This restaurant does not have any images
American
The Prop House
373 North East River Road
Lake Milton, OH 44429
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
Food
Appetizers
Fried Pickles
$10.00Prop House Chips
$10.00Bruschetta
$10.50Italian Greens
$14.00Hot Peppers in Oil
$10.50Coconut Shrimp
$18.00Boom Boom Shrimp
$16.00Fried Mozzarella
$12.00Half Order of Fried Calamari
$15.00Full Order of Fried Calamari
$21.00Mussels
$15.00Whiskey-Glazed Crispy Pork Belly
$14.00Boneless Chicken Tenders
$11.00Shrimp Spinach Dip
$14.00Fried Portabella Appetizer
$16.00Philly CheeseSteak Flatbread
$14.00BBQ Chicken Flatbread
$14.00Chicken Bacon Ranch Flatbread
$14.00Hot Pepper Flatbread
OUT OF STOCK$14.00Buffolo Chicken Flatbread
OUT OF STOCK$14.00
Soup and Salad
Poultry and Pasta Entrees
Steaks and Seafood Entrees
6 oz Filet Mignon
$38.00New York Strip
$39.00Top Sirloin
$27.00Horseradish Portabella Fillet Tips
$25.00Cajun Bleu Cheese Filet Tips
$25.00Tomahawk Pork Chop
OUT OF STOCK$21.00Pineapple Tomahawk Pork Chop
$21.001lb Bone In Ribeye
$40.00Sesame Tuna
$27.00Sirloin with Coconut Shrimp
$33.00Cod
$21.00Sauteed Salmon
$27.00Grilled Salmon over Greens
$27.00Fried Haddock
$19.00Broiled Haddock
$17.00Crab Stuffed Cod
$27.00
Sandwiches and Burgers
Fried Fish Sandwich
$17.00Chicken Sandwich
$16.00Blackened Chicken Sandwich
$16.00Blackened Chicken and Greens Sandwich
OUT OF STOCK$19.00Crab Cake Sandwich
OUT OF STOCK$19.00Prop House Classic Burger
$16.00Whiskey Burger
$17.00Blackened Blue Jay Burger
$17.00Peanut Butter and Grape Jelly Burger
OUT OF STOCK$17.00Southwest Chicken Sanwich
OUT OF STOCK$16.00
Dessert
Peanut Butter Pie
$7.00Creme Brulee
$8.00HoHo Cake
$8.00Carrot Cake
$8.00Bread Pudding
$8.00Itailian Love Cake
$8.00Limoncello Tiramisu
$8.00Strawberry Pretzel
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Hot Fudge Brownie w/ Ice Cream
$8.00Praline Cheesecake
$8.00add scoop of ice cream
$2.00Turtle Cheesecake
$8.00Reese Cup Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Death by Chocolate Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Mixed Berry Pie
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Blueberry Lemon Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Chocolate Oreo Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Neopolitan Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Bourbon Chocolate Caramel Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00White Chocolate Macadamia Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Plain Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Key Lime Pie
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Caramel Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Baileys Chocolate Caramel Cream Pie
OUT OF STOCK$8.00German Chocolate Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00White Chocolate Lemon Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Pumpkin Rolls
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Mandarin Orange Cake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Tiramisu
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Pineapple Upsidedown Cake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Peach Cobbler
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Orange Cream Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00cherry pie
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Pumpkin Swirl Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Pistachio Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Creme Brulee Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Strawberry and Cream Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00White Chocolate Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Lava Cake w/ Ice Cream
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Pumpkin Cannoli
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Mexican Mudslide Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00German Chocolate Cake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Double Chocolate Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Pina Colada Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Chocolate Decadence
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Smores Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Neopolitan Cake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Strawberry Pretzel Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Irish Cream Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Key Lime Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Vanilla Bean Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Cookies & Cream Cake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00German Choc Chz
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Blueberry Crumb Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Pistachio Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00White Raspberry Cake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Irish Cream Cheese
OUT OF STOCK$8.00White Chocolate Peppermint Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Chocolate Mousse Cake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Godiva White Chocolate Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00White Chocolate Pecan Cake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Tiramisu Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Rice Pudding
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$8.00Christmas Funfetti Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$9.00
Add On Sides
Baked Potato
$4.00Side One Meatball
$3.50Fries
$3.50House Chips
$4.00Salmon
$14.00Shrimp
$14.00Tuna
$14.00Steak
$14.00Chicken
$9.75Wedge Salad Side
$7.00Brussel Sprouts
$3.00Mushroom
$2.00Gravy
$1.00Loaded Baked Potato
$6.00Side Salad
$4.50Vegetable
$3.00House Potatos
$3.50Rice
$3.00Mashed Potato
$3.00Bowl of Soup Dijour
$6.00Greens
$6.00Add onions
$2.00Xtra Dipping
$0.75Lobster Tail
OUT OF STOCK$18.00Xtra Dressing
$0.75Xtra Special Dressing
$1.25TO GO 8 oz normal dressing
$5.00TO GO 16 oz normal dressing
$10.00TO GO 32 oz normal dressing
$20.00TO GO 8 oz Special Dressing
$8.50TO GO 16 oz Special Dressing
$17.00TO GO 32 oz Special Dressing
$34.00Xtra Cheese
$2.00Add Bacon
$2.5016 oz peppers in oil
$11.5032 oz peppers in oil
$21.00Loaf of Bread
$7.00Tangy Bleu sauce
$4.00Bleu cheese crumble
$4.00sweet potato fries
$4.50
Specials
Mango Cream of Coconut Cod with Rice
$24.00Seafood Pasta
$30.00Cajun Cream Salmon & Shrimp
$28.00Filet Steak Sandwich
OUT OF STOCK$25.00Lemon Cream Cod
$22.00Lollipop Lamb Chops
$26.00Greek Chicken Pasta
$28.00Cajun Salmon
$28.00Crab Stuffed Shrimp Appetizer
$18.00Chicken & Greens Gnocci
$24.00Guinness Cheese Pretzel
$14.00Corn Beef Cabbage
$22.00Sheppards Pie
$22.00Irish Stew
$22.00Beef Quesadilla
$14.00Chicken Quesadilla
$14.00Fried Chicken Sandwich
$18.00Pesto Gnocchi
$22.00Shrimp & Crab ala Vodka
OUT OF STOCK$30.00Bourbon Salmon
$26.00Blackened Grouper
$28.00Salmon Shrimp Scampi
OUT OF STOCK$26.0012 oz Sirloin w/ Coconut Shrimp
$32.00Mussels Marinara
$15.00Rosemary Chicken
$24.00Sauteed Salmon with Peppadews and Tomatos
$26.00Chicken Broccoli Pasta
$24.00Beef Tip Pasta
$26.00Beef Stew
$16.00Jumbo Gumbo
$26.00Pasta with Clam Sauce
OUT OF STOCK$22.00Beer Battered Cod
$18.00Chicken Cordon Bleu
$26.00
NA Beverages
Beverages
Non-alcoholic beer
If you use a credit card, The Prop House will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what The Prop House pays in fees.
Ginger Ale
$2.95
Customize your item
beverages
Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 3:30 pm - 8:00 pm |
| Thursday | 3:30 pm - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 3:30 pm - 8:00 pm |
| Saturday | 3:30 pm - 8:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Come in and enjoy!
Location
373 North East River Road, Lake Milton, OH 44429
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
