
American
Sully's in the Valley
5642 Beaver Pike (Main St)
Next door to Post Office
Beaver, OH 45613
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items

16" Cheese Pizza
$14.60
Philly Cheese Steak-Provolone, Grilled Onion, Grilled Green Peppers, Mayo
Grilled onions, grilled green pepper, provolone cheese, mayo. Add other toppings if you like$8.85
Wings 7 Tossed in Sauce (BONELESS)
Boneless wings tossed in your choice of sauce. Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch, or Blue Cheese$7.40
FOOD
Pizza

8" Cheese Pizza
$7.50
12" Cheese Pizza
$11.50
16" Cheese Pizza
$14.60
8" BBQ Chicken Pizza (BBQ base, Chicken, OPTIONAL Ranch Drizzle
BBQ base as sauce, cheese, chicken, OPTIONAL ranch drizzle$9.00
12" BBQ Chicken Pizza (BBQ base, Chicken, OPTIONAL Ranch Drizzle
Barbecue sauce base, chicken, optional ranch dressing drizzle on top$15.45
16" BBQ Chicken Pizza (BBQ base, Chicken, OPTIONAL Ranch Drizzle
Barbecue sauce base as the sauce, chicken, optional ranch drizzle on top$21.00
8" Garlic Cheese Bread Strips
Add pizza sauce, ranch, or garlic butter for dipping.$7.00
12" Garlic Cheese Bread Strips
Add a size of pizza sauce, garlic butter sauce or ranch for dipping$12.00
16" Garlic Cheese Bread Strips
Add a side of pizza sauce, garlic butter, or ranch for dipping. YES! WE HAVE SKI AND GLASS OR PLASTIC BOTTLES.$16.00
8" Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chicken, Bacon, and Ranch dressing. YES! you can add additional toppings$9.40
12" Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chicken, Bacon, and Ranch dressing, YES! you can add additional toppings$15.75
16" Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chicken, Bacon and Ranch dressing. YES! you can add additional toppings$21.10
8" BLT (Bacon Lettuce Tomato Cheese)
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato. Choose Ranch, Mayo, or Pizza sauce base$9.80
12" BLT (Bacon Lettuce Tomato Cheese)
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato. Choose Ranch, Mayo, or Pizza sauce base$16.00
16" BLT (Bacon Lettuce Tomato Cheese)
$20.45
8" Meat Lovers (Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Sausage)
Pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon. House made sauce, outer crust is brushed with our homemade garlic butter sauce. Add any other toppings to it that you would like$10.55
12" Meat Lovers (Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Sausage)
Pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon. House made sauce, outer crust is brushed with our homemade garlic butter sauce. Add any other toppings to it that you would like$17.50
16" Meat Lovers (Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Sausage)
Pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon. House made sauce, outer crust is brushed with our homemade garlic butter sauce. Add any other toppings to it that you would like$23.00
10" Cauliflower Pizza
$11.00
Crustless Pizza 7" round pan
Delicious pizza toppings served in a garlic buttered deep dish round pan, baked with cheese topping and our homemade sauce$8.00
8" White Alfedo Pizza (Alfredo Pasta Sauce)
Our fire brick oven crust, covered in ALFREDO sauce, and our garlic butter brushed crust.$8.00
12" White Alfredo Pizza (Alfredo Pasta Sauce)
Our fire brick oven crust, covered in ALFREDO sauce, and our garlic butter brushed crust.$14.00
16" White Alfredo Pizza (Alfredo Pasta Sauce)
Our fire brick oven crust, covered in ALFREDO sauce, and our garlic butter brushed crust.$18.00
Subs
Pizza Sub-sauce, cheese, pepperoni
$7.95
8" Italian Sub/Ham, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Banana Peppers, Italian dressing
Ham, Salomi, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Banana Peppers, Italian Dressing$8.60
Ham & Cheese Sub-Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo
$7.25
Philly Cheese Steak-Provolone, Grilled Onion, Grilled Green Peppers, Mayo
Grilled onions, grilled green pepper, provolone cheese, mayo. Add other toppings if you like$8.85
BLT Sub Bacon-Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese, Mayo
10 slices of bacon, lettuce, provolone or other cheese or your choice, mayo or other dressing of your choice.$7.80
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub-2 ChickenBreasts,Lettuce, Bacon,tomato,onion, cheese,Ranch
Two full chicken breasts, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, ranch dressing or any other dressing of your choice, provolone cheese or any other cheese of your choice.$8.85
Sandwiches
Hamburger
$5.75
Cheeseburger
$6.25
Double Cheeseburger
2 quarter pound patties, add American, Swiss or Pepperjack cheese and any toppings you like$9.30Bacon Cheeseburger
$7.00Double Bacon Cheeseburger
$10.90
BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger
$7.35Double BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger
$11.00Sully Burger 1/4 lb. (American Cheese, Slaw, Tomato, Onion, Pickle)
$6.80
Mushroom Swiss Burger (grilled onion, grilled mushroom)
$7.10
Double Mushroom Swiss Burger (grilled onion, grilled mushroom)
$10.00
Steakburger 1/2 lb. (8oz) Served on Hoagie Bun
1/2 pound steak burger, the same steak burger we sold when we had concessions for 27 years. add cheese, and any toppings. This sandwich DOES take a little longer to cook.$9.00
Tenderloin
The monster size tenderloin. The same tenderloin that we sold when we did concessions for 27 years. Add any toppings that you want$8.00
Reuben/Corned Beef, Swiss, Sauerkraut, 1000 Island
Best Reuben you'll ever have! Toasted rye bread, corned beef, sauerkraut, and cheese.$10.00
Foot Long Hot Dog
This is a TRUE 12in. Footlong hot dog. Great quality meat. Add just about anything you want... Sauce,cheese, relish, ketchup, mustard, jalapeno,$4.70
Hot Dog
$2.65
Corn Dog
Just like at the "fairs"$2.10
MONSTER Dog 1/2 lb. all beef
1/2 pound all beef, add toppings like sauce, slaw, cheese, relish, onion, Mustard, ketchup and more. Choose bun or NO bun$8.30
Spicy Breaded Chicken Breast
Spicy Chicken Breast Sandwich. Choose your favorite toppings, Bun or No Bun also$5.90
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
A delicious grilled chicken breast add your choice of toppings$6.30Chicken Strip Sandwich
Two nice size chicken strips, add any toppings you like$5.90
Sides

Banana Pepper Rings (Deep Fried)
Deep friend banana pepper rings. Choose a sauce to dip them in.....Ranch, Chipotle Mayo, Honey Mustard, Sour Cream, Ketchup$5.00
LARGE French Fries
$5.00
Small French Fries
$3.15
Wings 6 Tossed in Sauce (Bone In)
mixed wings and drumsticks. Choice of flavors. Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch, or Blue Cheese$7.40
Wings 7 Tossed in Sauce (BONELESS)
Boneless wings tossed in your choice of sauce. Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch, or Blue Cheese$7.40
Cheese Curds
Deep fried cheese. Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch, or Chipotle Mayo (Southwest) sauce$5.00
Chicken Strips
3 nice size strips deep fried. Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch, or Chipotle Mayo (Southwest) sauce, BBQ, Honey Mustard$7.00
Chili Cheese Fries
Large order of fries topped with chili and cheese. Loaded with cheese and bacon. Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch, or Chipotle Mayo (Southwest) sauce$7.75
Cole Slaw
Sweet like your grammaw made$2.00
Hot Pepper Cheese Bites
Deep friend hot pepper cheese. Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch, or Chipotle Mayo (Southwest) sauce$5.00
House Made Chips served warm
Crispy and warm$3.60
Loaded Fries 1/2 lb. (Cheese Bacon)
Large order of fries Loaded with cheese and bacon. Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch, or Chipotle Mayo (Southwest) sauce$7.75
Loaded Tater Tots (Cheese Bacon)
Large order of Tater tots loaded with cheese and bacon. You can add chili, extra cheese extra bacon. Loaded with cheese and bacon. Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch, or Chipotle Mayo (Southwest) sauce$7.75
Mushrooms
Deep fried. Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch, or Chipotle Mayo (Southwest) sauce$5.00
Onion Petals
One of our best selling sides. You can order dipping sauce such as Chipotle mayo, Ranch, marinara and others. Best sauce for this is Chipotle mayo$5.00
Pickle Chips
Deep fried, lightly breaded pickle fries. Choose a dressing such as ranch, Chipotle mayo, honey mustard, sour cream to dip them in.$5.00
Potato Skins (Cheese Bacon)
Potato skins with melted cheese and bacon, Add a side of Sour Cream, Ranch$7.75
Tater tots
$3.50
Small Bag Chips
Herr's brand. Choose flavor upon pick up$2.70
Large Bag Chips
Herr's brand. Choose flavor upon pick up$5.00
Salads
Ham, Pepperoni, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese, Banana Peppers, Green Pepper, Onion, Mushroom. 2 dressings included

Large Works Salad/Ham, Pepperoni, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese, Green Peppers, Onion, Mushroom, Banana Pepper
$8.00
Small Works Salad/Ham, Pepperoni, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese, Green Peppers, Onion, Mushroom, Banana Pepper
Ham, Pepperoni, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese, Banana Peppers, Green Pepper, Onion, Mushroom. 1 dressing included$4.60
BEVERAGES
Beverages

Fountain
Pepsi products with "the good ice", your choice when you pick up$2.85
Bottled Pop
Pepsi products and Gatorade. Your choice when you pick up.$2.85WATER (Fountain)
$0.25
Tea Sweet
Fresh House Brewed$2.85
Tea Unsweet
Fresh House Brewed$2.85
Bottle Water
$0.99Propel Flavored Water
$2.85Gatorade
$2.85Cup of Ice
$0.25
Specialty Beverages

Strawberry Lemonade FRESH SQUEEZED
Fresh squeezed, cold and refreshing$5.25
Lemon Shake Up*
Made with Fresh Squeezed Lemons just like at the fair!$5.00
Root Beer Float*
Served in a Frosted Mug with scoops of Perry's vanilla ice cream (dine in served in glass mug, take out available in "take out" cup.)$5.50
Frosted Mug Root Beer (DINE IN ONLY)
"MUG" Root Beer served in an ice cold frosty mug (dine in only)$2.75
ICE CREAM/SHAKES
Small Shake (12 oz.)
$6.00Large Shake (20 oz.)
$8.00
Small Cup
$3.50
Large Cup
$4.50
Small Waffle Cone
$4.50
Large Waffle Cone
$5.50Small Cake Cone
$3.50Large Cake Cone
$4.50Small Sundae
INCLUDES 1 scoop, 1 toppings, whip cream and a cherry. Choose your flavor of Perry's hand dipped ice cream.$4.25
Large Sundae
INCLUDES 2 scoops of Perry's hand dipped ice cream, flavors of your choice and 1 topping, whip cream and a cherry. Additional toppings available for .79 each$5.25
Banana Split
INCLUDES 3 ice cream flavors and 3 toppings of your choice, whip cream and a cherry. Additional toppings CAN be added at .79 each. Perry's famous New York hand dipped ice cream$8.95
DESSERTS
Funnel Cake Fries
Served warm with or without powdered sugar and your choice of a dipping sauce.
Hot Fudge Brownie Deluxe
Warm brownie covered in hot fudge, served with one scoop of Perry's hand dipped ice cream, real whipped cream, more chocolate syrup, and a cherry. Add Michael's roasted nuts
If you use a credit card, Sully's in the Valley will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what Sully's in the Valley pays in fees.
Italian
$0.60
1
All hours
| Sunday | 10:45 am - 8:30 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 10:45 am - 8:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 10:45 am - 8:30 pm |
| Thursday | 10:45 am - 8:30 pm |
| Friday | 10:45 am - 9:30 pm |
| Saturday | 10:45 am - 9:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Brick oven pizza, house made sauce, specialty subs, sandwiches and sides, specialty pastries, "Perry's" hand dipped ice cream, shakes of almost any flavor. '50s '60s diner atmosphere with an unbelievable amount of history of the Beaver Valley and local residents.
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.









