American
proper bagel
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
proper merch
b-boy short sleeve
printed on comfort colors adult unisex heavyweight t -shirts - 100% cotton$27.00
old school short sleeve
printed on comfort colors adult unisex heavyweight t -shirts - 100% cotton$27.00
1977 crewneck sweatshirt
as colour's relaxed fit crewneck - 80% cotton / 20% recycled polyester fleece$60.00
proper tote bag
the proper tote - perfect for bagels by the dozen$25.00
b-boy longsleeve
printed on comfort colors adult unisex heavyweight t -shirts - 100% cotton$45.00
bagels with custom cream cheese
NY KNICKS funfetti cake cream cheese
same original birthday cake cream cheese but make it NY KNICKS colors!$6.25peach pie cream cheese
$7.00plain cream cheese
$5.00scallion dill cream cheese
$6.25roasted garlic and rosemary cream cheese
$6.25fresh veggie cream cheese
$6.25jalapeño bacon cream cheese
$6.25olive cream cheese
$6.75lavender honey cream cheese
$6.25blueberry pie cream cheese
$6.25strawberry shortcake cream cheese
$6.25cookie dough cream cheese
$6.25dill pickle cream cheese
$6.25lox cream cheese with capers & onions
capers & onions are already mixed in. they can't be removed!$7.00birthday cake cream cheese
$6.25OUT OF STOCKwalnut raisin cream cheese
$6.75vegan scallion cream cheese
*CONTAINS SOY*$7.75vegan cinnamon hazelnut cream cheese
*CONTAINS SOY*$7.75
cream cheese by the pound - no bagels included
1/2 NY KNICKS cake cream cheese
same original birthday cake cream cheese but make it NY KNICKS colors!$9.50
1 lb NY KNICKS cake cream cheese
same original birthday cake cream cheese but make it NY KNICKS colors!$19.001/2 lb peach pie
$10.001 lb peach pie
$20.001/2 lb olive cream cheese
$10.001 lb olive cream cheese
$20.001/2 fresh veggie
$8.001 lb fresh veggie
$16.001/2 roasted garlic and rosemary
$9.501 lb roasted garlic and rosemary
$19.001/2 lox cream cheese with capers
$10.001 lb lox cream cheese with capers
$20.001/2 jalapeño bacon
$9.751 lb jalapeño bacon
$19.501/2 dill pickle
$9.501 lb dill pickle
$19.001/2 lavender honey
$9.501 lb lavender honey
$19.001/2 strawberry shortcake
$9.501 lb strawberry shortcake
$19.001/2 blueberry
$9.501 lb blueberry pie
$19.001/2 cookie dough
$10.001 lb cookie dough
$20.001/2 walnut raisin cream cheese
$9.501 lb walnut raisin cream cheese
$19.00OUT OF STOCK1/2 lb vegan scallion
*CONTAINS SOY*$10.251 lb vegan scallion
*CONTAINS SOY*$20.501/2 lb vegan cinnamon and hazelnut
*CONTAINS SOY*$10.251 lb vegan cinnamon and hazelnut
*CONTAINS SOY*$20.50
pastries
NY KNICKS black & white cookie
in honor of the new york knicks headed to the nba finals, we have decorated our classic authentic new york black & white cookies with blue & orange sprinkles.$5.50
NY KNICKS rainbow marzipan bar
classic new york - style tri color rainbow marzipan bar / cookie (contains almond). celebrating the new york knicks headed to the nba finals since 1999, these are colored in orange. blue and white!$5.50
NY KNICKS cupcakes
vanilla cupcake with vanilla buttercream frosting. decorated with an edible NYK topper. celebrating the team headed to the NBA finals since 1999!$6.00
french toast bread pudding
housemade bread pudding made with our cinnamon crunch and egg bagels, vanilla, cinnamon, sugar and a drizzle of salted caramel. served cold or heat at home.$5.50
strawberry poptart
housemade fresh strawberry pop tart$6.25OUT OF STOCK
pride funfetti sugar cookie bar
kick off pride month with a large slice of a rainbow themed funfetti sugar cookie shortbread bar topped with buttercream icing and edible glitter.$6.50
pride cookie sandwich
celebrating pride month with this funfetti sugar cookie sandwich filled with chocolate butercream and dipped in rainbow sprinkles!$5.00hazelnut & chocolate ganache crumb square
hazelnut & chocolate ganache crumb square.$6.00cinnamon crumb coffee cake loaf
$5.00chocolate chip fudge brownie
$5.00
cinnamon ruggalah
$5.00
chocolate ruggalah
$5.00
raspberry ruggalah
$5.00
cinnamon roll
large house made cinnamon roll with cream cheese glaze$6.00OUT OF STOCKcoconut macaroons (GF)
gluten-free chocolate-dipped coconut macaroons (6 per bag).$6.00
chocolate fudge gluten free donut
gluten-free chocolate fudge baked donut with sprinkles.$4.00chocolate chip cookie (GF)
housemade gluten free chocolate chip cookie$4.50
chocolate ruggalah
$5.00
Request advisory
SPECIAL REQUESTS WILL NOT BE HONORED. PLEASE DO NOT EVEN TRY!!! no refunds once your order is placed. allergies only will be honored in this section.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 8:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Monday | 8:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 8:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 8:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Thursday | 8:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Friday | 8:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Saturday | 8:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Restaurant info
family owned / authentic new york style bagel eatery & market / old school bagel making since 1977
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
