
American
Pie Shop
1339 H St NE
Washington, DC 20002
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
Chicken Dinner Pie Slice
This is not your typical soupy chicken pot pie. We take big pieces of white meat chicken and chunks of fresh veggies, and we roast them in EVOO, fresh herbs and seasoning before baking the mix into a flaky crust. This is a homemade chicken dinner in a pie$12.00Berger Cookie Pie Slice
The Berger cookie out of Maryland, is a shortbread cookie topped with fudge icing which we crumble into a vanilla buttermilk custard$9.00Chocolate Chess Slice
Swiss Dark Chocolate and coffee baked into a condensed chess pie, expect the classic flakey top layer and rich chocolate filling$9.00
Pies by the Slice
Quiche Slice
Bacon, Onion and Gruyere Cheese Quiche Slice
The perfect blend of crispy pieces of bacon, shredded gruyere cheese and roasted onion, folded into our silky quiche filling, and baked in a flaky crust$10.00Broccoli Cheddar Quiche Slice
Fresh pieces of lightly roasted broccoli mixed with shredded Cheddar, and gently folded into our smooth breakfast quicheOUT OF STOCK$11.00Ham and Cheese Quiche Slice
Layers of honey-baked ham and shredded Cheddar in a silky breakfast quiche, perfect for any mealOUT OF STOCK$11.00Mushroom Swiss Quiche Slice
Pieces or roasted mushroom and shredded Swiss cheese baked into our breakfast quiche, perfect for any mealOUT OF STOCK$11.00Quiche Supreme Slice
This supreme quiche is loaded with peppers, onions, bacon, ham and shredded cheeseOUT OF STOCK$11.00Roasted Veggie Quiche Slice
This hearty and healthy breakfast quiche is packed with layers of roasted fresh bell pepper, redskin potato, mushroom and onionOUT OF STOCK$11.00Spinach and Goat Cheese Quiche Slice
Layers of fresh baby spinach between pockets of silky french goat cheese, makes for a truly decadent quiche that is perfect for any meal$10.00Bag Fee
$0.05
Savory Slice
BBQ Pulled Pork Pie Slice
This is an 18hr pie. We slow roast pork butt with peppers, onions, and our homemade BBQ sauce til perfectly tender then pull the pork and bake it in our flaky pie crust.OUT OF STOCK$12.00Chicken Dinner Pie Slice
This is not your typical soupy chicken pot pie. We take big pieces of white meat chicken and chunks of fresh veggies, and we roast them in EVOO, fresh herbs and seasoning before baking the mix into a flaky crust. This is a homemade chicken dinner in a pie$12.00Fat Tire Beer Brat Pie Slice
Juicy locally sourced bratwurst, peppers, and onions slow-cooked in a beer bath and baked into our flakey crust.OUT OF STOCK$12.00Guinness Steak Pie Slice
This pie has developed a cult following and for a good reason. Drawing inspiration from authentic Irish stews, this pie meticulously incorporates the perfect blend of tender pieces of steak, roasted carrot, onion, and celery, and select secret ingredients.OUT OF STOCK$12.00Moechella
OUT OF STOCK$12.00Mumbo potato bacon
OUT OF STOCK$12.00Mumbo
Pieces of roasted red potatoes, bell peppers, onion, a mix of shredded cheeses, and a splash of homemade mumbo sauce all baked into a flakey crust, makes for the ultimate cheesy-potatoey comfort food.$12.00Pamela's Tofu Curry Slice
Fluffy brown rice, roasted cubes of fresh tofu, bok choy, cauliflower, onion and bell peppers folded into a tangy mellow yellow thai curry.$12.00Ratatouille Slice
The perfect pie to warm your insides. A medley of fresh veggies (eggplant, squash, zucchini, onion), roasted in garlic, EVOO, fresh herbs and seasoning, then stewed in a zesty homemade tomato-based sauce.$12.00Sausage Tomato, Fennel Slice
This pie is packed with slow roasted locally sourced sweet and spicy Italian sausage, freshly chopped fennel and crushed tomato. By far, one of our most popular and tastiest dinner pies.$12.00Steak, Mushroom, Onion, & Gruyere Slice
Tender pieces of seasoned steak, roasted slices of fresh seasoned mushrooms chopped onion, and a generous helping of shredded Gruyere cheese folded in, baked in our flakey crust.$12.00Date Night
OUT OF STOCK$35.00Date Night Booze
OUT OF STOCK$40.00Handheld Shepards Pie
OUT OF STOCK$10.00Irish Sausage Roll
OUT OF STOCK$5.00
Sweet Slice
Roasted pieces of Granny Smith apples seasoned to perfection and layered in a smooth cinnamon sugar custard.
Apple Crumble Slice
Layers of crisp granny smith apples, perfectly seasoned and topped with an oat and brown sugar crumbleOUT OF STOCK$9.00Apple Pie Slice
This is a double-crust pie with layers and layers of sliced crisp granny smith apples, seasoned to perfection$9.00Baked Banoffee Pie
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Baileys bourbon and butterscotch slice
OUT OF STOCK$10.00Banana Graham Slice
Smooth banana cream pie in a graham cracker crustOUT OF STOCK$10.00Banana Stand Slice
Chocolate banana cream pieOUT OF STOCK$9.00Berger Cookie Pie Slice
The Berger cookie out of Maryland, is a shortbread cookie topped with fudge icing which we crumble into a vanilla buttermilk custard$9.00Blueberry Pancake Pie Slice
Our secret, luscious pancake pie filling with fresh blueberries folded in, offers everyone the perfect excuse to eat pie for breakfast, but also makes for an incredible dessert$9.00Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Slice
We soak our high-quality pecans in Makers Mark Kentucky Bourbon and add it to the pie filling as well. Once baked off, we add a generous layer of dark chocolate ganache. This smokey, sweet treat has quickly become the go-to pie for all holidays and celebrationsOUT OF STOCK$9.00Bruiserberry Pie Slice
Black & blueberry pie that packs a punch! VeganOUT OF STOCK$9.00Caramel Apple Crumble Slice
Layers of crisp Granny Smith Apples perfectly seasoned, topped with an oat and brown sugar crumbled and finished with a drizzle of our homemade caramel sauceOUT OF STOCK$9.00Chocolate Chip Pancake Pie Slice
Top secret silky smooth pancake pie with Swiss dark chocolate chips sprinkled inOUT OF STOCK$9.00Chocolate Cream Pie Slice
Silky chocolate cream pie. Served chilledOUT OF STOCK$9.00Chocolate Chess Slice
Swiss Dark Chocolate and coffee baked into a condensed chess pie, expect the classic flakey top layer and rich chocolate filling$9.00Chocolate Peanut Butter Chess Pie Slice
We take our rich chocolate chess pie made with the best Swiss dark chocolate, and swirl in creamy homemade peanut butter$9.00Chocolate Pecan Slice
What makes our Pecan Pie so special? We source only the best pecans from a family-owned and operated pecan farm. This twist on the southern classic incorporates pieces of dark Swiss chocolate and could convert even the most devoted pecan pie purist$9.00cinnamonroll
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Key Lime
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Lemon Meringue Slice
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Mixed Berry Crumble Slice
A mix of fresh seasonal berries dusted with sugar and topped with an oat and brown sugar topping$9.00Mixed Berry Slice
A mix of fresh seasonal berries baked into a flakey crust, this pie has the perfect balance of sweet and tart and is fitting for any occasionOUT OF STOCK$9.00Mounds Slice
Our signature Coconut Chess -- toasted coconut in a tangy buttermilk custard -- topped with a layer of dark chocolate ganache! An elevated take on the classic candy barOUT OF STOCK$10.00P.B. Nutter Slice
Creamy peanut butter pie topped with a dark chocolate ganache drizzleOUT OF STOCK$9.00Pancake Pie Slice
You heard right! Inspired by the bakers love of pancakes and pie, this pie really tastes even better than licking the batter bowl AND gives everyone a good excuse for eating pie for breakfast (as if you needed one)!OUT OF STOCK$9.00Peach
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Peach Cobbler
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Pecan Slice
What makes our Pecan Pie so special? We source only the best pecans from a family-owned and operated pecan farm. This classic is the perfect balance of sticky sweet and crunch$9.00Pumpkin Slice
Roasted pumpkin blended and mixed with traditional spices makes this silky smooth classic perfect for any occasionOUT OF STOCK$9.00Roasted Apple Cinnamon Chess
$9.00S'mores Pie Slice
An elevated ode to the campfire classic, with rich dark chocolate, marshmallows and a graham cracker crustOUT OF STOCK$9.00Salted Caramel French Toast Slice
This buttermilk chess pie topped with homemade salted caramel sauce is perfect for breakfast and dessert (and any meal in between)OUT OF STOCK$9.00Samoa Cookie Pie Slice
One of our most popular pies, this is an ode to one of our favorite Girl Scout cookies. We take a smooth cheesecake-type filling and pour it into a chocolate cookie crust, and top it off with shredded toasted coconut, homemade caramel sauce and a generous$9.00Sour Cherry Crumble Slice
Sour cherries dusted with sugar and topped with an oat and brown sugar toppingOUT OF STOCK$9.00Sour Cherry Slice
Sour cherries dusted in sugar and baked to perfectionOUT OF STOCK$9.00Strawberry Rhubarb Slice
Fresh pieces of rhubarb and strawberries dusted with sugar, cooked down and baked in a flakey pie shell, for the best seasonal treat. We allow the produce to shine in this pie creating a delicious balance of tartness with a touch of sweetOUT OF STOCK$9.00Summer Berry
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Sweet Potato Coconut Pie Slice
This is a twist on a classic. With toasted coconut layered in adding some natural sweetness and the perfect amount of chewiness, this pie has been known to convert even the more devout of sweet potato pie puristsOUT OF STOCK$9.00Sweet Potato Slice
Roasted sweet potato mixed with all the right spices makes this subtle, smooth pie the perfect slice of comfortOUT OF STOCK$9.00The Chuck Brown Slice
We take our incredible classic pecan pie and top it with a generous layer of dark chocolate ganache and finish it with a generous drizzle of our homemade caramel sauceOUT OF STOCK$10.00Triple Chocolate Cream Slice
Smooth chocolate cream pie in a chocolate cookie crust topped with homemade chocolate whipped creamOUT OF STOCK$9.00winter berry crumble slice
OUT OF STOCK$9.00pie slice
OUT OF STOCK$3.14Cherry Blossem
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Blueberry
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
Whole Pies
Sweet Whole
Apple Crumble
Layers of crisp granny smith apples, perfectly seasoned and topped with an oat and brown sugar crumbleOUT OF STOCK$40.00Baked Banoffee Pie
OUT OF STOCK$40.00baileys bourbon butterscotch whole
OUT OF STOCK$40.00Banana Graham
Smooth banana cream pie in a graham cracker crustOUT OF STOCK$40.00Banana Stand
Chocolate banana cream pieOUT OF STOCK$40.00Berger Cookie Pie
The Berger cookie out of Maryland, is a shortbread cookie topped with fudge icing which we crumble into a vanilla buttermilk custard$40.00Blueberry Pancake Pie
Our secret, luscious pancake pie filling with fresh blueberries folded in, offers everyone the perfect excuse to eat pie for breakfast, but also makes for an incredible dessert$40.00Blueberry Pie
OUT OF STOCK$40.00Bourbon Chocolate Pecan
We soak our high-quality pecans in Makers Mark Kentucky Bourbon and add it to the pie filling as well. Once baked off, we add a generous layer of dark chocolate ganache. This smokey, sweet treat has quickly become the go-to pie for all holidays and celebraOUT OF STOCK$40.00Bruiserberry Pie
Black & blueberry pie that packs a punch! VeganOUT OF STOCK$40.00Caramel Apple Crumble
Layers of crisp Granny Smith Apples perfectly seasoned, topped with an oat and brown sugar crumbled and finished with a drizzle of our homemade caramel sauceOUT OF STOCK$40.00Chocolate Chip Pancake Pie
Top secret silky smooth pancake pie with swiss dark chocolate chips sprinkled inOUT OF STOCK$40.00Chocolate Cream Pie
Silky chocolate cream pie. Serve chilledOUT OF STOCK$40.00Chocolate Chess
Swiss Dark Chocolate and coffee baked into a condensed chess pie, expect the classic flakey top layer and rich chocolate filling$40.00Chocolate Peanut Butter Chess Pie
We take our rich chocolate chess pie made with the best swiss dark chocolate, and swirl in creamy homemade peanut butter$40.00Chocolate Pecan
What makes our Pecan Pie so special? We source only the best pecans from a family-owned and operated pecan farm. This twist on the southern classic incorporates pieces of dark Swiss chocolate and could convert even the most devoted pecan pie puristOUT OF STOCK$40.00Key Lime Pie
OUT OF STOCK$40.00Lemon Meringue
OUT OF STOCK$40.00Mixed Berry
A mix of fresh seasonal berries baked into a flakey crust, this pie has the perfect balance of sweet and tart and is fitting for any occasionOUT OF STOCK$40.00Mixed Berry Crumble
A mix of fresh seasonal berries dusted with sugar and topped with an oat and brown sugar toppingOUT OF STOCK$40.00Mounds
Our signature Coconut Chess -- toasted coconut in a tangy buttermilk custard -- topped with a layer of dark chocolate ganache! An elevated take on the classic candy barOUT OF STOCK$40.00P.B. Nutter
Creamy peanut butter pie topped with a dark chocolate ganache drizzleOUT OF STOCK$40.00Pancake Pie
You heard right! Inspired by the bakers love of pancakes and pie, this pie really tastes even better than licking the batter bowl AND gives everyone a good excuse for eating pie for breakfast (as if you needed one)!OUT OF STOCK$40.00Peach Cobbler
OUT OF STOCK$40.00Peach Pie
OUT OF STOCK$40.00Pumpkin
Roasted pumpkin blended and mixed with traditional spices makes this silky smooth classic perfect for any occasionOUT OF STOCK$40.00Pecan
What makes our Pecan Pie so special? We source only the best pecans from a family-owned and operated pecan farm. This classic is the perfect balance of sticky sweet and crunch$40.00Roasted Apple Cinnamon Chess
Roasted pieces of Granny Smith apples seasoned to perfection and layered in a smooth cinnamon and sugar custard. This pie incorporates all your favorite fall flavors and provides the perfect balance of a slightly tart apple, subtle cinnamon spice, and browOUT OF STOCK$40.00S'mores Pie
An elevated ode to the campfire classic, with rich dark chocolate, marshmallows and a graham cracker crustOUT OF STOCK$40.00Salted Caramel French Toast
This buttermilk chess pie topped with homemade salted caramel sauce is perfect for breakfast and dessert (and any meal in between)OUT OF STOCK$40.00Samoa Cookie Pie
One of our most popular pies, this is an ode to one of our favorite Girl Scout cookies. We take a smooth cheesecake-type filling and pour it into a chocolate cookie crust, and top it off with shredded toasted coconut, homemade caramel sauce and a generousOUT OF STOCK$40.00Sour Cherry
Sour cherries dusted in sugar and baked to perfectionOUT OF STOCK$40.00Sour Cherry Crumble
OUT OF STOCK$40.00Strawberry Rhubarb
Fresh pieces of rhubarb and strawberries dusted with sugar, cooked down and baked in a flakey pie shell, for the best seasonal treat. We allow the produce to shine in this pie creating a delicious balance of tartness with a touch of sweetOUT OF STOCK$40.00Summerberry
OUT OF STOCK$40.00Sweet Potato
Roasted sweet potato mixed with all the right spices makes this subtle, smooth pie the perfect slice of comfortOUT OF STOCK$40.00Sweet Potato Coconut Pie
This is a twist on a classic. With toasted coconut layered in adding some natural sweetness and the perfect amount of chewiness, this pie has been known to convert even the more devout of sweet potato pie puristsOUT OF STOCK$40.00The Chuck Brown
We take our incredible classic pecan pie and top it with a generous layer of dark chocolate ganache and finish it with a generous drizzle of our homemade caramel sauceOUT OF STOCK$40.00Traditional Apple
This is a double-crust pie with layers and layers of sliced crisp granny smith apples, seasoned to perfection$40.00Triple Chocolate Cream
Smooth chocolate cream pie in a chocolate cookie crust topped with homemade chocolate whipped creamOUT OF STOCK$40.00Winter Berry Crumble
OUT OF STOCK$40.00Cherry Blossom
OUT OF STOCK$40.00
Quiche Whole
Bacon, Onion and Gruyere Cheese Quiche
The perfect blend of crispy pieces of bacon, shredded gruyere cheese and roasted onion, folded into our silky quiche filling, and baked in a flaky crustOUT OF STOCK$42.00Broccoli Cheddar Quiche
Fresh pieces of lightly roasted broccoli mixed with shredded Cheddar, and gently folded into our smooth breakfast quicheOUT OF STOCK$42.00Ham and Cheese Quiche
Layers of honey-baked ham and shredded Cheddar in a silky breakfast quiche, perfect for any mealOUT OF STOCK$42.00Mushroom Swiss Quiche
Pieces or roasted mushroom and shredded Swiss cheese baked into our breakfast quiche, perfect for any mealOUT OF STOCK$42.00Quiche Supreme
This supreme quiche is loaded with peppers, onions, bacon, ham and shredded cheeseOUT OF STOCK$42.00Roasted Veggie Quiche
This hearty and healthy breakfast quiche is packed with layers of roasted fresh bell pepper, redskin potato, mushroom and onionOUT OF STOCK$42.00Spinach and Goat Cheese Quiche
Layers of fresh baby spinach between pockets of silky french goat cheese, makes for a truly decadent quiche that is perfect for any meal$42.00
Savory Whole
BBQ Pulled Pork Pie
This is an 18hr pie. We slow roast pork butt with peppers, onions, and our homemade BBQ sauce til perfectly tender then pull the pork and bake it in our flaky pie crust. (Serves up to 8)OUT OF STOCK$44.00Chicken Dinner Pie
This is not your typical soupy chicken pot pie. We take big pieces of white meat chicken and chunks of fresh veggies, and we roast them in EVOO, fresh herbs and seasoning before baking the mix into a flaky crust. This is a homemade chicken dinner in a pie$44.00Fat Tire Beer Brat Pie
Juicy locally sourced bratwurst, peppers, and onions slow-cooked in a beer bath and baked into our flakey crust. (Serves up to 8)OUT OF STOCK$44.00Guinness Steak Pie
This pie has developed a cult following and for a good reason. Drawing inspiration from authentic Irish stews, this pie meticulously incorporates the perfect blend of tender pieces of steak, roasted carrot, onion, and celery, and select secret ingredients/OUT OF STOCK$44.00mumbo potato
$44.00Pamela's Tofu Curry
Fluffy brown rice, roasted cubes of fresh tofu, bok choy, cauliflower, onion and bell peppers folded into a tangy mellow yellow thai curry. (Serves up to 8)$44.00Ratatouille
The perfect pie to warm your insides. A medley of fresh veggies (eggplant, squash, zucchini, onion), roasted in garlic, EVOO, fresh herbs and seasoning, then stewed in a zesty homemade tomato-based sauce. (Serves up to 8)$44.00Sausage Tomato, Fennel
This pie is packed with slow roasted locally sourced sweet and spicy Italian sausage, freshly chopped fennel and crushed tomato. By far, one of our most popular and tastiest dinner pies. (Serves up to 8)OUT OF STOCK$44.00Steak, Mushroom, Onion, & Gruyere
Tender pieces of seasoned steak, roasted slices of fresh seasoned mushrooms chopped onion, and a generous helping of shredded Gruyere cheese folded in, baked in our flakey crust. (Serves up to 8$44.00The Moechella
This pie is packed with sweet and smokey mumbo marinated slow-cooked shredded chicken. (Serves up to 8)OUT OF STOCK$44.00The Mumbo Potato Bacon
Pieces of roasted red potatoes, bell peppers, onion, a mix of shredded cheeses, and a splash of homemade mumbo sauce all baked into a flakey crust, makes for the ultimate cheesy-potatoey comfort food. (Serves up to 8)OUT OF STOCK$44.00
Drink Menu
Drinks
12 Oz Coffee
$3.0016 Oz Coffee
$3.25Bottled Water
$2.75Boylan's Black Cherry
$3.75Boylan's Orange
$3.75Boylan's Root Beer
OUT OF STOCK$3.75Bullpen Pilsner
OUT OF STOCK$8.00DC Brau Mango
OUT OF STOCK$8.00DC Brau Raspberry Limeade
$8.00Hot Tea
$2.50Iced Coffee
$3.25IZZE Blackberry
$3.75IZZE Lime
$3.75IZZE Mango
$3.75IZZE Strawberry
$3.75Kombucha
OUT OF STOCK$4.00Kombucha
OUT OF STOCK$4.00Kombucha
OUT OF STOCK$4.00milk
$2.00Modelo
Mexican lager 4.4%$7.00National Bohemian 16oz
$6.00Natty Boh - 12 Oz
Pabst blue ribbonOUT OF STOCK$5.00Old Bust Head Blue Lemonade Sour
$10.00PBR 16oz
OUT OF STOCK$6.00Waterloo Blackberry Lemonade
$3.00Waterloo Lemon-Lime
$3.00Waterloo Raspberry Nectarine
$3.00
Bag Fee
Baked Banoffee Pie
$40.00
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:15 am - 9:45 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 12:15 pm - 10:45 pm |
| Thursday | 12:15 pm - 10:45 pm |
| Friday | 11:15 am - 11:45 pm |
| Saturday | 11:15 am - 11:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Thank you for supporting your local pie shop!
Location
1339 H St NE, Washington, DC 20002
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.




