Pizza
Pizza Fenice
304 Fifth Ave
Pelham, NY 10803
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Slices-Rolls-Calzones-Panzerotti
Slices
Plain Slice
$4.00Sicilian Slice
$4.50Detroit Red Slice
$5.00White Slice
$5.75Grandma's Slice
$4.75Grandma Vodka slice
$5.50Specialty Slice 1
$6.00Specialty Slice 2
$7.00Specialty Slice 3
$8.00Crosby Sicilian
$4.75Slice Out Hunger
$6.00OUT OF STOCK$Coat Donation (14" pie)
$17.00OUT OF STOCKDOUGH
$15.00SIDE TOM SAUCE
$1.00
Rolls/Stromboli
Chicken Roll
$9.00ROLL Eggplant Parm
$8.50Roni Stromboli
$8.50Pastrami & Mozzarella Roll
$9.00Stefano Stromboli
Ham, Sausage, Pepperoni, Mozz Cheese & American Cheese$9.00Italian Combo Stromboli
Genoa Salami, Capicola, Soppressata, Mortadella, Provolone, & Mozzarella$9.00Meatball Parm Roll
$9.00Veggie Roll
$8.00Sausage And Pepper ROLL
$9.00
Calzones
Traditional Pizzas
Traditional Pizza
14" NY Cheese
$17.0014" NJ Tomato
$19.0014" Margherita
$20.0014" Marinara
$16.0014" White Pizza
$22.0014" Olio e Alice
$19.0014" Veggie
$22.00Side Of Mike's Hot Honey
$4.0016" NY Cheese
$22.0016" NJ Tomato
$24.0016" Margherita
$26.0016" Marinara
$20.0016" White Pizza
$28.0016" Olio e Alice
$24.00Grandma's Pizza
$30.00Sicilian Pizza
$29.00Parm Square Pizza
$36.0016" Veggie
$28.00Brooklyn Sicilian
$31.00TRIPLE GRANDMA
$34.00Crosby Sicilian
$36.00
Not So Traditional Pizzas
14" The Angry Drunk Bird
$25.0014" The Meathead
$27.0014" Sunday Sausage & Peppers
$26.0014" Eggplant Capo
$23.0014" Fenice Fire
$27.0014" Vodka Roni
$25.0014" The Cuban
$26.00OUT OF STOCK14" The Pastrami Reuben
$26.0014"CBSR- Chicken, Bacon, SpicyRanch
$25.0014" Loaded Baked Potato Pizza
$25.0014" The Jenny
$26.0014" Frankie V
$22.0014" 304 ( Roni ricotta hot honey)
$25.0014" Artsy
$28.0016" The Angry Drunk Bird
$33.0016" The Meathead
$35.0016" Sunday Sausage & Peppers
$34.0016" Eggplant Capo
$30.0016" Fenice Fire
$35.0016" Vodka Roni
$32.0016" The Cuban
$34.00OUT OF STOCK16" The Pastrami Reuben
$34.0016" CBSR chicken bacon spicy ranch
$32.0016" Loaded Baked Potato Pizza
$32.0016" 304 ( Roni ricotta hot honey)
$32.0016" Jenny
$34.0016" Frankie V
$28.0016" Artsy
$36.0016" Slice Out Hunger Special
$38.00OUT OF STOCK
Detroit Style Pizzas
Detroit Red
Classic Cheese Topped with rich tomato sauce Grated cheese and Basil$27.00Detroit Green Machine
Classic Cheese topped with HomeMade Pesto Sauce and grated Romano & Reggiano cheese$29.00Detroit Bandiera
A tribute to the Italian flag, stripes of tomato , pesto and creamy provolone cheese sauce with Fresh Mozzarella$29.00Detroit Spin Dip
Our take on spinach & artichoke dip, with mozzarella cheese & grated Romano$34.00Detroit Carbonara
Crispy guanciale with fresh mozzarella and topped with fresh made carbonara sauce and grated Parmigiano Reggiano cheese$34.00Detroit Pulled Pig & Pickle
12 hr pulled pork with mozzarella and jack cheddar, topped with kosher deli dill pickles and BBQ sauce$38.00OUT OF STOCKDetroit Eggplant Caprese
Breaded Eggplant cutlet layered with sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, fresh basil & drizzled with balsamic glaze$33.00Detroit It Takes Two
2 types of pepperoni ( Shredded and sliced ), topped with your choice of tomato , pesto or provolone sauce$34.00Detroit Veggie
$34.00Detroit Melendez
$38.00Detroit Bacon Tomato spicy ranch
$35.00Detroit Fenice Hawaian
$38.00Detroit Buffalo
$38.00
Breads-Balls-Toasts-Sticks
Breads
Garlic Bread
covered with seasoned roasted garlic brown butter$6.00Garlic Bread with Cheese
covered with seasoned roasted garlic brown butter$7.50Mozzarella Bread
toasted with melted Fresh Mozzarella topped with Sicilian Olive Oil, Sea salt and black pepper$6.00Honey Bacon Bread
Crispy Applewood smoked bacon sautéed with onions and glazed with Mike’s Hot Honey and topped with melted Jack Cheddar$8.50
Balls
Arancini
(Rice Balls) Cheesy Saffron Rice and rich Meat sauce with peas$16.00Homemade Meatballs
topped with rich tomato sauce and ricotta cheese$17.00Eggplant Balls
Delicious Eggplant “meatballs”, made w/roasted eggplant$13.00Potato Balls
(Potato Balls) Fluffy Potato mixed w/Caciocavallo & Romano & Reggiano$11.00OUT OF STOCKParmigiano Balls
Reggiano & Romano cheese mixed with eggs and cream, breaded and fried$12.00OUT OF STOCK
Toasts
Sandwiches
Chicken Parm Sandwich
$17.00Meatball Parm Sandwich
$17.00Eggplant Parm Sandwich
$15.00Smash Ball Cutlet Parm Sandwhich
Smashed Meatball breaded and fried$18.00Sausage Cutlet Parm Sandwich
butterflied link sausage, breaded & fried$17.00Sausage and Peppers Sandwich
$16.00Eggplant Ball Parm Sandwich
$16.00Grilled Chicken with Spinach Sandwich
$15.00
Party Rolls
Party Roll Roni Stromboli
Shredded Pepperoni with Mozzarella cheese$48.00Party Roll Chicken Parm
$45.00Party Roll Eggplant Parm
$42.00Party Roll Meatball Parm
$45.00Party Roll Pulled BBQ Pork and Cheddar
$48.00Party Roll Pastrami & Mozzarella
$45.00OUT OF STOCKParty Roll Broccoli & Mozzarella
$40.00Party Roll Spinach & Mozzarella
$40.00Party Roll Stefano Stromboli
Ham, Sausage, Pepperoni, Mozz & American Cheese$48.00Party Roll Italian Combo Stromboli
Genoa Salami, Capicola, Soppressata, Mortadella$48.00
16" Jenny
$34.00
Customize your item
16" Toppings
Optional
1
All hours
| Sunday | 1:00 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 1:00 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Wednesday | 12:30 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Thursday | 12:30 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Friday | 12:30 pm - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 12:30 pm - 7:00 pm |
Restaurant info
A unique menu combining classic and creative selections of pizza , sandwiches, and appetizers.
Location
304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
