American
Pints N Pies
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
DAIRY-FREE ICE CREAM PIES
Dairy-Free Ice cream pies
Lotus Pie
Lotus Ice Cream in Graham crust$35.00
Oreo Pie
Dairy Free Oreo Ice cream in Oreo pie crust$35.00
Peanut Butter Pie
Dairy-Free Peanut Butter ice cream in Oreo Pie crust$35.00
Cookie Dough
$35.00
Mint Chip Pie
Dairy-Free Mint chip ice cream in Oreo Pie crust$35.00
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Pie
$35.00
Tiramisu Pie
$35.00
Fruity Pebbles Pie
$35.00
Dulce de Leche Pie
$35.00
Chocolate Oreo Pie
$35.00
Cappuccino Chip Pie
$35.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
$35.00
Nutella Pie
$35.00
Halava Pie
$35.00Pistachio Pie
$35.00
Rocky Road Pie
$35.00
Salted Caramel Pie
$35.00
Strawberry Ice Cream Pie
Strawberry non dairy ice cream pie$35.00
S'mores Pie
Dairy-Free S'mores ice cream in graham pie crust$35.00
Spumoni Pie
Spumoni Ice cream Pie (Almond/Pistachio/Chocolate)$35.00
9" Dairy-Free Ice Cream Cakes (2 layer)
Dairy-Free Round 9" Ice cream Cakes
Lotus/Peanut Butter
$44.00
Lotus/Oreo
Dairy-Free Ice cream cake feeds 12-18ppl. 2 layers of ice cream with crunch in the middle & chocolate gnache on top.$44.00
Peanut Butter/Oreo
Dairy-Free Ice cream cake feeds 12-18ppl. 2 layers of ice cream with crunch in the middle & chocolate gnache on top.$44.00Oreo/Cookie Dough
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Oreo/Nutella
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Mint Chip/Peanut Butter
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Oreo/Mint Chip
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Nutella/Cookie Dough
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Nutella/Chocolate
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Oreo/Chocolate
OUT OF STOCK$44.00lotus/cookie dough
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Oreo/Cinnamon Toast Crunch
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Tiramius/Oreo
OUT OF STOCKVanilla/Chocolate
Dairy-Free Vanilla and Chocolate Ice cream cake.$44.00Choc oreo/Cookie dough
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Ferrero Rocher/Oreo
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Dulce De Leche/Oreo
OUT OF STOCK$44.00Oreo/Fruity pebbles
$44.00Chocolate/Peanut Butter
$44.00
Dairy-Free Premium Pies
Dairy-Free Ice Cream Logs
Strawberry Shortcake
$49.00
Twix log
12" Twix log (vanilla non dairy ice cream with caramel, chocolate and shortbread)OUT OF STOCK$49.00Oreo/Mint chip
$36.00+
Fruity Pebbles treat log
12" Fruity pebbles treat log with non dairy fruity pebbles ice cream.$33.00+
Rice Krispy treat log
12" Rice Krispy treat log with Vanilla non dairy ice cream$45.00Peanut butter/Oreo
$36.00+
Dubai Log
Pistachio non dairy ice cream with katafi and pistachio coated in premium chocolate shell.$70.00Lotus/Peanut butter
$36.00+
Lotus/Oreo
Dairy-Free Ice Cream log$36.00+Lotus
OUT OF STOCK$36.00Ferrero Rocher Log
$36.00+Knafe Log
OUT OF STOCK$49.00
*NEW* Ice Cream Sandwiches
Flying Saucers (3 Vanilla/3 Choc)
6 pack flying saucers- 3 vanilla, 3 chocolate (Dairy-free)$21.00
Limited Edition Chipwhich MINT CHIP pack
Dairy-free mint chip chipwhich pack of 6$24.00
Flying Saucers (Vanilla pack)
6 flying saucers with Dairy-free Vanilla ice cream.$21.00
Chipwiches (Vanilla pack)
Chipwich- 6 chocolate chip cookie sandwiches with Vanilla Ice cream. (DAIRY-FREE)$24.00
Flying Saucers (3 Oreo/ 3 Vanilla)
6 pack flying saucers- 3 vanilla, 3 Oreo. Dairy-Free$21.00
Chipwhiches (3 Vanilla/3 Choc)
6 pack Chipwhich ice cream sandwiches 3 Vanilla, 3 Chocolate (Dairy-free)$24.00
Flying Saucers (Oreo Pack)
6 pack Oreo flying saucers (Dairy-free)$21.00
Make your own Flying saucer pack
Pick your flavors for pack of 6 flying saucers. (Parve- Non-Dairy)$22.00
Chipwhich (DUBAI PACK of 5)
$28.00
Flying Saucer (DUBAI PACK of 5)
OUT OF STOCK$26.00
Flying Saucers (DAIRY-3 Vanilla/3 Chocolate)
6 pack Dairy (Chalav Yisroel) flying saucers- 3 Vanilla, 3 Chocolate$21.00
Flying Saucers (DAIRY-VANILLA)
6 pack Dairy (Chalav Yisroel) flying saucers. Vanilla pack$21.00
Flying Saucers (DAIRY- OREO pack)
$21.00
Flying Saucers (2 Vanilla/2 chocolate/2 Pistachio)
6 pack Dairy-free flying saucers. 2 Vanilla, 2 chocolate, 2 Pistachio$21.00
Flying Saucers (Pistachio pack)
Pistachio lovers- 6 pack Pistachio flying saucers (dairy-free)$21.00
Individual flying saucer (Vanilla)
$4.49
Individual Chipwhich (Vanilla)
$4.99
9" Dairy-Free Ice Cream Cakes (3 layer)
Oreo/Lotus/Peanut Butter
Dairy-Free Ice cream cake feeds 15-25ppl. 3 layers of ice cream with crunch in the middle & chocolate gnache on top.$55.00
Neapolitan (Vanilla/Strawberry/Chocolate)
Classic flavors Vanilla/Strawberry/Chocolate non dairy Ice cream cake.$55.00
Strawberry Shortcake 3 layer Cake
Dairy-Free Frozen Dessert cake Vanilla and Strawberry sorbet topped with Strawberry cookie crumbs.OUT OF STOCK$55.00
DAIRY-FREE POPS
Dairy-Free Pops
12 Assorted Pop
$58.00
Lotus Pop
$4.95
Oreo Pop
$4.95
Fruity pebbles
OUT OF STOCK$4.95
Strawberry shortcake Pop
OUT OF STOCK$4.95
Ferrero Rocher Pop
OUT OF STOCK$4.95
Peanut butter Pop
OUT OF STOCK$4.95Pistachio Pop
OUT OF STOCK$4.95
Nutella Pop
$4.95Cappucino chip pop
OUT OF STOCK$4.95
Chocolate Peanut butter Pop
OUT OF STOCK$4.95
Dubai Pop
Pistachio non dairy ice cream and crispy Katafi dipped in premium chocolate and pistachio drizzleOUT OF STOCK$4.95
Halava Pop
OUT OF STOCK$4.95
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
OUT OF STOCK$4.95
Knafe pops
OUT OF STOCK$4.95Twix Pop
OUT OF STOCK$4.95
7" Dairy-Free Ice Cream cakes
Lotus/Peanut butter
7" ice cream cake feeds 8-12 ppl. Dairy-Free (The cake is the smaller cake on the left side of the photo)$32.00
Oreo/Mint Chip
7" ice cream cake feeds 8-12 ppl. Dairy-Free (The cake is the smaller cake on the left side of the photo)OUT OF STOCK$32.00
Lotus/Oreo
7" ice cream cake feeds 8-12 ppl. Dairy-Free (The cake is the smaller cake on the left side of the photo)$32.00Fruity pebbles/Oreo
$32.00
Peanut butter/Oreo
7" ice cream cake feeds 8-12 ppl. Dairy-Free (The cake is the smaller cake on the left side of the photo)$32.00Lotus/cookie dough
$32.00Tiramius/Oreo
OUT OF STOCK$32.00Nutella/Oreo
OUT OF STOCK$32.00Choc/Oreo
$32.00Cookie Dough/Fruity Pebbles
OUT OF STOCK$32.00Salted caramel/Cookie Dough
$32.00Dulce de leche/Cookie dough
OUT OF STOCK$32.00Dulce De leche/Oreo
$32.00Rocky Road/oreo
OUT OF STOCK$32.00Oreo/Cookie dough
OUT OF STOCK$32.00Peanut butter/choc
OUT OF STOCK$32.00Cinnamon Toast crunch/Oreo
$32.00Oreo/Tiramisu
OUT OF STOCK$32.00Cookie Dough/chocolate
OUT OF STOCK$32.00
Vanilla/Chocolate
7" ice cream cake feeds 8-12 ppl. Dairy-Free (The cake is the smaller cake on the left side of the photo)OUT OF STOCK$32.00
DAIRY-FREE PINTS
Dairy-Free Pints
Vanilla Pint
$9.00
Strawberry shortcake Pint
$9.00
Cookie Dough
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
Peanut Butter
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
Cookies N Cream Pint
$9.00
Lotus
$9.00Choc oreo
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
Fruity Pebbles
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
Mint Chip
$9.00Pistachio
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
Ferrero Rocher
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Cappucino chip
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Chocolate Peanut butter
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
Chocolate Pint
$9.00
Nutella
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Dulce De Leche
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
S'mores
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
Tiramisu
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Cinnamon Toast Crunch
OUT OF STOCK$9.00Rocky Road
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
Oreo/Lotus/Peanut Butter
$55.00
Dairy-Free Ice cream cake feeds 15-25ppl. 3 layers of ice cream with crunch in the middle & chocolate gnache on top.
Customize your item
Optional
Optional
Request advisory
No substitutes. Additions may be charged extra.
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 9:45 am - 6:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 9:30 am - 6:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 9:45 am - 6:00 pm |
| Thursday | 9:45 am - 6:00 pm |
| Friday | 9:00 am - 3:45 pm |
| Saturday | Closed |
Restaurant info
🍦Delicous homemade dairy-free ice cream sold in pints, pies, cakes & logs in a variety of delicious flavors! ⭐️Star-K kosher & yoshon 🍨We cater, too!
Location
295 Avenue O, Brooklyn, NY 11230
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
