Pizza
The Pizzeria of Islip
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
*Food*
Pies
Large Pie
traditional new york style | 18”$21.95
Sicilian Pie
pizza sauce | mozzarella | thick sicilian crust$24.95
Grandma Pie
marinara | mozzarella | grandma style crust$24.95
Uncle Benny Pie
fresh mozzarella | cup & char pepperoni | pizza sauce | crumbled sausage | Mike's hot honey | basil | olive oil crust$32.95
Aunt Danielle Pie
vodka sauce | pepperoni | stracciatella cheese | fresh basil | Mike's hot honey$32.95
Islip Pie
fresh mozzarella | pizza sauce | parmesan | olive oil crust$29.95
Crumbling Vodka Pie
fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | crumbled sausage | grandma style crust$30.95
The Honey Pep Pie
cup & char pepperoni | Mike's Hot Honey | basil | sicilian crust$31.95
Vodka Marghertia Pie
fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | parmesan |olive oil crust$29.95
Bar Pie
pizza sauce | light mozzarella | burrata | Mike's Hot Honey | basil | olive oil crust$31.95
Tri-Fecta Pie
fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | pizza sauce | pesto | olive oil crust$29.95
Meatball Burrata Pie
homemade meatballs | tomato sauce | burrata | basil | parmesan cheese | grandma style crust$31.95
Upside Down Pie
mozzarella | marinara | olive oil | sicilian crust$27.95
Buffalo Chicken Pie
marinated chicken | mozzarella | buffalo sauce$32.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
breaded chicken | crispy bacon | mozzarella | cheddar | ranch$32.95
Thai Chili Chicken Pie
marinated chicken | mozzarella | thai chili sauce | grandma style crust$31.95
White Pie
ricotta | marscapone | mozzarella | white truffle oil | grandma style crust$29.95
Salad Pie
Choice of house salad or Caesar salad$34.95
Nonna's Non-Dairy Pie
mixed veggies | red sauce | grandma crust$29.95
Bruschetta Pie
balsamic-infused crust | fresh bruschetta | red onion | burrata cheese | basil | balsamic glaze$32.95
Vodka Sicilian Pie
vodka sauce | mozzarella | sicilian crust$25.95GF Personal Pie - Regular
Our GF crust is gluten and dairy free!$14.95
GF Personal Pie - Specialty
Our GF crust is gluten and dairy free!$13.00
Slices
Regular Slice
$3.67
Grandma Slice
$3.95
Sicilian Slice
$3.95
Uncle Benny Slice
$5.75
Aunt Danielle Slice
$5.75
Islip Slice
$5.75
Crumbling Vodka Slice
$5.75
The Honey Pep Slice
$5.75
Vodka Marghertia Slice
$5.75
Bar Slice
$5.75
Meatball Burrata Slice
$5.75
Tri-Fecta Slice
$5.75
Buffalo Chicken Slice
$5.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
$5.75
Upside Down Slice
$5.75
Thai Chili Chicken Slice
$5.75
White Slice
$5.75
Salad Slice
$5.75
Bruschetta Slice
$5.75
Starters
Garlic Knots
$0.70+
Buffalo Knots
$0.85+
Pepperoni Pinwheel
$4.95
Broccoli Pinwheel
$4.95
Rice Ball (1pc)
$2.25+
Chicken Roll
breaded chicken | mozzarella | tomato sauce | parmesan & garlic seasoning$11.95
Garlic Bread w/Mozzarella
$7.50
Homemade Meatballs
tomato sauce | ricotta | parmesan | basil | rustic bread$12.95
Mozzarella Sticks
$11.95
Fried Ravioli
$11.95
Wings
$15.95
Calzone
topped with garlic & parmesan$12.95
Salads
House Salad
mixed field greens | cherry tomatoes | red onion | cucumbers | freshly made croutons | mozzarella$13.95
Caesar Salad
romaine | shaved parmesan cheese | parmesan crisps | freshly made croutons | homemade caesar dressing$14.95
The Salad
mixed field greens | honey crisp apple sticks | cherry tomatoes | freshly made croutons | candied pecans | parmesan crisps | cheddar cheese$15.95
Primiano Chop
soppressata | prosciutto | fresh mozzarella | onions | sliced cherry peppers | romaine | tomato | red wine vinaigrette$15.95
Side House Salad
$9.95
Side Caesar Salad
$9.95Side The Salad
$10.95Side Primiano Chop
$10.95
Heros, Sandwiches & Wraps
Chicken Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | breaded chicken cutlet | mozzarella |semolina bread$14.95
Meatball Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | homemade meatballs | mozzarella | semolina bread$14.95
Eggplant Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | breaded eggplant | mozzarella | semolina bread$14.95
Shrimp Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | breaded shrimp | mozzarella | semolina bread$14.95Sausage Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | grilled saussage | mozzarella | semolina bread$14.95
Sausage and Pepper Parm Hero
tomato or vodka sauce | grilled saussage and peppers | mozzarella | semolina bread$14.95
THE Hero
choice of protein | burrata cheese | tomato sauce | fresh basil | olive oil | parmesan | semolina bread$16.95
Primiano Chop Hero
soppressata | prosciutto | fresh mozzarella | onions | tomato | sliced cherry peppers | romaine | red wine vinaigrette | semolina bread$15.95Focaccia Pesto Chicken Sandwich
grilled chicken | fresh mozzarella | roasted red peppers | house made pesto$14.95Focaccia Pizzeria Chicken Sandwich
arugula | roasted peppers | breaded chicken | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze$14.95Focaccia Chicken Caesar Sandwich
romaine | grilled chicken | parmesan | homemade caesar dressing$14.95
Focaccia Prosciutto Sandwich
prosciutto di parma | fresh mozzarella | tomato | basil | olive oil$14.95
Focaccia Caprese Sandwich
fresh mozzarella | tomato | basil | olive oil$13.95
Chicken Caesar Wrap
romaine | grilled chicken |parmesan | homemade caesar dressing | **This Item cannot be modified**$11.95
Pizzeria Chicken Wrap
arugula | roasted peppers |breaded chicken | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze | **This Item can not be modified**$11.95
Pastas
Penne Alla Vodka
housemade vodka sauce | penne pasta$21.95
Beggar’s Purse
cheese filled pasta pouches |crumbled spicy sausage | vodka sauce$21.95
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pasta
orecchiette | broccoli rabe | crumbled spicy sausage | garlic & oil$21.95
Baked Ziti
$21.95
The Mezzi Rig
mezzi rigatoni | mozzarella | spicy vodka sauce$21.95
Gnocchi
tomato sauce or creamy pesto$21.95
Endless Summer Shrimp Pasta
white wine | lemon | butter | garlic sauce | shrimp | spaghetti$24.95
Pasta with Meatballs
$21.95
Pasta with Sauce
$16.95
Penne Broccoli and Garlic Oil
$21.95
Dinners
Parmigiana Dinner
tomato sauce | mozzarella | choice of side$25.95
Vodka Parm Dinner
vodka sauce | mozzarella | choice of side$25.95
Chicken Francese
white wine lemon butter sauce | choice of side$25.95
Chicken Stracciatella
breaded chicken cutlet | vodka sauce | creamy stracciatella cheese | choice of side$25.95
THE Pizzeria Chicken
breaded chicken cutlet topped with arugula | cherry tomatoes | red onion | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze | basil | choice of side$25.95
Endless Summer Chicken
breaded chicken cutlet | fresh mozzarella | white wine lemon sauce | choice of side$25.95
Trifecta Chicken Parm
fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | pizza sauce | pesto | choice of side$25.95
On The Lighter Side
Grilled Chicken Broccoli Rabe
sautéed broccoli rabe | garlic | seasoned grilled chicken$20.95
Grilled Pizzeria Chicken
seasoned grilled chicken topped with arugula | cherry tomatoes | red onion | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze | basil$20.95
THE Caesar Cutlet
breaded chicken cutlet | romaine lettuce | shaved parm | croutons | house-made caesar dressing |$21.95
Vodka Marghertia Slice
$5.75
Customize your item
Optional
Optional
Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:15 am - 8:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:15 am - 8:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:15 am - 8:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:15 am - 8:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:15 am - 8:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:15 am - 9:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:15 am - 8:30 pm |
Restaurant info
Serving up authentic, handcrafted pies made with the freshest ingredients and a whole lot of love. From classic favorites to creative specialties, every slice is made to bring people together. Dine in, take out, or order online — your neighborhood pizza spot, done right.
Location
591 Main Street, Islip, NY 11751
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
