This restaurant does not have any images
Pizza
The Pie at Salvatore's 120 E Main St
120 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Food
Our Signature Pies
Small Original Neapolitan Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & basil$12.25Medium Original Neapolitan Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & basil$25.00Large Original Neapolitan Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & basil$27.25Small White Pie
Fresh mozzarella, garlic, grated cheese, olive oil$13.25Medium White Pie
Fresh mozzarella, garlic, grated cheese, olive oil$26.00Large White Pie
Fresh mozzarella, garlic, grated cheese, olive oil$28.00Small Caesar Salad Pie
Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese and our homemade Caesar dressing$12.00Medium Caesar Salad Pie
Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese and our homemade Caesar dressing$24.00Large Caesar Salad Pie
Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese and our homemade Caesar dressing$26.00Small Salad Pie
Tomatoes, carrots, red onions and mushrooms with an Italian vinaigrette$12.00Medium Salad Pie
Tomatoes, carrots, red onions and mushrooms with an Italian vinaigrette$24.00Large Salad Pie
Tomatoes, carrots, red onions and mushrooms with an Italian vinaigrette$26.00Small Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pie
$15.00Medium Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pie
$30.00Large Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pie
$33.00Small Clam Pie
$15.00Medium Clam Pie
$29.00Large Clam Pie
$31.00Small Clams Casino Pie
Our clam pie with bacon$15.50Medium Clams Casino Pie
Our clam pie with bacon$30.00Large Clams Casino Pie
Our clam pie with bacon$32.00Small Shrimp & Garlic (Red)
$15.00Medium Shrimp & Garlic (Red)
$30.00Large Shrimp & Garlic (Red)
$32.00Small Shrimp & Garlic (White)
$15.00Medium Shrimp & Garlic (White)
$30.00Large Shrimp & Garlic (White)
$32.00Small Vegetable Pizza
Artichoke hearts, mushrooms, spinach, sun dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers$16.00Medium Vegetable Pizza
Artichoke hearts, mushrooms, spinach, sun dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers$32.00Large Vegetable Pizza
Artichoke hearts, mushrooms, spinach, sun dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers$34.00Small Supreme Pizza
Bacon, meatballs, sausage, pepperoni and prosciutto$17.00Medium Supreme Pizza
Bacon, meatballs, sausage, pepperoni and prosciutto$33.00Large Supreme Pizza
Bacon, meatballs, sausage, pepperoni and prosciutto$35.00Small Tomato & Grated Cheese
$10.50Medium Tomato & Grated Cheese
$21.00Large Tomato & Grated Cheese
$23.00Small Half/Half Pizza
Medium Half/Half Pizza
Large Half/Half Pizza
Small Pizza Dough
$2.50Large Pizza Dough
$4.00Large Speciality Pie
$27.25Medium Speciality Pie
$25.00Small Speciality Pie
$12.25
Pasta
Baked Ziti
$18.95Baked Ziti Salvatore
$21.95Baked Ziti Sicilian
$21.95Homemade Manicotti
$18.95Linguine Garlic & Oil
$12.95Linguine Marinara
$13.95Linguine w/ butter
$11.95Linguine w/ Shrimp
$20.95Linguini with Clam Sauce
$24.95Penne Garlic & Oil
$12.95Penne Marinara
$13.95Penne Vodka
$19.95Penne Vodka Shrimp
$23.95Penne w/ butter
$11.95Penned Vodka Chicken
$21.95Plain Pasta
$10.95Ravioli Pomodore
$18.95Rig/Broccoli/Chicken
$22.95Rig/broccoli/sausage
$22.95Rigatoni Broccoli Rabe
$20.95Rigatoni Filleto Di Pomodore
$16.95Rigatoni Garlic & Oil
$12.95Rigatoni Marinara
$13.95Rigatoni w/ butter
$11.95Rigatoni/spinach/chicken
$21.95Side Of Feta
$2.00
Salads
16 oz Caesar Dressing
$8.2516 oz Greek Dressing
$8.2516 oz Mixed Dressing
$8.25Fresh Mozz/Red Peppers (4 pieces)
$13.95Fresh Mozz/Tomato (5 pieces)
$12.95Large Antipasto Platter
Fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sopressata, provolone, Sicilian olives, pepperoncini & prosciutto$20.95Large Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese and our homemade Caesar dressing$14.25Large Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, pepperoncini, red onions, feta cheese & Kalamata olives$15.75Large Lettuce & Tomato
$9.00Large Mixed Green Salad
Mixed greens, sliced tomatoes, red onions, carrots, mushrooms, croutons, pepperoncini & pecans with an Italian vinaigrette$15.25Pint Marinara Sauce
$5.50Pint Pizza Sauce
$4.50Pint Pomodore Sauce
$7.00Pint Vodka Sauce
$7.50Side Anchovies
$3.00Side of Fresh Mozz (8 pieces)
$9.95Small Antipasto Platter
Fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sopressata, provolone, Sicilian olives, pepperoncini & prosciutto$16.95Small Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese and our homemade Caesar dressing$9.50Small Dressing
$1.75Small Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, pepperoncini, red onions, feta cheese & Kalamata olives$10.25Small Lettuce & Tomato
$6.00Small Mixed Green Salad
Mixed greens, sliced tomatoes, red onions, carrots, mushrooms, croutons, pepperoncini & pecans with an Italian vinaigrette$9.75Tommy Salad
$25.00Tony Salad Meal
$35.00To Go
Desserts
1 Scoop Gelato
$4.001 Scoop Vanilla Ice Cream
$3.00Add Chocolate Syrup
Add Whip Cream
Ala Mode
$3.00Bacio Gelato
$6.95Cake Charge
$1.00Cannoli
$5.50Carrot Cake
$7.75Chocolate Strawberry Gelato
$6.95Hazelnut Gelato
$6.95Italian Cheesecake
$6.50Mini Cannoli
$1.75No Powdered Sugar
No Whip Cream
Strawberry Cheesecake
$7.50Pistachio Gelato
$6.95Pumpkin Cheesecake
$7.50Salted Caramel Gelato
$6.95Stracciatella Gelato
$6.95Strawberry Cheesecake Gelato
$6.95Tartufo
$7.25To Go
Vanila Ice Cream
$5.75Whole Cheesecake
$28.00Mississippi Mud Ice Cream
$9.00Tiramsu
$8.00Nutella Gelato
$6.95Chocolate ice cream
$5.75
Garlic Bread
Other Selections
Baked Clams
$7.95Dozen (12) Bakes Clams
$28.00Bread Squares
Side of Italian Bread
Chicken Francaise w/pasta
$21.95Chicken Marsala w/pasta
$24.95Chicken Parmigiana / Pasta
$21.95Chicken Parmigiana Hero
$17.00Eggplant Hero
$13.00Eggplant Parmigiana
$17.95Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
$14.00Large "Family" Calzone
$23.00Eggplant Roll
$12.00Chicken Roll
Grilled chicken, mozzarella and tomato sauce$12.00Sausage Roll
Fresh Italian sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella and tomato sauce$13.50Large Chicken Roll
$21.00Large Sausage Roll
$21.00Large Stromboli
$22.00Meatball Roll
$12.00Large Side of Shrimp
$7.00Meatball Hero
$12.50Meatball Hero with Mozzarella
$13.50Mozzarella Carrozza
$9.50Side of Bread Squares
Side of Broccoli & Chicken
$12.50Side of Broccoli & Sausage
$12.50Side of Broccoli Rabe
$10.50Side of Grilled Chicken
$6.25Side of Meatballs
$11.00Side of Meatballs with Mozzarella
$12.00Side of Ricotta
$1.75Side of Sauce
Side of Sausage
$7.95Side of Spinach
$8.00Small Calzone
$13.00Small Side of Shrimp
$5.00Stromboli
Imported salami, pepperoni, sweet red peppers and mozzarella$13.50To Go
Vodka Sauce
$1.50Large Eggplant Roll
$21.00Egg Plantparm over pasta
$22.00
Mother's Day
Sunday Football Specials
Drinks
Soda
Juice
Red Wine
Red By Glass
Red By Bottle
Red Sangria
White Wine
White By Glass
White By Bottle
White Sangria
Catering
Catering Party Package
Naples
Per person. House, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, our signature pies, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert$27.99Naples (Children)
House, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, our signature pies, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert$14.00Venice
Per person. Antipasto platters, house, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, rigatoni filleto, our signature pies, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert$35.99Venice (Children)
Antipasto platters, house, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, rigatoni filleto, our signature pies, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert$18.00Rome
Per person. Antipasto platters, house, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, rigatoni filleto our signature pies, chicken Parmagiana, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert$39.99Rome (Children)
Antipasto platters, house, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, rigatoni filleto our signature pies, chicken Parmagiana, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert$20.00Naples (Copy)
Per person. House, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, our signature pies, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert$27.99
Catering Trays & Half Trays
Dozen Baked Clams
$28.00Mixed Greens 1/2 Tray
$38.00Greek Salad 1/2 Tray
$38.00Caesar Salad 1/2 Tray
$30.00Full Tray Caesar
$60.00Lasagna 1/2 Tray
$55.00Baked Ziti 1/2 Tray
$45.00Baked Ziti Sicilian 1/2 Tray
$56.00Baked Ziti w/Meat 1/2 Tray
$55.00Rigatoni Pomodore 1/2 Tray
$42.00Rigatoni ala Vodka 1/2 Tray
$47.00Rigatoni ala Vodka w/Chicken 1/2 Tray
$55.00Rigatoni ala Vodka w/Shrimp 1/2 Tray
$59.00Ravioli (30) 1/2 Tray
$42.00Rigatoni Broccoli Rabe & Sausage 1/2 Tray
$59.00Rigatoni Broccoli Rabe & Chicken 1/2 Tray
$59.00Linguini Clam Sauce 1/2 Tray
$65.00Eggplant Parmigiana 1/2 Tray
$55.00Sausage & Peppers 1/2 Tray
$54.00Chicken Franchise 1/2 Tray
$58.00Chicken Marsala 1/2 Tray
$58.00Chicken Parmigiana 1/2 Tray
$58.00Meatballs 1/2 Tray
$48.00Broccoli Rabe 1/2 Tray
$45.00
Beers
Bottles
Taps
Monday Night Special
Large Pasta
Peroni 00
$4.25
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:30 am - 10:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:30 am - 10:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Best Pizza on Long Island
Location
© 2026 Toast, Inc.



