This restaurant does not have any images
Seafood
Proper Fish
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
BRITISH FISH & CHIPS
British Frish & Chips "Seattle's BEST Fish & Chips - Seattle Times & ZAGAT" Wild, sustainable, longline, organic Bering Sea Cod. Served with house minted mushy peas and tartar sauce , freshly hand cut FAT chips, cooked twice for the perfect bite- Voted Best OF Bainbridge 2019,$22.00
FISH TACOS
Traditional South Pacific Nayarit Bering Sea Wild Cod Beer Battered Taco with glazed chipotle aioli, salted green cabbage, house Pico de Gallo cured pickled red onions, Cilantro Crema and house chips stick potatoes in a flour tortilla.$18.00+
CHOWDER
Wild Bering Sea Cod Chowder Thick, creamy and delicious. We only use cream and butter as our liquid and is packed full of premium cod, finished with parsley oil, spring onions & oyster crackers$8.00+
FOOD
FIRST COURSE
Something To Get You Started
PRAWN COCKTAIL
Prawn & Crab Cocktail with Gulf Prawn. Prawns, crab and radicchio with baby gem lettuce tossed gently in our house seafood dressing, micro greens and a dusting of paprika.$19.00CHOWDER
Wild Bering Sea Cod Chowder Thick, creamy and delicious. We only use cream and butter as our liquid and is packed full of premium cod, finished with parsley oil, spring onions & oyster crackers$8.00+
MAIN COURSE
There's a little bit of something for everybody.
BRITISH FISH & CHIPS
British Frish & Chips "Seattle's BEST Fish & Chips - Seattle Times & ZAGAT" Wild, sustainable, longline, organic Bering Sea Cod. Served with house minted mushy peas and tartar sauce , freshly hand cut FAT chips, cooked twice for the perfect bite- Voted Best OF Bainbridge 2019,$22.00
FRIED OYSTERS
Lightly panko coated oysters, fried until "JUST COOKED" served with lovely chips & basil aioli$19.00FISH TACOS
Traditional South Pacific Nayarit Bering Sea Wild Cod Beer Battered Taco with glazed chipotle aioli, salted green cabbage, house Pico de Gallo cured pickled red onions, Cilantro Crema and house chips stick potatoes in a flour tortilla.$18.00+
LOBSTER POUTINE
Wild Bering Sea Cod Chowder served over double cooked fresh hand cooked fries, with Beechers cheese curds, lobster gravy with Fine Herbs and butter poached lobster claws$20.00OUT OF STOCKCHEESE STICKS
$11.00OUT OF STOCK
.
A Combo meal for Students only, The Fish Sandwich, hand Cut Chips and a Soft Drink. :) Student ID required, served 11am to 1:30 pm. Wild, sustainable beer battered Bering Sea cod loin, with slow roasted thyme and rosemary tomatoes & caramelized onions with an arugula salad on a Macrina butter toasted potato roll.$14.50OUT OF STOCK
LOBSTER ROLL
Proper Legit Lobster claw and knuckle, held together with a dab of house mayonnaise, old bay spice, on a square sided butter toasted Essential Brioche Bun, finished with chives- served with fries$33.00
BABY GEM LETTUCE CAESAR
It's all about the dressing, whole baby gem leaves with house made croutons, well dressed in "Rick" caesar dressing and shaved Parmigiano Reggiano$16.00
BRITISH KIDS FISH & CHIPS
Named as best Fish & Chips in Seattle by The Seattle Times & ZAGAT. Local beer battered whole fillet, wild, sustainable, organic, line caught Bering sea Alaskan cod, hand cut fat, twice cooked chips, and house tartar sauce- Voted Best Of Bainbridge 2019$14.00
FISH BITES
Wild Baring Sea Cod Loin, Sustainable, Hook & Line Fish Bites- Perfect for the kiddie winkies$13.00
EXTRA SIDES
A little extra perhaps
SIDE MUSHY PEAS
Mushy Peas. You either love them or you hate them.$5.00
HAND CUT CHIPS
Punched by hand daily and carefully selected. Soaked, blanched and then cooked to order- Nice and big 1/2", that taste like fluffy pillows of mashed potato with a crispy shell$7.00
BRITISH FISH (NO CHIPS)
British Frish ( No Chips ) "Seattle's BEST Fish & Chips - Seattle Times & ZAGAT" Wild, sustainable, longline, organic Bering Sea Cod. Served with house minted mushy peas and tartar sauce , Voted Best OF Bainbridge 2019 to 2022.$16.00
MERCHANDISE
Mugs
Its a Proper Mug for Tea or Coffee$17.00OUT OF STOCK
Caps
Get A Proper Hat$25.00OUT OF STOCK
S T-Shirt
Small T-Shirt$25.00OUT OF STOCK
M T-Shirt
Medium T-Shirt$25.00OUT OF STOCK
L T-Shirt
Large T-Shirt$25.00OUT OF STOCK
XL T-Shirt
XL T-Shirt$25.00
XXL T-Shirt
XXLT-Shirt$25.00OUT OF STOCK
M Ladies Tank Top
Medium Ladies Tanks$15.00OUT OF STOCK
S Long Sleeve T-Shirt
Small Long Sleeve T-Shirt$22.00OUT OF STOCK
M Long Sleeve T-Shirt
Medium Long Sleeve T-Shirts$22.00OUT OF STOCK
L Long Sleeve T-Shirt
Large Long Sleeve T-Shirt$22.00OUT OF STOCK
XL Long Sleeve T-Shirt
XL Long Sleeve T-Shirt$22.00OUT OF STOCK
S Hoodie
Small Zip Up Hoodie$25.00OUT OF STOCK
M Hoodie
Medium Zip Up Hoodie$25.00OUT OF STOCK
L Hoodie
Large Zip Up Hoodie$25.00OUT OF STOCK
LOBSTER ROLL
$33.00
Proper Legit Lobster claw and knuckle, held together with a dab of house mayonnaise, old bay spice, on a square sided butter toasted Essential Brioche Bun, finished with chives- served with fries
Customize your item
Select up to 1
Select up to 1
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
