The Bagel Mill
212 Western Ave
Petaluma, CA 94952
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
- Select your bagel
build your own bagel sandwich here. All bagels are sliced and toasted (unless noted otherwise). For a bagel and cream cheese, please select a spread. For bagels not sliced or toasted, please go to the 'Bagels To Go' section.
$2.50 - Bodega Egg & Cheese
organic egg, yellow cheddar
$6.50 - California Egg & Cheese
organic egg, yellow cheddar, thick cut bacon, smashed avocado, tomato
$11.50
Food Menu
Breakfast Sandwiches
- Avocado Toast
smashed avocado, lemon vinaigrette, pickled red onion, scallions, sprouts, everything mix (served open-faced)
$10.50 - Bodega Egg & Cheese
organic egg, yellow cheddar
$6.50 - California Egg & Cheese
organic egg, yellow cheddar, thick cut bacon, smashed avocado, tomato
$11.50 - Classic Lox Closed
cream cheese, 1 oz salmon lox, red onion, capers, fresh dill
$11.00 - Classic Lox Open
cream cheese, 2 oz salmon lox, red onion, capers, fresh dill (served open-faced)
$15.50 - Cream Cheese & Greens
scallion cream cheese, radish, cucumber, pickled red onions, sprouts
$9.50 - Frittata Sandwich
seasonal veggie frittata, smashed avocado, melted yellow cheddar
$11.50
Lunch Sandwiches
- BLAT
thick cut bacon, butter lettuce, smashed avocado, tomato, mayo
$12.00 - Egg Salad Sandwich
organic egg salad, butter lettuce, chopped scallions
$10.00 - Ham, Swiss & Honey Butter Sandwich
black forest ham, melted swiss, salted honey butter, arugula
$13.00 - Pastrami Reuben
pastrami, melted swiss, sauerkraut, russian dressing
$15.00 - Pork Banh Mi
marinated pork, pickled veggies, jalapeno, cilantro, Sriracha mayo
$15.00 - Spicy Turkey Club
smoked turkey, thick cut bacon, monterey jack, smashed avocado, tomato, lettuce, sriracha mayo
$15.00 - The Jorge Special
smoked turkey, sauteed red bell pepper, red onion & jalapenos, melted swiss cheese, sriracha mayo
$13.00 - Tuna Salad Sandwich
albacore tuna mixed with mildly spicy Sriracha mayo, celery & onions. Served with butter lettuce and tomato
$10.50 - Vegan Dream
house made cashew cheese, roasted bell pepper, pickled red onion, cucumber, radish, smashed avocado, sprouts
$12.00
Sides & More
- Fresh Fruit Salad
an assortment of fresh fruit
$7.00 - Lay's Potato Chips$2.00
- Overnight Oats
organic oats soaked overnight, honey, cinnamon
$4.00 - Side of Frittata
seasonal veggie frittata served warm with arugula
$6.00 - Simple Green Salad (Large)
butter lettuce, arugula, watermelon radish, cucumber, pickled red onions, & lemon vinaigrette
$9.00 - Simple Green Salad (Side)
butter lettuce, arugula, watermelon radish, cucumber, pickled red onions, & lemon vinaigrette
$5.00 - Straus Yogurt & Granola
organic Straus whole milk yogurt & housemade granola
$7.00 - Whole Dill Pickle
1 large kosher dill pickle
$3.00
Bagels To Go
- 1 Dozen Bagels
Please allow 48 hours notice for orders over 2 dozen.
$26.00 - 1/2 Dozen Bagels
Please allow 48 hours notice for orders over 2 dozen.
$14.00 - Cinnamon Raisin Bagel$2.50
- Everything Bagel$2.50
- Garlic Bagel$2.50
- Marble Rye Bagel$2.50
- Onion Bagel$2.50
- Pesto Bagel
contains nuts (walnuts)
$3.50 - Pizza Bagel$3.50
- Plain Bagel$2.50
- Poppy Seed Bagel$2.50
- Sesame Bagel$2.50
- Whole Wheat Bagel$2.50
- Whole Wheat Everything Bagel$2.50
- Gluten Free Bagel
from Mamamel's Bread in Petaluma
$3.50 - Black Pepper Parmesan Bagel (Mon only!)
a weekly special that is only available Mondays
$3.50 - Asiago Everything Bagel (Tues only!)
a weekly special that is only available Tuesdays
$3.50 - Asiago Bagel (Weds only!)
a weekly special that is only available Wednesdays
$3.50 - Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel (Thurs only!)
a weekly special bagel that is only available on Thursdays
$3.50 - Bialy (Fri only!)
a weekly special bialy with caramelized onions and poppy seeds that is only available on Fridays
$3.50 - Bagel Dog (Saturday only!)
all beef hot dog wrapped in sourdough bagel dough
$8.00OUT OF STOCK - Black Pepper Parmesan Bagel Dog (Saturday only!)
this week's special: black pepper parmesan!
$8.50OUT OF STOCK - Marble Rye Everything Bagel (Sat only!)
a weekly special bagel that is only available on Saturdays
$2.50 - Salt Bagel (Sun only!)
a weekly special that is only available Sundays
$2.50
Spreads To Go
- Egg Salad (1/2 pint)
8 oz of our house made organic egg salad
$10.00 - Flavored Cream Cheese (1/2 pint)
8 oz of our house made flavored cream cheeses & spreads, serves 4-6 people
$7.50 - Plain Cream Cheese (1/2 pint)
8 oz of cream cheese, serves 4-6 people
$6.00 - Salmon Lox (4 oz)
4 oz of our premium smoked salmon lox from Santa Barbara Smokehouse
$18.00 - Single Serving (2 oz)$1.50
- Tuna Salad (1/2 pint)
8 oz of our albacore tuna salad with Sriracha mayo, red onion & celery
$11.00 - Vegan Spreads (1/2 pint)$9.50
Sweets
- Basque Cheesecake$4.50OUT OF STOCK
- Candied Ginger Cake with Lemon Icing$4.50OUT OF STOCK
- Chocolate Apricot Rugelach$8.00
- Walnut Cinnamon Rugelach$8.00
- Cinnamon Roll with Cream Cheese Frosting (weekends only!)$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Pecan Sticky Bun (weekends only!)$6.00OUT OF STOCK
- Coconut Macaroons (Pack of 3)$9.00OUT OF STOCK
- Einkorn Chocolate Chip Cookie
organic cookie with house-milled Einkorn flour, an ancient wheat, and Guittard chocolate chips
$4.00 - Everything Cookie$4.00
- Sourdough Brownie$5.50
- Vegan Ginger Molasses Cookie$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Vegan Lemon Poppy Seed Cookie$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Vegan Tahini Chocolate Chunk Cookie$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Vegan Chocolate Coconut Cookie$5.00
- Brown Butter Shortbread "Bagel" Cookies
brown butter shortbread cookie sandwich with a white chocolate ganache with sesame seeds sprinkled on top
$8.00OUT OF STOCK
Drinks Menu
Coffee
Specials
- Black Rose Latte
house-made organic syrup infused with dark cocoa powder and fresh organic roses
$5.00 - Black Rose Lemonade
house-made organic syrup infused with dark cocoa powder and fresh organic roses
$4.25 - Black Rose Matcha Latte
house-made organic syrup infused with dark cocoa powder and fresh organic roses
$5.00 - Iced Black Rose Latte
house-made organic syrup infused with dark cocoa powder and fresh organic roses
$5.50 - Iced Black Rose Matcha Latte
house-made organic syrup infused with dark cocoa powder and fresh organic roses
$5.50 - Iced Lavender Latte$5.50
- Iced Lavender Matcha Latte$5.50
- Iced Salted Honey Latte$5.50
- Iced Salted Honey Matcha Latte$5.50
- Iced Strawberry Latte
made with organic strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm
$5.75OUT OF STOCK - Iced Strawberry Matcha Latte
made with organic strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm
$5.75 - Iced Strawberry Mocha
made with organic strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm
$7.00OUT OF STOCK - Iced Tangy Orange Latte$5.50
- Iced Tangy Orange Matcha Latte$5.50
- Lavender Latte$5.00
- Lavender Lemonade$4.25
- Lavender Matcha Latte$5.00
- Midnight Garden Tea Lemonade
arnold palmer with mint herbal tea (decaf) and lemonade with lavender and rose syrup
$4.25 - Salted Honey Latte$5.00
- Salted Honey Matcha Latte$5.00
- Strawberry Latte
made with organic strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm
$5.25 - Strawberry Lemonade$4.50
- Strawberry Matcha Latte
made with organic strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm
$5.25 - Strawberry Milk$6.00
- Strawberry Mocha
made with organic strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm
$6.50 - Tangy Orange Latte$5.00
- Tangy Orange Matcha Latte$5.00
Strawberry Matcha Latte
made with organic strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm
Tea & More
Cold Drinks
- Arnold Palmer$3.50
- Cold Brew$4.50
- Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice$7.00
- Iced Americano$3.50
- Iced Chai Latte$5.00
- Iced Latte$4.75
- Iced Matcha Latte$4.75
- Iced Mocha$6.00
- Iced Tea
unsweetened tea from Blue Willow Tea
$3.50 - Iced White Chocolate Mocha
made with our house-made Guittard white chocolate syrup *not available vegan* white chocolate contains dairy
$6.00 - Lemonade$3.50
- Matcha Tea Lemonade$4.75
- Sparkling Americano$4.00
Bottled Drinks
Catering Menu (72 Hour Notice)
Catering (requires 72 hours notice)
- Box of 1/2 Dozen Bagels & Schmear
Choice of 1/2 dozen sliced bagels in a box. Add on schmears. We recommend 1-2 per 1/2 dozen bagels (serves 6 people).
$15.50 - Box of 1 Dozen Bagels & Schmear
Choice of 1 dozen sliced bagels in a box. Add on schmears. We recommend 2-3 per dozen bagels (serves 12 people).
$28.50 - Veggie Platter
Choice of 1 dozen sliced bagels, 3 tubs of schmear, sliced cucumbers, watermelon radish, pickled red onion, tomatoes, red onion, sprouts, lemon wedges. Served on disposable platters with disposable tongs. Utensils, napkins & trays included.
$105.00 - Classic Lox Platter
Choice of 1 dozen sliced bagels, 3 tubs of schmear, 16 oz. sliced premium salmon lox from Santa Barbara Smokehouse, red onion, dill, capers, lemon wedges (serves 12 people).
$170.00 - Deluxe Lox Platter
Choice of 1 dozen sliced bagels, 3 tubs of schmear, 24 oz. sliced premium salmon lox from Santa Barbara Smokehouse, red onion, dill, capers, lemon wedges, sliced cucumber, tomato, watermelon radish, sprouts, pickled red onion (serves 12 people).
$235.00 - Coffee Carafe
96 oz. of brewed Ritual coffee. Comes with half and half, oat milk, whole milk, sweetener, cups, and wooden stirrers (serves 8-12 people)
$34.00
Retail
- Bagel Mill Beanie
charcoal beanie with logo on front
$25.99 - Bagel Mill Hoodie
Bella + Canvas charcoal hoodie with logo on front and back
$54.99 - Bagel Mill Men's Tee
Bella + Canvas charcoal Tee with logo on front and back
$26.99 - Bagel Mill Tote Bag
organic canvas tote
$10.00 - Bagel Mill Trucker Hat
trucker hat with logo
$31.99 - Bagel Mill Women's Black V-Neck Tee
Bella + Canvas Tee with logo on front and bag
$26.99 - Bagel Mill Women's Red V-Neck Tee
Bella + Canvas Tee with logo on front and bag
$26.99 - Blue Willow Loose Leaf Tea
2 oz container of tea from Blue Willow Tea Company in Berkeley, CA.
$11.00 - Ritual Coffee Beans$22.00
- Coffee Mug$12.00
- Coffee Tumbler$32.95
- Everything Mix
a jar of our organic Everything Mix. Perfect for seasoning salads, veggies, eggs, meat and more!
$9.00 - Heart Shaped Bouquet Flower & Vase$10.00
- LilClayGrl Mug$40.00
- Rozeris Clay n Cloth$12.00
- Raspberry Chia Seed Granola
12 oz bag of our house-made granola
$13.00 - Everything Granola
12 oz bag of our house-made granola
$13.00 - Bread Whole Wheat Flour 2lb.
2 lb. bag of our house-milled flour
$7.00 - Khorasan Whole Wheat Flour 2lb.
2 lb. bag of our house-milled flour
$9.00 - Pastry Whole Wheat Flour 2lb.
2 lb. bag of our house-milled flour
$7.00 - Rye Whole Wheat Flour 2lb.
2 lb. bag of our house-milled flour
$7.00 - Sourdough Starter$0.01
- NØRSE CØDE Plant Protein Powder
local Petaluma product made with upcycled barley
$44.50
Sunday | 7:00 am - 2:00 pm |
Monday | 7:00 am - 2:00 pm |
Tuesday | 7:00 am - 2:00 pm |
Wednesday | 7:00 am - 2:00 pm |
Thursday | 7:00 am - 2:00 pm |
Friday | 7:00 am - 2:00 pm |
Saturday | 7:00 am - 2:00 pm |
Our sourdough bagels are made with freshly-milled flour and whole grains using traditional bagel-making techniques and organic ingredients.
212 Western Ave, Petaluma, CA 94952