a la vodka sauce$18.50
L 16".. Vodka Margherita
Classic margherita with a la vodka sauce$23.00
Square & Sicilian
Sicilian Half
New York deep-dish stle pillow crust crisped in olive oil$13.00
Sicilian Full
New York deep-dish style pillow crust crisped in olive oil$21.00
Sicilian Hot Honey Pepperoni Half
Sicilian loaded with pepperoni, garlic and hot honey$16.50
Sicilian Hot Honey Pepperoni Full
Sicilian loaded with pepperoni, garlic and hot honey$26.50
Sicilian Bruschetta (Vegan) Half
Sicilian crust topped with our fresh house marinated bruschetta and margherita sauce$15.50
Sicilian Bruschetta (Vegan) Full
Sicilian crust topped with our fresh house marinated bruschetta and margherita sauce$26.00
Grandma’s Pizza
Old-world pan pizza baked with pizza sauce on top, olive oil, garlic and extra herbs$21.00
Italian Flag
Thin crust square pizza with fresh pesto, margherita tomato sauce, and white sauce$21.00
Calzones, Strombolis, and Pizza Rolls
Small Calzone
Ricotta and mozzarella cheese baked in a folded dough$11.00
Large Calzone
Ricotta and mozzarella cheese baked in a folded dough$20.00
Small Stromboli
Pepperoni, meatball and Capicola with provolone, mozzarella, choice of crust$13.00
Large Stromboli
Pepperoni, meatball, and Capicola with provolone, mozzarella, choice of crust$23.95
Small Pepperoni and Ham
Pepperoni, ham and cheese wrapped in dough and baked$12.00
Large Pepperoni and Ham
Pepperoni, ham and cheese wrapped in dough and baked$21.00
Small Spinach
Spinach, creamy ricotta sauce, garlic and grated cheese wrapped in a dough and baked$12.00
Large Spinach
Spinach, creamy ricotta sauce, garlic and grated cheese wrapped in a dough and baked$21.00
Small Steak Roll
Philly steak, cheese, creamy white sauce, mushrooms, onions, and peppers wrapped in a toasted dough$15.00OUT OF STOCK
Large Steak Roll
Philly steak, creamy white sauce, onions, mushrooms, and peppers in a pizza roll with choice of crust$25.00OUT OF STOCK
Small Chicken Roll
Philly steak, creamy white sauce, onions, mushrooms, and peppers in a pizza roll with choice of crust$15.00
Large Chicken Roll
Your choice of chicken style$25.00
Signatures Pizzas (Personal)
P 10".. Angies Veggie
Spinach, red onion, tomato and garlic with margherita, white and pesto sauces.$14.95
P 10".. Caprese
Fresh tomato, fresh mozzarella and garlic, drizzled with white sauce, balsamic and basil$14.95
P 10".. Chicken Lovers
Your choice of chicken style on a pizza.$14.95
P 10".. Cryin' Hawaiian
Hawaiian pizza with white sauce, spicy peppers and cappicola$14.95
P 10".. Hey Brooklyn
5 Classic toppings: pepperoni, sausage, onions and peppers$14.95
P 10".. Hot Honey Vodka Roni
Garlic margherita with vodka sauce, pepperoni, and hot honey$14.95
P 10".. Mama's Lasagna
Meatball, sausage, red and white sauces$14.95
P 10".. Meat Monster
Pepperoni, cappicola, sausage, extra cheese, and garlic$14.95
P 10".. Prosciutto Nelle Neve
Prosciutto, white sauce, roasted garlic, and arugula drizzled with balsamic glaze$14.95
P 10".. Quattro Formaggio Spinach
Blend of 4 cheeses with spinach, garlic and white sauce$14.95
P 10".. Vegan Special
Fresh spinach, eggplant, red onion and roasted garlic. Balsamic glaze.$14.95
Signatures Pizzas (Medium)
M 14"..Angies Veggie
Spinach, red onion, tomato and garlic with margherita, white and pesto sauces.$20.75
M 14"..Caprese
Fresh tomato, fresh mozzarella and garlic, drizzled with white sauce, balsamic and basil$20.75
M 14"..Chicken Lovers
Your choice of chicken style on a pizza$20.75
M 14"..Cryin' Hawaiian
Hawaiian pizza with white sauce, spicy peppers and cappicola$20.75
M 14"..Hey Brooklyn
5 Classic toppings: pepperoni, sausage, onions and peppers$20.75
M 14"..Hot Honey Vodka Roni
Garlic margherita with vodka sauce, pepperoni, and hot honey$20.75
M 14"..Mama's Lasagna
Meatball, sausage, red and white sauces$20.75
M 14"..Meat Monster
Pepperoni, cappicola, sausage, extra cheese, and garlic$20.75
M 14"..Prosciutto Nelle Neve
Prosciutto, white sauce, roasted garlic, and arugula drizzled with balsamic glaze$20.75
M 14"..Quattro Formaggio Spinach
Blend of 4 cheeses with spinach, garlic and white sauce$20.75
M 14"..Vegan Special
Sesame crust with spinach, eggplant, red onion and roasted garlic. Balsamic glaze.$20.75
Signatures Pizzas (Large)
L 16".. Angies Veggie
Spinach, red onion, tomato and garlic with margherita, white and pesto sauces.$25.95
L 16".. Caprese
Fresh tomato, fresh mozzarella and garlic, drizzled with white sauce, balsamic and basil$25.95
L 16".. Chicken Lovers
Your choice of chicken style on a pizza$25.95
L 16".. Cryin' Hawaiian
Hawaiian pizza with white sauce, spicy peppers and cappicola$25.95
L 16".. Hey Brooklyn
5 Classic toppings: pepperoni, sausage, onions and peppers$25.95
L 16".. Hot Honey Vodka Roni
Garlic margherita with vodka sauce, pepperoni, and hot honey$25.95
L 16".. Mama's Lasagna
Meatball, sausage, red and white sauces$25.95
L 16".. Meat Monster
Pepperoni, cappicola, sausage, extra cheese, and garlic$25.95
L 16".. Prosciutto Nelle Neve
Prosciutto, white sauce, roasted garlic, and arugula drizzled with balsamic glaze$25.95
L 16".. Quattro Formaggio Spinach
Blend of 4 cheeses with spinach, garlic and white sauce$25.95
L 16".. Vegan Special
Sesame crust with spinach, eggplant, red onion and roasted garlic. Balsamic glaze.$25.95
Beverages
Small Fountain / Cans
Pepsi - 12oz Can
The bold, refreshing, robust cola.$2.50
Pepsi Zero Sugar - 12oz Can
Real cola taste, with a refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without sugar$2.50
Starry - 12oz Can
A caffeine-free soda that provides a crisp, clear burst of lemon lime flavor$2.50
Mtn Dew - 12oz Can
Mtn Dew exhilarates and quenches thirst with its one of a kind citrus taste.$2.50Can Diet Pepsi
$2.25Can Starry
$2.25Water Bottle
$2.00
Food
Appetizer
3 Jumbo Fried Mozzarella
Sliced fresh and crispy fried$8.00
5 Jumbo Fried Mozzarella
$13.00
Crispy Chicken Bites
8 breaded chicken nuggets$5.00
Small smokey garlic fries
add bacon or cheese$4.00
Large smokey garlic fries
add bacon or cheese$7.00
6 Garlic knots
6 knots in seasoned garlic and oil, with marinara$4.50
12 Garlic knots
12 knots in seasoned garlic and oil, with marinara$7.50
6 Everything bagel knots
6 knots in seasoned garlic and oil, with everything bagel seasoning and marinara. (Vegan)$4.50
12 Everything bagel knots
12 knots in seasoned garlic and oil, with everything bagel seasoning and marinara. (Vegan)$7.50
Big Fat Sandwiches
Chicken parmigiana
Chicken on 11"Italian bread$14.00
Cheesesteak
Sliced ribeye, onions, peppers & mushrooms on garlic bread.$15.00OUT OF STOCK
Eggplant parmigiana
Eggplant on 11" Italian bread$14.00
Meatball parmigiana
Meatball on 11" Italian bread smothered in cheese$14.00
Chicken cutlet hero
Grilled-or-fried chicken, tomato, arugula, fresh mozz & house sauce.$15.00
Salads
Gardenia
Tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, parmesan, greens$5.50+
Cottage
Grilled veggies, chicken, feta, olives over romaine.$10.00+
Burrata Caprese
fresh burrata over tomatoes and a bed of arugula, topped with raisins and pesto.$15.00
Caesar Salad
Romaine tossed in Caesar dressing and parmesan with toast points.$8.00+
Pastas
Small Marinara
Additional charge for meatball.$7.00
Large Marinara
Additional charge for meatball.$12.00
Small Alfredo
Additional charge for grilled chicken$9.00
Large Alfredo
Additional charge for grilled chicken$16.00
Small Creamy Pesto
$10.00
Large Creamy Pesto
$19.00
Small Baked Spinach Bacon Alfredo
$12.00
Large Baked Spinach Bacon Alfredo
$19.50
Small A La Vodka
$12.00
Large A La Vodka
$19.50
Dinners
Cottage
$0.00
Grilled veggies, chicken, feta, olives over romaine.
Customize your item
Select 1
Select at least 1
Optional
Optional
Optional
Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:30 am - 10:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:30 am - 10:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Pienezza Pizza is Central Florida's spot for authentic New York pizza. Generations of Brooklyn tradition make our family-owned pizzeria the go-to for a quick slice, delicious classic pies, and homemade takes on the freshest food trends. Oh, and if you miss a great square, our Sicilian, Grandma's Pie, and (Vegan) Bruschetta are gonna make you think you're in The City —at least for a bite.
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
