
American
#PBH
14477 Fancher Ave
Sterling, NY 13156
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
PBH
ALL ABOARD
Soup of the Day
Chef special of the day$5.00+Lobster Bisque
Our Signature Soup$7.00+
Calamari
Lightly breaded, fresh, and deep fried. Topped with pepperoncini & shredded parmesan served with marinara sauce & homemade aioli$19.00
Tuna Triangles
Edamame Hummus - Sweet Asian Glaze - Pita$21.00
Fish Bites
Breaded fresh haddock bites. Served with cocktail or tartar sauce$19.00Chicken Quesadillas
Grilled flour tortilla stuffed with cheddar jack cheese, peppers and onions$16.00Tender Basket
Hand breaded served with choice of dipping sauce$14.00
Lobster Poutine
$19.00Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Lemon butter chardonnay sauce.$19.00Bangn' Shrimp
Jumbo fried shrimp tossed in boom boom sauce, and drizzled with sriracha$16.00Brussel Sprouts
$12.00
SALADS

Crispy Chic Cobb
Romaine and mixed greens topped with crispy chicken tenderloin, bacon, hard boiled eggs, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, avocado and Crumbly Bleu. Served with your choice of dressing.$19.00Katelyn's
$19.00OUT OF STOCK
Crunchy Fish Caesar
Romaine, parmesan, croutons, homemade dressing$21.00
Steak House
Romaine & mixed greens with ribeye steak, caramelized onions, crumbly blue & topped with crispy onion straws. crumbly bleu. Your choice of dressing$19.00Cajun Shrimp Ceasar
$21.00OUT OF STOCKGoat Cheese Beet
Mixed greens, beets, walnuts, Quinoa, cucumbers, carrots goat cheese and balsamic vinaigrette dressing$18.00
BURGERS
Captain Cheese
Choice of American, Provolone, Cheddar or Swiss cheese$19.00
Smokehouse Burger
Topped with cheddar cheese, bacon & barbecue.$19.00Veggie Burger
Our custom-blended veggie patty, with Swiss cheese, fresh avocado slices, sauteed spinach and roasted red peppers. finished with garlic aioli on a wheat bun.$20.00Plain Burger
$16.00
SANDWICHES

Uncle B's Reuben
Corned beef, red cabbage, Swiss cheese and 1000 Island dressing, served grilled on thick sliced rye bread.$19.00Fresh Haddock Sandwich
Fried fresh haddock and served with tartar sauce$20.00
PBH Haddock Reuben
Delicious fresh haddock made as a Reuben. If you like fish and Reubens, this will be your new favorite!$20.00Chicken Sandwich
Choice of fried or grilled with side of mayonnaise topped with lettuce, tomato and onion on a brioche bun.$17.00Fish Tacos
Fresh Haddock, lettuce, tomatoes and cabbage topped with our homemade sauce$20.00Cajun Chicken Sandwich
$18.00OUT OF STOCKHot Honey Chicken
Fried chicken breast tossed in house siracha infused orange blossom honey, pickled cabbage, chipotle lime aioli sauce served with Brioche bun.$19.00Shrimp Tacos
$20.00Grilled Chicken & Avocado
$18.00French Dip
$19.00
ENTREES
Cashew-Cornflake Crusted Fried Haddock
Fresh haddock lightly breaded with a delicious taste$30.00Fried Haddock Dinner
Fresh haddock lightly breaded with a delicious taste, with slaw$26.00Fried Shrimp or Scallops
Lightly breaded shrimp or scallops. Broiled | 2$29.00OUT OF STOCKRed Snapper
Grilled to Perfection, our Red Snapper is delicately enhanced with a flavorful Cajun cream sauce and the savory touch of Andouille sausage$31.00
SIGNATURE DISHES
New York Strip 12oz.
USDA Prime - Served with garlic mashed with mushroom sauce.$35.00Chicken Parmesan
Lightly breaded chicken breast smothered with cheese over pasta with our homemade red sauce$28.00Tortellini Calabrese
Bacon sauteed with artichoke hearts and roasted red peppers tossed with cheese filled tortellini in a basil asiago cream sauce$31.00Drunkin' Chicken Parm
Italian Panko breaded crust, fried chicken breast, roasted garlic cream, Monterey jack cheese, Ricotta cheese blend, tomato bruschetta with cheese tortellini pasta.$30.00Braised Short Ribs
Pan seared and fall apart tender beef short rib, over creamy garlic mashed potatoes and vegetables smothered in a rich sherry sauce finished with a cabernet jus.$32.00
FLATBREADS
LITTLE SAILORS
SIDES
Side Salad
Fresh greens$5.00Side Caesar SALAD
Homemade dressing$4.00SIDE French Fries
Deep fried$5.00Sweet Potato Fries
Thick and crispy with a sweet taste$6.00Signature Slaw
Aunt Judy's Signature$3.00Onion Rings
Crispy taste$6.00Chef's Vegetable
Fresh Veggie$3.00Sauteed Spinach
$4.00OUT OF STOCKGarlic Mashed Potato
$3.00Loaded Mash
$5.00Dip/Dressing
$0.75
DESSERTS

Lava Cake
Individual dark chocolate fudge bundt cake with a chocolate ganache filling, served warm and topped with vanilla ice cream$9.00Dessert of the Day
Homemade, local, while supplies last. Ask your server$10.00Brownie Sundae
Two scoops of vanilla ice cream topped with homemade brownie chocolate sauce, whipped cream and a cherry$8.00OUT OF STOCKLemon Blueberry Cheesecake
$10.00Flourless Chocolate Torte
Gluten Free - single scoop of ice cream and whipped cream$10.00Deep Fried Ice Cream
$10.00
N/A BEVERAGE
N/A BEVERAGE
Water
Cola
$3.50Diet Cola
$3.507up
$3.50Lemonade
$3.50Brewed Ice Tea
$3.50Shirley Temple
$3.50Arnold Palmer
$3.50Coffee
$3.50Hot Tea
$3.50Milk
$3.50Chocolate Milk
$3.50OJ
$3.50Cranberry
$3.50Bottled Water
Thirst-quenching yet portable, the essentia water bottle is a perfect size for an on -the-go lifestyle. Overachieving H2O$2.00Tonic
$3.50Club Soda
$3.50Ginger Ale
$3.50Water 6 pack
$18.00
DAILY SPECIALS OL
Serving fresh haddock w/ FF and coleslaw.
All hours
| Sunday | 4:00 pm - 7:30 pm |
| Monday | 4:00 pm - 7:30 pm |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4:00 pm - 7:30 pm |
| Friday | 4:00 pm - 8:30 pm |
| Saturday | 4:00 pm - 8:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Since 1910, the Historic Pleasant Beach Hotel, a delightful Victorian gem, has offered waterfront dining with stunning views. Unwind on the spacious deck or in the cozy indoor dining room and bar, sipping cocktails as you soak in the beauty of Little Sodus Bay.
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.




