American
sweet indulgence 845 s 55th st
Featured Items
No Nana deluxe pudding
No-Nana Deluxe Our classic creamy vanilla pudding without bananas, layered with extra Nilla wafer cookie crumbs and topped with whipped cream, caramel drizzle, whole Nilla wafers, and a chessman cookie.$12.00
Mini Sweet Potato Pie
**Mini Sweet Potato Pie (6-Inch)** Our homemade sweet potato pie baked in a buttery 6-inch crust, filled with a smooth, spiced sweet potato filling that’s rich, creamy, and full of flavor. Perfectly sized to share… or keep all to yourself—we won’t judge.$8.00Sweet Potato Cheesecake
$11.00
Puddings
Our homemade puddings are layered, creamy, and made fresh daily with rich flavors and delicious toppings. From our famous classic banana pudding to specialty flavors like Oreo, Biscoff, Strawberry Crunch, and more—there’s a pudding for every craving.
Classic Banana Pudding
Classic Banana Pudding Light, creamy vanilla banana pudding layered with fresh bananas and Nilla wafer crumbs, then topped with whole Nilla wafers for that classic homemade finish.$10.00
classic banana deluxe pudding
Deluxe Banana Pudding Our classic light and creamy banana pudding layered with fresh bananas and Nilla wafer crumbs, then topped with whipped cream, caramel drizzle, whole Nilla wafers, and a chessman cookie.$12.00No Nana deluxe pudding
No-Nana Deluxe Our classic creamy vanilla pudding without bananas, layered with extra Nilla wafer cookie crumbs and topped with whipped cream, caramel drizzle, whole Nilla wafers, and a chessman cookie.$12.00no nana Pudding
Our classic light and creamy vanilla pudding made without bananas, layered with extra Nilla wafer cookie and crumbs for the perfect cookie-to-pudding bite.$10.00
strawberry crunch pudding
Creamy vanilla pudding layered with strawberry crunch, fresh strawberries, and strawberry sauce, then topped with strawberry cake chunks and more strawberry crunch.$10.00biscoff cheesecake pudding
$10.00
oreo pudding
Layers of creamy homemade pudding, Oreo crumbles, rich chocolate cake chunks, and a drizzle of chocolate sauce for the ultimate cookies & cream dream.$10.00
Waffle Bowl banana pudding
Your favorite pudding flavor served in a delicious edible waffle bowl! Choose from Classic Banana, Oreo, Biscoff, or Strawberry Crunch pudding, topped with whipped cream and extra cookie crumble for the perfect sweet treat.$14.00
Cinnamon Rolls
Freshly baked, soft and gooey cinnamon rolls layered with cinnamon sugar and finished with our signature glaze. Available in a variety of flavors.
Classic Cinnamon Roll
Soft, warm cinnamon rolls made from scratch and topped with our rich homemade cream cheese icing.$7.00OUT OF STOCK
Sticky Bun Cinnamon Roll
Soft, scratch-made cinnamon rolls swirled with cinnamon and brown sugar, topped with a sweet brown sugar glaze, walnuts, and raisins.$7.00
Sweet Potato Cinnamon Roll
Our soft, scratch-made cinnamon roll topped with a rich sweet potato pie filling, a thin layer of homemade cream cheese icing, and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar.$8.00
Biscoff Cinnamon Roll
Our soft, scratch-made cinnamon roll filled with brown sugar and butter, topped with creamy Biscoff cream cheese icing, Biscoff cookie crumbles, a sweet cookie butter drizzle, and a whole Biscoff cookie.$8.00OUT OF STOCK
Peach Cobbler Cinnamon Roll
Our soft, scratch-made cinnamon roll topped with fresh sliced peaches, sweet peach syrup, buttery streusel crumble, and a drizzle of caramel$8.00OUT OF STOCK
Banana Pudding Cinnamon Roll
Our soft, homemade cinnamon rolls topped with caramelized bananas, creamy banana pudding, buttery Chessman cookie crumbles, vanilla wafer crunch, and finished with a sweet caramel drizzle. A banana pudding lover’s dream in cinnamon roll form. 🍌✨$10.00OUT OF STOCK
Savory Roll- Pizza Roll
Our scratch-made dough rolled with rich pizza sauce, melted cheese, garlic, and savory herbs, then baked until golden and delicious. Like your favorite pizza and a fresh bakery roll had the perfect little baby. 🍕✨$7.00OUT OF STOCK
Mini Cheesecakes
NY Style - Strawberry Cheesecake
creamy, rich cheesecake swirled with our house-made baked strawberry purée, topped with sweet strawberry sauce, fluffy whipped cream, and fresh strawberries. A strawberry lover’s dream in every bite!$10.00Banana Pudding Cheesecake
$11.00Biscoff Cheesecake
$11.00Sweet Potato Cheesecake
$11.00Oreo Cheesecake
$11.00
Cake Slices
Cake flavors rotate and change monthly.
Birthday Cake
$7.00OUT OF STOCKStrawberry Crunch Cake
$7.00Chocolate Cake
$7.00Biscoff Pound Cake
$8.00OUT OF STOCK
Lemon Blueberry Cake
A soft vanilla blueberry cake layered with sweet blueberry filling and finished with a smooth, tangy lemon buttercream. Light, fruity, and perfectly balanced with just the right hint of citrus in every bite.$7.00Strawberry Short Cake
$7.00
rainbow dot cake (viral cake cup)
layers of vanilla cake with, vanilla cream mouse. Topped with buttercream and rainbow sprinkles$8.00
Desserts, cobblers, pies
bread pudding
$5.00OUT OF STOCKMini Sweet Potato Pie
**Mini Sweet Potato Pie (6-Inch)** Our homemade sweet potato pie baked in a buttery 6-inch crust, filled with a smooth, spiced sweet potato filling that’s rich, creamy, and full of flavor. Perfectly sized to share… or keep all to yourself—we won’t judge.$8.00Peach Cobbler small 8oz
$7.00Peach Cobbler large 12oz
$10.00OUT OF STOCK
Biscoff Cinnamon Roll
$8.00
Our soft, scratch-made cinnamon roll filled with brown sugar and butter, topped with creamy Biscoff cream cheese icing, Biscoff cookie crumbles, a sweet cookie butter drizzle, and a whole Biscoff cookie.
Customize your item
Optional
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 7:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Sweet Indulgence Custom Cakes & Catering is a dessert bakery specializing in handcrafted cakes, banana pudding, gourmet cupcakes, cinnamon rolls, and a variety of classic and specialty treats. We focus on high-quality ingredients, fresh daily production, and creating visually stunning, great-tasting desserts for both everyday customers and special occasions.
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
