
American
SugarBakers Cakes
23 Mellor Avenue
Catonsville, MD 21228
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items

Amaretto Raspberry Cake
SugarBakers "signature" flavor. Almond cake filled with a layer of amaretto buttercream and European Raspberry preserves, covered in french buttercream.$48.00+
Smith Island Cake
Voted Baltimore's Best! Nine layers of moist yellow cake filled with fudge icing and optional peanut butter cups.$65.00+
Box of 12 Cupcakes
Choose two of our cupcake flavors.$44.00
Specialty Cakes

Let's Go O's!
A perfect cake for any Orioles fan!$70.00+
Purple Pride
The perfect cake for a Ravens fan! This cake is iced in American Buttercream and a great addition to your tailgate.$70.00+
Vintage Vibes
$79.00+
Neopolitan Cake
Layers of devil's food, strawberry and yellow cake filled with German buttercream. Iced with chocolate, pink and white buttercream.$65.00+
Pretty in Pink
Cake is extra tall, iced in light pink German Buttercream finished with a white drip, white chocolate shavings and a pink sugar sprinkle.$91.00+
Triple Chocolate Cake
Extra tall chocolate cake, filled with chocolate mousse, iced in chocolate buttercream draped with dark chocolate ganache and a chocolate candy garnish like the photo.$91.00+
Peachy Keen
Cake is iced in light peach German Buttercream, garnished with peach and ivory rosettes. Pick from five of our top cake flavors. If getting an inscription on the 6 inch, it will be put on the board.$70.00+
Confetti Birthday Cake
Pick one of our 5 preset cake flavors. The cake will be iced in German Buttercream and decorated with confetti sprinkles like the picture.$66.00+
Pink and Pearl's Cake
A 5 layer, 6 inch cake iced in American Buttercream. Decorated with pink icing and pearls.$70.00+
Smith Island Cakes

Smith Island Cake
Voted Baltimore's Best! Nine layers of moist yellow cake filled with fudge icing and optional peanut butter cups.$65.00+
Lemon Coconut Smith Island Cake
9 layers of lemon cake filled with toasted coconut buttercream. Iced in American buttercream and covered in coconut flakes.$65.00+
Oreo Smith Island
Nine thin layers of our chocolate cake, filled with American buttercream and crushed Oreo cookies. Iced in American Buttercream.$65.00+
Red Velvet Smith Island
Nine layers of red velvet cake filled with fudge. Iced in cream cheese icing.$65.00+
Strawberry Smith Island Cake
Nine layers of light pink strawberry cake filled and iced with a light cream cheese icing.$65.00+
Snickerdoodle Smith Island Cake
Nine layers of yellow cake, filled with a cinnamon cream cheese icing. Iced in cream cheese, and adorned with cinnamon crystal sugar.$65.00+
Fine Line Cakes

Amaretto Raspberry Cake
SugarBakers "signature" flavor. Almond cake filled with a layer of amaretto buttercream and European Raspberry preserves, covered in french buttercream.$48.00+
Classic Ivory Cake
Yellow cake filled and iced with French buttercream.$48.00+
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Devils food cake layered with chocolate mousse, iced in American buttercream.$48.00+
Pimlico Cake
A Baltimore Tradition. Most yellow cake layered with fresh pastry cream, covered in fudge icing.$48.00+
Country Carrot Cake
A dense moist combination of carrots, walnuts, pineapples, and spice, with our cream cheese icing, finished with toasted coconut and walnuts.$48.00+
Red Velvet Fudge Cake
Light chocolate sour cream cake colored a soft red and filled with fudge and cream cheese icing.$48.00+
Lemon Mousse Cake
Light layers of lemon cake layered with lemon mousse. Iced with French buttercream and fresh lemon curd.$48.00+
Yellow Cake w/ Fudge Icing
A classic! Yellow cake covered with fudge icing.$48.00+
Chocolate Decadence
Devils food cake layered with bittersweat ganache and chocolate chips simply finished with ganache and mini chocolate chips.$58.00+
Cannoli Cake
Layers of yellow and chocolate cake filled with cannoli cream covered in French buttercream.$59.00+
You've Got Chocolate in my Peanut Butter
Yellow and Chocolate cake layered with fudge and peanut butter buttercream. Iced in fudge, decorated with a peanut butter drizzle.$58.00+
Raspberry Ribbon Cake
Multiple layers of delicate yellow and devils food chocolate cake heightened by alternate fillings of raspberry buttercream and dark ganache, with a poured chocolate finish.$63.00+
Chocolate Truffle Torte (Gluten Free) - 10 inch
Flourless semi sweet chocolate cake with a ganache glaze. This torte is made in a facility that is not gluten free. Cross contamination is possible.$72.00
Coconut Cake
Yellow cake layered with American buttercream and sweetened coconut.$48.00+
20 Pack Gold Candles
$5.00
20 Pack Silver Candles
$5.00
12 Pack Multicolored Candles
$5.00
Cupcakes
Cheesecake

Vanilla Cheesecake
Grahamcracker crust topped with our creamy West Coast style Cheesecake.$55.00+
Chocolate Top Cheesecake - 10 inch
Shortbread crust with creamy cheesecake and chocolate top cookies. Topped with fudge icing.$65.00
Apple Pie Cheesecake -10 inch
Apple swirled through cheesecake batter baking in a shortbread crust. Topped with caramel and crunchy streusel.$64.00
Black Bottom Cheesecake - 9 inch
A layer of chocolate fudge cake covered with chocolate chip cheesecake.$56.00
Cherry Cheesecake
Vanilla cheesecake topped with cherries.$55.00+
Turtle Pecan Cheesecake
Vanilla cheesecake, iced in fudge, topped with caramel and pecans.$55.00+
Strawberry Cheesecake
Vanilla cheesecake topped with fresh strawberries.$60.00+
Fresh Fruit Cheesecake
Vanilla cheesecake topped with seasonal fruit.$60.00+Birthday Batter Cheesecake - 10 inch
A creamy vanilla cheesecake with rainbow sprinkles baked throughout. Topped with American buttercream and sprinkles.$64.00
Pies

Fresh Strawberry Pie - 9 inch
Pastry cream covered by glazed fresh strawberries.$42.00
Peanut Butter Pie - 9 inch
Chocolate cookie crust filled with a light and creamy peanut butter mousse. Drizzled with ganache and topped with white chocolate curls.$32.00
Key Lime Pie - 10 inch
A graham cracker crust with smooth creamy slightly tart key lime filling.$32.00
Caramel Apple Pie - 10 inch
Homestyle Apple pie drizzled with caramel.$32.00Peach Pie - 9 inch
9-inch Peach Pie with a cinnamon sugar sprinkle baked into the crust.$35.00
Home Style Apple Pie -10 inch
Traditional double crust apple pie dusted with cinnamon sugar.$32.00
Very Berry Pie - 9 inch
Traditional pie shell filled with strawberries, blueberries blackberries and red raspberries with a lattice top.$35.00
Black Cherry Lattice Pie - 9 inch
Sweet and juicy black cherries with a hint of sweetness.$32.00
Southern Pecan Pie - 9 inch
Rich caramel and pecan filling baked in a flaky crust. Drizzled with chocolate ganache and finished with fudge rosettes.$35.00
Coffee Cake, Cookies, Slices and Bars

Pecan Coffee Cake - Square
$6.50+
Cinnamon Pecan Coffee Cake
$47.00+
A Dozen Chocolate Top Cookies
A Baltimore Classic! A sugar cookie topped with a swirl of chocolate fudge icing.$28.00
A Dozen Homestyle Cookies
Minimum doz$25.00
Amaretto Raspberry Cake Slice
$7.00
Smith Island Cake Slice
$9.00
Fudge Brownie Bars
6 of our delicious fudge brownies cut in 3 inch by 3 inch squares.$27.00
Luscious Lemon Bars
6 of our delicious lemon bars cut in 3 inch by 3 inch squares.$27.00
Blondies
6 of our delicious blondies cut in 3 inch by 3 inch squares.$27.00
Pecan Bars
6 of our delicious pecan bars cut in 3 inch by 3 inch squares.$27.00
Peach Pie - 9 inch
$35.00
9-inch Peach Pie with a cinnamon sugar sprinkle baked into the crust.
Request advisory
Add inscription information here (for Cakes ONLY). Inscriptions may be a MAXIMUM of 6 words.
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 10:00 am - 2:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 10:00 am - 2:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 10:00 am - 2:30 pm |
| Thursday | 10:00 am - 2:30 pm |
| Friday | 10:00 am - 2:30 pm |
| Saturday | 10:00 am - 2:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.






