Skip to Main content
  • The Pie at Salvatore's 120 E Main St

    • Home
    • /
    • Bay Shore
    • /
    • The Pie at Salvatore's 120 E Main St

    This restaurant does not have any images

    Pizza

    The Pie at Salvatore's 120 E Main St

    120 E Main St

    Bay Shore, NY 11706


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Food
    Drinks
    Red Wine
    White Wine
    Catering
    Beers
    Monday Night Special

    Food

    Our Signature Pies

    • Small Original Neapolitan Pizza

      Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & basil
      $12.25
    • Medium Original Neapolitan Pizza

      Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & basil
      $25.00
    • Large Original Neapolitan Pizza

      Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & basil
      $27.25
    • Small White Pie

      Fresh mozzarella, garlic, grated cheese, olive oil
      $13.25
    • Medium White Pie

      Fresh mozzarella, garlic, grated cheese, olive oil
      $26.00
    • Large White Pie

      Fresh mozzarella, garlic, grated cheese, olive oil
      $28.00
    • Small Caesar Salad Pie

      Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese and our homemade Caesar dressing
      $12.00
    • Medium Caesar Salad Pie

      Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese and our homemade Caesar dressing
      $24.00
    • Large Caesar Salad Pie

      Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese and our homemade Caesar dressing
      $26.00
    • Small Salad Pie

      Tomatoes, carrots, red onions and mushrooms with an Italian vinaigrette
      $12.00
    • Medium Salad Pie

      Tomatoes, carrots, red onions and mushrooms with an Italian vinaigrette
      $24.00
    • Large Salad Pie

      Tomatoes, carrots, red onions and mushrooms with an Italian vinaigrette
      $26.00
    • Small Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pie

      $15.00
    • Medium Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pie

      $30.00
    • Large Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pie

      $33.00
    • Small Clam Pie

      $15.00
    • Medium Clam Pie

      $29.00
    • Large Clam Pie

      $31.00
    • Small Clams Casino Pie

      Our clam pie with bacon
      $15.50
    • Medium Clams Casino Pie

      Our clam pie with bacon
      $30.00
    • Large Clams Casino Pie

      Our clam pie with bacon
      $32.00
    • Small Shrimp & Garlic (Red)

      $15.00
    • Medium Shrimp & Garlic (Red)

      $30.00
    • Large Shrimp & Garlic (Red)

      $32.00
    • Small Shrimp & Garlic (White)

      $15.00
    • Medium Shrimp & Garlic (White)

      $30.00
    • Large Shrimp & Garlic (White)

      $32.00
    • Small Vegetable Pizza

      Artichoke hearts, mushrooms, spinach, sun dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers
      $16.00
    • Medium Vegetable Pizza

      Artichoke hearts, mushrooms, spinach, sun dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers
      $32.00
    • Large Vegetable Pizza

      Artichoke hearts, mushrooms, spinach, sun dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers
      $34.00
    • Small Supreme Pizza

      Bacon, meatballs, sausage, pepperoni and prosciutto
      $17.00
    • Medium Supreme Pizza

      Bacon, meatballs, sausage, pepperoni and prosciutto
      $33.00
    • Large Supreme Pizza

      Bacon, meatballs, sausage, pepperoni and prosciutto
      $35.00
    • Small Tomato & Grated Cheese

      $10.50
    • Medium Tomato & Grated Cheese

      $21.00
    • Large Tomato & Grated Cheese

      $23.00
    • Small Half/Half Pizza

    • Medium Half/Half Pizza

    • Large Half/Half Pizza

    • Small Pizza Dough

      $2.50
    • Large Pizza Dough

      $4.00
    • Large Speciality Pie

      $27.25
    • Medium Speciality Pie

      $25.00
    • Small Speciality Pie

      $12.25

    Pasta

    • Baked Ziti

      $18.95
    • Baked Ziti Salvatore

      $21.95
    • Baked Ziti Sicilian

      $21.95
    • Homemade Manicotti

      $18.95
    • Linguine Garlic & Oil

      $12.95
    • Linguine Marinara

      $13.95
    • Linguine w/ butter

      $11.95
    • Linguine w/ Shrimp

      $20.95
    • Linguini with Clam Sauce

      $24.95
    • Penne Garlic & Oil

      $12.95
    • Penne Marinara

      $13.95
    • Penne Vodka

      $19.95
    • Penne Vodka Shrimp

      $23.95
    • Penne w/ butter

      $11.95
    • Penned Vodka Chicken

      $21.95
    • Plain Pasta

      $10.95
    • Ravioli Pomodore

      $18.95
    • Rig/Broccoli/Chicken

      $22.95
    • Rig/broccoli/sausage

      $22.95
    • Rigatoni Broccoli Rabe

      $20.95
    • Rigatoni Filleto Di Pomodore

      $16.95
    • Rigatoni Garlic & Oil

      $12.95
    • Rigatoni Marinara

      $13.95
    • Rigatoni w/ butter

      $11.95
    • Rigatoni/spinach/chicken

      $21.95
    • Side Of Feta

      $2.00

    Salads

    • 16 oz Caesar Dressing

      $8.25
    • 16 oz Greek Dressing

      $8.25
    • 16 oz Mixed Dressing

      $8.25
    • Fresh Mozz/Red Peppers (4 pieces)

      $13.95
    • Fresh Mozz/Tomato (5 pieces)

      $12.95
    • Large Antipasto Platter

      Fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sopressata, provolone, Sicilian olives, pepperoncini & prosciutto
      $20.95
    • Large Caesar Salad

      Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese and our homemade Caesar dressing
      $14.25
    • Large Greek Salad

      Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, pepperoncini, red onions, feta cheese & Kalamata olives
      $15.75
    • Large Lettuce & Tomato

      $9.00
    • Large Mixed Green Salad

      Mixed greens, sliced tomatoes, red onions, carrots, mushrooms, croutons, pepperoncini & pecans with an Italian vinaigrette
      $15.25
    • Pint Marinara Sauce

      $5.50
    • Pint Pizza Sauce

      $4.50
    • Pint Pomodore Sauce

      $7.00
    • Pint Vodka Sauce

      $7.50
    • Side Anchovies

      $3.00
    • Side of Fresh Mozz (8 pieces)

      $9.95
    • Small Antipasto Platter

      Fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sopressata, provolone, Sicilian olives, pepperoncini & prosciutto
      $16.95
    • Small Caesar Salad

      Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese and our homemade Caesar dressing
      $9.50
    • Small Dressing

      $1.75
    • Small Greek Salad

      Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, pepperoncini, red onions, feta cheese & Kalamata olives
      $10.25
    • Small Lettuce & Tomato

      $6.00
    • Small Mixed Green Salad

      Mixed greens, sliced tomatoes, red onions, carrots, mushrooms, croutons, pepperoncini & pecans with an Italian vinaigrette
      $9.75
    • Tommy Salad

      $25.00
    • Tony Salad Meal

      $35.00
    • To Go

    Desserts

    • 1 Scoop Gelato

      $4.00
    • 1 Scoop Vanilla Ice Cream

      $3.00
    • Add Chocolate Syrup

    • Add Whip Cream

    • Ala Mode

      $3.00
    • Bacio Gelato

      $6.95
    • Cake Charge

      $1.00
    • Cannoli

      $5.50
    • Carrot Cake

      $7.75
    • Chocolate Strawberry Gelato

      $6.95
    • Hazelnut Gelato

      $6.95
    • Italian Cheesecake

      $6.50
    • Mini Cannoli

      $1.75
    • No Powdered Sugar

    • No Whip Cream

    • Strawberry Cheesecake

      $7.50
    • Pistachio Gelato

      $6.95
    • Pumpkin Cheesecake

      $7.50
    • Salted Caramel Gelato

      $6.95
    • Stracciatella Gelato

      $6.95
    • Strawberry Cheesecake Gelato

      $6.95
    • Tartufo

      $7.25
    • To Go

    • Vanila Ice Cream

      $5.75
    • Whole Cheesecake

      $28.00
    • Mississippi Mud Ice Cream

      $9.00
    • Tiramsu

      $8.00
    • Nutella Gelato

      $6.95
    • Chocolate ice cream

      $5.75

    Soups

    • Homemade Chicken Soup

      $7.00
    • Chicken Noodle Soup

      $7.00
    • Minestrone

      $7.50

    Garlic Bread

    • Garlic Bread

      Round like our pizza
      $9.00

    Other Selections

    • Baked Clams

      $7.95
    • Dozen (12) Bakes Clams

      $28.00
    • Bread Squares

    • Side of Italian Bread

    • Chicken Francaise w/pasta

      $21.95
    • Chicken Marsala w/pasta

      $24.95
    • Chicken Parmigiana / Pasta

      $21.95
    • Chicken Parmigiana Hero

      $17.00
    • Eggplant Hero

      $13.00
    • Eggplant Parmigiana

      $17.95
    • Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

      $14.00
    • Large "Family" Calzone

      $23.00
    • Eggplant Roll

      $12.00
    • Chicken Roll

      Grilled chicken, mozzarella and tomato sauce
      $12.00
    • Sausage Roll

      Fresh Italian sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella and tomato sauce
      $13.50
    • Large Chicken Roll

      $21.00
    • Large Sausage Roll

      $21.00
    • Large Stromboli

      $22.00
    • Meatball Roll

      $12.00
    • Large Side of Shrimp

      $7.00
    • Meatball Hero

      $12.50
    • Meatball Hero with Mozzarella

      $13.50
    • Mozzarella Carrozza

      $9.50
    • Side of Bread Squares

    • Side of Broccoli & Chicken

      $12.50
    • Side of Broccoli & Sausage

      $12.50
    • Side of Broccoli Rabe

      $10.50
    • Side of Grilled Chicken

      $6.25
    • Side of Meatballs

      $11.00
    • Side of Meatballs with Mozzarella

      $12.00
    • Side of Ricotta

      $1.75
    • Side of Sauce

    • Side of Sausage

      $7.95
    • Side of Spinach

      $8.00
    • Small Calzone

      $13.00
    • Small Side of Shrimp

      $5.00
    • Stromboli

      Imported salami, pepperoni, sweet red peppers and mozzarella
      $13.50
    • To Go

    • Vodka Sauce

      $1.50
    • Large Eggplant Roll

      $21.00
    • Egg Plantparm over pasta

      $22.00

    Mother's Day

    • Raspberry Sunrise Mimosa

    • Traditional Mimosa

    • Bellini

    • Coffee

    • Antipasto Platter

    • Greek Salad

    • Mozzarella Corrozza

    • Individual Frittata Pizza

      $45.00
    • Individual Brunch Pizza

      $45.00
    • Eggplant Parmigiana

    • Tiramsu

    • Tartufo

    Sunday Football Specials

    • Football Specials


    Drinks

    Soda

    • 2 Liter 7 Up

      $3.95
    • 2 Liter Diet Pepsi

      $3.95
    • 2 Liter Pepsi

      $3.95
    • 2 Liter Ginger Ale

      $3.80
    • 7up

      $3.50
    • Black Cherry

      $3.50
    • Cream Soda

      $3.50
    • Diet RC

      $3.50
    • Ginger Ale

      $3.50
    • Orange Soda

      $3.50
    • RC Cola

      $3.50
    • Root Beer

      $3.50
    • Seltzer

      $1.50
    • To Go Soda

      $2.75

    Juice

    • Apple Juice

      $3.50
    • Cranberry Juice

      $3.50
    • Fruit Punch

      $3.50
    • Iced Tea

      $3.50
    • Lemonade

      $3.50
    • Chocolate Milk

      $3.75
    • Milk

      $3.50
    • Orange Juice

      $3.95
    • Shirley Temple

      $3.50

    Waters

    • Small San Pellegrino Sparkling

      $3.50
    • Large San Pellegrino Sparkling

      $5.75
    • Poland Spring

      $2.00

    Coffee & Tea

    • Coffee

      $3.75
    • Tea

      $3.75
    • Cappuccino

      $6.25
    • Espresso

      Single
      $4.00
    • Double Expresso

      $6.00
    • Hot Chocolate

      $4.25
    • Herbal Tea

      $4.00
    • To Go Coffee

      $2.75
    • To Go Cappuccino

      $5.25
    • Sambuca

      $7.00

    Red Wine

    Red By Glass

    • Merlot Glass

      $10.95
    • Pinot Noir Glass

      $10.95
    • Chianti Glass

      $10.95
    • Cabernet Glass

      $10.95
    • Conte Spritz Classico

      $9.75
    • Wednesday Wine Special Glass

      $5.50
    • Super Tuscan "Dog"

      $10.95

    Red By Bottle

    • BTL Super Tuscan "Dogajolo", Italy

      $36.00
    • BTL H 3 Merlot

      $36.00
    • BTL Tribute Pinot Noir

      $36.00
    • BTL Castiglini Chianti

      $38.00
    • BTL The Federalist Cabernet

      $38.00
    • Cork Charge

      $12.00
    • Wine Special

      $20.00
    • Wednesday Wine Special Bottle

      $19.00

    Red Sangria

    • Red Sangria

      $12.00

    White Wine

    White By Glass

    • Champagne

      $9.00
    • Chardonnay Glass

      $10.75
    • Pinot Grigio Glass

      $10.75
    • Aperol Spritz

      $12.00
    • Mimosa

      $10.00
    • Prosecco

      $9.50
    • Sauvignon Blanc Glass

      $10.75
    • Wednesday Wine Special Glass

      $5.50
    • Rose

      $10.75
    • Riesling

      $10.75

    White By Bottle

    • BTL Lamoreaux Riesling

      $34.00
    • BTL 14 Hands Rosé

      $34.00
    • BTL Alverdi Pinot Grigio

      $34.00
    • BTL Hook & Crook Chardonnay

      $34.00
    • BTL Fernhook Sauvignon Blanc

      $34.00
    • Cork Charge

      $12.00
    • Wine Special

      $20.00
    • Wednesday Wine Special Bottle

      $17.00

    White Sangria

    • Sangria

      $12.00

    Catering

    Catering Party Package

    • Naples

      Per person. House, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, our signature pies, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert
      $27.99
    • Naples (Children)

      House, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, our signature pies, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert
      $14.00
    • Venice

      Per person. Antipasto platters, house, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, rigatoni filleto, our signature pies, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert
      $35.99
    • Venice (Children)

      Antipasto platters, house, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, rigatoni filleto, our signature pies, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert
      $18.00
    • Rome

      Per person. Antipasto platters, house, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, rigatoni filleto our signature pies, chicken Parmagiana, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert
      $39.99
    • Rome (Children)

      Antipasto platters, house, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, rigatoni filleto our signature pies, chicken Parmagiana, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert
      $20.00
    • Naples (Copy)

      Per person. House, Caesar, or Greek salad, garlic bread, our signature pies, includes soda, juice, coffee, tea, and dessert
      $27.99

    Catering Trays & Half Trays

    • Dozen Baked Clams

      $28.00
    • Mixed Greens 1/2 Tray

      $38.00
    • Greek Salad 1/2 Tray

      $38.00
    • Caesar Salad 1/2 Tray

      $30.00
    • Full Tray Caesar

      $60.00
    • Lasagna 1/2 Tray

      $55.00
    • Baked Ziti 1/2 Tray

      $45.00
    • Baked Ziti Sicilian 1/2 Tray

      $56.00
    • Baked Ziti w/Meat 1/2 Tray

      $55.00
    • Rigatoni Pomodore 1/2 Tray

      $42.00
    • Rigatoni ala Vodka 1/2 Tray

      $47.00
    • Rigatoni ala Vodka w/Chicken 1/2 Tray

      $55.00
    • Rigatoni ala Vodka w/Shrimp 1/2 Tray

      $59.00
    • Ravioli (30) 1/2 Tray

      $42.00
    • Rigatoni Broccoli Rabe & Sausage 1/2 Tray

      $59.00
    • Rigatoni Broccoli Rabe & Chicken 1/2 Tray

      $59.00
    • Linguini Clam Sauce 1/2 Tray

      $65.00
    • Eggplant Parmigiana 1/2 Tray

      $55.00
    • Sausage & Peppers 1/2 Tray

      $54.00
    • Chicken Franchise 1/2 Tray

      $58.00
    • Chicken Marsala 1/2 Tray

      $58.00
    • Chicken Parmigiana 1/2 Tray

      $58.00
    • Meatballs 1/2 Tray

      $48.00
    • Broccoli Rabe 1/2 Tray

      $45.00

    Beers

    Bottles

    • Bud

      $7.50
    • Bud lite

      $7.50
    • Coors lite

      $7.50
    • Corona

      $7.50
    • Heinekin

      $7.50
    • Heinekin lite

      $7.50
    • Miller Lite

      $7.50
    • Modelo

      $7.50
    • Peroni

      $7.50
    • Peroni 00

      $4.25
    • Stella

      $7.50

    Taps

    • Blue Point Toasted

      $9.00
    • Blue Moon

      $9.00
    • Michelob Ultra

      $7.50
    • Montauk Wave Chaser

      $9.00
    • 5 Boroughs Summer Ale

      $9.00
    • Schlafly Pumpkin

      $9.00
    • Kona Big Wave

      $9.00
    • Mango Cart

      $9.00
    • Beach Bum

      $9.00

    Nutrl

    • Black Cherry

      $9.25
    • Pineapple

      $9.25
    • Orange

      $9.25
    • Watermelon

      $9.25

    Monday Night Special

    Large Salad

    • large Ceasar

      $59.99
    • large Greek

      $59.99
    • large Mixed Green

      $59.99
    • large Antipasto

      $59.99

    Large Pasta

    • Baked ziti

    • Baked ziti salvatore

    • Baked ziti sicilian

    • Penne vodka

    • Rigatoni pomodore

    • Eggplant parm

    • Chicken Parm

    • Ravioli pomodore

    • Manicotti

    • Linguini clam sauce

    • Ravioli Pomodore

    Large Pizza

    • large Original pie

    • large White pie

    • large Broccoli Rabe Sausage Pie

    • large Clam pie

    • large Clam Casino pie

    • large Shrimp and Garlic pie

    • large Vegetable pie

    • large Supreme pie

    • large Tomato Grated pie

    • large Ceaser Salad pie

    • large Salad pie

    Peroni 00

    $4.25
    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
    1

    All hours
    Sunday11:30 am - 9:00 pm
    Monday11:30 am - 9:00 pm
    TuesdayClosed
    Wednesday11:30 am - 9:00 pm
    Thursday11:30 am - 9:00 pm
    Friday11:30 am - 10:00 pm
    Saturday11:30 am - 10:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Best Pizza on Long Island

    Location

    120 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Bar Lucy
    View restaurantnext
    The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
    View restaurantnext
    Mama Mia's Pizza 635 East Main Street
    View restaurantnext
    Le Dock
    View restaurantnext
    The Pizzeria of Islip
    View restaurantnext
    La Slice - West Islip 5 Udall Road
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook