American
Sherman Hotel 133 W Main St
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
LUNCH MENU
GRILL
BRISKET BURGER 1/2 lb W/CHEESE
BRISKET BURGER 1/2# W/CHEESE$13.99
DBL BRISKET BURGER 1 lb W/CHEESE
1LB Burger$17.99
SMITH HOT DOG W/SIDE
W/ 1 SIDE$7.99
SMITH HOTDOG SINGLE
$3.50
CHICKEN SANDWICH GRILLED
$13.99
Steak Sandwich
$13.99
QUAD BRISKET 2 lb BURGER W/CHEESE
$28.99
CAPTAIN HICKS 3 lb BURGER W/CHEESE
6 1/2lb Patties$49.99
BRISKET BURGER 4lb W/CHEESE 19m 48s
Under 19 Minutes 48 Seconds gets it free + a free T Shirt & brass plate for our wall! Record set by Alec Johnson$65.99
FRYER
SALAD
APPETIZER
STEAK FRIES
$4.00
WAFFLE FRIES
$4.00Garlic Smashed
$4.99
ColeSlaw
$3.99
ONION RINGS
$5.99
CHEESE STICKS
5 Per Order$7.99
Pretzel Sticks
4 Per Order$8.99MAC & CHEESE BIG
$6.99
Small Mac
$4.99
Big Beans
$5.99
Small Beans
$4.99
Poutine
Fries w/cheese curds and brown gravy$8.99Loaded Baked Potato
$6.00
Mac n Cheese Potato Skins Loaded
2 Per Order$8.99Straight Cut Fries
$4.00Baked Potato
$5.99
DINNER MENU
GRILL
SMOKE HOUSE
SALADS
SPECIALS
Beef
Pork
Pulled Pork Fries
$14.99OUT OF STOCK
Pulled Pork Sandwich W/Fries
$14.99OUT OF STOCK
Ham & Cheese Sandwich
$12.99
Sausage Jalapeno Honey
$15.99OUT OF STOCK
Pork Schnitzel Sandwich w/Fries
$15.99OUT OF STOCK
Pulled Pork & Mac Loaded Potato Skins
$14.99OUT OF STOCKPork Schnitzel Dinner w/2 sides
$18.99OUT OF STOCKCuban W/Fries
Pulled Pork W/Ham & Provolone Served W/ Pickles$15.99OUT OF STOCK
CHALLENGES
"INSANITY WING CHALLENGE" 2m48s
The real wing challenge! 1 pound of our wing in a blend of sauces and spices. No dips of drinks during timed challenge! Free if time is beat. Time to beat is 2.48$18.99
4lb Rib Eye Challenge
Must order in advance. Time to beat is ?$125.00BRISKET BURGER 4lb W/CHEESE 19m 48s
Under 19 Minutes 48 Seconds gets it free + a free T Shirt & brass plate for our wall! Record set by Alec Johnson$65.99
Small Beans
$4.99
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 10:30 am - 7:45 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 3:45 pm - 9:15 pm |
| Wednesday | 3:45 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Thursday | 3:45 pm - 7:45 pm |
| Friday | 3:45 pm - 8:45 pm |
| Saturday | 10:30 am - 8:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
133 W Main St, Sherman, NY 14781
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
