
American
Star Diner
1111 Waterloo Geneva Road
Waterloo, NY 13165
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
Bacon-n-Cheddar Burger Dlx
1/3 lb. burger topped with cheddar & bacon. with mayo, lettuce and tomato served with one side$9.99Fish Fry
12 oz. Haddock, batter dipped, breaded or crunchy we recommend crunchy to stay crispy on takeout$14.99Egg & Olive Sandwich
Egg salad with green olives mixed in on white bread$4.99
BREAKFAST
Breakfast Meals
#1 Workman's
3 eggs, 3 slices of bacon, 3 sausage links, potatoes, and toast$10.29#2 Village Visitor
Country fried steak topped with sausage gravy served with 2 eggs, potatoes and toast$9.99#3 Hungryman's
2 eggs, 2 bacon, 2 sausage links, 2 pancakes or french toast$9.99#4 Cheddar Delight
Hash browns, bacon, scrambled eggs, smothered with cheddar, served with toast$9.29#5 Lo-Cal
Eggbeaters omelet with onions, peppers, tomato and mushrooms, served with dry whole wheat toast and cup of fruit$9.29#6 Denver Corned Beef Hash
Corned beef hash with onions & peppers, topped with 2 eggs served with toast$9.29#7 The Classic Eggs, Meat, Potatoes & Toast
2 eggs, potatoes, meat and toast$8.99#7 Classic Eggs, Meat & Toast
2 eggs, meat & toast$6.99#7 Classic Eggs, Potatoes & Toast
2 eggs, potatoes, and toast$6.99#9 Corned beef Hash & Eggs
Corned beef hash topped with 2 eggs served with potatoes and toast$9.29#10 Sausage Benedict
2 poached eggs, biscuits and sausage patty topped with sausage gravy with choice of home fries or hash browns$9.99#11 Eggs Benedict
2 poached eggs, English muffin, Canadian bacon topped with hollandaise sauce, served with potato$9.99#12 Sausage Gravy & Biscuits
$4.99#12 Sausage Gravy Biscuits w/ Eggs
$5.99
Burritos/Steak/Sandwiches
8oz Steak & Eggs
8oz New York strip, served with 2 eggs, potato & toast$12.99Breakfast Sandwich
Egg, cheese, ch of meat and bread$4.29Bfast Sand W Potato
$6.29Breakfast Burrito
2 egg omelet with onions, ham and peppers with cheddar in a tortilla shell served with sour cream & salsa$6.99Burrito &Potato
$8.99
French Toast & Pancakes
California French Toast
4 pieces of cinnamon swirl bread topped with cinnamon sauce$6.99French Toast
3 thick slices dipped in egg, sprinkled with cinnamon and sugar$2.99+Stuffed French Toast
Stuffed with cream cheese, topped with strawberry or raspberry$6.99Pancakes
3 buttermilk cakes served with butter & syrup$2.99+Blueberry Pancakes
$3.29+Chocolate Chip Pancakes
$3.29+Pecan Pancakes
$3.29+
Waffles
Served with butter &syrup
Bacon & Eggs Waffle
Bacon inside & 2 eggs on top$8.59Belgian Waffle
Sprinkled with powdered sugar$6.59Blueberry Waffle
$7.59Chocolate Chip Waffle
Topped with whipped cream$7.59Georgian Waffle
Pecans inside, peaches and whipped cream on top$7.59Pecan Waffle
Topped with whipped cream$7.59Star Waffle
Waffle topped with strawberries, pecans & whip cream$7.59Warm Apple Caramel Waffle
Topped with warm apples & cinnamon with a scoop of vanilla ice cream & caramel sauce$7.59
Omelettes
Athenian Omelette
3 egg omelet with Tomato, feta and spinach served with potato & toast$8.99Cheese Lover's Omelette
3 egg omelet, Swiss, provolone and cheddar served with potato & toast$8.99Country Omelette
3 egg omelet bacon, sausage, onions, Swiss topped with hollandaise served with potato & toast$8.99Create Your Own Omelette
3 egg omelet up to 5 ingredients served with potato & toast$9.29Garden Omelette
3 egg omelet with Broccoli, spinach, tomatoes and artichokes with potato & toast$8.99Greek Omelette
3 egg omelet with tomato & Feta served with potato & toast$8.99Meatlovers Omelette
3 egg omelet with ham, sausage & bacon with potatoes & toast$8.99Mexican Omelette
3 egg omelet with tomatoes, onions, and peppers topped with chili served with potato & toast with chili and cheddar$8.99Star Omelette
3 egg omelet with ham, onions, peppers, bacon, tomatoes, and american cheese served with potatoes & toast$8.99Veggie Omelette
3 egg omelet with, peppers, mushrooms and tomatoes served with potato & toast$8.99Western Omelette
3 egg omelet with, peppers and onions, add cheese for $0.50$8.99Ham &cheese omelette
3 egg omelet with ham & American cheese with potatoes and toast$8.99Healthy omelette
3 egg omelet with turkey, tomato, onions, peppers, served with cottage & peaches$9.29Sausage &cheese
3 egg omelet with sausage & American cheese served with potato & toast$8.99Mushroom &cheese
3 egg omelet with mushroom & American cheese served with potato & toast$8.99Cheese Omelet
3 egg omelet with American cheese served with potato & toast$8.99Bacon & cheese
3 egg omelet with bacon & American cheese served with potato & toast$8.99Firehouse
3 egg omelet ham, onions, sausage, jalapeños, served with potato & toast$8.99tonys omelet
3 egg omelette ham sausage onion peppers and hash browns mixed in$8.99
Bfast Side Dishes
Home Fries
$3.29Hash Browns
$3.292 eggs & toast
$2.991 egg & toast
$2.29Side Sausage Link
$3.29Side Sausage Patties
$3.29Side Bacon
$3.29Corned Beef Hash
$4.991 Pancake
$2.99One blueberry pancake
$3.29One pecan pancake
$3.291 Sl French Toast
$2.992 Eggs
$1.991 Egg
$1.00Bagel
Add Peanut Butter or Cream Cheese for $.75.$1.99Biscuit
$1.79Bowl of Fruit
$4.49Cup of Fruit
$2.29English Muffin
$1.99Grilled Danish
$2.99Muffin
$2.59Oatmeal Bowl
$2.99Sausage Gravy
$1.00Side Blueberries
$1.00Side Cream Cheese
$0.75Side Ham
$3.29Side Hollandaise Sauce
$1.00Side of Canadian Bacon
$3.29Side Peanut Butter
$0.50Side Strawberry
$1.00Toast
$1.00Honey
$0.75Italian sausage
$4.99
Kids Breakfast
Breakfast Specials
Breakfast Garbage Plate
Homefries mixed with onions,bacon,and sausage topped with 2 eggs covered with sausage gravy & hollandaise sauce served with toast$9.99Firehouse Omelet
3 egg omelet with ham,onions,sausage & jalepenos served with potato & toast$8.99Steak Fritata
Steak, scrambled eggs onions, peppers, mushrooms mixed in home fries served with toast$10.99Tony's Omelet
3 egg omelet with ham, onions, peppers, hash browns inside topped with cheddar and toast$8.99Sausages &bacon pancakes
2 pancakes with sausage & bacon pieces inside topped with 2 eggs$8.99Porterhouse steak breakfast
$18.99
LUNCH & DINNER
Appetizers
Chicken Fingers
Served with choice of sauce If you want chicken finger dinner go to entrees$9.29Chicken Quesadillas
Grilled chicken with peppers, onions, and Cheddar cheese, served with salsa and sour cream$8.99Mozzarella Sticks
(6) sticks served with marinara sauce$6.99Pizza Logs
(5) logs served with marinara sauce$6.99Potato Skins
Potato skins topped cheddar,bacon Served with sour cream$6.99Bowl Chili
$3.99Cup Chili
$2.99Fried Calamari
Served with banana peppers and marinara sauce$9.99
Salads
Caesar Salad
Romaine tossed with Caesar dressing & croutons$6.99California Ranch Salad
Grilled chicken, Cheddar, boiled egg tomato, cucumber and onion$9.99Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled chicken strips served over Caesar salad$9.99Crispy Chicken Salad
Breaded crispy chicken, Cheddar, boiled egg, tomato, cucumber, and onions$9.99Greek Salad
Feta, black olives, pepperoncinis, our homemade greek dressing tomato,onions,cucumber on fresh greens$9.99Greek Salad w/ Chicken
Grilled chicken over Greek salad$10.99Julianne Salad
Turkey, ham, Swiss and American cheese, boiled egg, tomato, and cucumber and onion$9.99Sante Fe Salad
Spicy Cajun chicken strips, Cheddar and all the trimmings, served with Mexican Ranch dressing$9.99Taco Salad
Fresh greens topped with Cheddar, chili, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, sour cream and salsa in a taco shell$9.99
Wrap & Clubs
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Buffalo crispy chicken mozzarella, lettuce in a wrap$9.99Crispy Chicken Wrap
Breaded chicken strips, bacon, provolone, lettuce and honey mustard dressing$9.99Cajun Chicken Wrap
Grilled Cajun chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, cheddar & ranch dressing$9.99Philly Wrap
Served with peppers, onions and swiss$9.99Red Bird
Turkey, swiss, cranberry, cole slaw, thousand island dressing and bacon$9.99Veggie wrap
Broccoli, tomato, onion, mushroom, spinach, served with (tzatziki) cucumber sauce$9.99All American Club
Ham, turkey, roast beef, bacon & cheese served w/ cole slaw & chips. Made with mayo, lettuce, tomato on white toast$11.29BLT & Cheese Club
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, American cheese made on white toast served w/ cole slaw & chips$10.29Cheeseburger Bacon Club
Cheeseburger and bacon is made on white toast with mayo, lettuce, tomato served w/ cole slaw & chips$10.29Roast Beef & Swiss Club
Shaved beef, Swiss, lettuce tomato, mayo made on white toast served with coleslaw & chips$10.29Tuna & Cheese Club
Tuna, American cheese, lettuce, tomato made on white toast served with coleslaw & chips$10.29Turkey Bacon Club
Turkey, bacon, lettuce tomato, mayo made on white toast served with coleslaw & chips$10.29Ham &cheese club
Ham,American cheese,mayo, lettuce tomato on white toast served with chips & coleslaw$10.29
Quick Sandwiches
BLT Sandwich
Bacon , lettuce tomato, mayo on white toast$4.99Cheeseburger
$4.99Hamburger
$4.99Egg & Olive Sandwich
Egg salad with green olives mixed in on white bread$4.99Egg Salad Sandwich
Egg salad on white bread$4.99Fried Egg Sandwich
$2.99Grilled Cheese
Made with American cheese on white bread$3.99Hot Dog
$4.99Shaved Beef Sandwich
Shaved roast beef on white bread$4.99Shaved Ham Sandwich
$4.99Tuna Salad Sandwich
$4.99Western egg
1 egg with onions, peppers and ham$4.99Grilled ham & cheese
Shaved ham on grilled white bread with American cheese$4.99
Specialty Sandwiches
Fish Sandwich with slaw
Batter dipped fish on French bread Served with fries & coleslaw$11.99BBQ Bacon & Chicken On French Brd
BBQ chicken, cheddar & bacon on French bread$9.99Gyro
Grilled gyro, chicken or steak inside a pita bread with cucumber sauce, lettuce, tomato and onions$9.99Hot Roast Beef Sandwich
Shaved beef on white bread topped with beef gravy with 1 side$8.99Hot Turkey Sandwich
Sliced turkey on white bread topped with turkey gravy Served with 1 side$8.99Hot Meatloaf Sandwich
Meatloaf on white bread topped with brown gravy with 1 side$8.99Mozzarella Chicken
Chicken breast with grilled peppers and onions on French bread topped with mozzarella served with 1 side$9.99Philly Sandwich
Shaved steak with Grilled onions & peppers Swiss on French bread served with 1 side$9.99Rancher
Sliced roast beef, grilled onions, bacon, Swiss and ranch dressing on marble rye$9.99Reuben
Sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss and Thousand Island dressing on marble rye$9.99Steak Sandwich
8oz NY strip with grilled peppers and onions, served on French bread. Add $.75 for cheese$11.99Veggie Wrap
Made with Broccoli, Spinach, Mushroom, Grilled Onion, and Tomato served with Tzatziki$9.99Hot burger
Burger on a bun topped with gravy$8.99Hot Cheese burger
Cheeseburger topped with gravy$9.99
Melts
Charlie Melt
Breaded chicken breast, bacon and ranch dressing with cheddar cheese on sourdough with 1 side$9.99Honey Dijon chicken
Grilled chicken breast, bacon, Provolone cheese and Honey Dijon dressing on sourdough served with 1 side$9.99Patty Melt
Hamburger with grilled onions, American cheese, and Thousand Island dressing on sourdough served with 1 side$9.99Texas Melt
Sliced roast beef, Cheddar cheese, bacon and BBQ sauce on sourdough served with 1 side$9.99Tuna Melt
Tuna salad, tomato and American cheese on sourdough served with 1 side$9.99Turkey bacon ranch Melt
Sliced turkey, ranch, bacon with Swiss cheese On sourdough served with 1 side$9.99Western Melt
2 eggs with ham, onions and peppers with Swiss & American cheese on sourdough served with 1 side$9.99
Burgers, Deluxe Sand & Plates
Bacon-n-Cheddar Burger Dlx
1/3 lb. burger topped with cheddar & bacon. with mayo, lettuce and tomato served with one side$9.99Chicken Deluxe
Choice of grilled, Cajun or crispy chicken on a roll with mayo,lettuce & tomato served with one side$9.99Chsburger Deluxe
1/3 lb. cheese burger on a roll with mayo, lettuce tomato served with 1 side$9.49Hamburger Deluxe
1/3 lb. beef patty on a deluxe roll. Add $1 for cheese$8.99Montana Burger
1/3 lb. burger topped with cheddar, bacon, ranch & onion rings served with 1 side$9.99Mushroom Swiss Burger
1/3 lb. burger topped with mushrooms and Swiss cheese$9.99Towner Burger
(2) 1/3 lb. beef patties with bacon & cheese, served on a roll mayo, lettuce & tomato$10.59Single Gitsis Hot Dog Plate
Zweigle red hot over homefries & mac salad topped with gitsis sauce & onions$9.99Double Gitsis Hot Dog Plate
2 Zwiegle red hot dogs over home fries & mac salad topped with Gitsis meat sauce & onions$11.99Double Gitsis Chsburer Plate
2- !/3 lb cheeseburgers on homefries & mac salad topped with Gitsis meat sauce & onions$11.99Single Gitsis cheeseBurger Plate
1/3 lb cheeseburger on homefries & mac salad topped with Gitsis meat sauce and onions$9.991cheeseburger 1hot dog plate
$11.99
Entrees
4 Piece Fried Chicken
$13.99Baked Ham
Virginia ham cut to order with pineapple and 2 sides$12.99Center Cut Pork Chops
(2) 6 oz. cut to order seasoned and grilled$12.99Chicken Fingers Platter
Tenders breaded to order Served with dipping sauce$13.99Ground Sirloin Steak
10oz ground steak with mushroom gravy served with 2 sides$12.99Lemon Pepper Chicken
8oz breast seasoned with lemon pepper and grilled served with 2 sides$12.99Meatloaf
Our own recipe, topped with beef gravy$12.99Roast Beef W Gravy
Sliced roast beef cooked on premises with gravy served with 2 sides$12.99
Italian Dishes
Baked Ziti
Served with meatballs or Italian Sausage$11.99Spaghetti
Served with meatballs or Italian Sausage$11.99Chicken Parmesan
Served with spaghetti, garlic bread and salad$12.99Chicken, Broc & Spin Alfredo
Sautéed chicken, broccoli & spinach tossed with Alfredo and salad and garlic bread$12.99Seafood Alfredo
Shrimp, scallops tossed with Alfredo and ziti with salad and garlic bread$13.99Veggie Alfredo
Spinach, broccoli, mushrooms and onion tossed with Alfredo and ziti served with salad and garlic bread$12.99
Seafood
Fish Fry
12 oz. Haddock, batter dipped, breaded or crunchy we recommend crunchy to stay crispy on takeout$14.99Broiled Haddock
12 oz. Fillet seasoned with lemon pepper or Cajun seasonings or garlic Parmesan$14.99Mini Fish Fry
8oz haddock batter, breaded or crunchy$12.99Broiled Mini Haddack
8oz fillet seasoned lemon pepper, Cajun or garlic Parmesan served with 2 sides$12.99Athenian Haddock
12 oz broiled haddock topped with spinach tomato and feta served with 2 sides$14.99Batter Dipped Shrimp
Beer battered to order served with 2 sides$13.99Broiled Scallops
Cooked to order with lemon pepper, Cajun or garlic Parmesan served with 2 sides$14.99Fried Scallops
Fresh scallops batter dipped to order served with 2 sides$14.99Seafood Platter
Batter dipped Haddock, shrimp, scallops and clam strips with lemon tartar & cocktail sauce served with 2 sides$17.99Shrimp Basket
Breaded mini shrimp served with 2 sides$11.99Fish sandwich with slaw
Battered dipped haddock on French bread Served with coleslaw and fries$11.993way fish
$14.99
Extras/soup/sides
Soup of the day call 3155390108
$1.99French Fries
$3.29Fries W Gravy
$3.99Home Fries
$3.29Hash Browns
$3.29Mash Plain
$3.29Mash WGravy
$3.29Mashed W Butr
$3.29Coleslaw
$3.29Cottage Cheese
$3.29Curly Fries
$4.29Onion Rings
$4.29Soup &salad bar
$8.99Bowl Chili
Add $.75 for cheddar & onions$3.99Cup Chili
Add $.75 for cheddar & onions$2.99Bowl Soup
$2.99Cup Soup
$1.99Applesauce
$3.29Broccoli
$3.29Baked Potato
$3.29Sweet Potato Fries
$4.29Fruit
$2.99Cheese Sauce
$1.00Saus Gravy
$1.00Hollandaise Sauce
$1.00Gitsis meatsauce
$1.00Beef Gravy
$0.70Turk Gravy
$0.70Peas
$3.29Corn
$3.29Green beans
$3.29Tossed Salad
$3.99Stuffing
$2.99Meatballs w/ sauce
$4.99Loaded baked potato
Baked potato with cheddar & bacon Served with sour cream$4.99Mac salad
$3.29Honey
$0.75salad dressings
$0.75Skinny fries
$3.29Side of Italian sausage
$4.99
Kids PM Menu
GREEK DINNER pick up only @ St Michaels church, Geneva June 13 4-6pm
Moussaka(Greek lasagna),grilled chicken tenders,lemon potatoes,rice, Greek salad, rice pudding
DO NOT ORDER ANYTHING ELSE
THIS IS ONLY FOR THE GREEK DINNER FUND RAISER
NA beverages
Greek dinner
$20.00
Moussaka(Greek lasagna),grilled chicken tenders,lemon potatoes,rice, Greek salad, rice pudding Pick up only JUNE 13 4-6pm at StMichaels church 98 Gennesee st, Geneva Call Betty 585 738 9565 any questions
Request advisory
No substitutes. Additions may be charged extra. Please let us know if you need utensils. Go to menu and choose what you need.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 8:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Monday | 8:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 8:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 8:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Thursday | 8:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 8:00 am - 8:00 pm |
| Saturday | 8:00 am - 8:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
1111 Waterloo Geneva Road, Waterloo, NY 13165
© 2026 Toast, Inc.





